Ranking Summer 2016's Video Games From Worst To Best

From exploring the cosmos, to catching Pokémon in your back garden.

summer 2016 video games
Telltale/Square Enix/Nintendo

2016 may be looked back upon as when the racial hate-spewing Trumpocalypse began in full, but for gamers, it's been fantastic.

Not only did we start the year with the likes XCOM 2, Dark Souls 3, Firewatch and The Witness, but they were quickly followed up by The Division, DOOM, Uncharted 4 and the phenomenal Overwatch.

Contrastingly, the beginning of 2015 was remarkably stilted, its first couple of months only producing noteworthy flubs such as The Order: 1886 or Evolve, before The Witcher 3 dropped in May and finally kickstarted this generation in full. Since then, it's been full steam ahead, as CD Projekt RED's masterpiece heralded in the likes of Rocket League, MGS V: The Phantom Pain and Fallout 4.

That momentum has maintained to this day, and you need only look at the last few months to take stock of what an incredible generation it's been so far. Yes, there are always missteps and I'll cover them too, but once you start looking at everything in retrospect, worst turns to best pretty quick.

Now, for the sake of establishing some parameters for 'summer', the Met Office classifies it as beginning "on 1 June 2016 and ending on 31 August 2016", which gives us a solid three months to play with.

What are the best and worst game of summer 2016? See if you agree with my ranking, and let us know in the comments!

--

18. Mighty No.9

mighty no 9
Comcept

By far the worst game of not just the summer but 2016 overall (unless something astoundingly cack emerges between now and New Year), Keiji Inafune's return to the Mega Man franchise - because that's what this was, in all but name - should have been welcomed with open arms.

And initially, it was - the Kickstarter obliterated its stretch goals and raised almost four million dollars, resulting in developers Comcept deciding to support every platform under the sun, alongside adding in pointless multiplayer elements that nobody wanted in the first place, just to 'justify' the money at hand.

Naturally, it all fell apart. Inafune started multiple other projects instead of focussing on MM9, the game's launch trailer was one of the most pathetically misguided attempts at being "down with the kids" of all time, and the whole thing looked like a budget PS2 game made by someone who would struggle to even spell Mega Man, let alone code anything.


17. Umbrella Corps

Resident Evil Umbrella Corps
Capcom

In a move that initially made us all sigh and say, "Just... what the hell are you doing, Capcom?", Resident Evil spin-off Umbrella Corps now makes some modicum of sense when put next to Resi 7.

See, apparently the developer wanted to give fans of the more action-oriented parts of their titles, an entire game, whilst getting the train back on track with the next main game, being RE7 will focus on one man exploring a mansion in search of his wife.

See? It makes some sense now. Still, you still have to contend with why Umbrella Corps is more shallow than Peter Molyneux's business integrity, why there's barely anything to see or do other than hold the left trigger and then the right - or why you'd bother with this by-the-numbers over-shoulder shooter when you could play anything else on the market and have a better experience.


16. Trials Of The Blood Dragon

Trials Of The Blood Dragon
RedLynx

The result of Ubisoft realising that 'whacky' things tend to sell well (because the internet) Trials of the Blood Dragon was announced at E3 2016 as some carefree combination of Far Cry's best-selling DLC and Trials' own increasingly off-kilter plot, hinted at in Trials Fusion.

The result was... actually terrible. The game now saw awful platforming segments added where you'd hop off your bike to complete them, alongside some unresponsive shooting and an aesthetic that strived for Hotline Miami-levels of 80s noir cool, but ended up in the gutter instead.

You have to admire the pitch of Trials of the Blood Dragon, but playing it was unequivocally Not A Good Time.


15. Ghostbusters

Ghostbusters game
Activision

Speaking of things that were not fun for all involved, everything about Sony's 'resurrection' of a franchise people still pay tribute to every Halloween, meant they had to kill it first. The movie was an unmitigated disaster, but part of its one-two punch of mediocrity came in the form of a video game.

Now, props to developers FireForge for having a cast of 'busters that are both male and female (WHAT A REVOLUTIONARY THOUGHT), but in-game, you spent far too much time exploring and aimlessly wandering around, than actually taking down any spectres.

