Final Fantasy XV: 12 Hands-On First Impressions

Yes, it's still incredibly sexist.

Final Fantasy XV Cindy
Square Enix

After a decade of waiting, Final Fantasy XV is finally, finally upon fans, and what a road it's been getting here.

It's fair to say that the true fan reception to the game won't become clear for a little while as they dig deep into it, but having been lucky enough to play the game for a few days before release, we've got a pretty good idea of what people will and won't like.

Final Fantasy XV is sure to be a divisive game, that's for sure, an insanely ambitious effort that nevertheless feels regressive in a number of key areas. From the 10-or-so hours we've played so far, it doesn't feel like the game will go down as a classic of the franchise, but it's sure to have its passionate cheerleaders all the same.

This play-test is based largely off the 1.01 patched version of the game, with a small amount of time spent playing it following the 1.02 Crown update.

Here are 12 first impressions from Final Fantasy XV...

12. The Graphics Are Great... But Not The Frame Rate

Final Fantasy XV Archaeon
Square Enix

In terms of pure visual fidelity and art style, Final Fantasy XV is a gorgeous game. When running around the sprawling open world, the texture quality and lighting detail are really quite incredible.

It's just a shame, then, that playing the game on a base PS4 without the PS4 Pro enhancements, the console struggles to maintain a consistent frame rate, and early Xbox One players are also reporting a similar level of performance.

Enter a crowded city or get involved in a fight involving dozens of enemies and the frame rate can drop down to the late teens or early twenties, which is rather offputting and definitely detracts from the overall experience, immensely pretty though it is.


11. The Plot Is The Worst Thing About It

Final Fantasy XV Noctis
Square Enix

The Final Fantasy series is no stranger to plots that are, for want of a better word, nonsense. Even at its best, the franchise has had a scarce grip on coherence, yet FFXV takes a surprisingly minimal approach to narrative compared to previous games, instantly making it somewhat reminiscent of last year's Metal Gear Solid V.

The story works best when it sticks to the basics: a road trip centered around four bros, a Romeo and Juliet-esque romance, and a quest to claim a throne. Unfortunately, though, revelations are doled out in a fairly disinterested manner and so make it hard to get much invested in what's going on (so far, at least).

Make no mistake: buying FFXV for the story above all else would probably be a huge mistake. The gameplay is enjoyable enough that it's still a fun title, but this absolutely comes in on the lower end of the series' plots to date.

You can watch the recently-released Kingsglaive movie to get a better idea about the events leading up to the game, but honestly, a game, especially one in this series, really ought to stand on its own two feet.


10. Combat Is A Lot Of Fun

final fantasy XV
Square Enix

By far the most enjoyable part of the game so far is the combat, which feels incredibly diverse and fine-tuned.

Yes, at a most basic level it is entirely possible for a player to over-level, hold the attack button and just spam Hi-Potions every time they hit 0 HP for most engagements, but that totally ignores the immense array of options available to the player otherwise.

The fighting in the series has never felt this smooth or intense, to the point that it can occasionally feel a little too chaotic, but with the Wait Mode option in the game's menu (where the game freezes when Noctis isn't moving, allowing you to strategise your next attack), every style of play feels well catered for.

There will be a lot of things that are badly received in this game, but the combat sure won't be one of them.


9. Driving Is Very Clunky

Final Fantasy XV Driving
Square Enix

Traveling between quests is largely done in the Regalia, the already-iconic car Noctis and his pals drive around in.

The player is given two options, to allow Ignis to drive to destinations while you soak in the scenery, or take manual control yourself (as will be required at night time, as Ignis refuses to drive then).

Auto-driving is fine to a point thanks to the gorgeous sprawling vistas and character banter, and the game smartly allows you to fast-travel to some locations. However, manual driving is, well, awful.

The driving controls and mechanics are so low-effort that it's hard to believe they weren't just tacked-on late in the day. You're kinda-on-rails but at the same time not, and it results in an experience that doesn't feel remotely fun. It could be removed from the game with basically no impact at all.


8. The Open World Feels Huge

Final Fantasy XV
Square Enix

To Square Enix's credit, they've done a pretty damn great job with the open world. Yes, it feels like every AAA franchise is going this route now, but this world actually feels alive and lived-in, with a diverse array of locales even though the map actually isn't as gigantic as it at first seems.

The game makes excellent use of space, ensuring that boredom doesn't set in during some of its less-exciting chapters because the gorgeous locales usually more-than-compensate for it.

Given how nervous many fans were for the series to go this route, this is one aspect of the game that Square Enix has pulled off pretty much flawlessly.


7. It Is Incredibly Casual-Friendly

Final Fantasy XV Combat
Square Enix

One of the most surprising things about the game is just how casual-friendly it feels on the whole. Now, before you panic, it is still very much a quintessential Final Fantasy game, but it's clear throughout that the game has been made for both the hardcore crowd and those who've never touched an FF game before (an opening disclaimer even states as such).

