9 Disastrous Mistakes That Killed Star Wars Battlefront 2
Battlefront 2 has sold almost 1.5 MILLION units less than the original.
"Should I buy Battlefront 2?"
Such is the question on many fans' lips, as being The Last Jedi is set to drop within the month, "Star Wars fever" is well and truly underway.
However, Battlefront 2's launch has been a landmark mess on a scale not seen since No Man's Sky. Very rarely do you see a property so beloved - and one that should be a surefire hit (seriously, how hard is it to make a good Star Wars game?) - release to a mainstream reaction that vehemently despises everything it stands for.
That scorn and fury is well deserved, as it only took players a few hours to realise Battlefront 2's overarching systems were inherently greedy, predatory and worst of all, designed to be pay-to-win. Shocking sales include only 882,000 units versus the 2.1 million of the 2015 edition, Belgium's Gaming Commission labelling the game as "child gambling", and Disney stepping in to force EA's to remove in-game transactions altogether. Finally, one notable Hawaiian representative has stated the game is a "Star Wars-themed online casino designed to lure kids into spending money".
Ouch.
In defence, EA and DICE have spent the last few weeks rebalancing various aspects of play to please a furious fanbase. However, with The Last Jedi just around the corner, let's take stock of every major mistake that buried Battlefront 2.
9. Leaving Random Progression To Be Discovered In The Game's Beta
Almost like EA and DICE knew their pay-to-win framework was going to ruffle feathers to the point of plucking them straight out, nowhere in the run-up to release was their wider framework of completely random progression showcased.
Granted, it's damn hard to "show off" a component that literally asks consumers to pull a lever and hope they get a worthwhile upgrade, but at least Monolith livestreamed ahead of time how Shadow of War's loot boxes and structure was going to work. Crucially, they clarified that such things were completely optional.
In Battlefront 2's case, we found out during the beta.
Literally a week before release.
As was the case with Mass Effect Andromeda's early access play on EA Origins, once EA lost control over its marketing message, this was a demonstrable mistake that only got more and more out of control. Quickly fans rallied around which parts of the experience needed refining and which could feasibly still be "in testing", leading to a launch day that confirmed all our worst fears.
8. Locking Characters Like Vader & Luke Behind Huge Credit Amounts
Another thing that could've easily been communicated across the year, EA and DICE want Battlefront 2 to be a "service", just as much as an enjoyable, in-the-moment video game. You can see this in their seasonal plans for new maps and characters, as clearly they want a fanbase to "drop in" every few months, enjoying a constant stream of new content every time.
To that end, Luke and Vader (among others) were first priced at 60,000 credits a piece to unlock. Bearing in mind an average match only gives you around 350 credits, it would take a LONG time to get either Skywalker, never mind the full set of characters.
Thing is, there was a method to the madness, as such a slow burn could've factored into weeks or months-worth of play - keeping in mind the whole "games as a service" model.
EA even mentioned that unlocking Luke and Vader would “provide players with a sense of pride and accomplishment”, which it would have, if they communicated the whole "year long game" idea.
7. EA Admitting To Investors That The Bottom Line Wasn't Affected By Removing Microtransactions
A smoking gun if ever we needed one, an EA conference call post-release confirmed that microtransaction models were only in the game for money-grubbing purposes. Ye gads, what a shocker.
How do we know this? Because EA literally told their investors that the game's earnings would not be affected by the omission of microtransactions (being they were removed at Disney's request).
"[Removing in-game transactions] is not expected to have a material impact on EA’s fiscal year 2018 financial guidance" was the quote, which quite literally reads as, "The game will still make just as much money without them".
Granted we now know from recent sales that this isn't the case, but even at the time, EA were either lying to their investors (which is unlikely) or they're an optional framework designed to exploit consumers, fundamentally not affecting the bottom line (far more likely).
Either way, right here we have EA saying that the system itself doesn't need to be in the game. Perfect.
6. Revealing That Only 35% Of Players Buy Microtransactions
Though the information relates to FIFA's Ultimate Team mode (where card packs determine which players, attributes, formations etc. you can unlock and equip), startlingly, only 35% of that game's ENTIRE PLAYERBASE partake in microtransactions.
