10 Artists Who Grew Out Of Their Appeal

When your core appeal is based around teenage angst and the shoegazing, it's a bit hard to tap into it when you're say.....41 with a few kids of your own.

Artists grow out of their appeal in different ways. For a child or teen star, this can be a transitionary period we watch with bated breath just waiting for the car crash, the chaos and the outrageous behaviour we love to condemn. An older artist, or indeed a band, who appeals largely to teenagers and younger people may try to resist this transitionary period altogether, attempting to sustain the same sound or image that gained them their popularity in the first place; but often they find themselves struggling to cling to the limelight when commercial tastes change, or their initial fanbase grows up and loses interest. Then there are the artists who may have grown out of their appeal some time ago, but linger in our consciousness, gaining undeserved press attention purely due to their ridiculous antics. Former Oasis star Liam Gallagher and all-around-brat Justin Bieber are prime examples of this, seeming to think an outright refusal to grow up even a smidgen is somehow endearing. Gallagher even praised Bieber's antics last year, stating that 'anyone who goes on two hours late is f**king right in my book, man.' Not sure the fans would agree there Liam. In other cases, things take a more tragic turn. For Judy Garland and Lena Zavaroni, growing up was the exact thing that had a detrimental effect on their careers, and in turn, their lives. Garland's career survived, albeit with a number of turbulent moments and several periods of reinvention; but the residue of that initial change and the harm that it brought to her, both professionally and personally, would remain with her forever. It also doesn't help that the entertainment industry is not kind about age. We've all heard about the record executive who won't sign a band or artist unless they're under 20 years old, or the child actor who stopped getting offered parts as soon as they reached puberty. Here are ten examples of bands or artists who, for better or worse, simply grew out of their appeal.

10. Gareth Gates

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k9evVj8Vwhk Like far too many reality TV show contestants, Gareth Gates' relationship with fame was intense, but short lived. The Bradford-born Pop Idol runner-up had all the appeal of a tween icon, with his squeaky clean image, handsome looks and music that was so bland and inoffensive that even your grandmother didn't mind. But then something happened to Gareth: he, like most 18-year-olds, discovered partying. And booze. And glamour models. An alleged affair with Katie Price seemed to have an instantly detrimental effect on his wholesome image, even though he initially vehemently denied the claims. Eventually, he confessed: Ms. Price was telling the truth. Gasp! His constant porkies about the matter were a move which he has recently admitted may have cost him a few fans, as well as damaging relationships in his personal life. It is largely possible that this event also contributed to his commercial downfall - his second album, Go Your Own Way, was a failure in the UK charts, remaining there for only two weeks. Gareth has most recently been seen in the second series of ITV2's The Big Reunion as part of a bizarre supergroup that also includes Dane Bowers and a singer called Kavana. Yeah, we've never heard of him either.

9. Hanson

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NHozn0YXAeE With their unique brand of sunshine pop, nonsensical lyrics and memorable hair, Hanson made their breakthrough in 1997 when 'Mmmbop' became an international hit. A picture of innocence, not to mention remarkably young, tension arose between the boys and their record label when the former party decided they wanted more creative control over their output. Their request was refused, due to a belief that the material the boys had written wasn't marketable. One wonders if the lack of 'marketability' came from an inevitable move towards a more mature sound; it does seem as though everyone expected Hanson to retain their youthful appeal forever. Howard Stern even berated drummer Zac on his radio show for getting married too young. He was, at this point, 20 years old. Hmm. The Hanson story hasn't really graced the tabloids, mostly because there are no child star trainwrecks to see here. Nobody had a drug habit, physical confrontations appeared to be off the table and there were no run-ins with the law, or any other crazy behaviour for us to gawp at. In fact, the band managed to stick together despite the obstacles placed before them, and continued to pursue their new material. The band now release music independently, and still enjoy moderate commercial success in the United States.

