Avengers: 8 Ways To Save The Game

No matter where you stand, things could look a lot better.

avengers glitch
Crystal Dynamics

Marvel's Avengers is one of the most prominent mixed bags in quite some time.

On the one hand you've got a luxuriously presented loot-based brawler; a game that takes Ultimate Alliance 3's template and adds far more expensive production values. The characters look stunning, action is pyrotechnic as hell, and the story has a sincere enough heart that it propels you from one location to the next.

On the other hand... this is a grind-heavy, sponsorship-fuelled corporate box-ticker with very few takeaway positives other than "Well, I'm glad I can play as [insert character of choice]!" Gameplay becomes repetitive and stale, with the available beta roster quickly blurring into one. A loot system is supposed to keep you going, but its invisibility proves (to me, anyway) that this wasn't part of the mission statement from day one.

In so many ways, it feels like Square Enix have been given the keys to the Marvel kingdom, only to go hog-wild with as many money-making opportunities as possible.

There's a veneer of big budget cynicism that hasn't been seen quite so nakedly since 2017's Star Wars Battlefront II. Like that game, hopefully there's a future for Marvel's Avengers that pleases everyone, as its current state needs a lot of tweaking.


8. Add Visible Loot

avengers game
Square Enix

NOBODY wants an invisible loot system. Nobody.

As it stands, the entire wing of the game dedicated to number-grinds and gear doesn't result in any visible reward. The reason? Crystal Dynamics want to focus on skins and DLC, and a loot system would apparently break that.

Tons of loot-based games give you a choice of aesthetics while carrying across the number gain, but that isn't the case here. The solution, sadly, has been to include a stat-crunchy gear system, only everything is invisible on your character.

Needless to say it's supremely lame to grind out missions or challenges, only to never have anything to show for it.

Like Battlefront 2 first stating a loot system wouldn't work - and then implementing one after fans revolted against monetised elements - you simply can't have a system of drop-based rewards if they only reflect in numerics.

People simply won't play a game of this overall structure - especially when one of the hooks is customisation per player-and-hero combo - if the only thing at the end of the treadmill is another skin.


7. Allow Duplicate Characters On Non-Story Missions

avengers game
Square Enix

Another bizarre choice given the supposed directive of "making a hero your own" - you can't bring them on missions if someone else is playing as the same person.

Immediately you have to consider the Spider-Man DLC on PS4. The second that drops you'll have millions of fans wanting to play as Spidey... who can only match up with PlayStation owners who don't want to access their own exclusive content.

Again, a baffling oversight.

The solution allowing duplicate heroes on non-story related missions. The War Table already has a distinction for which quests will progress the story and need certain heroes present, so let us run the others as whoever we want.

Anything else and it's too restrictive in the longterm.


6. Hulk (And Other Tank Characters) Should Feel Heavy

avengers game
Crystal Dynamics

Speaking of heroes, Avengers has a huge problem with almost everybody feeling the same. I'll get to this in a wider sense soon, but Hulk stands out as a notable negative thanks to being entirely too light and floaty.

Yes, animations like grabbing a dude's leg and slamming left and right, Loki style, are great, but there's no overall weight to Hulk's movements when traversing levels or through basic enemy interactions.

It might sound nitpicky as hell, but when basic humans can hold up a shield and come away unscathed from a Hulk-sized haymaker, it's a problem. A workaround would be ensuring Hulk - and similar-sized characters - have the ability to wipe right through certain levels of infantry automatically.

Right there you've got some much-needed core character variation on top of the moveset side of things, and it keeps Hulk feeling authentic.

Oh, and while we're on, how about these same fodder enemies can't interrupt Hulk's charged attacks??


5. Give Xbox Owners An Exclusive Character/Feature

avengers spider man
Crystal Dynamics/Insomniac

Square Enix opened a can of worms by accepting Sony's Spider-Man exclusivity deal. Mainly, because it says to Xbox and PC owners, "You're paying the same amount of money for less content".

Now, platform exclusives are nothing new. From GTA 4's DLC being on Xbox 360 first to various Soul Caliburs having platform-specific characters, we've all been stiffed out of 100% of a title thanks to characters, items etc. being locked down elsewhere.

However, usually these things are timed or balanced between systems. At the very least it's rare a platform exclusive deal stays that way forever, and the vast majority centre more around "first access" than complete ownership.

Not in Spider-Man's case, though. Sony have paid to secure the Web-Head as they increasingly push for the character to be considered a "PlayStation hero", and they won't be letting him go any time soon.

The answer? Some sort of platform-based reward on the Xbox or PC side. If Spidey isn't a timed exclusive and other consumers literally are buying "less of a game", that should reflect in content or even a price drop outside PlayStation.


