FIFA 20: 10 Players That Will Be Ridiculously Overrated

FIFA 20 is almost here, but steel yourself for the usual round of overrated names.

Fifa 20 Overrated
Instagram/Wikimedia Commons/EA Sports

EA Sports has a long history of fumbling player ratings in its games; no matter if it's FIFA, NHL, Madden, or NBA. FIFA in particular though, seems to get short shrift if this sense.

Every year there are a swathe of players that are overrated, and plenty that are underrated. You can usually tell who they're going to be as well; big name stars always get a boost based on their popularity, while players at less popular teams seemingly get dealt the short straw. For example, no matter how good a player is for Genoa, he will never be rated as highly as a first-team Barcelona player. It wouldn't matter if he scored 50 goals a season.

So today we want to make some predictions about who will be overrated, based on a healthy dose of assumption and knowledge. FIFA 20 is mere weeks away and we're excited to get our hands on it, but we already know those ratings are going to make our blood boil. So let's prepare ourselves now for the sheer rage when we see the preposterous ratings these 10 players have, for no good reason at all.

10. Diego Godin

Diego Godin Uruguay
Ailura, CC BY-SA 3.0 AT [CC BY-SA 3.0 at (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/at/deed.en)], from Wikimedia Commons

Godin is one of those players who has been around a very long time, and been consistently rated in the 90's. He's an incredibly talented defender who made 277 appearances for Athletico Madrid, many as captain, and helped the team catapult to one of the best in La Liga.

Godin consistently proved himself as one of the best defenders in the world, not just the Spanish first division. In 2019 he made a move to Inter Milan on a three year deal. At the age of 33, the move was a little surprising, but it was a free move, so it wasn't much of a risk for Milan.

That said, when you take a step back and look at Godin's performances on the pitch and his stats, his standard 90 rating in FIFA is starting to look extremely generous. Godin has been a mainstay of Madrid and Argentina for a decade, but his best days are definitely behind him. He's not on the level of people like Virgil Van Dijk, yet he's higher rated, and that's something that needs to change but definitely won't in FIFA 20.


9. Luis Suarez

Luis Suarez
Splash News/Splash News/Corbis

Not too long ago, Luis Suarez could have been considered one of the top three football players on the planet. From 2012-2014, his final two seasons at Liverpool, Suarez scored 54 goals and tore the Premier League to bits.

Following several scandals and a bite at The World Cup that perhaps knowingly forced Liverpool's hand, Suarez was sold to Barcelona for £64 million. Unlike Coutinho who followed him a few years later, Suarez absolutely lived-up to the hype; netting a whopping 184 goals in all competitions.

The Uruguayan striker is still one of the world's best but his stats show he is on the decline. His goal tally has been steadily falling since his insane 64 in all competitions in 2015/16. As such, his standard rating of 91 in FIFA is beginning to look a bit much.

Last year Suarez scored a respectable 21 times in La Liga. Iago Aspas scored 20. Suarez is rated 91, while Aspas is 84. Does that make sense? Of course not, but Suarez is a big name at one of the biggest clubs in the world. If EA had a backbone, it would give Suarez a more accurate rating of 86 for FIFA 20.


8. Thiago Silva

Thiago Silva
Haouzi/Icon Sports/ZUMA Press/Corbis

PSG's Brazilian centre back has been one of the world's best defenders for years. Silva made a name for himself at A.C Milan, including becoming the first non-Italian captain in 50 years. It wasn't long until money came knocking and Silva made a big move to Paris-Saint Germaine.

Since then, Silva has been the first-choice centre back and the captain of the team. He has helped PSG to four league titles out of a possible five. He has been named the best defender in the world by various pundits and peers, and has captained Brazil in multiple tournaments.

So, with all that said, how could he possible not be deserving of his 88 rating in FIFA 19? Well it's simple: in the past year or two, Silva has been declining but his FIFA rating has not.

