10 Most Underrated Beatles Songs
The Lost Fabs.
Making a list regarding the overlooked gems in the Beatles' catalog almost feels silly to even try.
I mean, you have to remember that this is a band who has been studied time and time again to the point of parody. Even with the thousands of remixes and the Disney+ movie coming down the pipeline, there are still a handful of Fab Four cuts that never seem to get the time of day.
Outside of the neverending stream of #1 hits that they had back in the day, some of the best tracks that the group put out were always the album cuts, which came as a little surprise every time you put the record on.
And let's not forget B-sides, since most of the songs on the flip side of every single could have been enough to give any other British Invasion act a whole new career. Then again, it's not like these tracks have gone anywhere.
Along with the new versions of Abbey Road and Let It Be that have come and gone, these are the songs that deserve a little more evaluation for being among the group's best work.
From the Lennon/McCartney gems to the George Harrison songs that you forgot about, these are the real reasons why we'll never see a group this perfect again.
10. Martha My Dear - The White Album
As brilliant as the White Album is, it's a little difficult to get through the entire thing in one sitting. When you really think about it, here is an album that is longer than some feature films, and some of it has stuff like Revolution 9 which is...let's say divisive and leave it at that. Venturing into the deep cuts though, you do get a bunch of diamonds in the rough on here.
Case and point: Martha My Dear. Up until this point in the Fabs' career, we had gotten used to Paul McCartney's balladeer tendencies, and yet this one feels specifically different. Being an ode to his sheepdog that he acquired around this time, the structure of this song is the same as something like Happiness is a Warm Gun. For most Beatles fans, there's no real chorus of this song, instead going through different movements that makes the whole thing feel akin to classical music.
Apparently this kind of style was outside of Paul's usual tendencies as well, with him saying later that the piano lick was outside of his skill range and he decided to write the song to challenge himself as a composer. Considering how far they'd come as musicians, it's interesting to see one of the greatest songwriters on Earth make a song that makes them want to improve.
9. I'll Follow the Sun - Beatles For Sale
If you look back on the really good stuff from the Beatles, things don't start getting legendary until the mid '60s, where they start to experiment and use the studio as an instrument. For the first few years of their existence though, they were one of the most prolific stars in the world, churning out one pop classic after another. Things ended up going by so fast that most people didn't realize the folky jewel right in front of them.
Then again, Beatles for Sale has a name that was pretty much meant to get lost in the shuffle, considering most of the band was getting worn out and tired from Beatlemania 24/7. Though this was the one album that reverted back to cover songs, Paul's I'll Follow the Sun was the true standout, even getting a mention by producer George Martin as one of his personal favorites.
What makes the whole thing work though is because it's so simple, being one of the first melodies that Paul McCartney had ever written and deciding to polish it off when it came time to look for new material. It also speaks to how far Lennon and McCartney were already starting to grow as people.
While John may have been looking for a new way to express himself, Paul was content to follow the way the wind blows and go wherever life would take him.
8. Think For Yourself - Rubber Soul
George Harrison's songs during the Beatles' tenure have always been a little surprise whenever they turn up. Although it would be fine to just pad out an album with exclusively Lennon/McCartney material, Harrison's contributions were always a little more genuine than the straightforward love songs you were used to. Once Rubber Soul broke down the doors of what could be done, George decided to get salty on Think For Yourself.
Then again, it's not really George that's doing most of the heavy lifting on this song. Is there something about the guitar that seems a little bit off to you? Well, that's because most of the lead on this song is not actually a guitar, but Paul's bass with a ton of fuzz on it. This gives the whole song a much nastier bite, which really is needed when you look at the lyrics.
Instead of the typical doe-eyed love songs, George holds nothing back in letting his lady love know what he thinks of her, telling her that she has to think for herself in the future because he's kicking her to the curb.
There are also a few times when you'll have to break out the old thesaurus for something, being one of the few pop songs that has words like 'opaque' and 'rectify' in it. You listen to the song for the groove, and then you walk away with an English lesson.
7. Fixing a Hole - Sgt. Peppers
It's become a cliche at this point to call Sgt. Peppers a perfect album.
Even though the Beatles did have lightning in a bottle here, the timing of this album's release was equally as perfect, kicking off the Summer of Love and branching out into different ideas that no one else could have imagined before.
In between the Eastern mysticism and hard rock edge though, there was a lot more throwbacks on here than you remember.
As we get past the classic rock gems like Getting Better, Fixing a Hole is one of the weirdest songs on the album, with Paul McCartney talking about home repair. While it's easy to substitute the fixing a hole metaphor with expanding your mind through drugs, the real draw of the song is the chords, which are more suited to jazz than to rock and roll.
Though you'd hear stuff like this on an old jazz record from the '20s, the feel is decidedly rock, with the vocal and drums swinging and strutting their way through the song.
If anything, this ended up being a precursor for the 'granny' style songs that Paul would start to write a few years down the line like Your Mother Should Know, only with a more sophisticated tone this time around. Considering every song on Pepper changed the game, this is the kind of song that walked so a band like Steely Dan could run.
6. The Fool On the Hill - Magical Mystery Tour
As the Summer of Love started to get into full swing, the Beatles were turning to all different places for inspiration. That meant more exotic musical tastes, different mind expanding drugs, and also more complex topics about the inner self. Even though a lot of fans were turned off by the more mystical element of the Beatles' music, Paul McCartney decided to confront the issue directly on Magical Mystery Tour.
