8 Times Video Games Proved You Wrong

Surprising games and sequels that blew you away - Mortal Kombat, DOOM, Batman...

mortal kombat scorpion
NetherRealm

Expectations and hype make or break most games. While recently we're seeing out of nowhere titles completely dominate - your Fall Guys', your Among Us' - the majority of bigger budget games put millions of dollars into sizeable cross-media advertising campaigns, then essentially sit back and hope for the best.

Obviously we all have endless examples of being disappointed or misled, but what about the opposite? What about genuinely surprising efforts that didn't necessarily come out of nowhere, but left you feeling impressed; as though you haven't got this crazy industry we call gaming all figured out?

What about those times you went into a game thinking you knew exactly what was coming - only to be pleasantly surprised?

Those are the real rarities, especially if you've grown up alongside gaming from at least the early 2000s, as it takes quite a lot to impress us at this stage.

Gaming forever loves to play its cards close to a collective chest, but sometimes that results in an even more powerful sense of memorability.


8. Batman: Arkham Asylum

Batman arkham asylum
Rocksteady

There was a time before Arkham Asylum, when superhero games - and especially Batman games - weren't held up as anything close to true greats.

Yes, I love the original Batman Begins game as much as the next guy and Batman & Robin's 2D animation was phenomenal in 1994, but there was a whole decade plus-long period where Bat fans had to made do with the likes of Batman: Vengeance or Batman: Gotham City Racer.

Cut to 2009 and as a deal to make a Dark Knight tie-in game fell through, Warner Bros. turned to a bunch of complete nobodies as a way to still get something turned around featuring the Caped Crusader, for a much smaller budget.

The rest was obviously history, but Arkham Asylum didn't just tick the box of being a solid action game. It invented a combat system the competition would ape across the entire eighth generation, taking lessons from Metroidvanias that kept level design fresh and rewards genuinely worth seeking out.


7. Mortal Kombat (2011)

mortal kombat 9
NetherRealm

Saying Mortal Kombat is anything other than a reliable IP in 2021 might seem crazy, but across the 2000s - and despite how much hardcore fans like me still cherish the likes of MK Apocalypse's kart racing mode - the franchise was struggling.

Churned out releases with increasingly terrible new characters meant interest in the brand was waning, and after MK vs DC forwent all fatalities for an admittedly charming but toothless title, Midway were forced to file for bankruptcy in 2009.

Thankfully, Ed Boon and co. were snapped up by Warner Bros, and given the time to truly calculate one hell of a comeback.

2011 saw a revitalised Mortal Kombat invent a whole new way - and arguably THE way - to do a story mode in a fighting game. Centred around revisiting the original three 2D games from a new perspective, it was the perfect way to pay tribute to what went before, while forging a new path and perspective for the future.

Not to mention, fatalities were back and featured some of the most gruesome body horror in entertainment history, while combat was tighter and more satisfying than ever.

Since then, MK has gone from strength to strength, with Mortal Kombat 11 being the most successful instalment yet. A barrage of DLC and platform-for-content plans show no signs of slowing down.


6. Dying Light

Dying Light
Techland

After Dead Island, the gaming community was hurting. We all got swept up in that gloriously emotional trailer about the little girl and her family being overrun by zombies on holiday, and we were all subsequently let down by a shockingly basic final product with all the impact of a thrown cushion.

In hindsight it's pretty clear Dead Island was never going to be something like The Last of Us, but Techland as a studio ambled towards half-sequel Riptide, before taking three years off to come back in force with Dying Light.

To so many people though, Dying Light was to be avoided; endemic of not only the fact Techland's reputation was in the toilet, but that first-person platforming was a failed experiment VERY rarely done right.

Play Dying Light today though - especially The Following re-release and expansion - and it was a whole other story. An awesome day/night cycle changed enemy behaviours mid-mission, unlockables included a freakin' dropkick to clear out crowds, and the first-person parkour we were all so afraid of?

It became the benchmark for all vertical movement in first-person across gaming going forward.


5. Crash Bandicoot 4: It's About Time

Crash Bandicoot 4
Activision

They said it couldn't be done.

We said it VERY loudly in 2001 when Eurocom tried to do a Crash without Naughty Dog, and we only repeated ourselves with every failed attempt to continue the Orange Marsupial without the watchful eye of that same veteran studio.

Crash Twinsanity was the most enjoyable, but with Mind Over Mutant and Crash of the Titans bombing both sales and fan reception-wise, it seemed Crash was down for the count.

12 years passed without a new Crash game, until - powered by a remake collection reminding generations old and new that Crash gameplay was something to be treasured - we finally got a brand new Crash title that is a genuine great.

Developer Toys for Bob clearly carried across all the lessons they learned releasing the N. Sane Trilogy, but they went one better - getting in touch with ex-Naughty Dog team members to make sure the feel and humour of Crash was spot on.

