9 Major Video Games We Hate That Everyone Loves

A week ago we posed a question to the community, and here's what you all said...

In games - as with music and film - if anything suddenly becomes majorly popular, the amount of feedback online or otherwise is increased tenfold. Everybody and their gran flocks to the internet to share opinions on the major releases, and they sometimes become cultural events too, with titles across the board like The Avengers and Grand Theft Auto getting us all involved. But what if it seems like you're in the minority, and you just don't see what everyone else does in a certain property? There comes that encroaching feeling that you're not 'allowed' to dislike something the vast majority of people think is the best thing since melted cheese (on sliced bread). Where many surely dropped to their knees and thanked the gods for something like that ending of Bioshock: Infinite, you thought it was just a little bit...well...naff. There's no one title that unifies every single person on the planet (although many will tell you Zelda's Ocarina of Time comes damn close), therefore when we put out the question to the community, the games that people had been bursting at the seams to express some negativity on were understandably those where the assumed "WHAT!? You don't like that!?" reaction would apply. That being said, none of what's included here are unequivocally perfect, but for many of us who have put entire days into them - you'll have to try and contain your outrage.

9. Mass Effect

For the most part when people talk about the bad parts of Mass Effect they refer to the godawful third one's ending, as well as the myriad of graphical glitches and occasional lock-ups or dialogue hitches that completely break the immersion at the worst possible moment. However other players never even made it to the third game thanks to a plodding narrative that required you completely devote yourself to the universe before you would start to get anything back. People reported that the now infamous missions set inside the awkwardly-controlled Mako vehicle were just too much to suffer through for the sake of the story (something ignored by Bioware, as they're making a return in part four). It's a point which is compounded by the fact that back in the original game even if you managed to get across a particularly mountainous planet, all that awaited you was a badly animated and ill-feeling firefight with mechanics that felt like a bad Gears of War mod. The series definitely hit its high point in the second instalment, building on these foundational blocks of third-person combat and interactive dialogue options. But when looking back on the original title it's hard to recommend it other than purely for nostalgia, or just as a jumping off point that works under the guise of everything getting better from here on in.

8. Assassin's Creed

Although we're all still buying enough of the AC games to allow Ubisoft to give us two titles a year, the fact remains that the heart of the experience is in dire need of a complete overhaul. It's not hard to see why someone would be utterly sick to the back teeth of this franchise being that we've had annual instalments for the better part of a decade now - all still with only minor changes applied to the same game engine that initially wowed us back in 2007. With a climbing mechanic that was going to rely on throwing your body weight around a series of outcrops and architecture so you could make your getaway in style, the whole thing was reduced down to just pressing forward whilst holding the right trigger and the A button. It was a move that firmly favoured accessibility and after so many sequels and so little innovation, even upcoming AC: Unity looks like it's going to play exactly the same as all the others. Whilst it seems that both the WWE, FIFA and Madden series' get away with making only minor alterations to a winning formula, when the core gameplay isn't as drop-in, drop-out as those titles and has to power an entire 20-odd hour campaign, it gets tiring extremely fast. Chuck in a whole host of glitches and the fact that the only thing that separates AC IV: Black Flag from the previous three is some tacked-on boat combat that's about as far removed from what being an assassin is all about as you can get, and you have a collection of reasons that are incredibly off-putting to many players.

7. Bioshock

A series that invokes just as much hate as it does love if you scratch away at the major opinion surrounding it, Bioshock was always a series where we put up with some truly shocking combat for the sake of amazing worlds and stories. Fans of the series will stick up for the second instalment even though it always felt a bit pointless after such a highly-regarded first game, but it was with Bioshock: Infinite that the series turned into something more of a divisive franchise overall. With yet more cack-handed storytelling and central characters whose marketing did a better job of convincing us of their relationship than the actual script did, it wasn't hard to be initially put off by how fast the whole game moves and asks that you buy everything thrown in front of you, without adequately selling it. As major confrontations you'd worked towards end in scripted cutscenes where you were powerless to watch as the otherwise-controllable Booker DeWitt killed people you'd really rather have a word with, the game's intention of providing a thought-provoking time-travelling narrative was something that got lost underneath all the gore and repetitive gunfights.

6. Dota 2

"Dota who?" we hear you shout. Well, at this point in the year the majority of people are probably unaware of the series' existence, despite it being the first televised gaming 'sport' at last month's 'International' - opening up a whole can of worms when it comes to whether or not hardcore gamers can ever be called 'athletes'. A top-down 'MOBA' or 'Massive Online Battle Arena' (think Command and Conquer, but way bigger) the game is a free-to-play download on PC and Mac that sees you commanding a huge amount of units, characters and abilities alongside dedicated teams and players. The catch in the bigger leagues is that there's real money on the line, with first place last month taking home $5,000,000 (yes, that's not a typo). It takes real dedication to get to that sort of level - with the mental capacity to instigate multiple complex plans and react to situations on the fly being something that only a select few have been able to execute well - but the game asks that you give up considerable chunks of your life learning every little facet of its combat. Although it's weird to say that 'everyone loves' Dota 2 (or Defence Of The Ancients if you're being old school) the fanbase is actually staggeringly huge. The fact that amongst years of eSports and fighting game tournaments this was the title that took gaming in a whole new direction speaks volumes.

