10 Cover Versions No One Saw Coming

Unexpected surprises you couldn't have dreamed up.

Tainted Love When we heard that Taylor Swift had done a cover of Lose Yourself, undoubtedly one of the finest songs from Eminem's vast back catalogue, we immediately presumed it was some sort of wind-up. While usually when you hear "Taylor Swift" and "rapper" in the same sentence you jump to the conclusion that Kanye West has chucked her off the stage again, it turns out in this instance it's 100% genuine. It turns out that during an appearance on Froggy Radio the country star actually held her own pretty well while delivering her own version of Eminem's famous rap. It's not just Taylor Swift who has surprised the world by taking on a song that people mightn't have expected her to, though. This article collects together 10 of the most unexpected cover versions in recent musical history. Some of them are genre-crossing, some of them are gender-crossing, some of them are just plain inappropriate- all of them are unexpected..!

10. Britney Spears - (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction

Originally By: The Rolling Stones http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vF2l_rWdvDs When Britney Spears's sophomore album Oops..! I Did It Again was released in 2000, there was an audible gasp heard around the world when the title (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction emerged among the tracklisting. With her version of the song Britney stripped away the hard edge of The Rolling Stones's original and instead slowed it down and made it into more of a breathy pop song, typical of Britney's earlier work, before the chorus kicks in with an almost R&B beat. A lot of people worried that the Britney version of Satisfaction might fall flat, or that she might not be able to pull it off. It turns out they were right. One of the biggest icons in music taking on one of the most iconic songs of the 20th century should have been a huge deal, but instead this cover is actually pretty forgettable, especially compared with many of the more memorable songs on Britney's album (namely Stronger, which is still one of her finest songs to date). As it goes this would be the first of many covers for Britney, she would later take on Arrows' I Love Rock 'n' Roll and Bobby Brown's My Prerogative, both of which were a lot stronger than her take on Satisfaction, thankfully proving that given the right material a Britney Spears cover version doesn't need to be a bad thing.

9. Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Jolene

Originally By: Dolly Parton http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SuwyDGwfER8 Jolene is undeniably one of the most important song in country legend Dolly Parton's discography. Its lyrics, written by Parton herself (on the same night she also wrote I Will Always Love You, which went on to be re-recorded by Whitney Houston in one of the most praised cover versions of all time), tell a tale of hopelessness and desperation which Dolly Parton's vocals on the track convey perfectly in her delivery on the track. Therefore it was pretty unexpected when such an emotional song was taken on by English pop singer Sophie Ellis-Bextor, who is famous for her deadpan and nonchalant delivery in her own music, decided to record her own version of Jolene for the soundtrack to the British sitcom Beautiful People. It's hard to go wrong with a song so close to perfection as Jolene, so while the Sophie Ellis-Bextor version, of course, can't quite match the greatness of Dolly Parton's original, we still applaud her efforts.

8. Girls Aloud - I Predict A Riot

Originally By: Kaiser Chiefs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0gY5hwvRwBQ Over the course of their career Girls Aloud became known for their cover versions. As well as the ones everyone is already aware of, like I'll Stand By You or I Think We're Alone Now, the girls performed a whole range of covers during their live shows, taking on tracks from the likes of Britney Spears, Robyn and Carly Rae Jepsen. Their most ambitious cover version was taken from the girls' Chemistry tour in 2006. After having their track Love Machine covered by Arctic Monkeys in Radio 1's Live Lounge, Girls Aloud's street cred was at an all-time high which they clearly used to their advantage by taking on a track by indie rockers Kaiser Chiefs with their cover of I Predict A Riot. The result isn't something to put a smile on the face of your typical NME reader, but above all the energy and enthusiasm that Girls Aloud bring to their performance of the track is what makes this a worthy cover version for us.

7. Marilyn Manson - Tainted Love

Originally By: Soft Cell http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1nO_P4BH4pA Soft Cell's Tainted Love is one of the defining songs of the sound of the 1980s. Its synthesiser-based instrumental makes it one of the most recognisable songs of the decade, not to mention a floor-filler and party classic even over thirty years after its initial release. The Marilyn Manson version of the song, on the other hand, is not quite so dancefloor-friendly. Taken from the soundtrack to comedy film Not Another Teen Movie, the new version of the song is practically unrecognisable. The easy-listening synthesisers are out, and in their place are distorted guitar samples. As for Manson's delivery of the song, his menacing vocals actually do a great job in highlighting the lyrics of the song, which are a lot more angry and bitter than Marc Almond makes them sound. "Don't touch me please I cannot stand the way you tease", actually sounds a lot more effective when it's being almost screamed by Marilyn Manson than sung sweetly on the more recognisable 1980s version of the song. In fact, the 2004 remix is so far removed from the original that it stands up perfectly well on its own.