Thiago Silva was the best defender in the world in 2014, but this is 2019. Five years is a lot of time to pass and he has been entirely eclipsed by the likes of Raphael Varane and Virgil Van Dijk. Silva isn't in their league, and so his rating should be somewhere around 84. Harsh but fair.


7. Kyle Walker

View this post on Instagram

Ready to go again tomorrow down on the south coast!

A post shared by Kyle Walker (@kylewalker2) on

Manchester City's go-to right back, Kyle Walker, has done little to warrant his hefty price tag. Walker moved to Manchester City from Tottenham Hotspur in 2017 for £50 million - a price that made him the world's most expensive defender, at the time.

Walker lost respect from fans when he made the move; Spurs are a high-quality team on the rise, and his move was deemed one made solely for financial reasons. Regardless of the reasons behind the scenes, Walker's first season at City was solid. His defensive capabilities are decent, while his going forward leaves a lot to be desired.

His sophomore season at City was less impressive; Walker played 33 games, racking up only one assist and getting three yellow cards. Compare that to Liverpool's 19-year old Trent Alexander-Arnold, who racked-up twelve assists and one goal.

Yet Walker is rated 84 in FIFA 19, while Alexander-Arnold is rated 80. There is no reason for that, except the fact that Arnold is young and didn't cost Liverpool anything. This right here is perfect proof of EA's bias in regards to price tags, names, and teams. Kyle Walker is a good left-back, but a rating of 81 would be far more accurate.


6. Harry Maguire

View this post on Instagram

#5 ?❤️

A post shared by Harry Maguire (@harrymaguire93) on

Manchester United's block-headed and record-breaking centre back has a heck of a lot to prove in the coming year. If last year and his first few games are any indication however, he won't be the answer to United's problems.

Now, all that might seem a bit harsh, especially considering Maguire is a very good centre-back. However this is one of those painfully predictable situations where EA will overblow a player's quality based on his name, value, and club. Manchester United is one such club where players definitely get a bump, simply for being there.

Maguire has had a decent start to life at United, as he's probably been the team's second best player thus far. However he already has proven he is not the answer to United's defensive woes the way Virgil Van Dijk was to Liverpool's.

Maguire is a really good defender who is guaranteed to score a handful of goals with powerful headers. His name and big-money move will guarantee him a high 80's rating, but his performances should have him sitting much closer to 82. He's not a world-beater, and his rating should reflect that.


5. Paul Pogba

Paul Pogba, Manchester United
Martin Rickett/PA Archive

Manchester United's star player...or so we're told. The truth is, Paul Pogba may very well be the most overrated player on the planet.

Sure, on his day Pogba is truly great - he helped France win the World Cup and has played some blistering games - but his day comes about as frequently as Mario Balotelli's. For a player of his value and status, he should be racking up assists and scoring double digits each year, not fading out of games for months at a time.

Of course, because of his name, he's super divisive. Many Manchester United fans think he could walk into any midfield in the world, while others would rather see Angel Gomes get a chance in his stead. Pogba was once classified as an engine, a box-to-box midfielder, but it's honestly difficult to explain what he is. He isn't defensive but he's a great passer and can score a goal...when he wants to.

The fact of the matter is, no matter how much talent he may posses, if Pogba doesn't perform on the pitch on a consistent basis - and he doesn't - he can't be considered one of the world's best. 88 in FIFA? He should be closer to 82.


4. Mesut Özil

View this post on Instagram

〽❤ #M1Ö

A post shared by Mesut Özil (@m10_official) on

To be completely frank, Mesut Özil hasn't been good enough to play for a top team in a very long time. Now, we could make an easy joke about Arsenal not being a top team, but the truth is the Gunners are still world-class. Özil is not.

Mesut Özil has been on something of a downward trajectory since the 2010 World Cup. That might sound ridiculous but here's the thing; after that tournament he was considered an absolute world-beater. Since then it's been a downward spiral; he joined Real Madrid and failed to light the world on fire; signed for Arsenal three years later and has been little more than a suck on wages ever since.

