WWE 2K24: 10 Worst Looking Characters

WWE 2K24 is great, but we've got to talk about some of those character models!

WWE 2K24 Bayley
2K Games

It's worth saying over and over again that WWE 2K24 is one of the best wrestling games ever made. The variety of modes, superb gameplay, new match types to mess around with and the awesome creation hub (including that sweet Community Creations goodness) all combines to make 2K's latest a real champion.

Not everything is perfect though.

Some of the character models are a little on the wonky side. Of course, there's nothing here that tops the misery of a graphical nightmare like 2K20, but it is fair to say that a few workers were done dirty this year. Just ask Bayley, she'll tell you! No spoiler warning needed there - take a look at the featured image and you'll see that the freshly turned babyface has every right to be a bit peeved by her character in the new game.

Bayley isn't alone. Hair remains a real issue for 2K's artists, and too many of the legends on the roster feel a little bit off. Obviously, there's some nitpicking here, so know that going in. Maybe you think all of these models are perfectly fine, which is...perfectly fine.

Brace for slight disappointment if you're a perfectionist though.

10. Bobby Heenan

WWE 2K24 Bobby Heenan
2K Games

Either someone farted in the pic above or Bobby Heenan is holding one in himself!

Seriously though, the iconic manager looks fine enough at first glance in 2K24. In short, he's fine when patrolling ringside for old warhorses like Andre The Giant or Rick Rude, but Bobby could've done with a bit more polish. His hair is a little ragged, and there's a vacant stare on the sharp-witted legend's face that's hard to ignore.

Also, 2K couldn't have gone for a less inspiring outfit for the promo expert if they'd tried. Sure, they picked that one because of WrestleMania III in the Showcase mode, but still - where's the glitter and glam people came to know and love/hate? That's what alt attire slots are for, surely.

A nitpicky one to kick off with then, and there's no denying it. This writer is a massive Heenan fanboy though, so it was ever so slightly disappointing to see how low-res his model was in the new game. Especially with all the WrestleMania-inspired retro hype pre-launch.


9. Bret Hart

WWE 2K24 Bret Hart
2K Games

Bret Hart is one of those legends referenced in the intro about "feeling off". Facially, he's acceptable, and you never really notice anything errant whilst playing matches. Perhaps that's the most important thing, but icons like the 'Hitman' should be watertight even when you're scanning models on the edit screens.

He isn't, sadly.

The hair is weird looking for starters. It lacks the stringy, 'I've just sprayed endless amounts of water and baby oil all over myself' aesthetic that was a Bret 101 during his peak. This is Bret if 2K wanted to have him star in shampoo ads, and it just looks a touch awkward up close.

Generally, Bret's models in WWE games could do with an overhaul. He's one of the most cherished pro wrestlers of all time, so it sucks that people are forced to use a fairly subpar model for dream matches vs. today's roster. Please get the 'Hitman' right next year!


8. Candice LeRae

WWE 2K24 Candice LeRae
2K Games

Ouch.

It's hard to put one's finger on exactly why, but 2K seems to proper struggle with the women's division. Some models, like Rhea Ripley's for example, look resplendent and actually rank amongst the best in the entire game. Maybe that's due to Rhea's star power and importance, which would also explain why poor Candice LeRae here seemingly hasn't slept.

In fact, even LeRae's character seems downright p*ssed off by what 2K's artists conjured up for her this year. She's closer to the classic CAW "waxy" feel than the developers would care to admit. Being brutally honest, some of the CAWs popping up for AEW stars and other wrestlers are superior to Candice's official render.

WWE 2K24 boasts approx 200-ish wrestlers for gamers to choose from. That's a lot, so it was always likely some would get a bit less care and attention than others. Turning LeRae into someone who looks like an extra from MyRise is shoddy though.


7. Stephanie McMahon

WWE 2K24 Stephanie McMahon
2K Games

What was that about vacant stares?

Stephanie McMahon's character from this year's game is one of the worst offenders for that. This is probs the facial expression Stephanie had during epic 4/5/6 hour creative meetings headed by her now-disgraced father many moons ago. Those must've been torturous to sit through after a while.

It speaks to the McMahon name being quietly airbrushed out of WWE's product that Stephanie has such a frankly crap character in 2K24. Perhaps 2K just couldn't be bothered, because they know the promotion is set to move on from her famous surname long-term towards a bold new era.

Back to the model: Steph's hair clips through her shoulders in motion, which is never good (that's the kind of thing that should've stopped come the PS2!), and there's such a clear lack of effort put in here overall. Harsh? Could be, but there was a time when 2K's artists would've crafted a higher-res McMahon member than this.


6. Trish Stratus

WWE 2K24 Trish Stratus
2K Games

Several players have asked the question: Is Trish Stratus wearing a wig on top of her hair and extensions in WWE 2K24? Her barnet has volume, that's for sure, but it's another example of hair being problematic in the series. That's why it's so remarkable one Roman Reigns looks as phenomenal as he does in the new game.

Only a handful with loads of hair can claim that.

