FIFA 19: 11 Players Who Will Be Underrated

These lads won't get their due.

FIFA 19
EA Sports

The World Cup is an interesting beast. It's a tournament that rarely plays out the way we expect, and often the biggest name players fail to live up to the hype. By the same token, many players can rise from obscurity to announce themselves on the grandest stage of all, and likely earn a big transfer in the process.

That tangent is a way of saying that there are a number of players who shone extremely brightly in Russia, but it's clear their FIFA 19 rating won't reflect it. This list isn't all based on World Cup performances, but it's undeniable that the tournament reinforced those notions. Some of these players have been underrated for years, whilst others have improved at an unforeseen rate.

Unless you're a fan of Real Madrid, Barcelona or PSG, you'll be acquainted with some FIFA rating heartaches. Well, get ready for another year of frustration but hey, maybe these 11 players will get fixed in an update!

11. Hugo Lloris

Goalkeeper Hugo Lloris, Tottenham Hotspur.
Phil Cole/PA Archive

The Tottenham goalkeeper has quietly become one of the best in the world during his time in London. If it wasn't obvious to everyone but Premier League fans, it certainly is after his World Cup heroics.

Lloris has made 206 appearances for Spurs, and kept 74 clean sheets in the process. For comparison, Thibaut Courtois has made 126 appearances for Chelsea and kept 48 clean sheets. Yes there's a difference of 80 games but the clean sheet percentage is pretty similar, and yet Courtois is higher rated in FIFA 18. Why? Well, because Chelsea are a bigger team than Tottenham. Sadly that's what it often boils down to; no matter how fantastic a player is, if he plays for a less fashionable club like West Brom, he isn't going to be anywhere near 90 rated.

Hugo Lloris is certainly as good as his Premier League counterparts, and the World Cup champion's rating in FIFA 19 should reflect that.


10. Benjamin Pavard

Benjamin Pavard France 2018
wikipedia

An integral part of the French team that just won the World Cup, Benjamin Pavard has officially announced himself to the world. The 22 year old currently plays for Stuttgart and last year had a rating of 77. His recent performances demand a rating somewhere around 85, and a move to a bigger club would help as well.

It's good news for Pavard then, as he is rumoured to be on his way to Bayern Munich. That transfer, along with his performances, will almost certainly bag him a higher rating. The Frenchman was fantastic throughout the World Cup; bombing down the flanks and keeping the likes of Eden Hazard and Diego Laxalt in his pocket, not to mention the absolute cracker he scored against Argentina. Pavard is one of Europe's most exciting defenders and his FIFA rating needs to be almost ten points higher than last year.


9. Fernandinho

FILE - In this Tuesday, July 8, 2014 file photo, Brazil's Fernandinho reacts after Germany's Toni Kroos scored his side's third goal during the World Cup semifinal soccer match between Brazil and Germany at the Mineirao Stadium in Belo Horizonte, Brazil.
Natacha Pisarenko/AP

The Man City midfield maestro was absolutely crucial to their record-breaking 2017/18 season. He gets less plaudits than his teammates but his performances and influence should score him a high 80 rating.

Fernandinho bagged a rating of 85 in FIFA 18, which is the same as his Man City peer, Ilkay Gundogan. Not many would argue against the idea that Fernandinho is a better player than Gundogan and has a much bigger impact for City. He may not be as crucial to his team as Kevin De Bruyne, but Fernandinho is certainly number two or three in the champions' squad.


8. Domagoj Vida

Domagoj Vida World Cup 2018
wikipedia

Besiktas' wily centre-back is better known for his look and his antics than his performances, though Vida proved at the World Cup that he is as formidable as he is charismatic. The World Cup finalist isn't 30 years old yet, and last year he wasn't even rated 80.

Vida was part of the over-achieving Croatia team that got to the World Cup final, where they were beaten by France. One could argue that Vida was made to look better than he is by his compatriot, Dejan Lovren, but that would be a disservice to the blonde. He played with a ton of heart and looked like a player that belonged on the world stage. No offence to Besiktas, but Vida is still young and has certainly earned a spot at a bigger club, as well as a significantly higher FIFA rating.


7. Roberto Firmino

Brazil's Roberto Firmino celebrates after scoring his team's second goal during a Copa America Group C soccer match at the Monumental stadium in Santiago, Chile, Sunday, June 21, 2015. (AP Photo/Silvia Izquierdo)
Silvia Izquierdo/AP

Liverpool's talisman is even more crucial to the team than goal-machine, Mohamed Salah, and his overall stats put him ahead of any other #9 in Europe. Despite this, his highest FIFA rating has been 85!

Antoine Griezmann, Sergio Aguero, Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang; three of Europe's top strikers, rated 88, 89, and 87, respectively. Meanwhile Roberto Firmino is rated 85. It may surprise some, but Firmino actually scored more goals than all three of his peers, created twice as many chances, and made twice as many tackles.

