WWE 2K19 Ratings: 10 Most Underrated Wrestlers
We'd be p*ssed too, Seth...
It could be argued that Bryan Danielson circa 2003 deserves a higher rating than 76 in WWE 2K19. Yes, it could, although 2K's decision to reflect that Bryan (years away from catching on as the next top babyface and charming everyone in WWE with his passion for pro wrestling) was once considered lowly enhancement talent is fair.
Anyway, he's not the real concern here. There are loads of others on the game's roster that have been treated terribly by comparison. This schism between similar playable wrestlers is where 2K's logic falls down; whilst they're content to show Bryan's progression as a star by giving his 2013 character model a hefty 92 overall, they're not happy to make historically bigger legends than him anywhere near as good.
The whole system is wildly erratic.
OK, so it must be a chore to decipher who gets what rating every year, and there's always going to be some argument against whatever 2K choose. We get that, but we have to take the decision-makers to task for some of the alarmingly low ratings they've doled out in 2K19...
10. Mickie James
Rating: 78
Why It's Too Low: Mickie James is a peripheral figure on WWE TV at the moment. She's only really there to provide occasional backup for Alexa Bliss, and she's the perfect veteran for handy jobs to up-and-comers whenever the writers need them. Even so, her 2K19 rating is a bit low.
The question must be posed: does Mickie, who is a five-time Women's Champ and looks like she hasn't lost a step, deserve to be rated two points lower than semi or fully retired workers like Jacqueline (82), Ivory (80) or Paige (83)? 2K should have bumped James up a bit if they planned on making those scores so high elsewhere.
She's there to give Bliss some old-school street cred, no doubt, but she's a fine performer in her own right and has a bigger legacy than WWE sometimes acknowledge.
9. Becky Lynch
Rating: 83
Why It's Too Low: We're not sure about this one either.
Becky has shown a different side to her character lately, and (despite not catching fire as a heel the way WWE would like) she's cutting some of the best promos of her run to date. Inside the ring, the Irish 'Lass Kicker' is the same reliable talent she's always been too. Her 83 score could be doing with a slight raise to make it more accurate.
Lynch is still in the shadow of Charlotte Flair (85), even in the video game world. The fact she hasn't been pushed into that upper echelon of female talent in 2K19 is annoying to those who see her potential to be the lead name in WWE's female revolution.
85, and parity with Flair, would have been better.
8. Ronda Rousey
Rating: 87
Why It's Too Low: According to 2K, ex-MMA bad ass and current Raw Women's Champion Ronda Rousey is the highest-rated female in 2K19. Though that's fair, her 87 rating doesn't tell the full story. This year, Ronda had to be miles ahead of everyone else in that division, and streets ahead of some male members of the roster.
She's a legit fighter, and fans know it. Sure, she's a rookie when it comes to wrestling, but Rousey's powerful strike game, intimidation factor and submission skills should have had her heading towards the low-90s at least. If you're scoffing at that, then consider how she was presented at WrestleMania 34.
Rousey went toe-to-toe with Triple H, and he's rated 89 this year. Maybe that would've been a better shout for 'Rowdy' Ronda. She should easily have been one of 2K19's most powerful characters, female or not.
7. Braun Strowman
Rating: 89
Why It's Too Low: Ever since he traded The Wyatt Family for smashing jobbers, pursuing Roman Reigns, launching an organic babyface run and (eventually) settling back into a heel groove, Braun Strowman has been on fire as one of WWE's biggest acts. His 89 overall is a travesty of justice.
Braun has tipped over ambulances, pulled down lighting rigs, survived attempted vehicular homicide, won the Greatest Royal Rumble, snatched the Money In The Bank briefcase and, latterly, been involved in Hell In A Cell. If anything, his rating should be on par with WWE's golden boy Reigns.
If 92 seems a bit high, take a glance back at how he's been booked over the past two years. Strowman really had to be one of the game's most effective wrestlers, and he should have been as challenging as anyone else to play against or beat.
2K gonna' get those hands.
6. The Undertaker
Rating: 87
Why It's Too Low: This is a brilliant illustration of 2K's erraticism when it comes to deciding who gets what score every year.
The Undertaker, arguably WWE's most legendary character ever, is ranked lower than everyone from Goldberg (90) and John Cena (89) to Ric Flair (91) and The Rock (93). Those numbers might not seem shocking at first glance, but consider which versions of those wrestlers 2K have included.
90-rated Goldberg is the modern-day one, Cena is the same guy 'Taker mauled in quick order at 'Mania 34, Ric Flair is the creaking 'Nature Boy' from around 2008 and The Rock is that Hollywood star who sporadically pops up in between movies. In other words, most are part-timers just like The Undertaker, and Flair is actually retired.
