Metroid: Every Main Series Game Ranked Worst To Best

The Battle Of 2D and 3D Titles.

Metroid Prime samus
Nintendo

After a few years out of the mainstream, the Metroid series has been enjoying something of a resurgence in recent years. 2017's Samus Returns proves there's still an appetite for classic 2D style Metroid gaming, while fans are still eagerly waiting on news of the much-anticipated fourth entry into the Metroid Prime sub-series.

Unlike its more successful counterparts Mario and Zelda, which have upgraded and reinvented themselves over the years, Metroid's formula remains largely similar to that of the the original game, with the series' various developers focusing more on perfecting the formula than experimentation and reinventing the wheel.

While the series' debut 3D title, 2002's Metroid Prime, seemed to bring the franchise up to speed with Nintendo's flagship franchises, fans have longed for a return to more traditional 2D-style gaming, with many discussions focusing on the merits of both gameplay styles.

A bridge to merge the two, Other M on the Nintendo Wii, proved unsuccessful, but the series is overflowing with standout titles in both two and three dimensions.

Metroid Prime 4 may be a bit of a way off yet, giving players plenty of time to revisit the other classic titles in the Metroid series. But which of Samus' outings remain must-plays, and which are better left alone?

10. Metroid (1986)

Metroid samus
Nintendo

Some debut titles in video game franchises, like 1986's Super Mario Bros and 1991's Sonic The Hedgehog, have remained classics and fan favourites decades after their original release, laying the foundation for the games to come while also remaining wonderfully playable and enjoyable to this day.

1986's Metroid, released on the humble NES, is not one of these games.

While Nintendo's ambitious space-themed adventure platformer certainly laid the groundwork for the games to follow (even pioneering a whole genre of its own, influencing Metroidvania titles such as Hollow Knight over thirty years after its release), the original Metroid title is a pain to play today.

The lack of a world map, clumsy controls, long stretches of anonymous corridors and the most obnoxious password system seen in gaming, Metroid is as interesting a curio as it is infuriating a game.

Its 2004 Gameboy Advance remake, however, is another story...


9. Metroid II: Return Of Samus

Metroid II   Return Of Samus (World) 3
Nintendo

The series' first and only Game Boy title, Metroid II streamlined the non-linear Metroid experience to maximise the humble handheld's capabilities, effectively taking a step back even as Super Mario Bros III was solidifying the side-scrolling platforming genre.

Despite its relative linearity (and huge sprites taking up a little too much of the tiny screen), the Return Of Samus remains more playable and enjoyable than its predecessor, the stripped-back gameplay perfectly suited for pick-up-and-play bouts.

Sure, the restriction of only having two proper action buttons continues to be grating, but the division of the world into a smaller map of manageable chunks makes Metroid II much easier to navigate than the SR388 of the original, despite the awful monochrome/sickly green background screen.

By shaking up the formula somewhat, Metroid II also ensured the series wouldn't be just a one-trick pony, while thankfully not sidelining the series anywhere near as much as The Adventure Of Link did The Legend Of Zelda franchise.


8. Metroid: Other M

Metroid Other M
Nintendo

Criticised for its overwrought (and terribly acted) cutscenes, its awkwardly contrived linear progression, and its absolutely ludicrous idea to map 3D movement to a D-pad for the sheer sake of nostalgia, Metroid: Other M isn't half bad, an entertaining Wii shooter once you look past all its (glaring) issues. It just doesn't really feel like a Metroid game.

Like its contemporary The Legend Of Zelda: Skyward Sword, Metroid: Other M opted to steer its franchise into more overtly cinematic territory, losing the free-form exploratory aspects that made the previous entries into the series so fun to begin with.

While the story is needlessly clunky and imposes a little too much on gameplay, and the game's first-person aspects are severely under-utilised, Other M is a pretty entertaining shake-up to the formula, though all its criticisms are perfectly valid.


7. Metroid: Fusion

metroid fusion
Nintendo

Another game initially criticised for its relative linearity, Metroid Fusion - released alongside its GameCube big brother Metroid Prime - was the first 2D Metroid game in eight years, and sought to capitalise on the success of its predecessor Super Metroid.

While Fusion retains many of the gameplay aspects of the more famous third game in the franchise, like the Return Of Samus before it, hardware restrictions necessitated a more linear experience. Gone was the overarching inter-connected map of yore, in favour of separate map departments with few links between them.

An entertaining ride from start to finish (with the SA-X sections being a particular highlight), Metroid Fusion just doesn't add enough to the franchise to warrant too much revisiting. An obvious attempt to imitate Super Metroid, Fusion wasn't a bad game, but one which ultimately suffered thanks to the success of the contemporaneous blockbuster, Metroid Prime.


6. Metroid Prime 2: Echoes

metroid prime 2 quadraxis
nintendo

Following up on what is widely considered one of the best video games of all time was never going to be an easy task, but Metroid Prime developer Retro Studios stepped up to the challenge and delivered.

Taking a cue from The Legend Of Zelda playbook by including parallel dark and light worlds, complete with dungeon-style puzzles, Echoes attempted to shake up the formula established in the series' first 3D game.

Unfortunately, some of the changes were not so well received by fans. While replicating a past game to the letter is never wise (just look at the ill-fated "New" Super Mario Bros series), Prime's tight formula made any additions and variations feel somewhat extraneous.

Echoes has also been criticised for its unforgiving gameplay, reverting the series to almost NES-era nail-biting difficulty. While its challenging nature made it a hit with hardcore gamers, Echoes proved an awkward transition for those coming straight off the back of the more accessible Prime.