Özil doesn't add goals or assists to Arsenal, and he's only still at the club because no other team is willing to pay him his wages. The signing of Nicholas Pepe at Arsenal means Özil will spend the majority of the season on the bench.

The 30-year old would be far better suited at a mid-table Premier League team, or somewhere in Italy or Germany. He has survived on name alone and, with that in mind, anything above an 80 rating in FIFA 20 is preposterous.


3. Thomas Muller

Germany's Thomas Muller celebrates victory after the FIFA World Cup Final at the Estadio do Maracana, Rio de Janerio, Brazil.
Mike Egerton/PA Wire

There are a lot of players in the world that skate by on name value alone, and Thomas Muller is one of them. The German international was once a big name that was said to have endless potential, but he never fulfilled it.

Much like his counterpart, Mesut Özil, Muller was part of the 2010 German International team that took the world by storm. Just like Özil, Mario Gotze, Holger Badstuber, and Mario Gomez from that squad, Muller never really broke through to the level we expected.

These days he's scoring 5-8 goals a season for Bayern Munich and getting a handful of assists. Hardly stats befitting of a player rated around 86. Muller is not a world-class striker, nor is he a world-class false nine. He is nowhere near as talented as out-and-out strikers like Harry Kane or Pierre-Emerick Aubamayang, nor is he as talented as false nine's like Roberto Firmino or Paulo Bybala.

So why is he rated so high? Name and name alone. 86 is a truly baffling rating for such a mediocre player, and he should be rated around 80 at best. If he played for Stuttgart we would bet he'd be a lot lower than even that.


2. Gonzalo Higuan

Gonzalo Higuain
By Кирилл Венедиктов - https://www.soccer.ru/galery/1055457/photo/733440, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=70276734

Chelsea has had a real rough time when it comes to getting strikers in the past decade. From the tumultuous Diego Costa to the abysmal Alvaro Morata. After the departure of the latter, Gonzalo Higuain was another signing that was supposed to plug that hole but he failed to do the job.

In his time on loan at Chelsea, the 31 year old had a pretty mediocre time. In 14 appearances he scored 5 goals, followed by Chelsea refusing to extend his loan into anything more permanent. Higuain has returned to Juventus where he is, very much, surplus to requirements.

In fact, Higuain exposed himself greatly as a player that couldn't hang in the Premier League, therefore rendering his 87 rating in FIFA 19, highly questionable. The Premier League has served as a proving ground for foreign strikers to test themselves against the fastest and toughest league, and they either sink or swim. Higuain sank rapidly, albeit not quite as noticeably as Alvaro Morata before him.

So what should his FIFA 20 rating be? Well certainly nowhere near the 87 he got in FIFA 19. He's scored 11 goals in two seasons, meaning his rating should be squarely around 75, but that's never going to happen.


1. Alexis Sanchez

View this post on Instagram

@inter ⚫️?

A post shared by Alexis Sanchez (@alexis_officia1) on

Alexis Sanchez's best days are so far behind him that it's hard for us to even remember when he was good.

At one time, Alexis Sanchez was one of the best players in the Premier League. He ripped defences apart with Arsenal, before deciding he wanted to leave and basically refusing to play. His wish was granted in 2018 when he scored a move to Manchester United. Fans assumed he would immediately return to his absolute best, but it never happened.

Sanchez's form capitulated so much that he only played 32 games for United across two seasons, many of which were as a substitute, and only scored three goals. Manchester United was content to let Sanchez leave on loan to Inter Milan, despite not really having any depth on the right wing.

That alone should indicate just how poor Sanchez has been in the past three or so years. Which begs the question, why on earth is he rated 83 in FIFA 19? Sanchez literally couldn't get a start in the worst Manchester United side we've seen in decades, so a rating of 83 is sheer lunacy. If he wasn't called Alexis Sanchez, his rating would be around 70.


In this post: 
FIFA FIFA 20
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Curtis is from Ireland and lives in Canada now.