Mass Effect 4 Andromeda: 8 Awesome Fan Theories

Someone actually found a way to make Mass Effect 3's ending work, and it fits PERFECTLY.

It goes without saying that Mass Effect's future feels shaky at best, following the "never forget"-style way everyone talks about the closing of part three. Games being segmented into DLC later down the line is pretty much the norm in 2015, but back in 2012 the industry was just starting to play around with the idea - a very prominent casualty being the rollout of what should've been a glorious landmark finale in both sci-fi gaming, and the history of the medium itself. Sadly, pretty much everything about the way EA handled both themselves and the fan reaction was a complete disaster. DLC character Javik originally intended to be on-disc was infuriating, and although Bioware bent to allow for an 'Extended Cut' ending, the fact remains that to this day you can't get the 'full Mass Effect 3 experience' without coughing up extra cash for downloadable content packs. Flash-forward a few years, and although Bioware have lost some key members of their team (smoking gun-holder and lead producer Casey Hudson being one of them), they're back to try their luck at what should have always remained one of the most beloved franchises in all of gaming. There are rumours for gameplay and a laundry list of things that need fixing - but what about that plot? How can they go forward after such a defined endpoint? Well...

8. Andromeda's Timeline Runs Parallel With The Original Trilogy

A very cool timeline assembled by fan, NeroJoe, purports that across the entirety of the first three games, the events of Andromeda's story were also coming into being. According to the various leaks that have emerged regarding ME4's framework as humanity trying to find a new place to colonise and survive, it actually holds together perfectly well. The theory states that as far back as humanity's first discovery of Prothean tech on Mars, there has been existence of a mysterious entity known as 'the Ark'. Top minds from across the galaxy would then work on unlocking its potential in top secret, as the events of the trilogy play out. Right around the time of the Reaper invasion on Earth, Liara T'Soni passes on the same encryption keys used to decipher the Citadel's true purpose, to the previously-formed Ark Contingency (ARKCON), who have been getting nowhere with the artefact for around 30 years. Using the keys, scientists realise it's a gateway to the Andromeda galaxy, and make the necessary preparations to flee Earth through the Ark if the Reapers are successful in any severe capacity. No matter which ending your Shepard chose, Earth was left in one hell of a state of turmoil. The theory concludes that various flotilla ships with the necessary resources to colonise Andromeda leave through the Ark and destroy it on the other side to prevent being followed. These survivors of the Reaper War know nothing of how the battle actually ended, and continue forward, a new age dawning as the various species' within the groups begin to ruminate on what and who they left behind, before exploring what's ahead.

7. The Indoctrination Theory Was Right All Along

Bioware essentially wrote themselves into a hole with the very notion of the Reapers. It's par for the course that once you've introduced a galaxy-wiping reset button, the stakes are irrevocably changed for the worse - but fans picked themselves up and came up with 'The Indoctrination Theory' to explain everything away in the face of overwhelmingly naff odds. The original theory in a nutshell, is that Shepard passes out aboard the Crucible and is mind-controlled by the Reaper, Harbinger. The Starchild is a continued manifestation of the Reapers vying for control of his mind from the very beginning of the game when the same child is seen, and only if Shep chooses to destroy the Reapers - thereby freeing himself of their control - does he wake up after the credits. The assumption by fans, is that Andromeda will carry this forward; Shepard survived after all, and his tale continues to reverberate around the galaxy. Andromeda's plot is rumoured to be focussed on mankind searching for a new place to colonise out in deep space, and if the events of the original trilogy did actually matter, it could be a great way to carry on. However, does going with a 'definitive' ending fly in the face of all those who chose otherwise at the close of ME 3, or please everybody by reframing and salvaging all of Mass Effect 3's worst moments? Answers in the comments.

6. Commander Rider Is The New Main Character

This one is almost a given. In the latest trailer that dropped on 'N7 Day' (November 7th) we got a few scattershot images of various potential features and art assets, as the teaser essentially paid tribute to man's flirtatious foray into space travel and the depths of the back beyond. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rn98FdSg-Fo For the most part it was a ton of archival footage and game-teasing prospects such as first-person spaceship sequences, but one thing that seems poised to come true is the identity of our new main character. If you look very closely at the side of the cockpit during the teaser, you'll notice a set of dogtags that appear to say 'Rider'. Now, the word could just be random or the character could just be placeholder, but consider that 'Shepard' was the surname of the first American male in space, Alan Shepard. And what was the name of the first female American in space? Sally Ride. Boom.

