10 Video Games That Messed With Your Saves
Some nice saves you got there. Be a shame if something happened to them.
God bless the save file.
Before the hardware geniuses at Nintendo popularized battery-powered cartridges, if you wanted to see the ending of a video game it meant either plowing through the whole thing in one sitting, or writing down passwords on a piece of paper that would inevitably end up in the family waste bin. (Farewell, my Zero Tolerance saves...)
Allowing players to save their progress meant developers could focus on creating bigger, more complex worlds without the worry of increasingly complicated passwords (can you imagine the size of password needed to replicate the exact conditions of your last Skyrim save?), and were a necessary evolution in the history of video games.
Of course, evolution doesn't always run in a straight line, and there have been a few... interesting offshoots in the genealogy of the humble save file.
This article will take a look at some of the games that played around with their save files, to both the delight and detriment of the player (mostly the latter). From a simple fourth wall break to actual, real-world consequences, each game on this list memorably manipulated a function most gamers take for granted, teaching you that saves are a privilege, not a right.
10. Deleting Your Progress Fake-Out - Eternal Darkness
For a family-friendly console, the GameCube did quite well for itself when it came to horror.
As well as being the console of choice for the excellent Resident Evil remake, and the series' legendary fourth entry, Nintendo's purple box played host to the macabre delights of Eternal Darkness - a time-hopping survival-horror adventure filled with madness, death, and more elder gods than you could shake a tentacle at.
It's the foremost theme - madness - that Eternal Darkness is most remembered for. Alongside the traditional health and magic meters, players are also tasked with maintaining a third status - sanity. Let the green sanity bar hit rock bottom, and the game itself will start to break down around you.
The most infamous example is the game's notorious memory card wipe. Try to save with a low sanity meter, and the game will ask "Are you sure you want to delete all of your Saved Games?" No matter what you choose, the game assumes you chose "yes" before proceeding to delete your saves one by one.
Fortunately, it all turns out to be a trick. Simply boot up the save screen again and your saves will have been restored to pristine condition. Your heart rate, however, may take a bit longer to go back to normal.
9. Pirate The Game And You Can't Finish It - Earthbound
Piracy may be the bane of video game developers everywhere, but that doesn't mean they can't have a little fun with it. Case in point: Earthbound.
Anyone who pirated Nintendo's surreal SNES masterpiece back in the day was the victim of some quality trolling from the legendary studio. Adhering to the rule of "three strikes and you're out", Nintendo implemented a three-step program to punish the thieves:
1) Pirated versions of Earthbound would freeze at the start, with an anti-piracy warning replacing the title screen. This could only be bypassed by tinkering with the game files.
2) Anyone who circumvented the warning and started playing the game would be overwhelmed by a vastly boosted enemy count, turning the quirky JRPG into a tedious grindathon.
3) If the player did manage to struggle through the tsunami of enemy encounters and reach the final boss, their reward would be one final, game-ending crash just before the battle started. At which point, their save data would be deleted with no way to recover it.
Vigilante justice, Nintendo style. Certainly beats the heck out of DRM!
8. Some Boss Areas Can't Be Cheated - Banjo Kazooie
While Earthbound's save-erasing shenanigans were easy to justify (pirates should have an objectively worse experience than players who actually bought the game), Banjo Kazooie's salt-the-earth approach to cheaters was a tougher pill to swallow.
While BK (Banjo Kazooie, not Burger King) was happy to let players cheat their way to infinite items and lives, it was less forgiving of the player messing with Gruntilda's Castle (the game's hub).
Anyone caught opening doors they shouldn't have, or unlocking worlds they didn't yet have access to, would get a warning from the impressively-be'chinned witch: "Stop this cheating, Grunty says, or your Game Pak I'll erase!" She isn't joking - one more hub-altering cheat and she follows through on her threat, deleting the player's save data.