The results speak for themselves, and It's About Time lives up to its name in every respect.


4. Tetris 99 & Super Mario 35

Tetris 99
Arika

In a move more Nintendo than opening a theme park where you punch POW blocks and launch shells into question marks, the company's answer to the battle royale phenomenon was to... do it with Tetris and original 1985 Mario.

Even right now as you think about it, Tetris 99 and Super Mario 35 shouldn't work. The idea of "battle Tetris" had been done before, but not to such a large scale, where players are trading stacks of completed lines while actively targeting who's performing the best, resulting in a chaotic race to emerge victorious.

Same goes for Mario 35. Based on the original NES Mario, just take another seasoned veteran pool of players and pit them against each other in real time.

super mario 35
Nintendo

Who can complete Mario's iconic levels the fastest, and what about if scores of Goombas get thrown your way from other players?

It's damn-near genius, and opens up a gateway into various other legendary single player titles that would benefit from real-time battle royale leaderboards.

Synchronised GTA 3 races from Salvatore's mansion to the end of the airstrip in Shoreside Vale?

Let's GO.


3. DOOM

doom 2016 revenant
Bethesda Softworks

Sometimes it takes a franchise to get knocked down and dragged out, for enough reflection and wound-licking to reinvigorate the entire IP.

Such was the case with the risky and experimental DOOM 3 - something our own Josh Brown couldn't get enough of, but most longtime DOOM fans simply rejected outright.

After cancelled DOOM 4 footage looked to be exploring a late 2000s-style of city-based carnage and scripted set-pieces, iD Software seemingly stood back from everything and thought, "Is this REALLY what people want?"

That entire version of DOOM 4 was scrapped, and in came one of the most powerfully recommendable action games ever: The reborn DOOM of 2016.

Striking a perfect tone of self-awareness mixed with all-out embracing as much carnage and industrial metal-backed chaos as possible, this was like embodying a mosh pit full of chainsaws as your favourite band goes into a crushing breakdown.

(Yes that's a metal reference - ask your goth friend next time you see them).

Eternal would somehow go even further, pushing our brains to breaking point with 4K 120fps performance on PC and Xbox Series X. It was 2016's offering that reestablished DOOM as an IP that's here to stay, and the entry that dropped the most jaws.


2. Cyberpunk 2077

Cyberpunk 2077
CD Projekt RED

If you'd told the gaming populace of 2015 that CD Projekt RED's followup to The Witcher 3 would not only be a catastrophic letdown for millions of fans; not only a lied-about hodgepodge of promised and still-pending features; and not only a game so broken on last-gen systems, Sony wouldn't even sell it over Christmas, you'd rightly be asked if you were confusing them with Bethesda.

But no, with the only negative entry on this list comes a staggering fall from grace for a team who proved us all wrong in the worst way possible.

The cross-media promotional campaigns where everything from Keanu Reeves' motorcycle company to artists like Run the Jewels and Grimes were launching new music in tandem with the game. The clothing lines, big Christmas bundle deals, Xbox marketing partnership programs to sell Series systems alongside the game.

ALL of it imploded when the bottom fell out, as the base game just couldn't maintain quality across the board.

To this day we're sizing up the pros and cons of such a misaligned product and project, and in retrospect it remains one of the most public gaffes in gaming history.

Here's to Cyberpunk's patches, DLC and next-gen revamps proving us wrong again. The opposite way, this time.


1. Brutal Legend

brutal legend
Double Fine

To finish, something that was immensely disappointing and completely mis-marketed from EA at the behest of Double Fine and Tim Schafer, Brutal Legend appeared to be a God of War-meets-heavy metal action slasher, but was anything but.

See, having been conceptualised as a multiplayer strategy game first, the story side of things was more of an afterthought that quickly gathered steam, the more Schafer and co. were put in touch with the likes of Lemmy and Jack Black.

Point being: There is a brilliant, unique and genuinely recommendable strategy title here, that just happens to have a hilarious and charming set of story missions attached.

Gameplay is a hybrid of all-out action and top-down resource management, and if you simply treat Eddie Riggs as a controllable mouse cursor - thinning enemy ranks one minute before flying back to unleash new units the next - it all comes together.

Having Ozzy Osbourne play a slightly annoyed guardian of ethereal ancient upgrades while you posse up with Lemmy, Rob Halford and plenty more is also brilliant. The world itself feels like a mishmash of every overblown metal album's art combined, and the soundtrack might be the finest collection of rock and metal songs in gaming history.

Brutal Legend has amassed a cult following over the years for those who simply discarded the marketing or gave it another shot years later like myself. It remains my favourite Double Fine game after Psychonauts, and one that will likely prove you wrong too, if you pick it up today.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mortal Kombat
 
First Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.