5. Halo

Alongside Goldeneye it's usually Halo that gets a mention as bringing first-person shooters to consoles and 'making them work', as previously the idea of controlling an aiming reticule with anything other than a mouse and keyboard was sacrilege. However with that bulky original Xbox controller, we took to the beaches and ancient structures of the world with a newfound purpose - blasting and punching everything in sight. That being said though, the core Halo formula has barely changed in 13 years; evidenced perfectly by the fact that The Master Chief Collection that's coming out later this year has a defined selling point as being "exactly the same as it was ten years ago." Albeit with a shinier graphics engine of course. Add in the fact that not one of us actually really understands the story or could tell you what's going on this late into the series, and past the initial feeling of being sucked in by impressive graphics and fancy soundtracks, Halo is in desperate need of an overhaul.

4. Call Of Duty

Chances are COD was the first title that sprung to mind when reading this headline, as aside from Assassin's Creed it's the only other major non-sports title that receives annual releases - and is subsequently being ran into the ground because of it. For a time it was all well and good, as back when Modern Warfare's 1 and 2 came out they were suitably game-changing, revolutionising the way we all played competitive shooters in a similar way to that of the original Counter-Strike. Then came the sequels, and as Activision split development across two different studios so that they could trade off releases every year, things began to alter from changing the game, to just having to sell it. Although many of us got off the COD-train following Modern Warfare 3 or Black Ops II, last year's Ghosts' selling feature was that they'd accurately motion captured a dog to use in the game. That was it, a dog. A dog that you saw more of as he devoured your throat thanks to another player summoning him as a perk in multiplayer than anything worthwhile in the campaign. Later this year we're all set to get the Kevin Spacey-dictating, Titanfall-replicating COD: Advanced Warfare - as Infinity Ward hope to hook people back into the Modern Warfare label - but as many people have mentioned; there's just no appeal left in the series anymore.

3. Gears Of War

Like a great band who rigidly stick to a formula album after album, it's always going to separate the people who absolutely adore hearing a perfected version of a certain thing, to those who just wish for a second the band in question would at least try something different. Well, as is becoming apparent with many of these titles and their constant sequels, Gears of War is something of another 'AC/DC of games' in that what it does is incredibly enjoyable, but you couldn't play it forever. Luckily developer Epic spaced the three core titles in the series apart enough so we didn't have to, although saying that due to the only real upgrade between games being the graphics, if you already had an issue with the controls of the kebab-legged space marine protagonists you weren't suddenly going to come on board. There's also the English typist's nightmare Gears of War: Judgment though, as apart from that weird-looking spelling it was the first title in the series to not be fully developed by Epic. Tinkering with what was a winning formula in terms of the controls it put us in control of two characters that by this point in the story were roundly hated by some. All in all Judgment has been almost completely forgotten about, so it's over to the future to see what new developer Black Tusk can bring to the corpse-laden table.

2. Grand Theft Auto IV

Fast reaching (or you could say achieving) it's cultural zenith, as well as being as the highest selling entertainment property of all time, you'd have to bury your head in the ground for months on end to get away from hearing about Grand Theft Auto these days. Even though it's a strange idea that such a defining title in our list of popular entertainment is labelled after a major crime, it's one of those things where if you come across people who "just don't like" GTA, they tend to be met with scrunched-up faces and confused looks. However with that being said, as we look to the next instalment in the series and analyse previous releases too, it's immediately obvious that there's a whole heap of issues with the mission types, characters and sometimes just the overall structure of the game, that's wearing very thin. Sure Rockstar Games are absolute geniuses and the world of GTA V is easily far more impressive than that of anything on the newer consoles, but at the same time is the very formula that creates these games just overcooked by this point? How many more 'drive here, shoot this' missions can we possibly do? It's a fact that besides the handful of heist missions and despite how much fun the game might be and how polished it clearly is, we're pretty much doing the same tasks we have been for over a decade now.

1. Skyrim

Remember when we said to try and hold in your outrage? This is the title that's going to test such a thing. Easily one of the most replayable games of all time and one that to this day people essentially live in, Skyrim is the fantasy-fans dream come true, allowing you to live hundreds of potential lives in a world that dynamically responds to you and fulfils every Lord of the Rings-style dream you've ever had. Or at least, it should do.
Developers Bethesda are notorious for releasing their games in states that are still incredibly buggy and glitchy, mainly because combing every inch of a game that's this size - with so many variables - is a task they can never fulfil without entire decades of development time. Some people take things like the backwards-flying dragons, the randomly headless pedestrians or the quest-givers who are stuck in the ground as just something fun and quirky; a necessary evil in a game that can give so much back when it's working the way it should. For many though if adventuring through Skyrim was their first RPG or any number of crippling game issues (which have since been patched out) led to a story-centric character or item simply not appearing - or your character straight up just falling through the floor - it's not hard to see why people were completely put off. As we look forward to Fallout 4 here's hoping working with newer hardware to create even bigger game worlds doesn't mean we're going to get ten-times the amount of issues along the way. Are there any other games you hate that get way too much praise from critics, friends and colleagues? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.