Fallout 4: 11 Reasons It's A Disappointment

Take your pick...

Whether you've blasted through the campaign or only just scraped the surface, gamers the world over have now been able to sink a wealth of time into Bethesda's latest RPG opus, the rapturously-reviewed Fallout 4. That said, the initial afterglow is starting to die down, meaning it's time to put the adoring fanboyism beyond and take a more critical look at the areas where the game falls down, because for everything FO4 gets right, it also leaves plenty to be desired. From technical issues to lazy corner-cutting, bizarre design choices and elements that feel like a step back from previous Fallout games, there's plenty of quibbles that prevent the game from being the masterpiece it was so clearly capable of.

11. Those Ridiculous Loading Times

In an era where the PS4 and Xbox One are promising smoother, faster load times than ever, Fallout 4 sadly embarrasses them by boasting average load times on consoles of 30-50 seconds in length. Sure, this wouldn't be a problem if it appeared infrequently, but considering the amount of fast-traveling you're likely to be doing throughout the game, it can be especially aggravating if you need to quickly travel between several areas, resulting in a number of near-back-to-back loading screens. When other, much better looking games can muster load times of 5-10 seconds, it's rather aggravating that the game wastes so much player time loading everything in. Yes, it's widely accepted that Bethesda's engine is a mess, but is this really acceptable on current-gen tech, let alone a PC (though it admittedly isn't as bad on PC)?

10. The Graphics Are Just OK

In fairness, fans were made aware of this one a while back, when the initial trailer didn't even attempt to mask the fact that Fallout 4 just doesn't look that great. Yes, it's dripping in atmosphere and has a ton of mood, while the world-building is incredible, but on a basic aesthetic level, the game is fairly ugly. The textures are bland and flat, animations are often jerky and the lip sync is so laughably bad it's a surprise Bethesda even bothered. While this has been par for the course in pretty much every game the developer has made, it's fairly disappointing that they've made a game that looks like it could probably be released at the tail-end of the PS3, or at the very most as a launch title for PS4. Graphics absolutely aren't everything, but they are something, and this is one area where the commitment and attention-to-detail of the world as a whole just isn't found.

9. The Game Doesn't Explain Basic Mechanics

FO4 has been slammed even by those who generally love the game for the poor (or sometimes non-existent) manner in which it describes fairly basic gameplay elements. For example, when you're first able to build settlements and edit the environment around you, the game provides very little information on something as simple as connecting a power generator, all the more infuriating as the player is actually required to do this once in the campaign. Then there's cracking passwords on computer terminals which again is poorly explained even if players will eventually get the hang of it, it's possible to go hours without realising there's an advanced perk system, and you possibly don't know how to holster your gun or shoot from cover. There's a lot to be said for keeping in-game prompts and text to a minimum in order to sustain the immersion factor, but it would've been cool to know these things right out of the gate...

8. Glitches, Glitches Everywhere

It wouldn't be a Bethesda game without a ton of glitches, but holy crap, this game is absolutely riddled with them. Be it the infamous "meatspin" glitch which has plagued every 3D Fallout game (pictured above), characters getting snagged on random objects for no reason, dialogue not being subtitled or skipping altogether, the player being teleported across the map, enemies getting flung into the air for no reason or any of the other endless amount of glitches, it's astounding that they all made it into the final game. While it's understandably impossible for Bethesda to QA everything, the final product suggests their QA department consisted of a single pot-smoking intern with a severe case of Friday Afternoon Syndrome. Though some players insist they've not encountered a single glitch and others are prepared to put up with the jankiness because of the "charm" it infuses into the game, many just expect a AAA game of this stature to be significantly more polished. Compared to, say, Metal Gear Solid V, it's hot garbage from a presentational perspective.

7. The User Interface Is A Pain

To call Fallout 4's interface clunky is to probably be rather generous, but it's safe to say that navigating the various options the Pip-Boy has to offer, be it to select a new weapon or check the map, can feel like an arduous task at the best of times. You're almost duty-bound to find yourself returning to the Pip-Boy frequently to perform minor adjustments, and this will often require you cycling through several menus and pressing far too many buttons simply to add a new gun to your quick-select inventory. PC gamers have it arguably even worse, because the Pip-Boy menu idiotically doesn't cater for mouse scrolling, which seems like the most naturally intuitive way to navigate through the cumbersome array of options. Modders will inevitably fix it as they always do, but for the love of God, how does it still feel so fiddly and unresponsive to boot?