Honestly, this anti-cheating measure is a lot less justifiable than Earthbound's anti-piracy tactics. Once someone buys a legal copy of a single-player game, they should be able to cheat to their heart's content. It's their game, and they're not affecting anyone else's experience - why not let them play it how they want? And why even include that cheat if you're going to punish people who use it?
Given that this "feature" was erased from the Xbox Live edition of Banjo Kazooie, it's clear Rare came to feel the same way. Small comfort for those N64 players who incurred Grunty's wrath, though...
7. Killing Yourself To Beat The Game - Imscared
After that impromptu trilogy of Nintendo games, we now move to a *checks list* pentalogy of indies.
Which makes sense. Independent games have always been a breeding ground for unconventional ideas, so it makes sense they'd make up a good chunk of this list. And Imscared is nothing if not unconventional.
Developer Ivan Zanotti's 2012 horrorwork sees players pursued by the grinning ghoul White Face (pictured above). White Face is portrayed as a malevolent entity that has literally possessed the player's computer, and the developer fully commits to the bit by having White Face communicate with the player outside the game.
This trick is done by creating fake files in the game directory, which the player must manipulate to make progress. Unfortunately, no amount of file manipulation can restore your save game after you reach the true ending.
Said ending is reached by having the player character commit suicide to escape White Face's grasp. Which is bleak enough, but to really hammer the message home Imscared doesn't just wreck your saves but the game itself, crashing to desktop whenever you try to play it again.
Bleak stuff, then. But if you try to mess around with the files one last time, a message from Zanotti himself appears, essentially saying the game is over, thank you for playing and "You're great and so is your life! Don't commit suicide, okay? I love you :)"
Very nice, very evil. Truly the Danhausen of developers.
6. Killing Every NPC And Breaking The Game - Undertale
Toby Fox's Undertale was released in 2015 to great acclaim, with its combination of memorable characters, cheeky fourth wall breaks and belting tunes winning the hearts of many a player. It also won plaudits for putting traditional video game morality under a microscope, as seen in its now notorious Genocide Route.
Much as the label suggests, the Genocide Route invokes the spirit of Emperor Palpatine by asking the player to "Wipe them out. All of them", the "them" in this case being the game's cast of monsters. Once you go down this path of overkill, the game's save points start displaying the number of monsters left in each region, tacitly encouraging the player to hunt down and slaughter them.
Do so, however, and the game locks you out from replaying it. As Chara - the game's omniscient narrator - puts it, there's no-one left to go back to.
Erk.
Fortunately, if you wait 10 minutes Chara offers to restore your saves and let you try again. The cost? "Your human soul".
Now, obviously we have no way of knowing if Toby Fox is actually harvesting the souls of his audience. But, years from now, when you slip free of your mortal shackles and enter the gates of Valhalla, see if you can find a video game developer surrounded by subservient thralls bound to his every whim. That'll be Toby Fox, luxuriating in the triumph of his evil scheme.
5. Miss Your Shot And The Whole Game Dies - OneShot
Much like Undertale's Genocide Route, OneShot makes its intent known through its label.
OneShot is a̶ ̶v̶i̶d̶e̶o̶ ̶g̶a̶m̶e̶ ̶a̶d̶a̶p̶t̶a̶t̶i̶o̶n̶ ̶o̶f̶ ̶8̶ ̶M̶i̶l̶e̶ a game that tasks the player with guiding a child called Niko to save their world. And you really do only get one shot at it in the original version - leave before reaching the first save point, and the game would refuse to load again, flat out stating "You killed Niko".
You monster.
Fortunately, the updated Steam version is more lenient in this regard, allowing players to pick up where they left off. To compensate though, it does pull off one more piece of save-related trickery.
Upon completing the game for the first time, the game pulls the now-familiar trick of locking the player out of their savegame. To play again, you have to go to the game's .exe file and remove a file in the same folder to continue. This lets you load up a new game plus, and carry on to the game's true ending.
