10 Famous Bands With Rotating Lineups

A Musician Rollercoaster.

gorillaz band
Gorillaz

There’s always a bit of a band of brothers mentality when it comes to most rock bands. Even if there’s a de facto leader of the group, everyone seems to have their ideal rock band be the best of friends, always jamming in their free time and being psyched every time they take to the stage to deliver it to the people. That’s the dream, but reality can be a lot different than what we think.

For all of the great songs that these bands have made, the people playing the music is almost an afterthought half the time, with musicians coming in and out of the group with only a few people at the front. Although there might be some core members that help steer the ship most of the time, the rest of the band tend to be looked at almost like musical pawns, being put in just the right place to serve their purpose before being pitched to find someone else.

The whole idea might sound callous and cold, but there’s a method to the madness here. Most of the time, these artists have a certain idea in mind for their group, and that means getting every top of the line musician in tow to make sure you get the sound you’re looking for. There might not be nearly as much camaraderie as you would find in other acts, but the results are worth much more than a paycheck too.

10. Deep Purple

In the aftermath of the Summer of Love, rock and roll started to take things in a bit of a different direction half a world away. Although the British Invasion may have kicked everything off with acts like the Beatles, the new sounds were focused on bands that were more gritty, taking their cues from blues artists and gaining major traction like the Yardbirds and Led Zeppelin. Deep Purple were far more eclectic though, and it would take an entire gang's worth of musicians to push the boundaries of rock and roll.

Originally forming as a sort of jam band in the vein of Vanilla Fudge, both Ritchie Blackmore and Jon Lord came to the conclusion that they needed fresh blood, drafting in Roger Glover and Ian Gillan and turning towards a more hard rock style with tracks like Highway Star. Despite the massive singles like Smoke on the Water, there was never a lot of a camaraderie in the band or anything, and one too many disagreements led to Roger and Ian being replaced by Glenn Hughes and David Coverdale, each bringing a more soulful tinge to their vocals.

Though most fans divide the lineups into different phases of the group though, only drummer Ian Paice has been there through it all, as Ritchie left the fray to focus on medieval music and Jon Lord officially retiring in 2001 and leaving Don Airey to fill out the keyboard parts whenever they played live. In that timeframe though, Deep Purple had dipped their toes into rock and roll, blues, classical, funk and everything else in between.


9. Megadeth

There's a good case to be made for calling everything Megadeth has done to be the Dave Mustaine Experience. Coming off the heels of being shown the door by Metallica, the whole premise behind the band was to make a big enough thrash outfit to rival Dave's former bandmates, with songs that were more technical and heavier than what Metallica could do. It's debatable whether or not Megadeth is exactly a better act than Metallica, but any musician that has come through their ranks can definitely play circles around anything James Hetfield and co. have ever done.

While the original incarnation with Gar Samuelson and Chris Poland worked well coming from the jazz world, it wasn't long before things got out of control with drugs, with both of them being sacked shortly after the tour for Peace Sells. Ever since losing Gar and Chris, both the lead guitarist and drummer slot has practically been a revolving door, with Marty Friedman laying down some great solos during the Rust In Peace to now having Lamb of God's Chris Adler behind the kit in more recent years on records like Dystopia.

With every new member, you can also hear Dave's tastes change ever so slightly, from the pure thrash of the early days to writing more accessible stuff in the '90s until finally finding his way back to the metal that birthed him on albums like the System Has Failed, with Chris Poland even coming back to play solos. Everyone dreams of being in a successful metal band, but getting a gig with Megadeth is basically just being one of Dave's employees.


8. Black Sabbath

For a goof portion of die hard Ozzy Osbourne fans, Black Sabbath didn't have any business continuing on after the Prince of Darkness left his throne. The brooding sounds of his voice were practically irreplaceable, and his amazing solo career was proof enough that his reputation as a rock and roll drunk wasn't going to slow him down, especially with Randy Rhoads by his side. Sabbath wasn't Ozzy's band though. It belonged to Tony Iommi, and he was going to do everything he could to keep it rolling.

Launching back into the '80s with Ronnie James Dio behind the mic, Heaven and Hell turned into the career renaissance most Sabbath fans had been waiting for, taking the common tropes of the New Wave of British Heavy Metal and incorporating that into their sound. While it might have cost them substituting Bill Ward for Vinny Appice, that was just the beginning of the shakeups, including a period where Tony Iommi was the only active member of the band to the '90s where we had people like Ice T guesting on Sabbath records.