Playing in the mould of Diablo/Gauntlet, teaming up with your mates for some colourful shooting should've been a literal blast, but thanks to a combination of repetitive gameplay and the Ghostbusters name being dragged through the muck at the time, it sold so bad that Fireforge were forced to declare bankruptcy.

Bummer.


14. Dangerous Golf

Dangerous Golf
Three Fields Entertainment

"The guys behind Burnout and Black are making a new game!" came the headlines, only for us punters to realise that is wasn't a new blisteringly fast racer or debris-showering shooter - instead, they'd ostensibly made a physics demo, where you destroy things with golf balls.

O... kay?

Did you ever play PAIN, on PS3? Dangerous Golf has exactly the same amount of appeal and longevity as Sony's little "Look what the PS3 can do!" tech showcase. It's fun the first few times, watching objects crumple and smash off one another, but still, when you're the people behind Burnout and you make something other than another racing game?

Sorry, but no thanks.


13. Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter

sherlock holmes the devil's daughter
Frogwares

I really wanted to like Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter. There was so much potential for Frogwares' longtime series to continue building on the momentum of 2014's severely underrated Crimes & Punishments.

Then, like a solid rock band putting out a song with 'mainstream radio appeal', they redesigned Watson into more of an athletic, Jude Law/Guy Ritchie-type, opted to factor in a number of first-person platforming elements, amped up the action with some naff set-pieces, took the game's formula open-world (ish) and neglected to polish up animation across the board.

Not the best way to deliver a sequel, I must say.

Where Crimes & Punishments easily outdid L.A. Noire for pure, proficient detective work, multiple endings for cases and elaborating on how Sherlock thinks before making deductions, The Devil's Daughter focussed way too much on aping the silver screen adaptations of the character, which by me, are the worst versions of everything longt-time fans love about the character in the first place.


12. Mirror's Edge: Catalyst

mirrors edge catalyst
EA

There's something about first-person platforming that just doesn't feel right, unless it's done exquisitely well.

Enter Mirror's Edge, a game that mostly nailed the momentum of flying through space faster than the average human, but fell down a tad thanks to forced combat segments and not a ton of gameplay variety overall. Fans cried out for a sequel to remedy what was left behind, to which EA finally obliged... and nobody showed up.

Catalyst seemed to come and go back at the start of June with nary fans or critics championing any aspect of its production whatsoever. Stilted voice acting, glitchy graphics in spots and yet more forced combat, Mirror's Edge seems destined to hop, skip and jump its way into the bargain bin.


11. The Technomancer

the technomancer
Spiders

You can check out a full review of The Technomancer over here, but sufficed to say, Spider Studios nailed some aspects of their Mad Max-on-Mars vision perfectly, whilst falling down in many aspects of the game's overall presentation.

Basically, it's The Witcher 3's combat, except with three stances to hop between on the fly. One for agility and dodging, one for ranged combat and stick n' move poison damage, and one that lets you block, alongside delivering devastating counters. Swapping between these gives Technomancer a great feel and progression in terms of unlocking new moves before combining them all together, but its RPG aspects - the characterisation, voice acting and general animation necessary to hold the package together, don't add up.

If you're the forgiving sort who can get past the terrible narrative delivery prevalent in David Cage's games, you'll get a kick out of everything Technomancer is trying to achieve, but ultimately, it's the perfect 6/10 game.

An Alpha Protocol, if you will.


10. LEGO Star Wars: The Force Awakens

Lego Star Wars Millennium Falcon
Lucasfilm

Right, onto the good stuff!

At this stage, if you've played any of the LEGO games, you'll know their pros and cons; fun, light combat mixed with floaty platforming and repetition overall, right?

Well, yes, but they've smoothed over the naff platforming, and for TFA's case, have added some puzzles and cover-shooter mechanics to keep things fresh. Factor in that outside of Disney Infinity, this is the only way to play anything relating to one of 2015's biggest and most enjoyable movies, and there's enough appeal right there to paper over the remaining cracks that come with such a long-in-the-tooth franchise.

Oh, and the entire cast reprise their roles - even Harrison Ford (!) - for additional bonus scenes and dialogue. Boom.


