20 Most Underrated Video Games Of 2016

The best year so far this generation, but what's the cream of the crop?

Underrated 2016 video games
Microsoft/The Game Bakers/Telltale/D-Pad

It's taken three years, but the games industry finally back to firing on all cylinders. Sure, we've still got microtransactions, season passes and one hell of a sequel problem, but you need only take a look at the bonafide triple-A titles that have peppered each month from January to now, to see a sharp contrast with that of 2014 and 2015.

From Overwatch to DOOM, Uncharted 4 to Ratchet & Clank, chances are you could name a good 10 titles off the top of your head that would slip into a nice Game of the Year list - but what of those that didn't get as much exposure or wide recognition?

Let me know your own most underrated gems of 2016 in the comments below, and see if you agree with my 20 picks too.

--

20. Batman: The Telltale Series

telltale batman
DC

By adding in the quintessential 'Batman ingredient' missing from the Arkham titles, Telltale have managed to deliver the perfect Batman experience in a manner you probably didn't see coming.

That being? Bruce Wayne.

Relegated to minor cutscene appearances or omitted entirely in past titles centred around The Dark Knight, Telltale put the false smiles and high-life of being a playboy billionaire right up there with donning the cape and cowl. In doing so, it grounds the idea of Batman as a character and as an entity, showing the immediate pros and cons of living the double life.

You'll shake hands as the innocent Bruce, before following up with a few bone-breaks as Bats, allowing for the unique sense of answering someone whilst keeping in mind what will transpire once you have access to a full array of gadgets.

Simply because of that - and with Telltale's scribes taking some major risks with the established Batman canon - this incarnation of the Bat is the most interesting in years.


19. Gears Of War 4

Gears of war 4
The Coalition

For whatever reason - mostly the ditching of beloved main character, Marcus Fenix - Gears 4 pretty much came and went, despite being a brilliant The Force Awakens/Creed-style segue of old into new.

Playing this time as Marcus' son, JD Fenix, gameplay is everything you already know and love from Gears, with a couple of updated animations to speed things up. Now you're free to leap over cover and perform an instant-finisher to staggered enemies - and that's on top of the standard array of fatality-style moves you can pull off on downed foes.

Over-shoulder shooting, meaty weapons, chainsaws and a ton of gruff one-liners, Gears 4 has some of the strongest set-pieces in the franchise's history, topped off by a gruffer and more "Totally done with this sh*t" Marcus Fenix and the best graphics on Xbox One.

Gears 4 simply doesn't deserve to become another forgotten sequel like Judgment, and justly deserves your full attention.


18. Hitman

hitman japan hokkaido
IO Interactive

Initially seeing its reputation hampered by releasing in monthly instalments, IO Interactive used this extended development time to deliver what is honestly the best Hitman you'll ever play.

Levels are miniature worlds of A.I. scripts and intertwining animations, the sheer breadth of which should see Bethesda quaking in their boots. IO even listened to the complainers from years gone by too, smoothing over how the series' iconically over-the-top kills get triggered to make them more obvious - if you so choose.

Now, with a revamped step-by-step system easing you into taking out targets in the most ridiculous and impressive way possible, IO have managed to strike a perfect balance between making a Hitman for the hardcore and the newcomers, the final missing ingredient that elevates the series into quite possibly the finest stealth experience of the decade so far.


17. SUPERHOT

Superhot game
Superhot Team

This'll be in the running for Game of the Year as we near the close of 2016 (check back on the Gaming section going forward for that), but for now, it's worth highlighting the genre-progressing SUPERHOT as a supremely underrated title, too.

Going with the idea of "time only moving when you do", SUPERHOT is a gateway into reliving every last one of your Matrix-born fantasies from the Wachowski's first masterpiece. You'll stand still and watch time slow to a crawl before edging the analogue stick forward and ducking under bullets, returning fire with perfect precision before leaping into the air and grabbing another opponent's wayward kitana, finishing your run by cleaving the final foe in two.

It's as butter-smooth as that sounds, with all the sound effects and proficient control schemes to back it up. SUPERHOT f*cking owns, and I recommend you give it a shot as soon as possible.