The real unsung hero behind keeping the band afloat though was Tony Martin, steering Sabbath through some of their dark times in the '90s before being dropped to bring in Dio and Ozzy on occasion when they decide to tour. The Sabbath that we know today is now a thing of the past, but each member should be proud with coming up with some of the most demonic rock and roll that the world had ever seen.


7. Fleetwood Mac

There's a good half of Fleetwood Mac's discography that felt like it was made to blast out of classic rock radio. The kind of chemistry that comes with these folksy pop songs are almost perfect, sending songs like Rhiannon and Dreams into permanent rotation and any stripe of rock fan being happy to sing along whenever they come on. And like all good folksy acts of their caliber, The Mac actually found their calling in....the blues?

Before we had the likes of Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham taking the reins, the original incarnation of Fleetwood Mac had Peter Green at the front, penning the kind of lowdown and dirty songs that were commonplace around '60s England at the time. They weren't just hangers on either, with songs like Albatross being favorites of the Beatles back in the day and Santana turning their song Black Magic Woman into a rock classic. Once Peter left though, the change of the guard started with Bob Welch, bringing a jazz slant to the band's sound along with Christine McVie's keyboards.

After a falling out though, Lindsey was brought in under the condition that his girlfriend Stevie could be in the band as well, making for the lineup that birthed albums like Rumours and Tusk. This was only to be the beginning of the bickering between every single member of the band, but once you got them up onstage and in front of microphones, that long standing musical chain would always keep them together.


6. Guns N Roses

When the hair metal scene first started to get way out of hand, Guns N Roses was the breath of fresh air that most of us needed. Every other band along the Sunset Strip started to look more like a manufactured product, and these guys were the epitome of a street gang, ready to go to war with anyone who stood in their way. That magic could only last for so long, and fans have been subjected to the Axl Rose Show ever since.

Coming out of the tour for the double album Use Your Illusion, the band were already in shambles, with Steven Adler being replaced by Matt Sorum due to drug problems and Izzy Stradlin quitting halfway through because he couldn't deal with Axl's antics anymore. Once they arrived back in LA at the end of the tour though, there was no hope for the original band reforming, with the covers album the Spaghetti Incident biding them time before Slash and Duff McKagan walked out the door as well.

Ever since that day in 1994, fans have always known not to get too worked up about new GNR material, as Axl threw out an odd song here and there like Oh My God until finally giving us the mess of Chinese Democracy, which sounds like a passion project that took more than 20 years to bring together. Slash and Duff did find some time to come back to the band though, so it's anyone's guess as to whether that magic that was sparked back on Appetite for Destruction can come back or not.


5. A Perfect Circle

If you looked at any of the press surrounding A Perfect Circle at the beginning of their career, this looked like it was just an offshoot for what Maynard James Keenan was doing with Tool. There were the still the same tropes that you were seeing with something off of Lateralus, only this time with a bit of a gothic atmosphere more in line with mainstream metal. Before Maynard was even in the picture though, A Perfect Circle was already beginning in the mind of Billy Howerdel.

Being a guitar tech for Tool back in the day, Billy was itching to get his own songs out to the public and even had considered a female vocalist for the group before taking Maynard on. Though the first incarnation of the band was more in line with metal with session musicians like Josh Freese and getting Rob Halford's input for releasing the song Judith, the next phase of their career saw different players from the alternative world come in as well, from the likes of 30 Seconds to Mars and Queens of the Stone Age lending a hand.

Out of every "guest star" though, James Iha seemed to work his touch a lot more than his contemporaries, working on tracks off of Thirteenth Step and creating a different world for Billy's ideas to form in. Whereas Tool might try to trip your brain out with different concepts that can break your mental capacity, A Perfect Circle is just the right middle ground for making something that might *gasp* get on the radio.


4. Gorillaz

After the '90s came to an end, most of the biggest names in the world of Britpop tended to fall by the wayside. Giants like Oasis had already started to backslide a little bit after the success of Be Here Now, and all we had left was the more lightweight acts like Coldplay to try and carry rock and roll into the future. The Britpop golden age may have come to an end, but what Damon Albarn had cooking up seemed to go beyond rock and roll altogether.