9. Headlander

Headlander game
Double Fine

Tim Schafer's Double Fine studio know just how to craft a game world that's positively bursting with character and charm, and Headlander is no different.

Playing as a disembodied head that can attach itself to all manner of bodies, the whole thing has a retro-60s psychedelia feel to it - one routed in how society viewed the future back then. The score has that "chicka-wow" guitar noise associated with total cheese-fests, whilst graphical filters and environment design are occasionally washed out, yet still have robots and neon signs galore.

Gameplay is Metroidvania through and through, as you journey through immense structures, locating appropriate bodies for certain gateways, retrieving specific items, blasting enemies with lasers and of course, flying your booster-bottomed head all over the place.

Headlander is a delight, something that goes on the charm offensive without you even realising - it's easily one of Double Fine's greatest works this decade.


8. Monster Hunter Generations

monster hunter generations
Capcom

It's been quite some time since a game completely engulfed me in all sorts of different systems, to the point where I completely lost track of time. Monster Hunter Generations is such a game, and with the freeform narrative of simply being one of many titular monster hunters, you're afforded the freedom to spec and upgrade your character any way you like.

The bigger the creature, the fancier the loot, and soon you'll be wearing the hides of your defeated foes as armour for bigger and more challenging bouts. All creatures can be crafted into weapons and fancy items, and that's before you start buddying up with other players for special contracts, get talking to the villagers about requests they have, decide if you want to farm-kill a particular beast for a unique goal, and so on.

Once Monster Hunter has you in its grasp, its talons go deep - thank the gaming gods then, that the sensation is one of this year's best.


7. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt - Blood & Wine (DLC)

The Witcher 3 blood and wine
CD Projekt RED

Normally a DLC wouldn't be classed as its own 'game of the summer', but when said DLC is as feature-complete and content-packed as Blood & Wine, it simply can't be ignored.

Simply put, CD Projekt RED are on the form of their career, and after patching in a ton of free missions and items for the main game, have crafted an entire separate area for B&W. It's one whose size dwarfs many other full-price games, has an enthralling murder mystery narrative to unpack, andis just.absolutely.gorgeous.

See, the district of Toussaint is said to be the richest of the land in every respect, ostensibly setting it up to be some dark fantasy take on a fairytale kingdom. If you're already familiar with The Witcher 3 and how CDPR like to upend expectations at every turn, just know that the story of Blood & Wine is very much a beautiful rose with quite the number of razor sharp thorns.

It's continually staggering to compare the amount of effort CDPR put into their titles with that of the competition, but know this: as a body of work, The Witcher 3 is still the greatest achievement on this generation of consoles by a substantially large margin.


6. Batman: The Telltale Series (Episode 1)

batman telltale
Telltale

It's rare that a Telltale game actually manages to live up to the highs of 2012's The Walking Dead, but with Batman, they've truly outdone themselves. Taking place in its own universe but mixing together the likes of Nolan, Frank Miller and Affleck's versions into one, you play as both Bruce and Batman simultaneously.

As the playboy billionaire you need to attend dinner events and fancy galas, maintaining your cover - whilst also having the option to partake in conversations about "that masked bat vigilante" - and as Batman, well, you get to break some bones.

It's this duality - and the playing of Bruce at all - that gives Telltale's Batman a very unique and progressive edge, one that the Arkham games completely left out.

Batman: Arkham Knight made you feel like a veteran Bat protecting Gotham with every fibre of his being, but by doubling down on the freedom of wearing a mask and spinning a story about the inevitable repercussions towards friends and family, turns this into one of the best Batman games of all time.


5. No Man's Sky

No man's sky
Hello Games

Seems like you can't mention No Man's Sky without a horde of people springing out the ether yelling "BUT WHERE'S THE MULTIPLAYER?!" - and that's totally fine, the game definitely doesn't live up to what was touted in the run-up to release. But, it IS still an incredible experience - one that gives off the purest sensation of exploration this side of something like Skyrim, on an unprecedented scale that will most likely never be matched or seen again.

How that manifests in-game comes in the form of resource management - and lots of it. You'll need to venture to as many corners of the procedurally-generated cosmos as possible to upgrade your suit, ship and weapon, to go even deeper.

