WWE 2K22: Predicting The 20 Lowest Rated Superstars

Current WWE champions rank amongst the lowest of the low on 2K22's roster.

WWE 2K22 Sami Zayn
2K Games

WWE 2K22's roster is going to look very different to the one gamers played around with in the glitchy debacle that was 2K20. For proof, fire up a list of superstar ratings and check out the bottom 20 - most of the wrestlers included, such as Lana, Sarah Logan, No Way Jose, Heath Slater and more, are no longer under WWE contract.

They're about to be replaced by a boatload of newbies.

Not all of them are series newcomers, but a fair few on this list will make their WWE video game bow in 2K22. That's an exciting moment for sure, albeit one tempered by the thought that their ratings will be on the lower end of the spectrum.

Just...don't put some of these lads and lassies up against Roman Reigns or Charlotte Flair and you'll be fine. There are also a ton of workers returning for another royalty payoff who may see their character ratings slide through cracks in the floor though.

Behold the worst of the worst in 2K's upcoming brawler. You probably won't want to be picking anyone named here come March next year.

20. Sami Zayn

WWE 2K22 Sami Zayn
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 80

Predicted Rating: 76

Sami Zayn is probably the exception to that.

WWE's conspiracy theorist had a solid 80 rating in 2K20. Expect that to drop a little, if only because ol' Sam Zayn has become so damn good at playing the scumbag who scuppers his own plans by trying to be a cheating piece of sh*t.

A four-point slide seems fair for Zayn. He'll still be fun to play as though - fans appreciate how entertaining the SmackDown star is, and he could become a go-to pick for some. If you're one of those, then you'll probs get a weaker version than you did two years ago.


19. Nikki A.S.H

WWE 2K22 Nikki A.S.H
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 80

Predicted Rating: 76

80 seemed rather high for the then-Nikki Cross in the last game released before the wheels fell off 2K's wagon. Much like with Sami Zayn, the redubbed Nikki A.S.H could reflect her underdog wannabe superhero status by falling to an overall of 76.

That's still a respectable number, to be fair.

The highest ratings predictions figured that Charlotte Flair might dominate the women's division with a score of 91. That puts Nikki's projected 76 into context, and likely brings her in-game character closer to how WWE view her next to Flair in real life.


18. Cameron Grimes

WWE 2K22 Cameron Grimes
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 76

The bold Cameron Grimes is the only NXT star on this list. Why? Well, it's frankly far-fetched to imagine that many of the 2.0 crew will make it into 2K22. Some of them barely even come across as "WWE Superstars" (not yet, at least).

Mr. Grimes is different.

He's been an NXT stalwart, but that won't be enough to save him from a lower overall rating in the new game. This will be Cam's video game bow though, so 76 isn't anything to sniff at. He has time yet to improve that over the next few series entries.


17. Dominik Mysterio

WWE 2K22 Dominik Mysterio
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 75

Dominik's daddy Rey Mysterio netted a strong 86 score in 2K20. His offspring won't come anywhere close to that in 2K22 - it's much more realistic to expect a rating in the mid-70s for Dom. He's been cast as a bit of a rookie pest to Rey in 2021, so falling a full 11 points short of daddio makes sense.

The Mysterio clan's next generation is more fledgling future great than surefire solo success when Rey eventually steps away. 2K must go slow with him and remember that ratings above 80 are for the best of the best.

Dom isn't quite there yet.


16. Queen Zelina

WWE 2K22 Queen Zelina
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 83

Predicted Rating: 75

Yours truly had to double-check that Zelina Vega actually had a rating of 83 in WWE 2K20. It's true, and that's really exaggerated. Until recently, Vega had never actually been taken too seriously as an in-ring worker in the company.

A drop is incoming, people.

In fact, this is a sizeable fall. The first Queen's Crown winner could, in theory, drop from 83 to 75 in 2K22. On TV, she's a cowardly heel who rarely meets babyface fire face-to-face. 83 is absurdly high for a villainess who is currently part of the afterthought Women's Tag-Team ranks too.


15. Jinder Mahal

WWE 2K22 Jinder Mahal
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 76

Predicted Rating: 75

Where did it all go wrong for former WWE Champion Jinder?

His summer feud opposite Drew McIntyre flopped, and his alliances with both Shanky and Veer have done nothing for either party. Come the next game, Mahal's rating is about to take a slight hit. His work on Raw and SmackDown in 2021 doesn't deserve a 76 rating.

