10 Hilariously Terrible Album Covers And Why They Exist

What on earth were they thinking?

JIM COOPER/AP
JIM COOPER/AP
When it comes to music, album covers are important. They're an opportunity to sell the music visually when there's no opportunity to hear it, and the greatest album covers are the ones that stand out in a sea of other pieces of artwork. Sure, the best album covers are striking and do just that, but it's also possible for covers to be so terrible that they somehow fulfil the same purpose. Though most people laugh at awful album artwork, they rarely actually stop to question it, examining the reason why somebody decided it would be a good idea and what the intention actually was. This list, however, attempts to do just that, taking a look at some of the most bafflingly terrible (and hilarious) album covers and exploring why they exist. With all that said, when people compile terrible album covers they tend to pull from a pool of obscure Christian artists and nobody folk musicians from decades ago. This list attempts to avoid that, mostly using terrible album covers from well-known artists and figures of musical significance (in other words, musicians you've probably heard of).

8. Black Sabbath €“ Born Again

Vertigo Records
The cover for Black Sabbath's eleventh studio album Born Again is so terrible that musician Ian Gillan claims to have vomited when he first saw it. it depicts a baby with bright red skin and crudely edited fangs and claws. The band's drummer Bill Ward claims to have personally detested the cover, despite the fact that Sabbath's lead guitarist Tony Iommi approved it. Unfortunately for Iommi, time has not been kind to the cover of Born Again, and it's routinely regarded as one of the worst album covers in music history. While the intent was clearly for the image to be unsettling and slightly disturbing, the whole thing just looks hilariously cheesy. The cover was produced by Steve €œKrusher€ Joule, and was based on a photocopy of a baby from a 1968 magazine. Amazingly, Joule claims the idea for the cover was actually supposed to be a joke. Joule submitted the design expecting to receive nothing but a small rejection fee for it. The reason Joule wanted a rejection was because at the time he had a close relationship with Ozzy and Sharon Osbourne, and Ozzy had just been kicked from the band. Much to his amazement, however, the cover received Tony Iommi's approval and Joule was offered "a ridiculous amount of money" to finish the design.

7. Muse €“ Drones

Warner Bros
Warner Bros
When it comes to album covers, sometimes less is more. This was made incredibly obvious by rock band Muse on their 2015 album Drones. Over the years Muse have been becoming more and more overtly political, the band's lyrics being criticized for their clunkiness and simplification. Nevertheless the band clearly still knows how to write a rocking tune, but it's a pity they don't understand subtle art design. The cover of Drones depicts a large hand grasping a red lever emerging from the body of someone sitting in a chair. The figure in the chair is grasping their own red lever, and appears to be controlling a bunch of marching figures on a screen. The whole thing is extremely in-your-face to the point of being pretty cringe-worthy, and that's not to mention the laughably phallic nature of the giant hand grasping the stiff lever. The reason for the album's overt artwork is pretty simple. As mentioned, the band have been moving into a much louder political position over the years. They asked artist Matt Mahurin to explore "the abuses that come with control" in conjunction with the word Drones, in the hope of exploring "responsibility and purpose". The band wanted a striking political statement to be immediately apparent, it's just a shame they tried to beat fans over the head with it.

6. Manowar €“ Anthology

Magic Circle
Manowar is an American heavy metal band from Auburn, New York. The band formed in 1980, and mainly write music that deals with fantastical and mythological themes. Over the years the band has been praised for continuing to write the kind of metal that was popular in the eighties, refusing to drop their references to swords, magic and Norse mythology. Unfortunately for Manowar, this interest in mythology is the reason their compilation album Anthology (released in 1997) features one of the most laughed at and scorned album covers ever released. The cover depicts the members of the band heavily-muscled and scantily clad staring fiercely at the camera. Their eighties hair coupled with what appear to be leather chaps, cowboy boots and a large furry glove render the whole thing absolutely hysterical, the pretentious seriousness of it all only making the whole thing more laughable. According to the band they hoped to portray their music's subject matter with a certain grace and reverence, as metal had (in general) largely moved on from its close relationship with fantasy. The aim was to inspire metal fans to return to these fantastical roots. They also felt the cover summed up what most of the music on the album was really about, and what the band represented in general (homo-erotic undertones?). While that's certainly true, it may have been better if the guys had just slapped a dragon on the front and been done with it.

5. Iron Maiden €“ Dance Of Death

EMI
EMI
The words "Iron Maiden" when used alongside "album artwork" tend to conjure images of epic, colourful drawings and inventive depictions of Eddie the Head, the band's incredibly expressive mascot. Yet look hard and enough you'll find a few major duds, the worst of which is the cover for Dance Of Death, the band's thirteenth studio album released in 2003. It's understandable that the band might have wanted to shake things up around the turn of the century, given the increasing use of computer graphics and the relative cheapness with which they could be produced. Seeing a hellish Iron Maiden cover depicted in glorious computer graphics is conceptually very interesting, it's just a pity that the execution was so laughably poor. Turns out there's a reason for it, however. The band asked artist David Patchett to provide the cover art, providing a few general pointers (at the end of the day, it's pretty obvious what kind of thing Iron Maiden likes visually). Unfortunately for Patchett, the band randomly decided mid-way through the artist's drafting process to use a completely unfinished version of the artwork, which was still in need of substantial work. Patchett was so mortified by this decision that he actually requested his name by removed from the album's credits so as not to be tied to such shoddy work, and he was correct to do so: the artwork was received extremely negatively by fans and critics alike.

