10 Genuine Reactions That Made Songs Better
Sometimes even artists can't help but get excited when they're recording.
The process of recording music has changed considerably over the years. Whereas, originally, all songs were recorded live in the studio, technological advancements have enabled artists to record each instrument, and vocals individually.
Yet, despite these advancements, the finished piece of music isn't always as polished as it initially sounds to our ears. Sometimes, if you listen carefully, you can hear little background noises that you probably missed first time round. These noises can be mishaps picked up by the mics, or someone reacting to what is happening in the studio.
Whatever the reason, they usually add to the finished recording rather than spoil it for our ears. It can be genuinely thrilling to hear someone react to the magic that is going on the studio - to know that the artists recording the songs are just as excited making music as you are listening to it. It can also be quite amusing to know that some of these reactions happened due to mistakes they made during recording.
No matter why they ended up on the record, once you hear them the first time, you wait for them every time afterwards.
10. Louie Louie - The Kingsmen
The history of this song will always be remembered for the FBI's 31 month investigation into the supposed obscenity and subversiveness of the nearly unintelligible lyrics. Unsurprisingly, the FBI were not able to find anything wrong in the songs words, no matter how hard they tried. Yet the one thing the FBI didn’t seem to pick up on was an "F" bomb in the recording.
The actual recording of song, itself, is filled with errors. Singer, Jack Ely's vocals are hard to understand due to the mics being positioned too high in the studio. At one point he comes in too soon after the lead guitar break, and the song, as a whole, was unintentionally recorded in the wrong time signature.
But, it is a mistake by the drummer, Lynn Easton, that first hits your ears. Around the 0.54 mark on the record, Easton can be heard yelling “f***”, in the background. He did this due to messing up a drum solo. It is a funny moment in a fun song, but it leaves you wondering what the FBI were looking for when investigating the song.
9. Rearviewmirror - Pearl Jam
From a drummer swearing to a drummer showing his frustration whilst recording. This particular incident occurred whilst Pearl Jam recorded the song Rearviewmirror for their second album, Vs.
Although Dave Abbruzzese had been on tour with the band for the previous year, this was his first time recording with the rest of the band. Admittedly, Abbruzzess was someone who didn’t exactly see eye to eye with the rest of his bandmates. Nevertheless, it was the album’s producer, Brendan O’Brien, who was the source of Abbruzzese’s irritation.
Abbruzzese felt as though too much pressure was being put on him by O’Brien whilst recording Rearviewmirror. As the recording of the song came to an end the drummer threw his drum sticks against the studio wall, which can clearly be heard at the end of the record as the guitars fade out.
Even after the recording Abbruzzese was still incensed. The story goes that he punched a hole through his snare drum, which he subsequently threw off the side of a cliff. He would be fired by the band a year later citing personality differences.
8. The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonite - REM
During the recording of their bestselling album Automatic For The People, REM knew that they needed a catchy, lighthearted song on the record. As most of the songs dealt with heavy subjects, such as mortality, suicide and the passage of time, it was seen as a wise move to break up the prevailing bleak mood. They decided to record The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonite.
On the 4th line of the 3rd verse you can hear Michael Stipe laughing as he mentions Dr. Seuss. His laughter is a response to his own inability to pronounce the children's author‘s name right. Although he had been a big fan since he was a child, Stipe had always had trouble saying the name properly. Even the continued efforts of bass player Mike Mills couldn’t help him with his error. No matter how hard Stipe tried, he kept pronouncing the name wrong.
Afterwards, the band decided to keep Stipe’s laughter in the final version. The result is a rather charming accident which fits in with the nonsensical nature of the song.
7. Been Caught Stealing - Jane's Addiction
At the beginning of Jane’ s Addiction’s 1990 hit Been Caught Stealing, the sound of a dog barking can be heard. The use of the dog’s bark was purely coincidence.
Lead singer Perry Farrell had recently got a dog, named Annie, from a shelter. As the dog was still rather needy, Farrell decided to bring her to recording sessions rather than leave her at home. As Perry went into the booth and started to sing, the dog started to get excited, jumping around and barking.
It was at this point that everyone in the studio thought it might be interesting to hear what the dog's barking on the record would sound like. Perry brought Annie into the studio and got her excited enough to bark again, whilst someone hit record. The result was, as Rolling Stone would put it, “the best use of dog barks since Pet Sounds.”
6. Here Today - The Beach Boys
Talking about Pet Sounds, the recording of The Beach Boys' classic album was a long and painstaking affair. The whole process took its toll on songwriter, and composer, Brian Wilson. In his quest for perfection he would constantly re-record the vocals and instruments. A little bit of Wilson's direction in the studio can be heard on this song.
On the original mono release numerous voices can be heard during the instrumental break. At first there is a conversation between two voices talking about cameras. Then Brian Wilson is heard saying “Top, please”. This order was him instructing an engineer to rewind the tape to the beginning, so the band could attempt another take on the vocals. None of this was meant to be on the final recording, but it gives a little insight into what the mood was like in the studio at the time.
