FIFA 16: 12 Monster Strikers Who Need Downgrading
Just because you've scored goals in the past, doesn't mean you can score them now
Every year, the boffins at EA Sports spend a heck of a lot of time giving ratings to all the players, tweaking their stats as they improve or decline with age and / or form.
Inevitably, there are always going to be players who are overlooked and get criminally low ratings - check out Charlie Austin's FIFA 15 rating, a measly 74, which after the winter update only made it to 75, though he's banged in 17 goals this season and provided more than a few assists too. So while fans of small clubs may be treated to top-class goal scorers on the pitch, they are regularly disappointed when they see their star player's rating a darn sight lower than it should be.
On the flip side of the coin, though, there's always a few players who are more hype than ability, and who end up with unrealistically high ratings, usually because they play for a big team. Countless players are brought in to the world's top leagues in big money moves, with great reputations and the heavy weight of expectation on their shoulders.
Some carry it well, and exceed all expectations by solidifying their reputations among the world's elite, but time and time again FIFA gives grossly inflated ratings to pretty average players who have had a few good games, or who scored a heap in a weaker league.
So here's a list of 12 monster strikers who haven't exactly lived up to expectations, and could do with being taken down a peg.
12. Ciro Immobile - 80
After Borussia Dortmund lost star man Robert Lewandowski to arch-rivals Bayern Munich, they needed a player to come in and fill his shoes - a tough task, considering the quality of the player they were losing.
Enter 24-year-old Italian international Ciro Immobile, who scored 22 goals in 33 games to help Torino to a respectable 7th placed finish in Serie A. While he was by no means a ready-made replacement for the mercurial Polish marksman, much was expected of him when he arrived at the Westfalenstadion.
He wasn't a spectacular failure (unlike some of the others on this list), but 9 goals in 37 games for both Dortmund and Italy really isn't good enough, and Dortmund struggled in the absence of Lewandowski's goals, and were in the relegation zone at Christmas. They have since hauled themselves out, but they could certainly have done with more input from their new star man.
He probably shouldn't be taken down too much, as he's only 25 and has now had a year to settle, but he must be downgraded nonetheless.
Ciro Immobile Recommended rating: 76
11. Emmanuel Adebayor - 80
Adebayor is a strange one. He has a habit of moving to a club and having a fantastic season with them, before he appears to get bored, lazy and lose all interest. This is when the goals dry up.
He had a pretty respectable season last time out at Tottenham Hotspur, considering he only played a single game under André Villas-Boas before Tim Sherwood replaced the Portuguese manager. 14 goals in just 25 games was nothing to be sniffed at, but after Sherwood's departure at the end of the season, the goals vanished once again. The big Togolese striker has only hit the back of the net twice in 17 appearances this season.
While it's fair to say he's been living under the shadow of Harry Kane this season, who has been phenomenal in all competitions, that's no excuse for a player who had a good long run in the side before he was dropped.
If he's kept at 80, he'll still be a quality striker on FIFA, with solid ratings all round. Unfortunately, FIFA doesn't exactly take into account things like work ethic, which Adebayor is sorely lacking. New manager Mauricio Pochettino will hope he can get Adebayor scoring again, as he can't rely on Kane forever.
Emmanuel Adebayor Recommended Rating: 74
10. Samuel Eto'o - 81
An overall rating of 81 flatters Eto'o considerably. He may have played for Barcelona, Inter Milan, and Chelsea, but he has really fallen short of those heights in recent years.
In reality, the once best-paid player in the game has never had a stunning record. His best tally was at Inter Milan, where he scored 25 in two seasons. At Barcelona, he scored 24 in three years, but in a similar number of games.
He moved to Chelsea on a free last season from super-rich Anzhi Makhachkala to much fanfare, but his respectable tally of 9 goals in 16 games wasn't enough to convince Mourinho to keep him on.
Since then, however, it's all gone downhill. He moved to Everton on a free and scored 3 times in 8 games, but again wasn't sufficiently good enough for Roberto Martinez. If you feel like you haven't seen him in the Premier League recently, you'd be right - he slipped away to Sampdoria in the January transfer window, again on a free.
One goal in 12 is frankly abysmal for the once best-paid player in the world, and EA would be wise to MASSIVELY lower his rating for FIFA 16's release.
