Ranking Every Rockstar Game From Worst To Best
16. Manhunt 2
When the first Manhunt arrived, it felt as though Rockstar were embracing their bad boy image to create something that would completely own the fear-mongering headlines. Though simply because of that fact, when Manhunt 2 started whirring into life, the media were ready to pounce.
The centre of many controversies surrounding potential links to real-life murders and an easy scapegoat for various politicians to stage "We've got your best interests at heart" campaigns, it didn't matter that Manhunt 2 actually played extremely well.
Though it lacked the overall character arc and table-turning power fantasy of the original, the introduction of more weapons and ways to kill - alongside a solid story that ended with a brilliant twist - was enough to make this extremely fun, if you were a fan of all things covered in claret.
Ultimately the game just couldn't escape the entire western hemisphere gunning for it, resulting in many bans and an AO age rating, leaving Rockstar to apply vision filters over gorier scenes, alter how the game's ending was unlocked and completely remove the 'rating' system for your kills.
Still, great game - if you can see through the blood.
15. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories

Just like with Liberty City Stories, Rockstar weren't ones to just churn out feature-stripped version of an older game.
Instead, alongside having all-new characters, a banging soundtrack, cutscenes and new grapple fight animations for Lance Vance's brother Vic, we now had a Scarface-style property tycoon substructure governing your overall progression outside of the story.
It gave you a constantly moving set of goals involving the buying out of locations and the defending of others - not unlike San Andreas' gang turf wars. Multiplayer once again returned (yes, GTA multiplayer in Vice City) for up to six players and performance could render the whole city in far greater detail than the 2002 original.
This was a technical marvel, and for all those wanting GTA to "return to Vice City", Rockstar already did - it was fantastic.
14. L.A. Noire
Often thought of as being developed solely by Team Bondi, Rockstar utilised many of their worldwide studios to help out, ultimately earning them enough of a credit to appear on this list. After all, L.A. Noire includes all the 'Rockstar tropes' such as a corner mini-map and an open-world mission structure.
As for the game itself, certain combinations of trigger-able dialogue meant main-man Cole Phelps could fly off the handle and return to cool, calm calculation within seconds, but it wasn't enough to derail the project entirely.
Pioneering the best facial technology gaming had ever seen, L.A. Noire's ambition covered any cracks in the consistency of individual conversations, as at any given moment you could be scouring crime scenes, interrogating suspects, engaging in firefights or ramming another target off the road.
Like a 'thinking man's crime game', L.A. Noire is the sort of thing you were just appreciative to even see the light of day - so refreshing and accomplished was its approach to realising a certain vision of old-school Americana detective work.
13. Grand Theft Auto IV
Arguments in the comments as to whether GTA IV really is the 'worst' of the main bunch, as personally I'll always drop it points for having such an unlikeable setting, cast of characters and motivation.
Niko's supposed to drive to secure the 'American Dream' was forever at odds with actions that saw him genocidally wipe out an entire city block with a rocket launcher, only to complain in-cutscene that he "was trying to leave this life behind". It just simply didn't add up, but thankfully all of Rockstar's past efforts in designing the perfect game engine paid off.
From a pure gameplay approach, GTA IV was a technical marvel. The amount of ways you could approach and complete missions felt almost unprecedented once you factored in real-world physics.
Shattering windscreens with a hail of bullets, popping tires to send your target careening into a food cart or rigging explosions to pirouette an enemy across an abandoned warehouse, there was a grit and realism to GTA IV that didn't always 'feel' like GTA, but was an altogether more accomplished beast.
12. Midnight Club 3: DUB Edition
Taking all the lessons learned from Grand Theft Auto and refining them so that driving was the main focus, Midnight Club 3 was the fastest instalment yet. Even the starting cars would see the screen shake and tunnel vision set in once you prodded the nitrous button - the immediately enjoyable rush of pulling ahead connoting that scene in the first Fast & the Furious where we see what these supercars can do at 100mph.
Reprising the same checkpoint races that always made Midnight Club that breath of fresh air against the more linear Need for Speeds of the world, MC3 expanded this freeform "Just find a way to the marker" approach to some of the series' most detailed cities yet. And best of all, there were three of them - San Diego, Atlanta and Detroit.
Customisation was also a notable step-up, though what the game lacked in complexity it doubled-down on with dedicated upgrade paths. It more than suited the feel of Midnight Club as this bastion of arcade racing entertainment: You're always racing, always upgrading, and always going faster.
Sublime.
11. Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories

Proving the impossible, before minds were blown many years later by putting the PS2 GTAs onto phones, Rockstar shrank GTA III's Liberty City down onto the PSP.
Not content with a straight port, we got one of the best 'callbacks' and expansions of an original game in history. Playing as Toni Cipriani (a mission-giver in GTA III), LCS was a prequel, though alongside the basic layout of the same city we got motorbikes, clothing options and scores of interiors to blast our way through.
All of this, plus Rockstar's first attempt at making GTA multiplayer. Multiple PSPs could hook up and partake in races and deathmatches - which let me tell you, made for some spectacular high school lunchtimes.
Understandably there was a small knock to graphics being it was all being crammed onto a UMD, but as the first attempt at "GTA on the go", this was phenomenal.
10. Midnight Club: Los Angeles

Returning after a three year break to assumedly reassess just what they wanted to do with the franchise, Midnight Club L.A. dropped with some of Rockstar's best graphics to date, smoothing over the more completely ridiculous aspects of MC3 (such as jumping bikes across the city in huge arching stunts) to produce a sequel that was a little more mature.
Bikes still returned despite being fine-tuned, and man were they a lot of fun. Street racing games shine when they allow multiple vehicle types to face off against one another, and though past Midnight Club releases include crotch-rockets before, Los Angeles' weightier handling let them fire out of corners like nothing else.
From vehicle types to the variety of classes therein, design of the world, much more fun cop A.I. and the best levels Rockstar have put together just begging to be memorised and mastered, Midnight Club's big send-off was also it's finest hour.
9. Grand Theft Auto V
You could tell Rockstar pulled out all the stops for GTA V. After having rode high on top of the world with one of the most lucrative franchises in gaming, they'd reinvest all that cash into making one of the most expansive and technically impressive games of all time.
Every last inch of GTA V feels laboured over to a ridiculous degree. From the undersides of quad bikes to the thousands of NPC design choices, the way Rockstar's RAGE engine reacts to pretty much anything you can think of with a hilarious repercussion is straight-up genius.
The beauty of watching day turn to night is something else - this is the culmination of everything that was first set in motion way back in 1997. A living, breathing, dynamic world just waiting for you to get lost in.
Up against the other GTAs it's very hard to say V's story, characters or humour hold up, but as a pure achievement in game design, it's a lifetime achievement.
8. Max Payne 3
Max Payne 3 is one of those games that was simply shown to the public in the worst possible way. Electing to show us a "new Max" that was bald, wearing a Hawaiian shirt and standing in the Brazilian favelas, you couldn't get further away from the hard-boiled New York detective we new and loved.
Of course in the end, this sequence was played for laughs, symbolic of how much Max had stopped caring; shaving his hair off and wearing such outlandish clothing as some hilariously dark comment on how completely f*cked his life had become.
What a life it was. Max's third outing does take on a completely different tone with Dan Houser behind the pen, turning in a Man on Fire-looking blend of intrusive editing techniques and self-deprecating one liners.
Actual gameplay was stellar as Rockstar put their all into crafting the best third-person combat money could buy. Ragdoll physics, super slow-motion, every individual bullet perforating the environment and Max himself needing to be piloted through the levels, carrying with him a sense of heft and regret.
I might go so far as to say Max Payne 3 is a noir masterpiece - something every action fan should play, as if you were put off by the initial marketing, don't let it continue to pass you by.
7. Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
When you were Rockstar circa 2004, just what boundaries were there left to break?
With GTA III and Vice City, we had two landmark releases that redefined the very idea of a world on the other side of the screen, though once we saw San Andreas, all assumptions was obliterated all over again.
Playing basketball in the cul-de-sac of Grove Street, base jumping off Mt. Chiliad, donning a suit to gamble in Las Venturas, stealing a plane from the local airport - San Andreas encapsulates that older, more 'punk rock' mentality Rockstar used to exude before they'd fully given in to the big time. As a location it represents the 90s rap aura so many artists to this day harken back to, with one of the best soundtracks in gaming history backing every bullet.
The only thing that stops it rising higher comes from how much Rockstar pushed GTA III's tech to the point of splitting at the seams. San Andreas had some of the worst missions in the franchise simply because they were asking the player to perform feats that the control scheme and physics models were never built for.
At the same time, it did give us the cultural meme of "You were only supposed to follow the damn train, CJ!"