After going to different meetings with the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, Paul wrote this song to suggest that not every wise guru is as silly as they come across in interviews. Outside of the madcap movie that came with this album, The Fool on the Hill is a lot more delicate and serious, as Paul sings about the man of a thousand voices with no one to actually hear what he is saying.
Considering this was written by the man who was always the fun Beatle, the chorus of this song also takes a pretty dark turn, as the titular fool sees the sun setting on his life and the world spinning around him. Though we do get a few whimsical elements like a recorder solo, it's anyone's guess as to whether this guy will ever actually connect with people. For all we know, he may still be sitting on that hill waiting for someone to listen.
5. I've Just Seen a Face - Help!
Of all the genres that the Beatles pulled from, country music was never really the standout in their repertoire. Even though they covered people like Buck Owens back in the day, there's nothing from the band's early catalog that brings to mind people like George Jones or Johnny Cash in the minds of fans. And yet when they decided to put that country bounce into things, it turned into one of the most infectious songs of their mid period.
Though most of the actual Help! movie is a little bit strange, the back half of the record gave us I've Just Seen a Face, with every member on acoustic guitars behind Ringo's drums. When writing the song, Paul had always liked the rapid fire vocal delivery of the track, having it always pull you to the next line with every verse, which is very true if you ever try to sing along with it.
This is also one of the few times where the American/British album differences actually helped a song get more exposure. Even with the more expanding sounds on Rubber Soul, this actually replaced Drive My Car as the first track on the album in the States, which gave the whole album a bit more of a folksy feel. So if you need some Beatles material around a campfire and don't want to use Hey Jude for the 900th time, this will be a definite change of pace.
4. Two Of Us - Let It Be
Considering the disastrous sessions for the White Album, the idea of the band getting back to their roots at least seemed like a good idea on paper. Though most of them ended up disagreeing and started to work outside of the Beatles' mold, the album Let It Be at least gave us some gems to salvage after Abbey Road. From the opening track alone, it felt like this back to basics approach could have actually worked.
Out of all the songs on Let It Be, Two of Us feels the most homemade, with Paul just playing acoustic guitar alongside John like they used to do in the early days. Despite the song allegedly being written about Paul's relationship with Linda, it's easy to think of John and Paul when they sing about two people riding nowhere and going back to where they started.
Combined with the Everly Brothers style harmonies that come in on the chorus, this gives us a glimpse back to the lovable lads from Liverpool who were just trying to make it as rock and rollers before Beatlemania had really set in. At this point, we know that most of Let It Be wasn't able to be salvaged into a complete album. If more songs were able to sound like this though, we may have gotten a more coherent record to close off their career.
3. Hey Bulldog - Yellow Submarine
By the time they reached the mid '60s, the Beatles were never going to go into the studio and create a song for the hell of it. These were some seasoned musicians who were going to push the boundaries of what they could do to create the best songs they knew how. When they did resort to some good natured fun though, they still made it sound amazing on Hey Bulldog.
The most surprising thing about this song is that it's not technically supposed to exist. When the Fabs went into the studio that day, they were originally supposed to mime along to their new single Lady Madonna, only to work on their new song instead. Needing some more material for the Yellow Submarine soundtrack, there's a lot more bite to this song that most of the other Fab tracks, with George wailing with a new distortion box and one of the most badass piano licks in the Beatles canon.
Granted, it's not like the words necessarily mean anything. As John Lennon would tell you, the record was not meant to be taken seriously, with most of the lyrics being either incoherent from one line to the next or just filler words in between barking sounds. Of all the Beatles deep cuts though, there's no other that really captures a hard rock vibe quite like this one.
2. Yes It Is - Past Masters
This may sound apocryphal, but the majority of the Beatles' output in the early years was meant to be disposable. Don't blame your humble author for that statement though...John Lennon himself had talked about having written songs for the 'meat market' in the early days before deciding to write about himself around 1965. Then again, you can feel some of that darkness creeping in if you just flipped over the vinyl.
Being one of the deep cuts from the Help! era of the band, Yes It Is is one of the more disheartening songs in the Beatles' catalog. The character in this song does still have hold of a lady friend, but his feelings are more tangled up with the love he knew before. It gets to the point where he wants her to stop wearing red because it reminds him too much of the love he left behind.
Combined with the pedal steel guitar and the aching harmonies, you can practically feel the sorrow in your headphones, with this guy not being able to put his pride away and choosing to wallow in his sadness about the one that got away. This may have been a bit of an oddball back in the day, but if it were released a few years down the line, this would have been a great addition to the goth pop set.
1. And Your Bird Can Sing - Revolver
Throughout most of this list, we've paid a lot of lip service to Sir Paul McCartney. It's no big surprise either, with him being one of the masters of melody compared to the raw rock and roll that came from John Lennon most of the time. When it came time to cut tracks for the Revolver album, Lennon actually made a track that managed to beat his songwriting partner at his own game.
Years later, Lennon admitted that And Your Bird Can Sing was a song that was meant to copy the happy go lucky formula that McCartney's songs had, and it pays off in spades. In just over two minutes, Lennon wrote an absolutely perfect pop song, with a lyric about his love needing more than just material things when the world starts to bring her down. Though the entire song is carried by John's vocal, having the last verse be sung entirely in harmony by all three band members makes the song come alive again.
And for any of the guitar enthusiasts, this is one of the most energetic riffs of this era of the band, being a mix of the psychedelic distorted rock and a nod to the chiming sounds of bands like the Byrds. Even though this is the same album that has songs like Eleanor Rigby and For No One on it, the Beatles could still rock out with the best of them when they wanted to.