6. Companions Have The IQ Of A Potato

It's fun to have a companion around to keep you from getting lonely out in the wasteland, but do they have to be so freaking dumb? Hell, even for the standards of a dog some of this stuff is pretty unforgivable: companions will stop following you, get snagged in objects, walk around in circles and run headlong into enemy gunfire rather than take up a strategic position. This is all pretty basic stuff that should've been caught pre-release (especially the latter point), but most depressingly it makes having a companion around more of a chore if anything. Needing to babysit a sub-functional character can be immensely frustrating, which is a shame considering how charming some of them can be (especially Dogmeat and Nick Valentine).

5. There's Not Much Quest Variety

As was also a problem in September's Metal Gear Solid V, FO4 just doesn't have a particularly impressive variety of quest types. Yes, there's an entertaining mission where you explore some memories and a couple of quests that stick out, but the backbone of the game is governed by fetch quests, wild goose chases and the inevitable "clear a huge building of every enemy" missions. Improved (if still heavily flawed) gunplay softens the blow a bit, but even so, it just doesn't seem very inspired or imaginative. Where are the ambitious set-pieces which might make the fairly standard story feel more involving?

4. Combat Is Improved...But Still Needs Work

It's almost universally agreed that FO4's combat is a huge improvement over Fallout 3 and New Vegas, but it still leaves a lot to be desired in many areas. Yes, shooting now isn't quite the chore that it once was and allows semi-competent players to finish most of the game without even using the V.A.T.S. targeting system, but why are the controls still so damn floaty? During an intense firefight, they just don't feel precise or accurate enough, and though skilled players will likely endure regardless, you'll probably end up healing yourself far more than necessary simply because there feels like a slight but notable input lag on commands. Sure, PC players can just edit their .INI file to fix this (not that they should have to), but console folks? Not so much.

3. The Dialogue Wheel Is Too Simplistic

Dialogue selection has been overhauled in FO4...and not for the better. Now players are given four options, one good, one bad, one sarcastic and one vague, all described by just a few words which often don't even give enough context to indicate their true intent. Compare this to the last two FO games, where you could choose from full sentences which weren't so evidently signposted towards a certain inclination. In this regard, FO4 is an unmistakable step back, and there doesn't seem to be much more reason for it than laziness on Bethesda's part: it's extremely infuriating when you misinterpret what a dialogue command says, possibly resulting in a conversation that doesn't go your way. Wouldn't it be so much more interesting if the character's moral trajectory wasn't laid out quite so blatantly?

2. It Won't Be Great Until The Modders Are Done With It

A common defense you'll hear for Bethesda's games is that "it'll be better once the mods get to work on it", and while this isn't wrong, it does feel like an attitude which gives the developer a free pass for the countless issues they've let slip through the cracks (in some cases gigantic, gaping cracks, mind). This is why there's no real incentive to rush out and buy FO4 now: you can easily just wait a few months until it's been optimised and a lot of the niggles have been ironed out and your experience will be decidedly richer than the janky, uneven state that it's in today.

1. Character & Story Could Use Some Work

And ultimately the most disappointing thing about FO4 is the thing that should matter above everything except the gameplay: the story, and the characters that inhabit that story. From the get-go the game feels pretty rushed when the epilogue sequence could easily have gone on for much longer, then some guys near-randomly give you Power Armour despite barely knowing you, missions typically lead to huge exposition dumps, there's a plot twist you can see coming a mile off, and then the game just...ends. It's also very telling that the most likable and personable characters in the entire game are robots, Nick and Codsworth, while most of the humans are flat and uninteresting, especially the player character. Considering that we're supposed to be invested in the protagonist's quest to get his son Shaun back, it's actually difficult to feel much about it, no matter how many side-quests you distract yourself with, What do you make of FO4 so far? Shout it out in the comments!

In this post: 
Fallout 4
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.