Think of the whole thing as a quirky indie project given the big budget exposure of Sony, because that sensation of being the only soul in an entire galaxy, spending hours on a planet only to leave and see it disappear as a spec in your rear-view mirror - that is a feeling no other form of entertainment will ever give.

It's for that reason that I've always thought Hello Games' mathematical masterwork can rise above the negativity - it really does have a way of making you question life, our apparent 'need' to explore, and humanity's place in the galaxy overall.


4. Furi

Furi gameplay
The Game Bakers

Do you like brutally hard video games? I'm talking the sorts of things like Dark Souls, Super Meat Boy and the delightfully hard-edged Nioh? Good, because Furi will test your patience and hand-eye coordination more than all three combined.

Being a glorious blend of Devil May Cry hack n' slashery, screens-worth of projectiles to dodge every few minutes and the frequent switch into a side-on, fighting game-style camera for the close of each battle, Furi is the story of one warrior battling his way through ten bosses, with only a slick synthwave soundtrack and bouts of walking in between to break them up.

Each boss has patterns to learn, attacks to dodge and weak spots to identify. They're all memorable as hell, but the real meat of Furi is learning to bust out your anonymous character's set of abilities as if they were your own.

Once you've become symbiotically linked to that blade in the above image, then the really intense battles begin, and I've never had a game route me to the spot for hours of eye-straining concentration in quite some time.


3. Inside

INSIDE game
Playdead Studios

Very rare do you come across a studio that put all their effort - and I do mean, ALL their effort - into perfecting one, solid vision. Usually, somewhere along the line, corners have to be cut to make deadline dates, features removed because they don't work as intended, and so on.

That is categorically not the case here, as Playdead Studios' have spent the last five years genuinely perfecting every last part of Inside, the substantial cash from Limbo supporting them throughout.

The result is an immaculate physics-based platformer where every facet of the end product is polished and smoothed over to stand the test of time. Its gameplay? Physics-based platforming with puzzles that gently ramp up in difficulty, without ever being too hard. Graphics? Sublime, pockets of colour pepper a dystopian landscape that intentionally doesn't tell a straightforward narrative, leaving you to pick up the pieces yourself. The score, progression and overall feel? All exemplary, all factoring into a supremely confident package that establishes Playdead as a studio that wear their artistry on their sleeves.

Pause any screen and you'd have a painting thousands could analyse with infinite interpretations. Apply that across an entire game, and you have something altogether more enthralling.


2. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided

Deus Ex Mankind Divided
Eidos

Mankind Divided may be a direct continuation of Human Revolution, but being that game already saw Eidos innovate on the original Deus Ex formula of the early 2000s in all the right ways, it's more than a perfect sequel.

Protagonist Adam Jensen continues to be a walking Swiss Army Knife of transforming limbs and augmented skin textures, going from blasting groups of goons with a pressurised cannon, to leaping tall buildings in a single bound, disappearing entirely for ultra-cool stealth kills and deploying gas grenades from his elbows - basically, it's the Six Million Dollar Man on steroids.

For all the controversy-courting 'Mechanical Apartheid' posturing Square put behind this as some sort of well-written political and racial message, its characterisation and aesthetic is more Metal Gear Solid 4 than George Orwell.

One of the best-designed games in quite some time, with levels and A.I. that let you mix up a staggering amount of tactics on the fly, Deus Ex: Mankind Divided is already one of the Games of the Year, but there's one that can still usurp it here...


1. Pokémon GO

pokemon go hobbit
New Line Cinema/Nintendo

The fad may be dissipating a smidge now, but since its release in July - and across the entirety of 2016's sunniest months - you couldn't move for Pokémon GO players. Seriously, it became a 'thing' to assume anyone even looking at their phone was playing.

No one title or entertainment product has ever enraptured the masses to such a degree, becoming so instantly widespread and enjoyed as a community, not to mention it actually played very well - its tracker and catching systems being simple, with a nice amount of depth under the hood.

Sure, the game has its detractors - and yes, if we really start looking at Pokémon GO purely as a video game, strip away the nostalgia, social factors and associated branding, it doesn't truly contend with the competition - but looking back at summer 2016, there's only one game that stands out from the rest.

--

What's the best game of the last three months? Let us know in the comments!


Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.