Samuel Eto'o Recommended Rating: 72
9. Stevan Jovetic - 81
Poor Stevan Jovetic. He had a cracking record at Fiorentina over several years, making him one of the most sought-after strikers in the world. Manchester City struck a £22 million deal for the Montenegrin superstar, but injuries and lack of playing time have hampered his progress.
When he joined Manchester City, he boasted an overall rating of 84. The following year it was dropped to 81 after a disappointing season in which he only scored 8 goals in 20 appearances for club and country.
Realistically, it should be dropped again. He may be a world class player who has simply stubbled for game time and deserves a high rating, but as they say, you're only as good as your last game. Well, if we go by his last season, he's gotten even more goal shy, scoring only 6 times in 30 appearances, all but 2 scored against weak opposition (he scored twice in City's 3-1 victory over Liverpool back in August.
Another player who is more hype than end-product, he needs his overall rating lowered - something that may irk Manchester City fans, but may well please fans of some of the smaller clubs.
Stevan Jovetic Recommended Rating: 78
8. Álvaro Negredo - 83
When Manchester City were hit by UEFA's Financial Fair Play fine, they were forced to cut their wage bill, and start recouping some of the millions they have spent, by shipping out some of their top earners.
Negredo was one of the first to go, and was initially loaned out to Valencia CF, though with a clause which stated Valencia must purchase the player on a permanent deal at the end of the season for a reported €27 million. At the time it looked like a steal. He'd just scored 26 goals in 52 appearances for the English champions, but he well and truly failed to live up to what was expected of him, scoring only 6 times in 33 appearances.
His original rating of 83 may have seemed low at the beginning of the season, but as the months passed, it has looked more and more like an overestimation than under.
It's maybe to be expected though, as he's approaching the wrong side of 30, and it appears as though his career is already in decline. Valencia will be kicking themselves that they're paying such an astronomical fee for a 6 goal-a-season player.
Álvaro Negredo Recommended Rating: 79
7. Danny Welbeck - 78
Right, let's not beat about the bush. Danny Welbeck is not a good player. His work ethic is admirable, but his goalscoring record is woeful, and his £16 million move to Arsenal from Manchester United has not changed that one bit.
It was suggested that, given more opportunities to lead the line in Giroud's many absences (as he continues to struggle with injuries), he would be able to become a real poacher from inside the penalty area, but this simply hasn't been the case.
His pace is pretty much the only stat you can reasonably give him, but the rest of his game is based around stupidity. He has some skill, lots of tricks and flicks, and you could argue that his teammates just aren't on the same wavelength as he is. It's his decision making that lets him down, over and over again. It might not seem like a 78 rating is worth bringing down, particularly after his decent record for England, but Ultimate Team has his rating as high as 82, which is preposterous.
His 9 goals for Arsenal this season are below what should be expected of a striker given as many opportunities and openings as he is. Considering Charlie Austin has more goals for QPR than Welbeck has for Arsenal and England, lowering his rating is certainly justified.
Danny Welbeck Recommended Rating: 75
6. Roberto Soldado - 81
How Soldado managed to keep an 80+ rating after his first, poor season at Tottenham is beyond belief. 11 goals in 36 games is pretty poor to start with, considering the roster of talent in the squad, and the supporting players around him. To make matters worse, the first five of those goals were penalties. 6 goals from open play is either the sign of a poor striker, or one who is simply out of his depth in this league.
This season, he's gone from bad to worse, scoring only 5 goals from 39 appearances. In January there was talk of a move to Bayer Leverkusen, but that did not materialise, and Spurs boss Mauricio Pochettino is keen to keep Soldado on to help him rediscover his lost form. We know where his best form was, Poch! He left it in Valencia!
Everything about him is overrated and over-hyped. He's not quick, he's not accurate, his not strong or powerful, and can't hold off defenders. His link up play isn't great either, and FIFA really need to do seriously bring his rating down.
This one is a no-brainer. If you only score 16 goals in 75 games, you're definitely undeserving of an 81 overall rating.
Roberto Soldado Recommended Rating: 75
5. Mario Balotelli - 82
Mario, Mario, Mario. What is anyone going to do with you? Wherever you go, you're a disaster waiting to happen because of all your off-pitch 'antics'.
Here's another player who is all hype. It's all 'potential' with Balotelli. "If only he would knuckle down and focus, he'd be a great player", "If only he could realise his potential, he'd start banging them in."