Trish certainly isn't one of the best. She actually looks a fair bit older in-game than she does in real life, which is an achievement. As everyone can attest, the yoga-loving legend looks amazing in 2024, so christ knows what went wrong with her model. If 2K sorted that wig out, then it'd be miles better.

Being fair, Trish's character looks better during matches. The same could be said for most of the workers on disc, but fans want the game's graphics to shine no matter which mode or menu screen they happen to be in. Unfortunately, Stratus' doesn't.


5. Mick Foley

WWE 2K24 Mick Foley
2K Games

Insert that same fart joke from the Bobby Heenan entry here.

Hardcore legend Mick Foley is fully represented in WWE 2K24. His Cactus Jack, Dude Love and Mankind (the white shirt version) are all there, and so is a more modern take on the famous brawler sans gimmicks. Tragically for long-time fans, it isn't actually that good. This is generic CAW Mick more than anything.

You'll notice a trend there with the worst characters in the new game - a lot of them look like they were thrown together in a half hour. That wouldn't have been the case, but it's arguably even more depressing that someone agonised over models like this for days/weeks/months.

Foley's face is surly when it should be bright and full of glee. It's one thing for Cactus Jack or Mankind to sport this kind of gruff look, but not ol' Santa Mick. He's always been more of a happy go lucky sort to fans, and so that's what they expect to see.

Nice plaid shirt, to be fair.


4. Kevin Nash

WWE 2K24 Kevin Nash
2K Games

The WrestleMania X "manager" version of Diesel in 2K24 is splendid. It reeks of being a labour of love for the devs, likely 'cause they knew he'd be accompanying Shawn Michaels down the aisle for that iconic ladder bout vs. Razor Ramon in the Showcase. Elsewhere, Kevin Nash doesn't get the same sort of love.

Is that 'Big Sexy' or longstanding Judas Priest bassist Ian Hill?

It's a puzzler, but 2K made Nash a tad older when sitting down to work on his nWo character model. Who knows why? This is supposed to be Nash between 1996-1999, but it's more like Kev wearing a wig and grabbing the Just For Men today than that. It's just a wee bit disappointing to those who love going retro in these games.

There are some CAWs on Community Creations more facially spot on that this Kev effort. It should've been a lot better than it turned out up close.


3. Carmella

WWE 2K24 Carmella
2K Games

Who else is ready for Carmella's comeback with some banging new dreadlocks?

The 'Princess Of Staten Island' has ill-fitting (and inaccurate) hair in 2K24. Worse, she's a little waxy and plastic around the face. It's like 2K patterned Mella's model on an action figure instead of the real deal. Also, her head doesn't properly fit her body.

Weirdly, everything from the head down is acceptable, but this might well pass as a character from the prior generation of consoles more than one on PS5/Xbox Series X. Think about it: If somebody showed you this and told you it was Carmella from WWE 2K on PS4, you'd probably nod and say, 'Yes, yes it is'.

It isn't though. It's Carmella in the latest entry, and therein lies the problem. The hair is awful, the eyes are glassy and looking right through you, the facial expression is frozen and more. All the hallmarks of a phoned-in effort are here, which is rubbish to report.


2. Randy Savage

WWE 2K24 Randy Savage
2K Games

As the old WCW theme used to say: "What up, Mach?!".

No, really. What's wrong with Randy Savage in this year's game? His character models have felt a bit suspect for years now, but he's never been this glum. Again, like Carmella, the model's body is a lot better than the face. Randy is recognisable, but barely. You have to use some imagination with his character, which isn't wonderful for one of WWE's most famous heroes from yesteryear.

Apparently, 2K decided to give Savage the same hair as Shawn Michaels from Survivor Series 2002 as well. It's a little on the floaty side, and just doesn't look like it sits properly on top of Randy's head (no jokes about baldness, please). One gets the sense this could've been a lot better.

Randy is included in the '40 Years Of WrestleMania' Showcase too, so you'd be forgiven for imagining he'd be one of the most pristine models on the roster. Nope, he's upset-looking and less 'Macho Man' than Skinner wearing Randy's ring gear.


1. Bayley

WWE 2K24 Bayley
2K Games

Even Bayley was hacked off by her character model in WWE 2K24, and rightly so.

She replied to a fan tweet in January when 2K revealed the character by saying: "HELP ME!". Admittedly, the devs did tweak Bayley before launch, but they've papered over cracks. She might look fine enough in the screengrabs above, but trust the doubters on this occasion: Bayley does not look like Bayley the closer you get.

One of the worst things about her model this year is that various facial expressions totally change what she looks like. For example, pause when Bayley is selling an attack and it's like someone totally different is in the ring wrestling. That's a Bayley cosplay, not the ex-Damage CTRL leader!

There's an angular harshness to the model that makes it seem as though 2K stretched the thing too. They surely didn't, but that's how it comes across when you're viewing Bayley 3D in the character edit screens.

Who do you think are the worst looking characters in WWE 2K24? For more like this, check out WWE 2K24: 15 CAWs You Must Download Immediately and HORRIBLE Matches WWE Forced On Fans!


In this post: 
WWE 2K24
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.