4. Fix Matchmaking & PC Bugs

Avengers game
Crystal Dynamics

You almost can't be mad at Crystal Dynamics when it comes to the state of their multiplayer servers.

One, because part of a beta is testing this stuff before launch, and two, because they've never come close to developing a game like Marvel's Avengers.

Synchronised multiplayer sessions, loot drops (some shared, others on an individual basis), ensuring we're all fighting fluidly no matter what? It's one hell of a step up from Tomb Raider and Legacy of Kain.

Still, come launch those points won't matter, nor should they. Avengers is a premium product sold for a premium price tag, and it should work right off the bat - something the beta barely does.

PC users saw repeated crashes and character faces not loading in, while console users struggled to get into games or even search for players.

The matchmaking side of this is integral to everything other than the story, and that's a key component to perfect.


3. Take Risks With DLC Character Movesets

She hulk
Marvel

One of the biggest issues with Avengers and something you'll feel even as the game is trying to showcase a diverse character roster, is that everybody feels nigh-on the same.

Yes, Black Widow has more parry-specific animations and Iron Man can fly, but all have light and heavy attacks, all can hold the left trigger to aim a projectile even if they don't possess a firearm, and all largely fit into the same combo possibilities. Across the board, every character so far has various canned animations applied to the same buttons and allocations.

Now, this could be because the starting roster is very much that - a way to introduce us to what's coming.

Thanks to a huge datamine from the PC version we know everybody from Black Panther to Scarlet Witch, Dr. Strange to Kate Bishop and She-Hulk are incoming, but they need to feel more experimental and unique in the field.

The sad reality comes from realising many DLC heroes could simply serve as ways to get around the lack of duplicates I mentioned earlier. Those who can't play as Hulk could pick She-Hulk, those not picking Hawkeye get Kate Bishop, and so on.

Avengers combat ran its course even after a few hours with the beta. This upcoming fleshed our roster HAS to bring big changes.


2. Ditch The Soulless Corporate Feel

Marvel's Avengers Store
Square Enix

Although sometimes it's hard to put your finger on precisely which elements trigger this sensation, some titles are overrun with corporate influence and money-making schemes, to the point where any creative vision actively requires effort to see clearly.

Star Wars Battlefront II had it, with a Star Card system initially ruined by microtransactions and pay-to-win elements. Destiny 2 had it as we were chasing "White Engram" loot boxes. Shadow of War had it with orcs tied to paid random drops, and Evolve being "built with DLC in mind!" siphoned all rewards into monetised tiers.

Avengers, though? It's the worst example in quite some time.

Sponsorship deals are one thing, but when you're forced to set up a Square Enix account to access the beta - something that only serves marketing departments with fresh data and profit - it's an insulting shambles.

The good news, is that this feeling can go away. It almost immediately evaporates after launch, as various sponsorship deals have been cashed in on, launch window sales satisfy the number-crunchers and the publisher-developer pendulum swings far more towards the latter.

This is what saved Destiny as Bungie left Activision, and after EA finally let DICE work on Battlefront without interference, we got the best Star Wars multiplayer game of all time. Even Shadow of War's microtransactions were stripped out eventually.

It'll take many changes (and leaving Verizon/Virgin Media costumes in the rear view mirror), but going forward, hopefully the heart of Crystal Dynamics can win out against the money-first priorities of Square Enix.


1. Release The Story As A Standalone Experience

Avengers kamala kahn ms marvel
Square Enix

You can almost boil down the icky, money-charged portion of the game and the creative, forward-thinking portion to the multiplayer and story-focused "single player" split.

Multiplayer is full of XP boosts and skins tied to sponsorship deals, focuses on the invisible loot grind tied to re-running the same missions over and over, and it's where the game feels the most aimless.

The story side though, includes one of the best voice actor casts ever assembled, included Troy Baker, Nolan North, Laura Bailey, Sandra Saad and many more. It feels genuinely propulsive in terms of knitting together a fractured Avenger team after Captain America dies and the gang are blamed for infecting half of San Francisco with unwanted superpowers.

Saad's Ms. Marvel is - so far - the only bright spot in a sea of bland everything, and using her as a story anchor to energetically remind these dogged veterans why they matter is at least engaging from the get-go.

Point being: Avengers would benefit tenfold from admitting it's a game of two halves.

Clearly we're launching with everything in one place for now, but as Call of Duty: Modern Warfare has proven with Warzone mode going separate, or Ghost of Tsushima's new "Legends" multiplayer showed by being plugged into the main game, segmented releases can serve different fanbases to great effect.

Separate the story mode, let us rank up the requisite fighters there as we check out the narrative, then plug in the all-out loot grind and number-fest that is the multiplayer on top. Conversely, let multiplayer become a free-to-play grind-fest with paid character tiers to keep it afloat, and let the connection between the two be optional.


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.