5. Metroid: Zero Mission

metroid zero mission
Nintendo

Essentially an upgraded re-release of the original 1986 Metroid title, Zero Mission rehashes Samus' earliest story through a Super Metroid and Fusion filter.

Zero Mission gains points over its GBA counterpoint for revisiting the original title's interconnected world map which would come to define the series.

Zebes is a joy to explore, Zero Mission's updated graphics making previously anonymous stretches of corridor actually feel distinct, and the presence of an actual in-game map is a massive relief. Gone too is the original title's password system, the save rooms making Zero Mission the definitive version of the game.

But Zero Mission provides more than just a layer of spit and polish, with an entire new stealth section added at the end of the game. It might not elevate the overall package by much, but it mixes up the gameplay enough to be notable, as well as cementing Zero Mission as a worthy game to play itself rather than just being a straightforward port.


4. Metroid Prime 3: Corruption

Metroid Prime 3
Retro Studios

Probably one of the few games in any franchise that actually benefited from the implementation of the Wii's motion controls, the ability to point Samus' laser cannon at the screen increased immersion, making players feel like Nintendo's infamous bounty hunter herself.

Toning down the difficulty of its predecessor, Corruption streamlines the formula somewhat, with Samus hopping between different planets too often to explore them in too much detail.

While this gives the third (and apparently final) title in what was then the Metroid Prime Trilogy a semblance of Metroid Fusion-style linearity, arguably paving the way for its widely panned successor Other M, Corruption's gameplay never feels stale or contrived.

More action-oriented than its GameCube predecessors (no doubt to capitalise on the WiiMote's pointing mechanics, the success of Corruption prompted Nintendo to re-release the original Prime games on the Wii in the form of a Trilogy bundle.

Get this on the Switch soon, Nintendo.


3. Metroid: Samus Returns

Metroid samus returns
Nintendo

Doing for Return Of Samus what Zero Mission did for Metroid 1986 and then some, the success of Samus' first 2D outing in thirteen years proves there's still an appetite for classic side-scrolling Metroid gaming.

Finally giving players the ability to aim in any direction, Samus Returns added a bunch of new features into the mix, the most notable being the bounty hunter's melee attack. While zipping through enemies has always been satisfying, this subtle touch was a refreshing and well-implemented way to shake up the gameplay without feeling like an arbitrary gimmick.

Moreover, Samus now has the ability to scan rooms to reveal certain secrets, a welcome addition for newcomers to the franchise given how well-hidden these can be. Thankfully, this is entirely optional, so the more hardcore gamer out there can still get their Metroid exploration fix.

One of the best looking games on the Nintendo 3DS, SR388's three dimensional backgrounds make the environment seem like a living world.

Come on Nintendo, it's about times we get a new original 2D adventure.


2. Metroid Prime

Metroid Prime
Nintendo

While Nintendo's flagship franchises Mario and The Legend Of Zelda received 3D updates on the Nintendo 64, fans of the Metroid franchise had to wait until 2002 to see how Samus would play in a fully fledged and entirely explore-able environment.

And boy, was it worth the wait. Not only does the first entry in the Metroid Prime sub-series still look fantastic eighteen years later, it somehow perfectly mapped the refined gameplay of Super Metroid onto a 3D environment.

Thankfully not turning the game into a full-blown shooter, Metroid Prime's first-person viewpoint seems at odds with the game's focus on exploration, though Retro Studios managed to merge the genres seamlessly.

Up there with the likes of Ocarina Of Time, Metroid Prime is still considered by many to be one of the best video games of all time. While its sequels have not quite managed to live up to its heights, if the much-anticipated Metroid Prime 4 manages to do to the series what Breath Of The Wild did to Zelda, fans are in for a treat indeed.


1. Super Metroid

Super Metroid
Nintendo

Like its distant SNES cousin, The Legend Of Zelda: A Link To The Past, Super Metroid on the Super Nintendo is in many ways the purest game in its series, perfecting the Metroid experience.

The labyrinthine puzzle-world of Zebes remains impressive to this day. Each distinct part of the map fit so seamlessly together that at times the game seems to anticipate the overarching interconnected worlds of 3D games, despite remaining firmly fixed to a 2D plane.

While the game implements areas present in the franchise's original outing, Zebes has been given more than a minor face lift. Gone are the endless identical corridors, the frustrating lack of a map, and the clunky two button system of its predecessors. Super Metroid refines the Metroid experience while never streamlining it, and remains a game that bursts with discovery around every corner.

Quite possibly the best-looking 2D game of all time, this almost 30-year-old title has barely aged a day, both in terms of its visual design and gameplay. The tight controls (with plenty of customisation options) make Samus a joy to play, and the atmosphere evoked by the game's small details (dead scientists in the corridor, an unexpected boss battle in the opening minutes of the game) gives Super Metroid a cinematic air.

It's a true testament to the strength of Super Metroid's design that it not only remains a joy to play, but is still influencing games three decades after its original release.


Watch Next


The IMPOSSIBLE Nintendo Quiz: How Well Do You Know Their Games?

Kid Icarus
Nintendo

1. Who Directed Kid Icarus: Uprising?

In this post: 
Metroid
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

When Matteo isn't cashing in on a lifetime of devotion to his favourite pop culture franchises and indie bands, he's writing and publishing poems and short stories under the name Teo Eve. Talk about range.