Even if it's true that 'Taker in 2018 isn't as fearsome as he once was, 87 is dreadfully low for such an iconic character.
5. Demon Finn Bálor
Rating: 87
Why It's Too Low: Maybe it's not something to whinge about that Finn Bálor's demonic guise has the same overall as The Undertaker this year. That could be 2K's way of giving Finn a major compliment; if he's on par with 'The Deadman', then his face-painted, floor-crawling gimmick is credible, right?
Hmm, maybe not.
Bálor's Demon is supposed to take the happy, smiling mortal man and turn him into an unbeatable monster who terrifies those before him. Look at Baron Corbin's reaction this past SummerSlam. He was booked to have zero chance against the Demon, and with good reason.
It sucks a bit that Finn's alter ego only has a two point edge over his regular character in 2K19. The Demon really should have an unstoppable vibe in the games, and be hard-as-nails to beat when using all but the best of the rest.
4. Kurt Angle '01
Rating: 86
Why It's Too Low: Check out Kurt Angle's irritated expression in the graphic above. It's there for a reason.
Back in 2001, Angle was one of the best pro wrestlers on the planet. His matches with Steve Austin, Chris Benoit and The Rock were something else, and he also managed to get the best out of Shane McMahon in a bruising brawl at King Of The Ring. Yep, Kurt was at the top of his game 17 years ago.
Why then is his '01 model rated lower than his '06 one, and a full six points worse off than Daniel Bryan's best score (again, his 2013 character has a 92 rating)? In 2K's world, Angle in his prime is a poorer choice than Edge, John Cena, modern-day Sting and today's Triple H. All have a rating of 89, which is three higher than Kurt's.
This is another example of the illogical thread running through some of these ratings. Apparently, someone at 2K wasn't a fan of this. How dare they.
3. Seth Rollins
Rating: 88
Why It's Too Low: This is the same Seth Rollins who has often been tasked with carrying Raw as Intercontinental Champion, right? 2K haven't mistaken him for some other Seth Rollins who is a worse all-rounder than Roman Reigns, John Cena or Triple H? Apparently not.
In 2K19, Seth's rating is at last two points off the mark it should be. He's level with Kevin Owens and Samoa Joe (both great workers, yes, albeit not as crucial to programming as Rollins has been this year), and sits three off cover star AJ Styles. Hardcore fans of both men would agree they're of similar quality, and should've had similar scores.
The most depressing thing is that Rollins was rated 92 in last year's game. Why the fall then? He's been even better in-ring than ever, has played a major role in the IC Title's continued importance and, again, has carried Raw on his back at times.
2. The British Bulldog
Rating: 81
Why It's Too Low: Here's a quick run down of some characters Davey Boy Smith can't touch in 2K19...
Baron Corbin (84), Big E (84), Bray Wyatt (83), Xavier Woods (83), Kofi Kingston (84), Jinder Mahal (83), Sami Zayn (82) and Christian (83).
That doesn't seem fair for someone who was a company legend, former main-eventer and renowned powerhouse in his heyday. The British Bulldog was certainly better than a meagre 81 overall. This is an unacceptably low rating, and it becomes more bothersome when seeing the one 2K handed current UK Champ Pete Dunne.
Dunne has the same overall as Bulldog. What were 2K thinking here? Dunne's awesome, but he's a long way from cementing the same legacy Smith did. The iconic Brit should have had a score closer to the mid-80s at least, not one that makes him look like a throwaway mid card wannabe.
For the record, Smith's rating is three less than it was in 2K18. Figure that one out, if you can.
1. Kane
Rating: 80
Why It's Too Low: When you've finished cracking the Bulldog code, start work on the bizarre decision to drop Kane's overall by a point (81 in 2K18 to 80 this year) when he's rumoured to be a big part of WWE's upcoming Crown Jewel pay-per-view in Saudi Arabia.
Nobody is pretending that Kane is one of WWE's premier performers in 2018, not for a second. He is a legend however, and befitting of a better rating than a stinking 80. Much like Davey Boy Smith, this renders 'The Big Red Machine' all-but-useless against guys like Sami Zayn, Jinder Mahal and Xavier Woods.
That doesn't seem fair.
Kane's rating is the same as Bayley, Velveteen Dream, Ruby Riott, Luke Gallows, Karl Anderson, Lars Sullivan and Johnny Gargano, to name a few. How's that for a mish-mashed motley crew of WWE talent? Keeping Kane's 81, or making him the same as the Kane '12 (83) character would've been nice.
Which other 2K19 characters do you think are underrated? Let us know down in the comments section below!