16. Deus Ex GO

Deus Ex GO
Square Enix

Of all the 'GO'-named games this year, it's Square Enix's latest that deserves lasting attention. Not knocking the mighty, flash-in-the-pan Pokémon GO, but Squenix Montreal's puzzle-based adaptations of the publisher's many iconic franchises continue to excel.

Building on the grid-based foundations of Hitman GO and Lara Croft GO, Deus Ex introduces many more elements centred around planning two, three, four steps ahead, you'll slowly learn the perfect path through a number of expertly crafted levels.

There's always the big-budget Deus Ex: Mankind Divided if you want your face-stabbing to be way more visceral, but when it comes to the age-old satisfaction of seeing a plan come together, it's this smaller incarnation that truly excels.


15. Furi

Furi game
The Game Bakers

Every now and then, there exists a game that really tests a player's mettle. For the majority of the decade it was the Dark Souls series (and Dark Souls III also came out this year), but there's one smaller-budget game that'll challenge every fibre of your primal cortex: Furi.

A timing and reaction-based top-down shooter that doubles as a side-on fighting game when you deal enough damage to a foe, Furi is a series of boss battles set across an epic, stylised sci-fi landscape.

Developers The Game Bakers give you a handful of moves including sword-swipes, dodges and gun-blasts, all of which can be charged for more offensive/defensive options. As the game ranks up the difficulty considerably, you'll need to genuinely perfect how to use and combine these moves to make it through.

It'll try and test your patience, break you down and beat you into the ground, but overcoming Furi is one of the most satisfying and personally rewarding titles you can ever experience.


14. Owlboy

Owlboy Setup Free Download
D-Pad Studio

Across 2014 and 2015 we were all getting a bit sick of 'side-scrolling pixel platformers' - and even if you still are, I guarantee there's room for the luxurious Owlboy.

2016's critical darling by a landslide, everything from the stunning, laboriously hand-painted backgrounds to the loveably old-school cast of characters elevates Owlboy into the same territory as a Chrono Trigger or a Shovel Knight - simply an inviting world of passionate execution you'll want to get lost in at every turn.

Gameplay-wise you'll alternate between flying and picking up a number of characters that all come with bonus abilities - many of them projectile-related. Ostensibly it allows Owlboy to transition between platformer and twin-stick shooter every few moments, itself being a game mechanic that highlights the fluidity and effortlessly playable nature of everything on display.


13. Fire Emblem: Fates

fire emblem fates
Nintendo

If you like your combat and strategy turn-based, look no further than the Fire Emblem series.

Whereas the home console market has access to the mighty genre king, XCOM 2, the 3DS exclusive Fire Emblem takes the idea of strategic turn-based gameplay and injects it with a story more reminiscent of a Saturday morning anime.

It all helps fuel the stakes of each battle, as whilst every step of a bout matters in gameplay terms, backing that with a cast of characters you'd like to see make it out alive makes every encounter stupidly intense. Fates actually released as two separate stories depending on which warring faction you wanted to side with, reconciling for a concluding chapter named Revelations that ties everything back together.

All of this results in a TON of content if you want the full Fates experience - perfect for playing in short chunks, - especially if you can free up the time on a regular basis.


12. The Banner Saga 2

The Banner Saga 2
Stoic

Think Game of Thrones' gritty, death-is-everywhere tone and match it to a more fantastical backdrop - one filled with world-ending serpents and hulking giant races struggling to make peace with 'lowly humans' that require their help to make it out alive.

That's The Banner Saga in a nutshell, and after a stellar first instalment, this eventual trilogy landed a sequel in 2016 that carried on its epic story perfectly. The art style tends to be one of the major driving forces behind a recommendation too, as developer Stoic co-founder Arnie Jorgensen has teamed up with Igor Artyomenko to really prioritise the game's visual identity.

Thankfully, The Banner Saga 2 isn't just a pretty face, its combat centring on the unique idea of your health bar matching your attack power, before balancing it with a separate defence stat for armour. Attacking a foe's health directly means attacks get absorbed, or you can chip away at their defences and risk more powerful attacks in return.

Together it's a very neat way to rework an otherwise standard strategy formula, providing the foundation for The Banner Saga 2's direction, and elevating it as one of 2016's finest.


11. Unravel

unravel game
ColdWood Interactive

Physics-based platformers are a dime a dozen these days, but sometimes you'll find one with real heart; real passion behind its design.