For the stereo remix, released in 1996, Brian Wilson would have the voices erased from the track. Luckily, the original mono mix is still available, and listeners can compare whether the track sounds better with or without the background noise.
5. Armagideon Time - The Clash
When The Clash decided to record a version of Willie Williams’ song Armagideon Time, there was much talk in the studio about what the perfect length of a song should be. Their associate Kosmo Vinyl, was convinced the perfect time was two minutes and fifty eight seconds. The band agreed, and Joe Strummer asked Kosmo to stop the recording when they got to the allotted time.
As the recording progressed, it was clear to Kosmo, and everyone else in the studio, that The Clash were cutting a great version of the song. Two minutes and fifty eight seconds was soon approaching on the clock, and The Clash were in full swing. Not sure what to do, Kosmo decided to order the session to stop over the studio intercom. His command of “All right, time’s up! Let’s have you out of there!”, is clearly audible on the finished track.
In most cases, such an action would have ruined a take, yet it was Strummer’s reply that saved everything. Clearly knowing how good the recording was, Strummer shouted back “Ok, ok! Don’t push us when we’re hot!”, without breaking rhythm. The band kept playing for nearly another minute and a potential costly error turned out to be the highlight of the recording.
4. In My Time Of Dying - Led Zeppelin
Whilst recording their double album masterpiece Physical Graffiti, Led Zeppelin decided to lay down their own version of the traditional Blues song In My Time Of Dying. Using Bob Dylan’s cover of the same song as a guide, the band started to arrange, and structure the piece.
Led by John Bonham, all the various sections of the track were worked out, and they recorded it live in the studio. What followed was an absolute force of sound, highlighting the strengths of each band member’s skills as musicians.
After just over eleven minutes of music the song comes to an abrupt end. Yet, this was not the intended ending. The band were busy jamming away when, all of a sudden, Bonham stopped playing as he needed to cough. This caused the rest of the band to stop, at which point Bonham can heard saying “That’s got to be the one, hasn’t it?”, believing it was their best take. The rest of the band agreed and left it on the album to show fans that they were a band that took care in their recordings.
3. The Jean Genie - David Bowie
One of Bowie’s most famous songs, The Jean Genie was recorded as he toured the USA in 1972. Built around a Bo Diddley inspired guitar riff, the track stomps its way through the four minutes duration. It is a catchy and well-polished piece of glam rock.
There has been much debate about who the song is about. Bowie, at different times, alluded, that it was about Iggy Pop, the French literary figure Jean Genet, or the actress and model Cyrinda Foxe. What is very rarely talked about, though, is the very audible voice heard at the 0.37 mark. Just as the song enters the first chorus someone can be heard saying “Get back on it.”
The words are coming from Bowie himself. The song was recorded live and bass player, Trevor Bolder, went to the chorus too early. This prompted Bowie’s telling-off. When it came to mixing the song Bowie liked the mistake, and the remark, and decided to keep it in the final version.
2. I Want You (She's So Heavy) - The Beatles
There are a couple of interesting facts in relation to this Beatles song off the Abbey Road LP. Firstly, it is the last song The Beatles recorded in the studio together, and secondly, the track we hear on the album is actually two different takes mixed together.
Despite the technical skills required in piecing two different takes together, some background noise from the sessions was left on the final recording. There are numerous songs in The Beatles catalog with unintended voices and echoes on them, yet somehow the reaction heard in I Want You (She's So Heavy) seems to fit the song perfectly.
After John’s scream, around 4.30 mark, there is an audible yell in the background. Different theories have arisen as to why this happened, from a sound engineer protesting that Lennon’s screech was too loud, to Ringo saying “What was that about?” The most likely source of the sound, however, is probably someone in the studio – maybe Paul - yelling their approval. Whoever it was, it goes to show that despite their strained relationship at the time, The Beatles were still capable of producing bits of magic in the studio.
1. Gimme Shelter - The Rolling Stones
Written for their Let It Bleed album, Gimme Shelter is probably one of The Rolling Stones greatest songs. Yet, what we hear today could have been very different had it not been for a last minute decision by producer Jimmy Miller.
Even though the track was ready to be mixed, Miller felt as though the song needed a female vocal. Phone calls were made and fellow producer Jack Nitzsche managed to contact singer Merry Clayton. It was the early hours of the morning when she arrived at the studio. Still in her pajamas, and with her hair in curlers, the heavily pregnant Clayton proceeded to sing the lines "Rape, murder, it's just a shot away."
It's her singing of the word "murder", around the 3.00 mark that is really magic. As her voice cracks, someone can be heard responding with a "whoo", in the background. That reaction was from Mick Jagger, expressing how impressed he was with Clayton's singing.
It only took Clayton a few takes to lay down her legendary vocals, and soon after she went back home to bed. It seems unbelievable now, but if she hadn't answered the call, then one of the best happy accidents ever recorded would never have happened.