This is most apparent in the game's difficulty, which at least so far is barely existent, due to the player getting a "grace period" of sorts when Noctis' HP reaches zero, allowing them to drink a Hi-Potion and get back into the fight immediately.

I've not hit a single Game Over screen yet while playing on Normal difficulty, and given how capable most early players seem to feel so far, there have already been calls for Square Enix to introduce a Hard difficulty to make those epic battles feel a little more rewarding.


6. The Camera Is Absolutely Terrible

Final Fantasy XV Camera
Square Enix

This game's camera sorely needs a rethink. Before the 1.02 Crown update was released (which marginally improves camera issues), the camera would prove a frequent annoyance during combat, making it difficult to make sense of your place in a large battle, and if your fight ended up near some bushes, you could forget about being able to actually see anything at all.

The update does reduce the agony a little, but the camera is still one of the game's most poorly thought-out aspects, and feels incredibly amateur coming from developers as prestigious and well-known as Square Enix.

This is an issue you might expect and even tolerate from a lot of new IPs, but not one with decades of history behind it.


5. The Bromance Works Surprisingly Well

final fantasy XV 15
Square Enix

Considering that the game's story is pretty forgettable, who expected there to be much effort actually put into any of the characters?

Look, Noctis is no Cloud by any means, but a surprising amount of care has actually been paid to the central bromance between Noctis and his three pals, Ignis, Prompto and Gladiolus.

It helps a lot that an insane amount of seemingly off-the-cuff dialogue has been recorded for those driving sections, and though it will repeat eventually and not all of it is top-tier stuff (but we'll get to that in a moment), it does at least make the central bro-bond feel authentic and convincing.

For one thing, the party members sure are more memorable than the dullards from XIII, even if they do undeniably look like a boy band.


4. Female Characters Are Pretty Embarrassing

Final Fantasy XV Cindy
Square Enix

It's a Final Fantasy game, and more to the point it's a Japanese video game, so it shouldn't be massively surprising that the game's approach to women is, well, a bit rubbish.

The very first female character you meet in the game is Cindy, and of course, she's wearing hot pants and an unbuttoned jacket which reveals her heaving bra underneath.

Other female characters you meet in those earlier hours, such as Iris, feel like they're blatantly pandering to 14-year-old nerds who want their anime-infused wet dreams satisfied, and to any adult playing, it's just rather embarrassing.

The series has always had a rather dubious relationship with women, and that is totally unchanged by the latest entry. Of course, this shouldn't be surprising in the slightest.


3. There Aren't Many FMV Sequences

Final Fantasy XV Noctis
Square Enix

FMV sequences have been a staple of the FF franchise since Final Fantasy VII took the world by storm two decades ago.

High-budget cinematics have been employed to sell big, epic moments to fans and make them totally unforgettable: Aeris' death in FFVIII, the ballroom in FFVIII and that first Blitzball match in FFX to name just three.

Sadly, though, FFXV seems rather low on cinematics, instead opting to tell much of the story through in-engine cut-scenes, which while fine, does take a little of that distinctive, robust FF sheen away from the game.

Yes, these sequences are expensive to produce, but it feels like Square Enix cut corners a little by not including them, and also by simply clipping scenes from the Kingsglaive movie and including them on occasion.

Again, that Metal Gear Solid V comparison rears its head...


2. Quest Diversity Could Be Better

Final Fantasy XV Dungeon
Square Enix

Another thing FFXV has in common with MGSV: the mission diversity is seriously lacking despite the immense array of tools the player is given to cut foes down.

In the main questline in particular, there's not a lot of variety to missions so far, and the dungeon crawling sometimes gets monotonous given the familiarity of the core gameplay.

Yes, the fun combat prevents if from being a total bore, but given the tools, ingenuity and money Square Enix have at their disposal, it feels a little lazy to opt for so many generic, almost MMO-esque quests that basically feel like padding.

It's a common complaint in open world games and RPGs alike, and unfortunately not one that this game has been able to overcome at all.


1. The Dialogue Will Make You Cringe

Final Fantasy XV Prompto
Square Enix

It's a Final Fantasy game, after all, so this shouldn't be unexpected, but yes, there's a lot of bad writing in this game, and while this sometimes results in some unintentional laughs, it's also often straight-up painful to observe.

The abundance of puns and Prompto's frequent singing and screaming about chocobos is enough to make you want to plug your ears up with gauze on occasion.

Though the newer FF games are definitely put at a disadvantage due to having fully voice-acted dialogue (the written word never seems as bad), there's still a lot of ropey chit-hat that's just painfully lacking in self-awareness.

--

What are your expectations for FFXV? Been lucky enough to play it yet? Shout it out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.