Being charitable, Jinder could likely get away with a well-rounded 75. That'd keep him on the ride side of mediocrity in-game without pretending that he's some super-powerful bad ass who's a threat to the top names on the card.


14. Drew Gulak

WWE 2K22 Drew Gulak
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 82

Predicted Rating: 74

Anyone who watches Drew Gulak work bell-to-bell could tell you that he's an excellent technician and one of the most stable hands WWE has. Unfortunately, he comes across as someone who's just scraping by on the roster, and it's obvious that the company don't give a sh*t about him.

Therefore, that 82 rating from 2K20 needs to go.

It's too high. Gulak's current standing on WWE television isn't deserving of anything higher than a mid-70s number; 74 would cut it. There's no way Gulak should be on the same level as other 82s like Sheamus, put it that way.


13. R-Truth

WWE 2K22 R-Truth
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 79

Predicted Rating: 74

If Vince McMahon had his way, R-Truth would rival Roman Reigns for the top rating. McMahon clearly adores Truth, which is why the 24/7 funny man has lasted so long in WWE when other stars who are younger and have more to offer have been cut free.

2K must start dropping Truth down the ratings pile though.

A five-point fall is anticipated for his character in 2K22. 79 is a little too much, and 74 sounds more than fair for a guy who only really knocks around in "ha ha" segments these days. That's what's up. Sorry, Vin man - your pal isn't a video game fave.


12. Cedric Alexander

WWE 2K22 Cedric Alexander
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 80

Predicted Rating: 74

WWE's woeful decision to whip Cedric Alexander from the midst of The Hurt Business before...putting him back in again badly hampered his 2021. 2K must've thought that Cedric was headed for big things when they released 2K20, because they handed him a big 80 rating.

Time to knock off six points.

Alexander is a midcard tag act at best these days. That's a shame, because his push was over in the blink of an eye, but it's the way things are. There's no way he should be pushing into the 80s any longer. Riddle was an 80 himself in 2K20, for christ sake.


11. Shelton Benjamin

WWE 2K22 Shelton Benjamin
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 77

Predicted Rating: 74

The same goes for Cedric's partner-turned-enemy-turned-partner Shelton Benjamin.

77 may seem fair enough to most, and that's cool, but Shelton is a peripheral figure in WWE yet again. His Hurt Business shine has faded, and that's why he's down for a three-point decrease to 74 in the next series release; making both he and Alexander exactly the same sounds like the way to go.

They're a so-so tag-team who exist in the bargain basement levels of the division as calendars creep into 2022. That's unlikely to change before 2K22 blasts onto store shelves. 74 keeps Shelty B in the 'bang average' category of stars on-disc.


10. Mustafa Ali

WWE 2K22 Mustafa Ali
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 81

Predicted Rating: 73

Mustafa Ali was just plain old Ali when 2K20 launched. Despite that, someone at 2K deemed him worthy of an 81 score (which put him in the same bracket as Big Show and Shane McMahon - both of whom also had higher-than-necessary ratings).

In 2K22, it won't be a mega surprise if Mustafa falls into the lower card glut of those struggling to maintain relevancy in these games. He'll replace outgoing workers like Sin Cara, Curtis Axel and Bo Dallas at the lower end of the 70s scale.

73 seems fair enough for someone who hasn't been up to much.


9. Mansoor

WWE 2K22 Mansoor
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 73

"Hasn't been up to much".

Doesn't that describe Mansoor's main roster career perfectly? He was cast as a wet-behind-the-ears rookie after years of winning on Saudi Arabian supercards, then fell in with Mustafa Ali for a union that went nowhere. That inauspicious run will be mimicked in 2K22.

73 maybe even seems a little generous.

Mansoor is set to become to 2K22 what Rico was to SmackDown: Shut Your Mouth. In other words, he's a wrestler few will bother to pick when firing up the game. His only hope for future titles is to become something more on real life WWE TV.


8. Humberto

WWE 2K22 Humberto
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 76

Predicted Rating: 73

WWE took a giant dump on Humberto's new Los Lotharios tag-team with Angel by having them job to Shinsuke Nakamura and Rick Boogs in less than 90 seconds on a recent SmackDown. All one could think was, "Well so much for that!".

2K's stat monkeys will be paying attention, and they'll notice that Humberto isn't exactly thriving on programming. That's why his 76 score is about to turn into a 73 just like that. He's another who props up the tag-team division, and will continue to do so in 2022.

Side note: Remember Jerry Lawler used to call this guy a Justin Bieber lookalike?!


7. Angel

WWE 2K22 Angel
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 73

Rinse and repeat for Humberto's tag partner.