4. A Game Where You Destroy Your Own Personal Files - Lose/Lose
Between OneShot and Imscared, indies seem to have a thing for making file deletion a key game mechanic. Lose/Lose takes this idea to its logical extreme.
Lose/Lose is a shoot-'em-up that tasks the player with manning a spaceship and vanquishing a horde of alien invaders. So far so video games, but Lose/Lose ups the stakes considerably higher than your average shooter. If you are killed, the game deletes itself from your hard drive, forcing you to start over. Which isn't too bad, as it's a meagre download and a score attack game to boot.
What's worse is when you win.
Lose/Lose's USP (Unbelievably Stupid Premise) is that every alien in the game represents an actual file on your computer. Kill the alien, and the file is deleted permanently. Photos, word documents, or even System32 itself - all cattle in the slaughterhouse that is Lose/Lose.
A game that deletes its own save files may be regarded as genius - a game that deletes others looks like madness.
3. The Game That Erases Itself - Killswitch
What could be more potent than a game that deletes itself when you die? A game that not only pulls the same trick, but erases itself so thoroughly that no-one is sure if it ever really existed!
Killswitch was a side-scrolling point-'n'-clicker in which players had to guide a woman called Porto through an undead-infested mine. There was also a demon called Ghast, who was literally impossible to control as he was completely invisible.
And that's not even the weirdest thing about the game. Allegedly, once Killswitch was completed, the game would not only uninstall itself, but wipe out every file so thoroughly that there was no way to retrieve them again - "One and Done" in its purest form.
Given the game's prevalence on sites like CreepyPasta, it's easy to believe that the game never really existed in the first place. Yet it does, indisputably, linger on in some form - Kotaku even played through it - although that was likely a fan recreation inspired by the original myth.
That's Killswitch: a game that erased itself - a game that may never have been real in the first place - forced to live on through its fans.
*cue Alanis Morissette*
2. Can You Sacrifice Your Own Save? - NieR Replicant Ver. 1.22474487139...
Rounding off the list, we have the NieR duology! (Which kind of spoils what the no.1 entry will be, but oh well).
Replicant, the first game in the NieR saga, contains one of the most well-known examples of save-screwing in video games. To summarize: after completing the game again...and again...and again...the protagonist is finally within touching distance of his goal - a cure for his sister's terminal illness.
The catch? To attain it, he must sacrifice everything. And by "everything", the game means "all your save data".
We'll give the developers credit: it's certainly a memorable dilemma. Which means more to the player: The life of the digital child they've purportedly been playing the game to save, or the real-world hours they spent in pursuit of that goal? Because once those saves are gone, they're gone for good.
Or at least, that was the case.
In the recent remake, the developers evoked the spirit of Steve Jobs and added "One More Thing..." - a chance to regain your saves through one final playthrough.
It's certainly a lot more hopeful than the original game's downer ending, and echoes developer Yoko Taro's increasingly optimistic world view. A view best encapsulated in...
1. Becoming Something Greater - Nier: Automata
...the best end credits in all of video games.
NieR Automata's end credits have gone down as a seminal moment in gaming history, and for good reason - no other game has made such a poignant, triumphant statement about the power of the human spirit. (Yes, we know how hyperbolic that sounds, but trust us - no one who experiences Automata's credits walks away unaffected).
Automata ends with one final choice - to complete an impossible shoot-em-up to save the lives of the main characters, or to give up in the face of failure (And the insane difficulty means you will fail). Choose to persevere, and the developers assist you with a squadron of ships to up your firepower & act as much-needed bullet shields.
The catch? Each ship in the squadron is created from the save files of other players, who deleted their saves to give you a chance to succeed. Once you reach the end, you are given the same chance to help others, at the same cost. Given what you've just experienced (and it really is an experience), only the most churlish would refuse.
tl;dr - "I regained my faith in humanity, and all it cost me was a lousy save file".