8. Justin Bieber

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kffacxfA7G4 Oh, Justin Bieber. Where did it all go wrong? There was a time when this young singer was on the right track. Yes, people have always made fun of his music (and his hair), but speaking objectively and realistically, he really could have made that smooth transition from teen pop idol to accomplished R&B star. Instead, Bieber favours acting like a little brat and upsetting pretty much everyone, with his habits of making offensive comments, spitting on fans and generally swanning around with the air that his excrement does not carry an odour. At present, he is struggling to sustain his current fanbase, let alone acquire new 'Beliebers '. Bieber would be foolish to chase the unattainable goal of trying to maintain a sweet, squeaky-clean persona; he was destined to grow out of his appeal eventually. This faux-gangsta badboy thing he's been trying could even have been something interesting if it worked - that's interesting, not likeable or enjoyable - but sadly it's just really irritating. One wonders when he might actually grow up and fight to save any chance of success he may still have - although it may already be too late.

7. Blink-182

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9Ht5RZpzPqw Fun, zany and accessible enough for rockers and poppers alike, Blink 182 were the quintessential pop punk band. Despite their popularity, they attracted criticism early on in their career for their 'manufactured' sound and general daftness - but arguably, the latter was a key factor in their popularity rather than any obstruction to it. To this day, Blink are still considered one of the most influential bands of their kind. Their career has not been without misfortune. As with many other bands in a similar vein, as time wore on, Blink's appeal wore thin and conflict mounted in the group when bassist and vocalist Tom DeLonge wanted to steer the band in a more punk direction, rather than the pop-driven sound they had become known for. Nevertheless, 2005's self-titled release was certainly a departure from their earlier style, one that drove the band in a new, mature direction, and one that some fans and critics felt was much needed. Others, however, were alienated by this newfound sincerity, and the band themselves were also unsure of their direction. Growing tension among them led to their indefinite hiatus in 2005, where all members pursued other projects. Blink 182 returned in 2011 with their sixth studio album Neighborhoods. Though not as commercially successful as prior albums, it reflected further the group's evolution as artists - even if the appeal that once made the band so irresistible was long gone.

6. Charlotte Church

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n8g6Tqqc6DQ By the age of 12, Charlotte Church's spectacular voice had won her international stardom and a devoted following of fans young and old. She went on to release four successful albums, encompassing opera, classical, swing and Broadway showtunes - all cementing her status as something of a child prodigy. Cut to the mid-noughties and Church was ready to shed the image that had propelled her to superstardom to make her much-awaited transition into a mainstream pop artist. Things initially looked promising; her first pop album Tissues and Issues spawned the debut single 'Crazy Chick' which hit number 2 in the UK charts and received wide airplay on radio and music channels alike. However, the subsequent singles saw a comparatively poor chart performance, with half of the album's releases not even breaking the top 10. A year later, her record deal with Sony was scrapped. Church's lack of mainstream success raises a couple of harsh questions; If she had appeared in 2005 for the first time with her admittedly generic style of pop, would anybody even remember the name Charlotte Church? Doubtful. If she'd never attempted this transition in the first place, would she continue to go strength to strength in the classical world? Possibly - but maybe not. Church may have garnered the level of fame that most classical stars can only dream of, but how much of this was due to her age? People are always impressed by a beautiful voice, but when it comes from someone who is not yet even a teenager, we can do little but gawp in disbelief. With these factors considered, Church definitely sticks in the mind as one of the prime examples of a star who grew out of their appeal.

5. Avril Lavigne

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5NPBIwQyPWE When she arrived in a puff of teenage angst, trendy ties and eyeliner, Avril Lavigne was considered a breath of fresh air by some, if a phony by others. As she expressed her frustrations with poseur boyfriends and wailed about being stood up on a bridge in the dark, teens and pre-teens everywhere - largely female - saw a kindred spirit. Avril may now being nearing thirty, but she has held on to her rebellious teen image, with her attire still on the safer side of alternative and her music retaining that juvenile disquiet. Whilst some may sneer at her for this, there is one thing that separates her from others on this list: she's actually still pretty damn good at those things. Although the hype may have died down a long time ago, Avril has managed to remain relevant and commercially successful, maintaining her allure as the poster girl for teenage angst. Her music has seen natural maturity, of course, and there have been one or two disasters - see 'Girlfriend' - but love or hate her music, Avril deserves to be commended for still managing to make this work.

