10 Best Replacement Members In Hard Rock Bands
Hey hey, my my, rock and roll can never die when these folks are the substitutes.
Every now and again, events conspire to disrupt the harmony of a rock and roll band. Infighting gets the better of them, musical directions diverge, occasionally tragedy strikes. In the majority of instances however, a gap emerges if the rest of the members decide to continue that needs to be plugged - and more often than not, groups make the mistake of trying to hammer a square peg into a round hole.
But sometimes, the new guy isn't just a scrappy inferior. Sometimes, they prove their mettle and emerge as a key player in advancing the band's sound and vision. Sometimes, they become just as loved as the individual they replaced - and sometimes they exceed the wildest expectations.
With that in mind, we've listed ten such musicians who really brought their A-game to their new job - and smashed it out of the park like Keith Moon blew up televisions. It's by no means definitive - but these guys have proved their worth on the biggest stages. With that in mind, read on...
10. Phil Rudd (AC/DC)
The only Australian-born member of the veteran Australian hard rock outfit for many years, the drummer's motoring presence beneath the riffs of the Young brothers and the wails of both Bon Scott and Brian Johnson was the bedrock for many years - but he isn't the man behind the kit on their first domestic album.
The original version of High Voltage was instead laid down with then-member Peter Clack - at least for one track, before the rest of the record was completed with session player Tony Currenti. Rudd has spent time out of the band since his arrival too, most recently sitting out their Rock or Bust Tour when he was replaced by Welshman Chris Slade.
9. Nils Lofgren (Bruce Springsteen And The E Street Band)
The former Crazy Horse guitarist had carved out a solo career for himself during the seventies but it was his association with Bruce Springsteen that helped his stock rise even further when he was called in to replace Steven Van Zandt in the E Street Band ahead of the Born in the U.S.A. Tour.
Lofgren brought with him a different, arguably more clinical style that sat in contrast with his predecessor and he remained a mainstay of Springsteen's group until their dissolution in 1989.
When the band reuinited a decade later, both him and Van Zandt were called up for guitar duties, and the contrast between the pair remains part of the pronounced joy of catching the group in concert ever since.
8. Eric Carr (Kiss)
The first replacement drummer for original sticksman Peter Criss in the famed glam rock outfit faced less creative input than his predecessor throughout his tenure - but many agree that as a musician, The Fox had him beat with his sense of rhythm and skill behind the kit.
Alas, Carr was only to enjoy just over a fruitful decade with the band, including their move away from makeup, before his life was tragically cut short. He did from complications surrounding heart cancer in 1991 - coincidentally on the same day as Queen frontman Freddie Mercury, whose own passing somewhat overshadowed the news.
7. Ronnie Wood (The Rolling Stones)
The multi-instrumentalist had found success as the bassist in the Jeff Beck Group before forming the Faces alongside Rod Stewart - but it was his arrival in the Rolling Stones that perhaps truly cemented his standing as a musician.
He was drafted in initially as a touring replacement for Mick Taylor in 1975 but following the dissolution of the Faces, became a full-time member, one who - as the band have progressed through the years - has proved to be a key part of the group's musical bedrock underneath Keith Richards' more expressive stylings.
6. Dave Grohl (Nirvana)
The Foo Fighters frontman's name is forever entwined with the legacy of the grunge icons, but he remarkably was MIA for their debut album Bleach, only making his full LP debut with the arrival of iconic sophomore record Nevermind.
Instead, the man on the kit for that first effort was Chad Channing, whose work ultimately fell out of favour with Kurt Cobain and Krist Novoselic. The drummer himself was growing dissatisfied with a lack of input in the songwriting process and he duly departed, paving the way for Grohl to establish himself as one of the world's greatest sticksmen.
5. John Frusciante (Red Hot Chili Peppers)
The acclaimed guitarist has just returned to RHCP for his third stint with the group - and if he can replicate his particularly brilliant sonic songcraft once more, fans are in for a treat - but his original arrival to the group came on the back of tragedy.
He replaced original axe man Hillel Slovak after he died of a drug overdose, joining the group as his teenage successor - but he quickly managed to make his mark on his first record with the band, Mother's Milk, which saw his melodic prowess come to the fore. He remains the benchmark for guitarists within the group.
4. Phil Collins (Genesis)
When Peter Gabriel made his exit from the art-rock favourites, they turned to their drummer to lead them on - a move made all the more impressive given he wasn't even their original sticksman. In fact, the Chiswick native was only drafted in after the previous occupier of the position John Mayhew was fired following the departure of guitarist Anthony Phillips.
With his solo career more dedicated to his pop leanings, Collins was able to lead Genesis into a harder-edged extension of their progressive sound - both Mama and Land of Confusion spring to mind as particularly percussive examples. The Invisible Touch-era three-piece have reunited and are set to tour later this year.
3. Bruce Dickinson (Iron Maiden)
The singer-songwriter with the air raid-siren voice is about as synonymous with the veteran heavy metal outfit as their mascot Eddie - yet he remarkably only came to the group three albums in, when he was drafted to replace Paul Di'Anno following the latter's struggle with drink and drug abuse.
His first record with the band, The Number of the Beast, is widely considered one of the genre's seminal moments - and Dickinson has the odd distinction of being a double replacement within the group, having returned to the fold in 1999, over five years after he previously left to forge a solo career, to follow on his own original successor Blaze Bayley.
2. Matt Cameron (Pearl Jam)
Having gone through a revolving door line-up of drummers across their first five albums - including former Red Hot Chili Peppers man Jack Irons - the Seattle grunge icons decided to pillage their neighbours when it came to finding their fifth man to sit behind the kit.
Soundgarden man Cameron has proved an inspired choice too, arguably the most energetic and groove-friendly of the bunch to hold the position in Pearl Jam to date. He's worked on their six subsquent records, including this year's Gigaton, and continues to form the beating heart of their mammoth live performances.
1. Robert Trujillo (Metallica)
The task of following former bassist Jason Newsted as the newest member of the seminal thrash group was arguably the lesser of the two tasks the former Suicidal Tendencies man had to complete. Namely, he also had to win over a band who had effectively sidelined their own member following his succession of the late Cliff Burton before him.
Trujillo took to it like a duck to water however, to the acclaim of both his fellow musicians and fans. He's coming up on twenty years in the band, almost as long as both his predecessors combined - and his particularly deft, brilliant style makes him among the most formidable musicians at his craft on the arena and stadium circuit.