12 Most Disastrously Disappointing Video Game Launches In History

"Server connection failed, please try again"

Microsoft/Comcept/Warner Bros./EA

I'd go as far as saying 2016 is the best year for gaming this generation, and that's a damn good thing, because until the last half-year or so, the 'next generation of console hardware' was a laughing stock. Half-baked game engines, character models falling apart - and the worst part?

Even the developers and publishers didn't have the answers.

Like the gaming equivalent of buying a car, having it break down and seeing the supplier shrug their shoulders, far too many of us were left completely out in the open, our empty wallets flapping in the breeze.

Sometimes, naff software is just the beginning of a media sh*tstorm surrounding a given game, and these 10 entries remain the most egregious examples of all involved dropping the ball, before rolling it away and forgetting it existed in the first place.

12. Halo: The Master Chief Collection

halo master chief collection
Microsoft/343 Industries

Did you know that to date, regardless of the fact Halo's Master Chief Collection came out in 2014, it still doesn't work?

Sure, you can hop online and eventually get a match after waiting upwards of five solid minutes in a queue, but at launch that would routinely fail altogether. Even now the game might simply forget to tell you this, as it sits there on a nebulous "Looking for matches" prompt.

It's testament to just how ruddy much people LOVE Halo, that this somehow didn't result in a court case at launch. At this stage, developers 343 Industries have moved on entirely to Halo 5, its microtransaction-encouraging REQ system positively raking in the cash.

There's no incentive for them ever to deliver on what should've been the finest multiplayer package of all time (seriously, you can hop between all four games' maps in massive online playlists), and instead, Master Chief's legacy lies broken and tattered, a testament to the overarching pursuit of financial gain over all else.


11. Batman: Arkham Knight (PC Version)

batman arkham knight
Warner Bros

Speaking of companies that move on after realising something is too broken to fix, Warner Bros. pilfered the living daylights out of Rocksteady's runaway success with Arkham, first siphoning off costumes for DLC in Arkham City, and then entire levels for Arkham Knight.

The result was a game that had the best intentions ("Be the Batman"), yet due to the 'need' for every major platform to be serviced, a PC version was also on the cards - despite Rocksteady prioritising consoles.

As such, the PS4 and Xbox One versions ran like a dream, but the PC... well...

Batman Arkham Knight glitch
Rocksteady

Not so much.

To this day, you can't get a PC copy of Arkham Knight that's guaranteed to run smoothly, due to a ton of errors Warner Bros./Rocksteady simply stopped fixing.

Their last act of defeat was resorting to offering refunds for all PC players in November 2015, because they'd literally given up. How's that for customer service?


10. Mighty No. 9

mighty no 9
Comcept

Perhaps you can scratch off the 'disappointing' part of this entry, as from the initial "HOLY BALLS THAT'S AN AMAZING IDEA" to the "...Why is he starting other Kickstarter projects?" comments that framed Keiji Inafune's 'return' to the Mega Man series, it went from bad to worse - and from worse to insulting.

There's always a risk when backing a project on Kickstarter, as you're ostensibly paying for a job before it's done. And can you honestly say you'd try as hard in your current position, if you'd already reaped the rewards? Exactly.

Such was part of the case with Mighty No.9, as developers Comcept just didn't know when to say no. The game raised almost four million dollars after an initial ask of $900k, and that prompted them to plan a release cycle aroundevery console on the market.

The result was a ludicrously amateurish affair. Graphics were positively prehistoric, the tone of the launch trailer insulted the fanbase by going down the outdated, 90s-esque "nerds are virgins" route, and even Inafune's final words were that the game was "better than nothing."

The sad thing is... it wasn't.


9. Assassin's Creed: Unity

assassin's creed unity
Ubisoft

Hands up - how can you tell when even a developer admits they shipped a game too early?

Yes, "When there's a 'day one patch' they insist you download" is a good shout, but in Assassin's Creed: Unity's case, it was replacing the entire game on the hard drives of all Xbox One owners.

Indeed, after a month of apologies and quick-fixes, Ubisoft eventually issued a 40gb patch, effectively reinstalling the retail version of Unity with the now functional one.

Or rather, they released what we would have gotten and been far happier with, if Ubi had held off greasing their palms for a month.