6. Madonna - American Pie

Originally By: Don McLean http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8BIAi3Oo7To The story goes that Madonna was starring in the film The Next Best Thing, co-starring Rupert Everett and, oddly enough, Neil Patrick Harris. During the film, her character Abbie sings Don McLean's American Pie at a friend's funeral, which apparently Rupert Everett managed to convince Madonna would be a good song for her to record her own version of. Madonna's electropop version of the song, produced by William Orbit, cuts out most of the original verses to try and make it a bit more radio-friendly (some would argue this is sacrilegious, others would say it's just practical as the original goes on for about six months). The British public were clearly impressed with Madonna's cover, the song went to number 1 there, and even Don McLean himself has described her version as a "gift from a goddess". As it turns out, Madonna herself was not such a fan of the song. She claims her record company "twisted her arm" into recording it and as such it was never released in America and was left off her second greatest hits collection GHV2. According to Madonna this was her way of "punishing" the song.

5. Susan Boyle - Wild Horses

Originally By: The Rolling Stones http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yb3XAP0c8WU The world watched as Susan Boyle became an overnight sensation thanks to her appearance on Britain's Got Talent. She eventually became runner up in the competition, and was signed immediately to Simon Cowell's record label SyCo. While she got busy recording her debut album I Dreamed A Dream, everybody wondered what kind of material she'd be releasing. What nobody could have predicted was that Susan Boyle's debut single would be a cover of a Rolling Stones track. However while the Stones' original is gritty and guitar-led, the Susan Boyle cover slows everything down and turns the track into what is almost a torch song with simple piano accompaniment. This allows her to really show off her voice, which she manages to do perfectly on her recording of the song, which makes for a totally different listening experience to the original. It's unusual, but we'd say it works.

4. Scissor Sisters - Comfortably Numb

Originally By: Pink Floyd http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRk5Gjl_cAg Some covers are notable for stripping everything back so that the emotion of the track can truly be heard. The Scissor Sisters' version of Comfortably Numb is not one of those instances. In fact with their version of Pink Floyd's Comfortably Numb, rather than stripping it back it seems like the Scissor Sisters took an "everything but the kitchen sink" approach by reworking the song into a disco-influenced dance track that you can't help but single along with. A million miles from the rock-based original recording, the Scissor Sisters cover sounds like it's straight from Studio 54, with influences from Donna Summer and the Bee Gees clearly audible. It might not be to everybody's tastes, and certainly might not be a favourite amongst Pink Floyd fans, but we challenge anyone not to want to dance by the time they're done listening to the Scissor Sisters' reworking of Comfortably Numb.

3. Tori Amos - '97 Bonnie and Clyde

Originally By: Eminem http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g7YxrYKQBP8 It is often the intention of an artist performing a cover of a song to pay a tribute to the original song or its performer, but with her interpretation of '97 Bonnie and Clyde Tori Amos takes a very different approach. Eminem's original version of the track caused controversy for its lyrical content when it was first released. It details a fantasy in Eminem's head wherein he and his young daughter drive to a lake and dispose of the body of his ex-wife Kim, who he has murdered. Defenders of the song claimed that rather than being threatening, Eminem is actually using black humour rather than violent imagery. Meanwhile the song's critics claimed that the song promoted violence against women. With Tori Amos's cover of the song, which appeared on her album Strange Little Girls, she neither sings the song's lyrics nor tries to rap them. Instead she speaks them in a sinister whisper over the top of a string orchestra, which makes for a truly harrowing, though equally thought-provoking, listening experience.

2. Gwen Stefani - Wind It Up

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9sY-TsLXiDo OK, so this isn't technically a cover but this song is just bonkers enough that we decided to include it on the list anyway. Gwen Stefani's debut album Love Angel Music Baby included a song called Rich Girl, a re-imagining of the song If I Were A Rich Man from the musical Fiddler On The Roof. Clearly, Gwen thought she was onto a winner with this "take a showtune and turn it into a pop song" formula, as she and producer Pharrell Williams tried it again with Wind It Up, the lead single from her second album The Sweet Escape. Wind It Up is set against a remix of The Lonely Goatherd from The Sound of Music. It's a totally mental re-working of the song that is frenetic, unpredictable and leaves you wondering exactly what it was you just spent 3 minutes and 11 seconds listening to. And then you realise: a mix of Gwen Stefani rapping and Gwen Stefani yodelling a song that was first made famous by Julie Andrews.

1. Alanis Morrissette - My Humps

Originally By: Black Eyed Peas https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W91sqAs-_-g Sometimes a video really does need to be seen to be believed, and this is one of them. Alanis Morrissette is an artist you're probably more used to hearing singing angrily about her breakup, or pondering how ironic a situation is, rather than telling you how she's "gonna get get get you drunk, get you love drunk off my hump", but with her re-working of the Black Eyed Peas hit My Humps she did just that. By stripping away the song's production, Alanis Morrissette turns My Humps into a piano ballad which leaves you with nothing to concentrate on but the song's lyrics. And, oh, those lyrics... Point proven, Alanis. Well done.

Contributor
Contributor

My name is Daniel and I live in Newcastle. Nothing makes me happier than excellent pop music, big hair or a C-list celebrity having a Twitter meltdown.