10 Best Rock And Roll Breakup Albums

Rock’s Bleeding Heart.

Fleetwood mac rumours
Warner Records

Rock and roll has gone through its fair share of love songs in its time. Ever since acts like the Beatles were talking about how all we needed was love, there have been countless artists willing to stick their neck on the line for the people they care about. Life can play tricks on you though, and even some of the biggest acts in the world aren’t safe from emotional trauma every once in a while.

To be fair, not all of these are breakup albums in the truest form. As much as it would be easy to fill a list like this up with songs about how your ex is an awful person, a lot of these have to deal with the loss of someone else in the picture, whether that be the family members that you’ve had to leave behind along the way or moving on without one of your fellow band members.

In this case though, the band doesn’t really lean into their anger all that often. Rather than just talk about the emotional slog that they went through, a lot of these songs turn inward to see what they could have done better, and whether they can even find that kind of happiness ever again. Some of these might be a bit less rocking than before, but you get to see a lot more about the person when you hear songs like this.

10. Brand New Eyes - Paramore

For people who are coming here for nothing but breakup ballads, not every breakup record really works that way. Throughout every one of these records, you can always feel a pretty clear split in the music, as you hear the artists at their emotional wit's end as they come to terms with losing some of the most important people in their lives. It could be your love interest, but it could also be the bandmates that you've struggled with as well.

Before even going into cut Brand New Eyes, Paramore were already fairly burnt by the last few years, tired of the touring life that came after Riot! and getting more than a little bit jealous that Hayley Williams was being treated as the main person in the group instead of it being a band effort. There are some love songs on here to be sure, but the core message behind this record is tension within the band, as a few of these songs mirror the kind of turmoil that they were going through at the time.

Even when they were able to lash out at each other on songs like Ignorance and Playing God, the next cycle for the album wasn't necessarily going to be happy either, with both the Farro brothers leaving the group on very bad terms and relegating the band to a trio for their next self titled album. Breakups are always a delicate subject, but there are only a handful of albums where you can feel that separation happening in real time.


9. Ghost Stories - Coldplay

There's a good chance that the textbook definition of the word 'overexposed' could just be a picture of Chris Martin's face. Ever since the days of Viva La Vida, Coldplay's rise as one of the few active stadium rock bands has garnered both love and hate from both sides of the fence, from the beautiful ballads to people who find their music some of the most bottom of the barrel pop rock you can come by. Chris might like to indulge himself every now and again, but it's not like he can't wear his heart on his sleeve when he wants.

Throughout a fairly messy public divorce with wife Gwyneth Paltrow, Ghost Stories had the band stripping things back a lot more, going for songs that had more of an electronic tinge. Though songs like a Sky Full of Stars mark the point where a lot of the rock crowd jumped off the bandwagon, the inner workings behind this record tell a much different story, as Chris goes through the different stages of separation, from reminiscing on the past during Magic to then talking about wanting his old flame back on Ink.

Even if the Coldplay train seemed to be operating at half capacity most of the time, hearing a song like Midnight is a much different flavor for the band, giving you the sense of feeling truly alone in the darkness. Martin would get back into sunnier territory just a few years later, but it's nice to hear the more melancholy side of his work every now and again.


8. RAM - Paul McCartney

In the acrimonious split between the Beatles, every one of the Fab Four had their own say as to what really happened behind closed doors. As George Harrison carried on with recording songs that he had been sitting on, John Lennon pulled no punches with his audience, saying that the dream of these lovable Liverpool boys was gone forever on his album Plastic Ono Band. Though Paul McCartney may have been the first person to release a solo record, he wouldn't get to really have his say until one album later.

Seeing how McCartney's self titled debut was released before Let It Be, it was meant to just be a way to blow off steam in between the tumultuous sessions for that last record. Now that there was no chance of building bridges, RAM is the first time Paul knew he was on his own, and decided to hide away on his farm and create something much more homespun. Although the record was actually recorded in New York, you can hear that more organic side of Paul coming out in these songs, from the Beatles-esque moments like Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey to the more ambitious sounds of The Back Seat of My Car.