4. Ted Nugent €“ Scream Dream

Epic
Epic
Released in 1980 as the sixth studio album by American hard rock guitarist Ted Nugent, Scream Dream is a relatively short album that nevertheless was received quite warmly by critics upon release, and sold decently well. Sadly, this positive response did nothing to stop people laughing at the album cover, which was intended to be a visual representation of the title. Snapped by photographer Lynn Goldsmith, the cover depicts Nugent... well, screaming. As for the dream part of the equation, Nugents arms appear to be merging into guitar fret boards, with the bodies of the guitars clearly visible at the bottom of the picture. Perhaps the whole thing wouldn't be so hilarious if Nugent wasn't wearing nothing but a glorified loin cloth, but fortunately for people who like to laugh at silly things, he is. Interestingly, the cover does have a well-intended meaning for its bizarreness. At the time of the album's release, Nugent's career was beginning to falter. His label Epic Records was beginning to doubt Nugent's merits as a signed artist and his sales were slipping, with his previous record State Of Shock netting the worst sales of his career. Since it was Nugent's hard rocking and guitar-based prowess that sold, and since that's what his marketing largely hinged on, the label believed a guitar-centric cover would help boost Nugent's sales. Rather than depict Nugent playing his instrument traditionally, they wanted to give the impression he was reinventing himself, too. Unfortunately for Epic Records, most people just thought the cover was... well, weird.


3. Lady Gaga €“ Born This Way

Interscope
Interscope
Despite constant criticism for her attempts to be €œshocking€ and the regular criticism that comes with pop music and popular music in general, Lady Gaga is a talented musician who is often more savvy than people give her credit for. Nevertheless not everything that Gaga does lands, and often when she fails the result can be hilariously cringe-worthy for everybody. Never has this been more obvious than on the cover of her 2011 album Born This Way. At the time of its reveal, the album was arguably the most anticipated release of the year, as Gaga's first album had spun her massively into the limelight and created a huge amount of hype. In the end what fans were given was a depiction of Gaga fusing into a motorcycle, alongside a typeface so ugly that it looks like a default inclusion of Microsoft Word's Word Art feature. So what was the intention? According to Gaga herself:
"The vision is of me in an endless journey. I am a vehicle. I am a vehicle for all of the ideas. And I'm not riding away or towards anything, I'm just in endless state of creativity."
It's a nice idea, but the execution leaves a whole lot to be desired.


2. Village People €“ Renaissance

RCA Records
RCA Records
Wait a minute, the Village People released more songs than just YMCA and In The Navy? Shockingly, yes. Over the course of their career the band released a total of nine studio albums, five of which were certified platinum in at least one territory. Over the course of their career the band sold more than one-hundred million records worldwide, which is pretty impressive for a band that largely relied on the gimmick of being extremely camp. Which brings us to their seventh studio album Renaissance, released in 1981, and the glorious piece of artwork that adorns its front. The cover shows the various members of the band decked out in leather and caked in thick make-up, their fringes straightened and flattened against their foreheads in anticipation of a million emo haircuts several decades later. The whole thing looks totally awkward, and has about as much stylistic consistency as a spilled tin of paint. Covers in the eighties could be cheesy, but the artwork for Renaissance is just hilarious bad. You've got to wonder what exactly was the band thinking? Well, the truth isn't particularly complicated. After releasing six albums of disco music, the band were desperate to reinvent themselves. The only problem was that the Village People were known for each having signature costumes, and so they attempted to create new costumes and personas more in line with the New Wave genre. The result of this was the cover of Renaissance, which was meant as an introduction to the band's new aesthetic but really only scared people away from the record, which was described by critic Stephen Erlewine as "simply an embarrassment that never should have seen the light of day".

1. Queen €“ The Miracle

Parlophone
Parlophone
Fear not, that isn't some monstrous alien creature, it's just the album cover of Queen's thirteenth studio album The Miracle, home to classic songs like Breakthru, The Invisible Man and I Want It All. Recording the album is said to have lasted for a whole year, beginning shortly after Freddie Mercury was diagnosed with AIDS and while Brian May was going through substantial marital issues. The cover art depicts the faces of all four members merging into each other using a then state of the art piece of image-manipulation software known as Quantel Paintbox. What may have been striking then today looks like a fairly crude piece of photo-shopping, and renders each individual member looking like some sort of goofy alien firmly situated in the uncanny valley. The cover's origin, however, is rather interesting. According to Derek Riggs €“ the man responsible for illustrating many Iron Maiden album covers €“ the band actually stole the idea for the cover from his artwork for the single The Clairvoyant. While this may sound unlikely, Riggs specifically cites Freddie Mercury as the one who took the idea, who Riggs claimed was a "headbanger" and a huge fan of metal. Riggs claimed Mercury had purchased the single, which was released the year before, and decided to depict the exact same visual image.

In this post: 
Iron Maiden
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Commonly found reading, sitting firmly in a seat at the cinema (bottle of water and a Freddo bar, please) or listening to the Mountain Goats.