Angel (don't call him Garza!) looked like a fool when he and his Los Lotharios mate stared at the lights for Nakamura and Boogs. That defeat came at the end of a feud that seemed questionable in the first place; Lotharios were trying to make waves in the tag division by going after the Intercontinental Champion? Huh?

The handsome swine will make his WWE video game debut in 2K22. That's a proud occasion for him (or, at least, his wallet), but he won't be one of the roster's strongest workers. Not even close, actually. 73 sounds right.


6. Akira Tozawa

WWE 2K22 Akira Tozawa
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 77

Predicted Rating: 72

How the fudge did Akira Tozawa earn a 77 rating in WWE 2K20? Was he paying someone at 2K towers off, or something? To put that into context, it was one point higher than ex-WWE Champ Jinder Mahal and four points better off than Mr. McMahon's character.

No chance in hell!

Seriously though, the glory days (ahem) are over for Tozawa. He's 24/7 Title comedic fluff, and his rating needs to reflect that. A score of 72 would drop Akira down into the lower bracket, which is where he really belongs in 2022.


5. Madcap Moss

WWE 2K22 Madcap Moss
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 72

What do you call a pro wrestler who's making his first appearance in a WWE game but won't get picked by many gamers? Madcap Moss! Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha. OK, that wasn't funny, but neither are Madcap's jokes on SmackDown every week.

He's Happy Corbin's jester-style backup, and that means he's getting one of the lowest ratings in 2K22. Anyone who does play as the pair as a tag needs to feel a drop off when Moss enters the ring. Meanwhile, big Corbs can maybe come down a bit himself - 87 is massive for somebody playing a comedy gimmick.

Make him 77, or therein thereabouts, and slap a 72 on Madcap.


4. Tamina

WWE 2K22 Tamina
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 73

Predicted Rating: 71

It was genuinely heartwarming to see Tamina win the Women's Tag-Team Titles alongside Natalya in 2021. She was so happy, and that was enough to put a smile on even the frostiest of fan faces. Even so, the veteran's rating will continually fall with each passing game.

Tam is about to go from 73 to 71.

She needs to be one of the weaker female stars in the game. Put it this way: Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, Sasha Banks and even legends like Trish Stratus should have a noticeable advantage in-ring against Tamina. They have to be faster, smarter and just all-round better.


3. Aliyah

WWE 2K22 Aliyah
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 70

Aliyah has taken over the same role that Maria Kanellis once played on television. Basically, she's the starry-eyed dolt who's happy to be there and falls for every nasty trick heels try. That's a character trope WWE loves, but it doesn't do much for someone's standing with the audience.

Cue a 70 score for her at best.

Like Cameron Grimes, Dominik Mysterio, Mansoor and Angel, Aliyah is making her video game debut in 2K22. That's assuming she's picked for the roster, of course. If she is, then she'll be the second-weakest female star involved.


2. Dana Brooke

WWE 2K22 Dana Brooke
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: 69

Predicted Rating: 69

...but not the weakest.

That spot belongs to poor Dana Brooke. The consistently-overlooked try hard star was only behind the 2008 version of Maria Kanellis as 2K20's worst women's wrestler. In fact, the only characters Dana beat were Maria, Ribbie, Reilly Flash (made up MyCareer workers) No Way Jose, Noam Dar, Mike Kanellis and Ariya Daivari.

What a line up that is!

Dana's 69 rating won't be bolstered in 2K22. She's doomed to be someone WWE and 2K Games gloss over whenever they can. This is another year in the digital doldrums for Brooke, but she can take solace in the fact that there's somebody else worse off than her.


1. Reggie

WWE 2K22 Reggie
2K Games

WWE 2K20 Rating: N/A

Predicted Rating: 67

It's the guy who held that 24/7 Title before Dana.

Reginald/Reggie/Reg/WWE's parkour guy barely delivers any offensive strikes or moves during his matches on TV. Instead, he used his circus skills to acrobatically avoid contact. That's why he was only useful in those increasingly-drab 24/7 skits.

This dude is destined to be the worst playable character in 2K22 if he makes it onto the roster. A 67 overall could be in his future. That'd make Dana Brooke smile, if nothing else. She can't score worse than Reggie, let's be honest here.

Do you agree that these wrestlers will be the bottom 20 in WWE 2K22? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestlers Who Could Win Their First World Title In 2022 and 10 Shocking WWE House Show Moments You Haven't Seen!


In this post: 
WWE 2K22
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.