Despite getting some pretty nasty reviews back in the day, the legacy of RAM is a lot clearer now with the benefit of hindsight. This wasn't just some weird experiment where the Cute Beatle lost his way. This was a man coming to grips with losing his best friends and using the entire span of a record to make sense of it.


7. Alice in Chains - Alice in Chains

Most of the heavyhitters of the grunge community were not really having the best time post 1994. After Kurt Cobain's suicide sent shockwaves through the entire town of Seattle, bands started to distance themselves from the sound that made them famous, either by going down different directions like Pearl Jam or breaking up in the case of Soundgarden. Alice in Chains may have kept on trucking, but they happened to have a walking nightmare singing for them.

Despite the years trying to recover and even finding himself on steady ground with Mad Season, Layne Staley's return to the band meant another relapse on heroin, which became much more pronounced as the sessions went on. In making a handful of these songs, Jerry Cantrell was doing most of the heavy lifting, going for songs that are a lot sludgier and even singing a handful of these tunes completely by himself because Layne wasn't physically able to.

It also wasn't a good sign when there wasn't as much touring going on for the project either, which made fans question just how bad a shape Layne was in. Though a hiatus seemed to be the right move to get everyone on track, it was too late for Layne to clean himself up, getting more dependent on his vices until he was found dead in his apartment. The MTV Unplugged appearance may have been one of the final releases from the old Alice, but this record really marks the beginning of the end for one of the greatest voices of the '90s.


6. Year of the Tiger - Myles Kennedy

As far as traditional rock and roll is concerned, Myles Kennedy has always been like musical medicine for some bands. After saving the rest of Creed from the butt rock of Scott Stapp by making Alter Bridge, he has also turned in time for Slash on most of his solo shows, where he actually pulls off Guns N Roses material a lot better than Axl Rose probably could these days. He is far from just a hired gun though, and his debut solo record gave us a talent who had a lot of emotion to unpack.

Since his past few gigs have been him reinterpreting the work of his friends, Year of the Tiger feels like the first time that we're seeing Myles Kennedy as he was meant to be, along with very few stompers this time around. For a guy who's known for hard rock and metal, this is a slice of pure Americana, with every song dealing with the loss of Myles' father in the past few years.

As the album plays on, you really can hear him get a lot more personal than he would normally, talking about the complicated relationship that he had with his father and how he makes his peace with his loss from a non spiritual perspective. Both Slash and Alter Bridge are definitely great gigs to have for a traditional rock singer, but if something catastrophic were to happen, Myles seems more than up to the challenge of making it on his own.


5. Echo - Tom Petty

Divorces are always bound to be messy even if you aren't one of the biggest stars in the world. Untangling yourself from another person is never a pleasant experience, especially if you've been able to muscle through some of your greatest hardships together. Tom Petty may have been tough as nails whenever he stepped behind a microphone, but Echo was the one album where he seemed to be truly lost.

Although Wildflowers is the one album where Tom started to see cracks in his marriage, this record is really the aftermath of all that pain, taking each song as a way of comforting himself, whether that means begging for his wife to take him back on Room at the Top or knowing just how alone he's going to feel once this is all over on the title track. There might have been a lot of sore wounds on this album, but the real carnage was happening right in front of the band's eyes whenever they went into the studio.

Around the same time that Tom was secluding himself from the rest of the world, bassist Howie Epstein was slowly losing himself to heroin addiction, going further and further into denial and barely playing on the album before passing away just a few years later. The Heartbreakers have always felt like a unit both on and off the stage, but this was the first time where there was legitimate fear about how long these good times were going to last.


4. Blue - Joni Mitchell

Part of the appeal behind most of Joni Mitchell's material is just how different it sounded from every other folk singer out there. Joni was always a woman who knew what she was doing whenever she strapped on her guitar, and she was never afraid to share the more complex sides of her musical background, bringing in people like Jaco Pastorius from the jazz world to play on some of her more acclaimed records. She also knew a thing or two about the complex sides of herself as well, and Blue is when she really started to feel lost.

