Ranking Every Rockstar Game From Worst To Best

6. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City

GTA Vice City
Rockstar

There's style and then there's Vice City. Suffering a smidge from occasionally poor mission design, the majority of Vice City was like a playable montage of everything people love about the 80s.

The clothes, the sun-scorched Miami/Vice City strip, the ludicrously OTT cars. The soundtrack... what an exemplary collection of songs, responsible for getting an entire generation into all sorts of forgotten bands and styles of music.

Vice City wasn't just a video game or a set of characters, levels and moments, it was a cultural movement. On the gameplay side, Rockstar would add such quality-of-life improvements as diving from moving cars, popping tires and swimming, but together as a package there's not been any time period in any game since that came quite so close to replicating an era like this.


5. The Warriors

the warriors
Rockstar

Nobody apart from a certain sect of film buffs had even heard of The Warriors before 2005, but after it would see a huge resurgence in popularity, reintroduced to a new generation some 26 years after the movie's release.

Clearly a passion project on behalf of Rockstar themselves, The Warriors had studio attempting to revitalise the ageing brawler. Giving you a number of bone-snapping melee attacks, gang commands and minigames to pull off for, say, stealing a car radio, this was retro GTA with a side of being otherwordly.

I say the latter because you were up against gangs like the face-painted Baseball Furies or the all-women Lizzies. The Warriors became a cult classic because it was like Mad Max set inside the underbelly of the big city with an ice-cool soundtrack to boot.

Rockstar's adaptation - in a genius move - fleshed out the events of what happened before, during and after the film, providing the perfect tribute to the source material before letting the team have fun with all the characters many fans already had affinity for.

Hopefully going forward, they'll take a look back and implement some of The Warrior's perfect combat controls when designing GTA VI.


4. Manhunt

Manhunt game
Rockstar

The beauty of Manhunt's unrelentingly bleak presentation comes from Rockstar reframing the GTA 'underdog' story into one that happens more preternaturally. In this case you're literally on the back foot, fighting for your life as one Lionel Starkweather has recruited various gangs and cordoned off chunks of the city so he can make a "last man standing" snuff film.

Simply down to such a horrific scenario, you'll go from scrabbling to secure kills against individuals distracted from their respective packs with plastic bags and shards of glass, to getting your hands on rifles, hammers and eventually, a chainsaw.

By the time you've adapted to blending into the shadows and turning the tables on your oppressors, walking up to Starkweather - chainsaw-in-hand - for the ultimate retribution is possibly Rockstar's most emotionally charged moment yet.


3. Grand Theft Auto III

gta iii
Rockstar

It is very hard splitting the hairs necessary to parse out which out of GTA Vice City, San Andreas or III is the best, but if we're talking about them on the whole - factoring in optional open-world features just as much as the designed mission path - GTA III takes the cake.

Being a far more straightforward, grounded crime story, there's none of the experimental off-putting stuff like piloting helicopters around building sites or trying to gun down gangsters in a toy plane like in the sequels. GTA III gets to up its visuals thanks to the world being fairly small in retrospect, but that also means this 2001 version of Liberty City has a really inviting and memorable identity.

A lot of the pedestrian banter is just hilarious, your weapon set is perfectly varied and the hierarchy of cars you "unlock" by finding them only mirrors the swathe of destruction you cut from Portland to Shoreside Vale.

GTA III is just as much a masterpiece now as it was then, responsible for the open-world genre's rise to prominence and every last freeform exploration quirk we've seen the industry create since. The only quibbles come from unresponsive targeting, but when playing now that still won't stop you getting embroiled in one of the best crime capers Rockstar have ever created.


2. Bully

Bully game
Rockstar

Proof positive that Rockstar do their finest work away from the big budget 'necessities' of "another GTA". Bully saw them apply GTA's engine and design philosophy to high school, replacing the gang violence, gunfire and vehicular carnage for jocks vs. nerds, slingshots and skateboards.

Though the game garnered monumentally incendiary impressions as something promoting violence between children, Bully (or Canis Canem Edit in the UK) was actually about keeping the peace. Yes, you could indulge your anarchic side and thwack a teacher with a wayward stink bomb, but this was more Little Rascals than Brick, and spud-faced Jimmy Hopkins was just as much being bullied by those around him as he was trying to establish a sense of place in the madness of hormone-fuelled elementary.

Ultimately this playfully used GTA's reputation and mechanics to springboard into another echelon of pure young adult escapism. The soundtrack was straight-up Harry Potter, whilst the game would recognise your system clock to ensure come Christmas you booted up with a snowball in-hand, ready to fight back against those pesky prefects.

Therein lies the genius of Bully and a game with an identity so loveable, Rockstar both need to do a sequel, but can also let it age with grace.


1. Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption
Rockstar

There's a quality to the very way Red Dead controls and feels in motion that elevates it above everything else Rockstar have ever done. Everything, from the way John Marston tips his hat at a barman to the sun breaking over the horizon of another dusty day in the outback has a cinematic, perfectly handcrafted quality.

The very life you lead in Red Dead feels far more nuanced and impactful, too. Take a moment away from hogtying bandits to read the paper and you might find an advert for a shop wanting animal pelts. Journey off across the wilderness to secure said pelts from whatever comes your way - stopping to help someone being robbed or wrangling a wayward horse for its owner along the way - and you can actually follow the address from the advert to find the place and complete the transaction.

That, is a level of immersion and a deft mastery of the open-world genre you won't find anywhere else. On top of this you've got things like the crossover into Mexico (complete with Jose Gonzales' haunting So Far Away in the background), one of the finest scripts ever written delving into philosophical and socio-political themes on the power of wealth, religion and purpose, and a finale that lets you seek revenge completely of your own accord.

When the bar of quality is this high, Red Dead Redemption II can happily be "more of the same", but on the other hand, perfection has already been reached, and the whole world should explore every last inch of this 2010 masterwork first.


Watch Next


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.