That game is Unravel, and whilst EA didn't do the kindhearted developer Coldwood Interactive any favours by bringing them onstage during an otherwise sports and action-focussed E3 presentation in 2015, the final game has an instant sense of lovability that could win over even the most stone-hearted of gamers.

Literally the tale of a ball of yarn coming to life and leaving an old grandmother's house in the woods, the sheer visual delight of climbing trees, riding the occasional fish and frolicking with other wildlife is charming as hell.

If you're looking for the digital embodiment of "D'awww", it's right here.


10. Watch Dogs 2

Watch Dogs 2
Ubisoft

Watch Dogs 2's impact on the gaming sphere was like a mouse farting in the distance, its sales dropping off a staggering 80% from the original.

Such statistics are testament to the power of consumers voting with their wallets, yet what Ubisoft have done here is 'another Assassin's Creed II'. Which is to say, they fixed everything people didn't like about the original and course-corrected to the point where Watch Dogs' world and game mechanics are actually pretty damn enjoyable.

You'll infiltrate all manner of high-tech compounds, deploy drones to explore and play with enemy A.I. in equal measure, take selfies at the most inopportune/opportune times - all whilst some pretty solid and genuinely funny dialogue fleshes out a world of hackers around you.

If you can find it cheap, Watch Dogs 2 is everything the original should've been, and then some.


9. Mafia III

mafia 3 III
2K

Say what you like about how repetitive Mafia III's combat becomes in the long run - it easily has some of the finest third-person shooting of any open-world crime game.

You'll bludgeon enemies with brutally effective melee attacks, pop headshots from afar, call in hit-squads and even have a mobile armoury on-hand to restock and change your loadout at any point.

The story is one of the most innovative in all of gaming, and the world design overall contains one of the most impressive showcases of a particular time period since GTA: Vice City.

It's a shame the balance of things to do falls a little too much towards gunplay, but if that aspect of the experience clicks, Mafia III might be your new favourite crime game of choice.


8. Headlander

Headlander game
Double Fine

From the masterminds over at Double Fine (who you can thank for everything from Psychonauts to Broken Age), Headlander is a Metroidvania-style side-on action adventure with a concept you just wouldn't get anywhere else.

Playing as a random disembodied head - complete with rocket boosters - you'll alternate between docking with a variety of bodies (everything from gun-happy guards to tiny dogs and random dancers) to flying around various environments yourself, the gameplay being a tight mix of shooting and light puzzle-solving.

It all takes place under a brilliantly enjoyable 60s psychedelia backdrop, mixing wakka-wakka guitar music with disco balls and lava lamps - a recipe that's every bit as enjoyable to play as it is to imagine.


7. The Witness

the witness
Thekla Inc.

Regardless of whether or not you 'got' what developer Jonathan Blow was going for in his latest masterwork, you at least have to be grateful that gaming as a medium can birth something as wildly original as The Witness in the first place.

Basically, the game serves as the digital embodiment of how we process and understand knowledge - shown through a variety of symbols and their utilisation on a simplistic puzzle interface. See, you'll have to pilot a dot from one side of a square to the other, but once you factor in what the symbols mean and how they relate to one another - something that happens naturally, without any tutorialisation - you'll slowly start to 'read' each puzzle like a language.

Think Matrix code, and how that movie's hackers could look at it and know exactly what was going on, and you're pretty much there. The Witness is an astounding achievement regardless of how much you like brain-breaking puzzles, and should be commended as such.


6. No Man's Sky

No Mans Sky Foundation
Hello Games

*deflects incoming spear*

There's nothing left to say about how No Man's Sky launched - in fact, it might be the single-most disastrous and most negative game launch in history.

However, firstly, it just wasn't anywhere near as bad as people were saying (the procedurally-generated universe was pretty epic to explore) and second, The Foundation Update that added base-building, quests, a revamped graphics engine and purchasable freighters to bomb around in, adds almost every last thing developer Sean Murray lied about that was missing at launch.

From the brilliantly harsh and immersive Survival Mode to dogfighting between asteroids, mining for better suit components or just seeing what the game's algorithms throw your way, No Man's Sky has a ton to offer... if you'll only give it a chance.