5. A Billionaire's Mad Dream

Very similar to the 'events taking place alongside' theory, another goes with the idea that a wealthy billionaire amassed the funds and personnel to help him/her create their very own Mass Relay. In the established canon, Relay's exist to transport considerable bodies of matter from one specific place to the next, so the idea is that having seen the oncoming Reaper threat, this anonymous billionaire had a Relay constructed, that takes him and his team to the Andromeda galaxy. To give the idea a little bit more credence, there is already the in-canon tale of Victor Manswell, another billionaire who embarked on an excursion in 2070 across the stars with 300 cryogenically frozen crew members. His story goes that they ran into an Asari ship and had a quite tense standoff of "What the hell are you?/No, what the hell are you!?" reactions, until the Systems Alliance calmed things down. Back to the theory, and it closes by saying you'd be playing as one of this rich guy's crew, but the main takeaway is that it still allows all the events of the trilogy to remain canon, albeit discussed vaguely in retrospect as the crew push forward.

4. You Are Shepard's Child

Many fans really don't want to let the original trilogy go, despite it most likely being for the best as we could do away with any character-based ties and focus on the mythology of the world itself. Anyway, a popular theory is simply that your new character is Shepard's child, conceived before the final battle for Earth, and no matter which ending was chosen (although Synthesis certainly throws up some questions) you were quickly stashed away and made your way to the Andromeda galaxy... at some point... somehow. I mean, sure, okay, maybe. For this to even begin to be plausible, you'd have to factor it into the one of the aforementioned 'preparations to leave Earth were underway'-type theories. It's definitely plausible for a wild billionaire or the ARKCON faction to gather up a newborn child as they depart for Andromeda - the purpose being to guarantee as long a life as possible once they arrive - but by itself, this feels more like people desperately hoping for something that guarantees Andromeda feels like a bigger part of the canon. There's also the fact that if you played a lone wolf or had homosexual relations, this entire thing would have to be some sort of 'adopted child' angle? Yeah... it's not the most plausible. Back to the awesome stuff...

3. Humans Are A Threat To The Andromeda Galaxy

Race relations and general distrust were core themes across all three previous games, with the ultimate goal in ME3 being to unite every major race in the galaxy under one cause. This particular theory goes that the Andromeda galaxy have been almost completely unaware of the goings-on within the Milky Way, and as such have only heard bits and pieces about what a 'lowly human' (remember, humans are the last species to join the approved Citadel Races) has been doing to the galaxy or universe itself. A rumoured villainous force we're supposedly going up against are the Khet, a powerful sect of enemies who are seeking to establish dominance by opposing all others. There's also the mysterious Remnant (essentially the new Protheans) whose influence hangs large over the new galaxy, with many stories motivating both the Khet, remaining Remnant and other races to establish what a threat humankind poses to their wellbeing. Also, as mentioned earlier, humans were accepted as a 'trusted' race to the Systems Alliance until they became a Citadel Race in 2165, before discovering Reaper tech and triggering the mass genocide of all species within their own galaxy not 18 years later. It's not a stretch to assume that we humans are actually to be feared, judged and analysed, should any of us then arrive in another galaxy.

2. The Remnant Are Protheans

It's essentially par for the course that your intergalactic menagerie of space politics and laser-blasters has an overarching power structure dating back thousands of years. For Mass Effect it's the Protheans, and to extrapolate further, the Leviathans and the Reapers. For the original trilogy, we occasionally dabbled into the history books to see how the former waged war with the Reapers, the story going that they were completely wiped out - aside from Mass Effect 3's Javik. ...Or were they? Andromeda's story is apparently focussed on another timeless entity known only as the Remnant i.e. something (or someone) that's been left behind. It's completely plausible that as their cities were falling, the highly advanced Prometheans managed to find a way to hop across time and space into the Andromeda galaxy, setting up shop with only a fraction of their populous. In fact, if you check out the original reveal trailer for Andromeda, you'll see some very Promethean-looking architecture sticking out the ground, alluding to where the plot may be heading. We know the doomed race had the technology to survive cryo-stasis, as Javik emerges unscathed 50,000 years later. That could be the same tech that's allowed a small amount of Prometheans to survive across the universe, emerging in a far more volatile and hostile state, thanks to fleeing for their lives beforehand.

1. You're A Survivor Of A Council Scout Ship

It's very hard to get away from the notion of escaping the past trilogy both in a real-world sense, and in the game's canon, so user TBroadhurst has theorised another way to move humankind away from the Citadel in a particularly interesting way. They go with the idea that all the minds working for the Council must've put in place an escape plan, sending out a handful of scout ships as far out as possible when the Reaper invasion was first discovered. Comprised entirely of EDI A.I. programs and Geth members (assumedly going with the idea that an understanding was reached, as oppose to ME1's storyline where they were our initial antagonists), these ships could then journey for as long as necessary without the need for sustenance. The idea is that the majority of these scout ships perish over the course of many lightyears out in the abyss regardless, until the one your character is on lands and begins anew on an unknown planet. The ship you were on contains embryos and other means to kickstart a new civilisation, but the key part is you're completely unaware of the hazards surrounding you, nor the other races or what the galaxy itself holds within. Broadhurst ends his idea saying that eventually you'd figure out the means to travel again, and therein would be the signature pull of Mass Effect; assembling your crew and heading off to see what you could find. Perfect. What are your favourite fan theories so far that make Andromeda fit perfectly? Let us know in the comments!

Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.