While living with cartoonist JAmie Hewlett, the idea started to form for a completely electronic band, taking the same rock and roll hangups and putting them in a more zany soundscape. Damon would take on the role of the titular 2D, but every other instrument in the Gorillaz canon was something new, with new artists coming in and out of the studio on each album, from The Clash appearing on Plastic Beach to hooking up with Noel Gallagher on the album Humanz.

The biggest switch up with Gorillaz is how well they work in the world of hip hop, with some of their greatest tracks featuring guest contributions from everyone from MF Doom to De La Soul to Snoop Dogg. You can say that it's all just the fictional band evolving along the way, but it goes a lot deeper than that in reality. Damon was a man who knew that his rock star days were behind him, and now was the time to take on something that could mean more than just a fad.


3. Steely Dan

Up to this point, most people at least have a passing understanding on what an actual rock band is. For all of the people that come and go, there's at least a set lineup to these acts that tends to consist of guitar, bass, drums, and vocals most of the time, with added session musicians coming in to fill out everything else. In the golden age of rock and roll though, Steely Dan took everything you expected and basically threw it out the window.

Out of all the great musicians that have come and gone throughout each record, it's almost cheating to even call Steely Dan a band in the true sense. While the main members include Walter Becker and Donald Fagen, their roles have primarily been served as studio labrats, taking the building blocks of the songs they liked and getting just the right musician to perform on them. Going through their discography, you can find a whole host of different musicians coming in and out of the control room, from Larry Carlton laying down the solos of Kid Charlemagne or Steve Gadd teaching a clinic on drum solos on Aja.

There are even a few choice moments on their records where Donald and Walter take a back seat, like Babylon Sisters, which barely features them playing on the track in any capacity. That's because this isn't really the kind of democracy you would see in a band. Given all of the people that have come and gone, Steely Dan feels more like a state of mind than an actual band.


2. Nine Inch Nails

Given the man's pedigree, Trent Reznor didn't really need a band moniker to get Nine Inch Nails off the ground. Before he had even put together a collaborative project, he had already shopped demos around to record labels of just him playing all of the instruments in the studio, with almost every one of them offering him a deal in some capacity. It can get lonely as a solo outfit though, and Trent was always just as good as the people he was working with at the time.

From the start at Pretty Hate Machine, the inclusion of Richard Patrick brought something that was a lot more aggro than what we had seen in the industrial scene, with songs that went into a lot more psychotic directions. Once Trent was left to his own devices in the Tate house for records like the Downward Spiral though, using the guitar voice of Robert Fripp brought a certain haze to the record that was more suited to ambient music than something loud and abrasive.

Although he may have still been the pinup industrial superstar, Trent was always looking to expand his vision and make something that would hit you in the face, bringing in people like Josh Freese to lay down drums on Survivalism before finding a partner in crime with Atticus Ross, who has practically become the co captain of the group in recent years. Now with film scoring under his belt, the warped mind of Trent almost seems to use his fellow musicians like instruments by themselves, always trying to push them that one step further to get what he wants.


1. Queens of the Stone Age

Once the rest of the stoner rock movement got underway, it was pretty clear that the first incarnation of Kyuss had done all that they could do together. Any other forward movement would have turned them into sell outs, but Joshua Homme wasn't looking to just sit on his hands and retire from music either. He wanted something more than just a normal band, and Queens of the Stone Age quickly turned into one of the most elaborate collaborations in rock history.

Because throughout their entire history, there has hardly been a consistent lineup for any of the Queens of the Stone Age projects. Going through their rough around the edges debut up to the modern day, Josh tends to have a few friends that he loves jamming and normally ends up holding onto them for a little while before getting a different set of guys in the room with him. While most people are fond of the Songs for the Deaf lineup with Nick Oliveri and Dave Grohl, there's so much more to explore on later albums, from Julian Casablancas turning in time on Era Vulgaris to Mark Lanegan being the unsung hero of the band with how much his raspy tone mixes in with Josh's smoky voice.

For just a taste of what they can do, Like Clockwork is practically a sample of every kind of weird that Josh is able to pull out of his musicians, from bringing back familiar faces like Dave Grohl and Nick Oliveri to having strange additions like Elton John and Trent Reznor come in and bring their own flair to their respective tracks. Queens were never ones to just make the same album twice, and if you're going to make a new experience on every record you put out, you're going to need some more people to get it.


 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97