The only reason Balotelli has an 80+ rating at all is down to his 20 goal blinder of a season with Manchester City the year they ripped the title from the hands of their red neighbours in the dying seconds of the 2011/12 Premier League.
His £16 million move from AC Milan to Liverpool was always a punt, but it's one that hasn't even remotely paid off. At the time, people laughed that Welbeck and Balotelli had been purchased for the same price, with many wondering why anyone would buy Welbeck when Balotelli was available. As it turns out, both have had poor seasons for their clubs, but Balotelli's return of 4 goals, but 7 yellow cards, in 28 games has been woeful.
EA, will you sort this one out before you release FIFA 16, please?
Mario Balotelli Recommended Rating: 77
4. Karim Benzema - 85
This may seem like an odd name to have on this list. His stats look great. 22 goals in 47 games this season is pretty decent, particularly as he's been missing through injury at times.
Nevertheless, Karim Benzema is a poacher, playing in one of the best teams in the world, surrounded by the likes of Ronaldo, Bale, James Rodriguez, and Modric all feeding him the ball in a league where there are really only 3 big teams and everyone else is there to be crushed.
His record at Lyon was decent too, with a goal every other game, but again, he was surrounded by very good players, and playing in a weak league.
If a move to Liverpool or Arsenal transpires, he wouldn't score nearly so many goals. 10-12 a season perhaps? His work rate just isn't high enough to cut it in the Premier League, and he will quickly be exposed as less than world-class.
Regardless of how many goals he has scored at Madrid, his rating should be brought down to more accurately reflect his talents.
Karim Benzema Recommended Rating: 82
3. Robin Van Persie - 88
Sure, Van Persie is all class. Sure, he scored that wonder header at the world cup just last summer. Sure, he's been injured a lot, and sure, on his day, he's a fantastic goal-scored.
Unfortunately, it's not been his day for quite a while now. Injuries take their toll, and the flying Dutchman turns 32 before the new season starts. He's getting older, he's slowing down, and he's not able to get himself in the right positions to score goals as often as he'd like, or needs to nowadays.
13 goals isn't a bad return from 36 games, but 3 of those goals were for Holland. He's simply not done the job for Manchester United, and his 88 rating has been too high for a few seasons now.
There's talk of him going to Real Madrid next season, which seems like a strange move for someone who is not only not getting any better, but is definitely getting worse.
Robin Van Persie Recommended Rating: 82
2. Zlatan Ibrahimovic - 90
He is the best player in the world. He has always been the best player in the world, since the moment of his conception. No-one, living or dead, has ever come close to his talent, ability, and the delivery of his full potential. At least, in his own eyes.
No, not Lord Bendtner, Zlatan Ibrahimovic.
His talent is undoubted, but, let's face it, he's no Messi or Ronaldo. He isn't even top scorer in Ligue 1 this season. That title belongs to Alexandre Lacazette, unless, of course, Zlatan gets 9 goals in the final game. He's not even the second top scorer - that's André-Pierre Gignac. It's not like he has the excuse of playing in a poor team either. PSG is the French equivalent of Manchester City, and they have a team of superstars (and David Luiz) playing for them.
In the same way that Benzema does as well as he does because of the team around him, it's only fair to bring down Zlatan's rating too.
He's still one of the best, and has proven he can bang them in at any level of the game, but 90? Really? THAT goal against England doesn't mean he should have an unrealistically high rating on FIFA forever.
Zlatan Ibrahimovic Recommended Rating: 85
1. Radamel Falcao - 88
Another Manchester United striker who simply hasn't done what was expected of him.
People far and wide have speculated at why on earth the Colombian hasn't been able to bang them in for United, who have had the attacking talents of Rooney, Mata and Di Maria behind him (though Di Maria's been pretty poor too, despite leading the league in assists).
Perhaps it's because of his many, many injuries. Perhaps it's because he's homesick, or that he simply hasn't been able to integrate into the culture. Either way, only managing to net 4 goals in 29 appearances for the Red Devils isn't the kind of tally the United faithful wanted, and Louis Van Gaal will have to think very hard about about whether or not he wants to take the risk of signing Falcao on a permanent deal.
It's probably too early to write off Falcao entirely, as he could easily turn his fortunes around at another club, or simply settle in better next season, but this season has shown he is completely undeserving of the 88 rating EA has given him. If he doesn't turn it around early though, his rating could take a further hit after the winter update.
Radamel Falcao Recommended Rating: 83