4. Liam Gallagher

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6hzrDeceEKc Liam Gallagher was once described by his own brother Noel as 'a man with a fork in a world of soup.' - and scores may agree that this seems apt. Gallagher's volatile behaviour, boozy aggression and general douchebaggery may have had its place in 1990s 'Cool Britannia,' but now, as a 41-year-old father of four, it doesn't look quite so good on him anymore. Gallagher frequently looks wrecked, continues to spew inflammatory and barely coherent comments that only serve to make us roll our eyes rather than raise any semblance of a snigger, and can often be seen wearing the same parka from 1996. One can't help but wonder if the former Oasis star will ever grow out of the ridiculous behaviours that helped to propel him to stardom so many years ago. "Mad fer it!" indeed.

3. Judy Garland

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EVwN1M2jZqw Known in the 1930s as 'the little girl with the big voice', Judy Garland was arguably at her peak in her role as Dorothy in the much-loved The Wizard of Oz. Having enjoyed success in vaudeville and short films for many years before this, she was the perfect example of a child star - cute, charming and remarkably talented. Garland's transition into more adult roles in the 1940s was wobbly at best. Many producers felt that she was not conventionally beautiful enough to be a true Hollywood leading lady; she was frequently typecast in wholesome, girl-next-door parts, something she found highly frustrating. She still enjoyed a comparatively short-lived movie career, until her personal problems and increasing alcohol and drug abuse made her career aspirations impossible. But Garland survived. In the 1960s, after several unsuccessful comebacks, she returned to her roots, coming into her own as an adored vocalist and performer who gave concerts all over the world. Despite her new-found adult appeal and apparent return to form, the pressure she faced in her childhood and the insecurities she had developed over her talent and attractiveness continued to haunt her, unfortunately dying of a barbiturate overdose in 1969 after battling substance abuse problems for years - yet many theorise it spawned from dependence on medication supplied to her as a child by MGM Studios.

2. Lena Zavaroni

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG4y6WCY1RA Lena Zavaroni found fame as a singer and TV presenter before even hitting her teenage years. Aged just ten years old when her debut album, Ma (He's Making Eyes At Me) was released, she remains, to this day, the youngest person to have ever had an album in the UK Top 10. As with Garland, Zavaroni's appeal came from her age, natural charisma and gift for singing and performing. After winning 1970s talent show Opportunity Knocks five weeks in a row, performing at the White House and appearing on stage with the likes of Frank Sinatra, Zavaroni seemed destined for international stardom; but as she grew, she found it increasingly difficult to sustain her juvenile image. Under pressure from her management, she would struggle to fit into the childish costumes that a developing teenager simply couldn't wear, and as a result, started suffering with depression and anorexia. Despite continuing to sing, as well as host her own shows throughout the 1970s and early 80s, her popularity began to wane. Her health worsened, and she later dropped out of the public eye altogether. In 1999, Zavaroni underwent neurosurgery as a last resort attempt to relieve her illnesses. She died three weeks later, after developing pneumonia.

1. Marilyn Manson

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bacm20rFO4 A heartbroken guy splits up with his girlfriend then, to express his pain, lipsyncs along to a slow song whilst self-indulgently wrapping himself in drapes and pouting sulkily towards the camera. This video, which clocks in at over six minutes, takes a slightly more sinister twist when an image of a bloodstained girl in her underwear flashes into the drape-whining set for a split second. This later leads into some bizarre and really quite unacceptable torture porn in which Heartbroken Guy essentially beats the culprit of his pain to death. The question then became; was Heartbroken Guy just a silly, emotionally volatile 16-year-old film studies student who roped in some unfortunate friends to help him make this violent expression of despair? Don't be silly. Heartbroken Guy is Marilyn Manson, of course! And this was the video for his release 'Running To The Edge of the World,' a song composed about his split with actress Evan Rachel Wood. Rather like others on this list, 'shock rocker' Mr Manson grew out of his appeal a long time ago by simply refusing to change what made him so edgy - and sadly, this isolated incident from 2010 more or less sums up where he's been for quite some time. We're not shocked anymore - just a bit creeped out at this stage. Grow up, Marilyn. Not even conservative suburban parents are that afraid of you anymore. Which artists do you feel have lost their core appeal as time has ticked by? Let us know in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stephanie is a writer and free spirit who likes to pretend she's a Londoner, though strictly speaking she's from Watford. She likes books, music, elephants, and hairspray.