8. Battlefield 4

Battlefield 4 Problem
EA DICE

As a launch game for both the PS4 and Xbox One, EA DICE's malformed baby bore the brunt of the 'next generation' of hype - which is to say, "We'd paid hundreds for these shiny new systems, and were suitably peed off that they didn't do much."

But Battlefield 4's qualms weren't just teething issues, they were full-blown haymakers, shattering its pearly whites across the parking lot. Single player campaign progress would randomly delete itself, online matches would drop out or not connect whatsoever, entire 64 player battles would crash depending on 'set-pieces' in the world triggering - and the best (worst) bit?

EA even acknowledged their failings, with EA's Andrew Wilson quite frankly admitting that the entire debacle was "unacceptable."

Live and learn, EA. Live and learn.


7. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 ending
Bioware

One of the most infamous examples of public outcry following a game's launch, Mass Effect 3 went down about as well as bacon-scented bath bombs on a vegan honeymoon.

People (read: everyone) were p*ssed, the result seeing thousands of fans who felt completely betrayed by the game's finale taking to Consumerist's online pole and voting EA the "Worst Company in the World."

The larger issue came from the huge disparity between pre-release interviews and real-world execution, as the developers seemed to be painting a completely different version of Mass Effect 3 than we actually got.

A rather incendiary forum post entitled "Bioware's lies condensed" can be read over here, but sufficed to say if you've played ME3, the following pre-release quotes from Associate Producer Mike Gamble will make your blood boil:

“There are many different endings. We wouldn’t do it any other way. How could you go through all three campaigns playing as your Shepard and then be forced into a bespoke ending that everyone gets?""Every decision you've made will impact how things go [...] You'll get answers to everything [...] Because a lot of these plot threads are concluding and because it's being brought to a finale, since you were a part of architecting how they got to how they were, you will definitely sense how they close was because of the decisions you made and because of the decisions you didn't make”

Bioware eventually caved and released free DLC entitled the "Extended Cut" to placate those who wanted further explanation for the randomly celestial way ME3 went, but the damage was done. Mass Effect 3's launch period and subsequent months were dogged by negative press, and the series had to go dark for years, just to escape the volleys of arrows being sent its way.


6. Watch Dogs

watch dogs
Ubisoft

You can't talk about anything being disappointing or disastrous, and not mention Watch Dogs.

Ubisoft's tagline for the entire project was "The next generation starts here", and you can pretty much blame this single title for the overwhelmingly "meh" reaction to the new hardware overall. After all, people were pinning all their hopes on Ubisoft's Assassin's Creed followup as some all-singing, all-wish granting concoction of pure joyous escapism, so when it fell short of even being a decent, fun game, the pitchforks came out in full.

Mostly though, this all centred around graphics, and the fact the game had changed considerably since its first unveiling at E3 2012.

It didn't help that Ubi had left the unused render files (which drastically and instantly increased the visual quality) intact on the PC version, meaning modders restored them with a click, and proved the game worked totally fine in this higher-res state.

Caught out by their own fans and unable to adequately clarify why this was the case other than "optimisation", Watch Dogs went down in history as one of the most disappointing games of all time.


5. Driveclub

Driveclub ps4
Sony Computer Entertainment

Remember Driveclub? If you do, those memories are probably focused around its godawful launch window, as oppose to weighty gameplay and incredible weather effects.

Alas, developers Evolution Studios attempted to roll it out in 2014, touting Driveclub as an 'always-connected' experience featuring communities, leaderboards - you know how it goes.

Naturally, with so much server strain across the globe, it tanked, but the strange part was Evolution simply didn't know why - only managing to state that the game was very ambitious, and the resulting fallout "certainly wasn’t any ill-intention on behalf of the team".

driveclub server error
Sony

The pre-announced PS Plus version was delayed for months until Evolution were "comfortable", and PlayStation UK boss, Fergal Gara said he and the team were "embarrassed" by everything that had occurred.

The final straw was Sony shutting down Evolution altogether (you can draw your own conclusions as to why), but thankfully they were picked up by Codemasters in April 2016, so greener pastures should eventually be around the corner.


4. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5

Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5
Robomodo

There was a glimmer of hope for this, you know. Back when it was first leak-announced on Twitter, when Tony Hawk was reappearing and when the idea of a 'return to its roots' THPS masked the fact that developers Robomodo also released the shoddy Tony Hawk's Ride and Shred, yes, there was some hope.

Then it released, and...

tony hawk's pro skater 5
Activision

Hmm, not putting your best foot forward there, Hawkster.

Sadly for all involved, THPS 5 was an absolute disaster on all fronts. Releasing in a state that felt like a conceptual alpha or a copycat developer attempting to make a Tony Hawk's game from the early 2000s, even core gameplay didn't have the requisite signature feel we associated with the franchise.

It played bad and looked worse, with Robomodo eventually issuing an 8gb patch that added extra levels and skaters, almost as though the game had been released early - a theory supported by that fact that Activision's deal with the titular star expired right around its launch window.

Nothing like taking the money and running, eh, Activision?


3. Diablo III

Diablo iii 3
Blizzard

Diablo 3's horrendous launch was testament to two immortal truths: 1. No server-dependent game will EVER work on its midnight launch, and 2. The internet will always make memes of even the most stressful of things, if only as a coping mechanism.

Thus, you've mostly seen a ton of GIFs more often than any gameplay footage for Diablo III, but such was the excitement around the return of one of gaming's most beloved franchises, that the 'day one blues' set in hard.

Problem was, not only could we not get connected to Blizzard's servers for co-op/multiplayer sessions, but the single player was locked out, too. Ostensibly fans had bought high-priced paperweights and chunks of data with no purpose, the now-infamous 'Error 3007' sending shivers up our collective spines to this day.

Blizzard took it on the chin and profusely apologised, saying they felt "sh*tty" for letting people down, going on to say,

“Even our most outlandish estimates for day one, ended up being massively conservative in reality. And it hurt – people had been waiting for ten years to play this game, and the worse fear of an always-online game, is not being able to play. That’s exactly what happened.”

Thankfully, although it still had a bit of a rocky start, Overwatch launched far smoother in May of 2016.


2. SimCity (2013)

SimCity Fail
EA

Proof that even after Diablo 3's landmark face-plant, you can always leave it up to EA to not learn a damn thing. SimCity was set to be another landmark franchise revival, until the dreaded "Always-connected universe!" buzz-phrase came in, and suddenly we were all more than a little apprehensive.

Cut to launch day and the above image was what everyonewas seeing, coupled with the fact that there was no offline mode whatsoever. SimCity's entire hook is debating precisely how to build your own custom metropolis, and it was abundantly clear that the notion of having this omnipresent multiplayer component was a hindrance, rather than an luxurious extra.

In the end, it took a solid week to even let you get into the game, a state of affairs that EA themselves labelled as "dumb", before handing out free copies of their other games to - and I quote - "get back in your good graces".

The fact we've literally heard nothing in the way of sequels proves this didn't work, and instead it was 2015's superb Cities: Skylines that finally gave empire-builders the game they'd been waiting for.


1. Godus

godus game
22cans

The most royal balls up of all time, Peter Molyneux's return to self-popularised 'God simulators' like Populous and Black & White was Godus, a Kickstarter game twinned with a mobile app.

Said app challenged all to slowly erode an onscreen cube, with the reward for the person who hit the core being a role in the game - God himself - alongside a share of the profits. Another "Yes, really", as Molyneux talked only in vagaries, discussing words like "power" and "responsibility", whilst not following through on any of them.

Godus launched in Early Access only for Molyneux to move onto other projects, leaving the community around the game to step in and attempt to get it running. One Konrad Naszynski actually landed a job on staff thanks to the dev team being so tiny, and after months of trying to do right by the fans (the opposite of what studio 22cans had done), eventually left in June, 2016.

As for the person who won the 'Godus app challenge', Bryan Henderson, you can read the disheartening account of his interaction with 22cans on Eurogamer, but it amounted to playing Godus "for three hours straight", before the developers tried to get him drunk at a local pub.

If you're looking for some semblance of justice for all that squandered cash and all those broken promises, there's an absolutely scathing Rock, Paper, Shotgun interview, where the opening question immediately calls Molyneux a "pathological liar", but sufficed to say, Godus was a hot mess even before the heat got turned up.

--

What's the worst game launch in history? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.