See, there's a term in the games industry called a "Whale". Known as a player with an exorbitant amount of disposable income - your lawyers, doctors, business owners etc. who can afford to blow/waste endless extra cash (sometimes to the tune of 1000s of pounds/dollars) - it's this demographic that's become increasingly focused on over the years. Especially at EA.
Thus, it's not a stretch to say that cumulatively, this lot are the 35%, yet you have to wonder why on earth EA are designing multiple games around mechanics that only a minority of their playerbase can engage with. I mean, the reason is pure money, as that 35% pay far more than the majority's one-off purchases combined, but it still means more players put up with obfuscating structures and mechanics than they should.
5. Making Rey And Kylo's The Last Jedi Costumes Pre-Order Content Only
You've got the biggest movie of the year, from the biggest property in entertainment history, and you're creating tie-in content that's going to let millions of fans play as their favourite characters, post-viewing.
So what do EA do? Resign both Rey and Kylo Ren's Episode VIII costumes to a pre order-only "bonus".
Again, it's straight business needs over good fan service, but at the very least you'd expect some sort of "pre-order to get them now, others can wait"-style setup to please everyone. Doing anything else is such a hollow, translucent business move, and we immediately saw right through it.
As it stands, these two sought-after costumes are only used by a select few players online, and though they might free up over time (nearly every "limited edition" piece of content always does), right now, one of the biggest reasons to invest in the game isn't going to be available with the movie.
Lame.
4. Saying Cosmetic Options Would "Violate Star Wars Canon"
One HELL of a back-pedal if ever there was one (especially seeing as leaks have shown cosmetic DLC is now coming), DICE's brilliant reason Battlefront 2 had to have performance upgrades in its crates instead of cosmetics?
Why, because EA didn't want to "violate the canon" of Star Wars with aesthetics, of course.
I mean, of course. It's not like having Rey fighting alongside Darth Maul does that, and it's certainly not like every single Star Wars character has had a different costume in every single movie, either.
Even Vader has a variety of slightly different robes and chest computer combos over the saga, so even though EA say that "no one wants a pink Darth Vader", they're certainly right, but there are a myriad of other ways to spice things up.
3. Constant Server Lag
Here's a kicker: Even if you still bought a copy despite all the backlash and warnings, you're just as likely to have a match crippled with server lag as one that runs smooth throughout.
Many players have thus reported being stuck trying to run down a single corridor (seeing their character reset to the beginning over and over), as others attempt to fly the game's variety of vehicles, only to find locking onto anything impossible.
Battlefront really does seem to have a problem in matching its huge worlds with so many players, and at time of writing there's still no guarantee you're going to have a smooth experience.
2. Repetitive Map Algorithms Lack Variety & Reinforce Grind
A lot of Battlefront 2 is grind. Grinding for better weapons, grinding to upgrade damage outputs and grinding to improve incremental things like ship turning circles and regenerating health speed, one percentage at a time.
Although this isn't exactly the most "fun" unless you like seeing numerics go up, it would be more acceptable if the game's maps were doled out with more variety. As it stands, Starfighter Assault favours Fondor above all else, meaning you'll repeatedly be beamed back into the same map over and over, with only a few others ever popping up.
Same goes for Blast and Strike, which more often than not, place you on the same two or three maps, without rotating the entire amount.
With no matchmaking options outside of literally telling the game which mode you fancy, there's no way to filter down which maps or eras you prefer, and it only reinforces how much you're banging your head against the game's inherently grind-heavy nature.
1. Half-Baked UI Oversights Deny Usability
Bless DICE, they're always so close with their menu systems, and yet so far. So very, very far.
Fresh off the back of Battlefield 1's menu being a weird tribute to the Windows phone, we now have Battlefront attempting to be more minimalist, but dropping the ball in a number of key areas.
Things like not being told which map you're beaming into during consecutive matches (thereby not knowing which class or ability loadout you should use), not being able to claim rewards without quitting, barely having any idea how weapon attachments work and suffering terribly slow load times, it's all unnecessarily awkward to use.
Taken on its own, this wouldn't have stood out too much, but when the main menu itself had a typo ("Star Cars" instead of "Cards") for weeks and there are so many contributing factors to just engaging with the game, Battlefront 2 falls apart from a little to a lot on almost every level.