5. Firewatch

Firewatch 2
Campo Santo

Essentially to 2016 what Gone Home was to 2013, Campo Santo - a developer made up of ex-Telltale/The Walking Dead developers - turned in a brilliant tale of isolation and retrospection, all centred around how we deal with life's hardships.

Do we run from them, embrace them? What happens if it's the former, and how can that come back around in time?

Such concepts ended up seeing a ton of critics and consumers dissatisfied with how Firewatch wraps up, but if you're along for a ride of glum reality and philosophical pondering amidst the gorgeous, sun-kissed Wyoming wilderness, it's absolutely stunning.


4. Monster Hunter: Generations

monster hunter generations
Capcom

One of the most addictive gameplay loops you can ever experience, Monster Hunter's streamlined approach in this 2016 incarnation is the most accessible yet.

Bolstering its standard "Bigger monsters, better loot" ideology with a refined camera system and a ton of one-tap special attacks, it's easier than ever to settle into an immersive rhythm of picking a quest or two, downing a hearty meal to boost your stats and journeying out to take down whatever screen-sized behemoth is looming on the horizon.

Before long you'll be crafting all sorts of weapons, armour and items from your downed enemies too, resulting in kitanas forged from jawlines or shoulder pads that match the skulls of whatever enemy was unlucky enough to get in your way the day before.

Seriously, there's nothing more freakin' badass than striding into battle with equipment built from the harvested corpses of your most fearsome foes.

Over to you, Horizon: Zero Dawn...


3. ReCore

ReCore game
Microsoft

For better or worse, the games industry very rarely make games like ReCore. Its primitive animations, basic cutscenes and minimal exposition are a welcome throwback to the likes of the PS3 shooter, or even the halcyon days of the PS1, when reduced game budgets allowed a far greater array of ideas to get greenlit by publishers.

Indeed, ReCore is hampered by a litany of issues from falling-through-the-floor glitches to straight-up muddy textures, but its gameplay as a lock-on shooter with a focus on loot-grabbing and customisation is still worth a look. You'll roam the open-world, gather up all sorts of materials for your array of A.I. companions, and swap out their personality-driven 'Cores' into different chassis, resulting in a great feeling of progression alongside the tactile and feedback-heavy shooting mechanics.

It's not polished, it's not a triple-A system-seller, but if you're anything of a 90s gamer or someone who adored older consoles for the sheer breadth of what was on offer, ReCore is a weirdly nostalgic throwback that actually works.


2. The Last Guardian

The Last Guardian
Team ICO

10 years in development... almost zero hype outside of those who've been waiting all this time.

Yet, Director Fumito Ueda and his crew over at Team ICO knew exactly what they were doing. The Last Guardian is unapologetically non-mainstream: There are barely any tutorial prompts, zero 'vision modes' to tell you where to go - just zero help whatsoever. It's you and your bird-dog-cat-thing from beginning to end, but that's what makes the experience so refreshing and ultimately, so preciously memorable.

Hands-down, Trico is the best animal that's ever been in a game, period. His inquisitive animations and improvisational animations help create the 'illusion' that this is a real beast you're dealing with - one that'll look out for itself, call after you and occasionally misinterpret your commands along the way.

The latter has provided a lot of negativity to those who'd prefer the game was more streamlined (and that's fair), but for those moments when your own primitive thoughts match up to that of Trico's, there's nothing quite as special as The Last Guardian.


1. Titanfall 2

Titanfall 2
Respawn Entertainment

By far and away, the finest video game of the year that nowhere near enough people are playing is Titanfall 2.

Released in a dreadful place, slap-bang in the middle of Battlefield 1 and Call of Duty (literally, the week in between the two), it goes without saying that some of the biggest-selling franchises in gaming history maxed out many peoples' spending limits, leaving little behind for Respawn's (infinitely better) shooter to claim.

And that's a crying shame, because from some of the most innovative first-person shooter levels in history (one that sees you hop between multiple timelines at will, the other a shootout taking place inside an assembly line of moving houses), Respawn's pedigree as a team made up of ex-Infinity War guys shines through.

Titanfall 2 is everything you want out of an FPS, and its frenetic, mech-fuelled multiplayer is some of the most rewarding and tactile you can play - a far cry from the twitch-based likes of the competition.

--

What's your most underrated game of 2016? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.