Firmino is the total package. He's like 2010 Wayne Rooney but with style and consistent goal-scoring ability. Last season, Premier League pundits started coming around to the Brazilian but it's clear he hasn't won everyone over quite yet. Firmino was overlooked in every match of the World Cup in favour of Manchester City forward, Gabriel Jesus. That team selection persisted until Brazil were knocked out, despite the Man City man not registering a shot on target, while Firmino scored and made assists from the bench. The definition of underrated.


6. Johnathan Tah

jonathan tah
© Axel Heimken/dpa/Corbis

The hulking German centre-back is a stalwart in the Bayer Leverkusen defence, despite being only 22. He played 28 games last season, only received one yellow card, and made some assists to boot. Those are impressive stats that depict a modern centre-back in the vein of a more cool-headed Sergio Ramos.

The young CB should be much higher rated than 82, as he finds himself lower than the likes of Laurent Koscielny, Pepe, Sokratis, and many more. Tah may not be a household name as of yet, but chances are he will move to a bigger team than Leverkusen in the near future. He should have been picked for the Germany national team and could perhaps have saved them from their early elimination.


5. Kasper Schmeichel

Kasper Schmeichel Denmark
Stephen Pond/EMPICS Sport

Schmeichel is often rated around 80 in FIFA, despite being an integral part of the Leicester City team that won the shocked the world and won the Premier League. Further cementing himself as a fantastic goalkeeper, Schmeichel's World Cup performances show his talent is wasted at a mid-tier Premier League team.

In lieu of his heroic, albeit in vain, performance for Denmark against Croatia, Schmeichel has been linked with both Roma and Chelsea. His Leicester City career has been a fantastic one but the former champions are unlikely to ever challenge for the league again, something Kasper certainly deserves to do. Schmeichel proved he is just a step below the world's finest keepers and his rating should be in the mid to high 80s as a reward.


4. Nacho Fernandez

Fernandez Nacho, Real Madrid
Mike Egerton/EMPICS Sport

Nacho Fernandez is often overshadowed by his two Madrid teammates, Sergio Ramos and Raphael Varane. That said, he rarely puts a foot wrong and would be far higher rated if he featured in any other team.

Considering just how good Fernandez really is, it's astounding that he's rated lower than other centre backs like Joel Matip, Vincent Kompany, and Shkodran Mustafi. Nacho Fernandez is unequivocally a better player than all three of those defenders, and his talent is seemingly wasting away at Real Madrid. He is far more disciplined and reliable than the ageing Sergio Ramos, and Raphael Varane had a poor season in 2017/18 (superb World Cup aside). Nacho shouldn't be the third-string centre back at the world's biggest club, nor should his FIFA rating suffer because of it.


3. Harry Maguire

Harry McGuire
TheFA.com

The Leicester City man had a great season and an incredible World Cup. You would think these performances would put Maguire a lot higher than his 79 rating from last year's game, but he won't be on the level of his overrated England team-mate, John Stones.

Maguire will, for sure, be in the 80s in FIFA 19 - he has certainly earned that much. However, the fact that he plays for a mid-tier Premier League team will hinder his chances of reaching the mid-80s where he belongs. Maguire's great season flew under the radar until he proved it on the world stage with England, so it won't be surprising to see him rated around 81 in FIFA 19. However, should his 2018/19 season be just as impressive, EA will be guilty of crime if he isn't rated significantly higher in FIFA 20.


2. Kylian Mbappé

Kylian Mbappe 2018
By Антон Зайцев (https://www.soccer.ru/galery/1058179/photo/737087) [CC BY-SA 3.0 GFDL, CC BY-SA 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0) or GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html)], via Wikimedia Commons

Mbappé was rated 84 in FIFA 18, and he's sure to be closer to 90 in FIFA 19. So how could he possible be underrated?

Well, really it boils down to one thing: Neymar. Given Mbappé's extremely impressive first season at PSG - and World Cup win - is he really a lesser player than Neymar? His Brazilian teammate is undoubtedly extremely talented but he's also a tad overrated. Neymar is the result of a big personality and over-hype - he spent more time on the floor at the World Cup than Paulo Dybala did on the field.

Mbappé proved at the World Cup that he isn't just a big prospect and good understudy to Neymar - he proved that he is already a world class player and, at least, on the same level as the Brazilian. He scored four goals for France, and 22 for PSG in all competitions. Mbappé should be rated 90, as should his teammate, Neymar.


1. Mohamed Salah

1331704

The Liverpool goal-scoring machine set the Premier League alight last season. Salah scored 44 goals in all competitions, on par with Robert Lewandowski, Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi.

Salah quickly became a huge bargain for Liverpool, costing a mere £42 million from Roma. He also became a hero to Egypt, and played admirably for them in the World Cup, despite just returning from a dislocated shoulder. He's looking to repeat that form for Liverpool in the coming season, and drive them towards the club's first ever Premier League title.

Salah's stats prove he should be rated just as highly as Messi and Ronaldo - in the 90s - but he's more likely to be around 87. That puts him below Sergio Aguero, De Bruyne, and Eden Hazard - despite Salah being the undeniable best player in the Premier League.


Contributor
Contributor

Curtis is from Ireland and lives in Canada now.