Leading up to this project, Joni had separated from her boyfriend and felt like she had been thrown away, which made for songs that are a little more downtrodden than usual. After writing about the bright sunshine on songs like California or Big Yellow Taxi, Joni has a lot more miles on her soul on this album, with the title track being a tearjerker about the fallout of everything and not letting up on songs like My Old Man.

Even when there were more pop leaning tracks in the mix like River, the core message behind this song isn't care free, as Joni wishes to have a river where you can skate away from all of the troubles in your life. For an artist that was a ray of sunshine whenever she came on the radio, this is what happens when that beam of light suddenly runs cold.


3. A Moon Shaped Pool - Radiohead

There's a good chance that nearly half of Radiohead's biggest hits could make for a decent breakup song playlist. When they're not talking about the destruction that's going on around them on albums like Kid A, songs like Fake Plastic Trees, High and Dry, and even Creep seem like the perfect songs to listen to when you've lost someone you're close to. With years comes experience though, and A Moon Shaped Pool may be the closest they've come to pure melancholy.

During the making of this record, Thom Yorke had separated from his wife, which makes for songs that feel a lot more wounded sonically. Though most of these songs were started years before this record was made, hearing them in this form has a more foreboding feel, like the subtle strings on Burn the Witch or the acoustic sounds of Present Tense. Even if songs like Decks Dark have to do with an alien invasion, there's just an added sense of surrealism in the mix, which makes for a record that has a lot more sadness running through it.

The album packs even more of a punch when Thom's ex-wife passed away a short time after their separation, giving a new meaning to a lot of these songs once you hear them in context. A song like True Love Waits may have been hard to get through when they played it live back in the '90s, but you practically need a trigger warning before listening to this version of the song knowing what we know now.


2. Blood on the Tracks - Bob Dylan

Any emotional trauma that artists go through is going to pop up in their music sooner or later. Every one of the greatest artists tend to stay true to themselves, and to sidestep something as hard as a divorce is going to be hard for anyone to take in. And when you're being looked at as one of the greatest songwriters to put pen to paper, you're going to need to do some major unpacking when you actually come to address it.

Coming into the '70s, Bob Dylan was already on a bit of shaky ground, not comfortable with his Voice of a Generation tag and putting out records that were meant to reflect his more human side. During his separation from his wife Sara though, Dylan tried to work outside of his comfort zone, learning to paint in New York and indulging himself in different artistic mediums to take a break from his songwriting. When he did return to his roots though, Blood on the Tracks had a lot more pain than expected.

Throughout every song here, you can hear Dylan wrestling with the different emotions inside himself, from pointing the finger at both himself and his ex on Idiot Wind to making a pretty compelling love song on You're Gonna Make Me Lonesome When You Go. While all of these songs can be messy, Tangled Up in Blue may be the mission statement of what the entire record means. It was a long road to get here, and it may have all fallen apart, but you have to try and pick up the pieces and move on.


1. Rumours - Fleetwood Mac

It would be bad enough for any artist to have to deal with a breakup right in the middle of an album cycle. When you're trying to make some of the best music you can, some of that pent up emotion is bound to come through sooner or later, and might lead to something pretty nasty when you come out on the other side. That's just one messy breakup, but Fleetwood Mac had three to deal with at the exact same time.

During the recording of Rumours, Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks had officially broken up, Christine and John McVie were filing for divorce, and Mick Fleetwood was in the midst of a separation with his wife due to his drug dependency. Nothing in that previous sentence points to this record being good, but something about all of that negative energy made them channel it into their material, which made for something a lot more potent when the songs actually came to fruition.

Outside of the internal drama, these songs might be some of the best music that have ever put out, taking the rootsiness of the band's acoustic sound and making solid gold out of it. When you look beyond just the basic construction of the tunes, this album reads like a walking soap opera of emotion, as every song deals with the separations, from Lindsey getting bitter on Go Your Own Way to Christine making her peace with her divorce from John on Songbird. An album like this may have been a nightmare to live through, but for every single member of Mac, music will always be the chain that keeps them together.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97