10 Most Underrated Fall Out Boy Songs
I'm just a notch in your bedpost, but you're just an entry on a list.
Like lengthy fringes and parental disappointment, Fall Out Boy are always considered a phase that we all travel through on our way to a decent music taste.
An essential step on the journey to fandom of artists like The Strokes, The Killers, Foo Fighters and Thirty Seconds to Mars, Fall Out Boy were, at one point, the favourite band of every 15-year-old across the land. But, as we advance in our music preferences, we often forget the quality of what came before.
Fall Out Boy were a seminal band for the pop-punk movement of the mid-2000's, and their popularity was born, first and foremost, of great albums and a top tier list of sing-a-long songs.
Dance Dance and Thnks Fr Th Mmrs are still in your playlist today, and while we can all rock-out to the classics, we often forget about the remainder of great tunes that come from the Chicago-based band.
A great album is comprised of more than just a few good songs, and Fall Out Boy have racked up a mountain of critical acclaim over the years. Why, then, are so many of their offerings overlooked?
10. Young Volcanoes
Fans rejoiced in early 2013 when the band they once loved were returning with an all-new album mere months later.
Produced by music legend Butch Walker, Save Rock and Roll saw Fall Out Boy lean further into pop than ever before, ditching the fringe and nail polish in the process of creating an album that stands the test of time, despite what some disgruntled fans might think.
For as good as the offering is, it takes the majority of the release to arrive at the best track of all, with Young Volcanoes being amongst the final few songs on the album. Released as the fourth and final single, Young Volcanoes is simply delightful, as a surprisingly uplifting acoustic riff replaces any whinging electric guitars throughout.
Lyrically, it isn't poignant or thought provoking, but does well to evoke a sense of youthfulness that no other Fall Out Boy song really replicates. It feels innocent, lively and communal, as the chorus is always accompanied by backing vocals that give the tune much needed complexity.
Young Volcanoes failed to break the UK Top 40, only scratching the low 60's on the official charts. It's perhaps expected considering the goliath pop artists who commandeered the music industry at the time, but disappointing nonetheless.
9. Disloyal Order Of Water Buffaloes
By most people's taste, the extensive, pre-hiatus Fall Out Boy catalogue concluded with a whimper as the follow-up to the sublime Infinity On High was largely forgotten about by fans.
Critically, Folie A Deux was in-keeping with the band's previous work, but it didn't offer anything amazing. Singles were inconsistent, as the catchy-yet-annoying I Don't Care pales in comparison to the beautiful What A Catch, Donnie. The one that stands above them all, however, is the opening track: Disloyal Order of Water Buffaloes.
The song was written towards the end of the album's production, and it continued the magic just a moment longer, as the lyrical quirks that the band are known for are on full display. 'I'm a loose bolt of a complete machine' or 'detox just to retox' were surely lines that etched across every late-2000's teen's Facebook profile.
Stump's offering to the tune is razor sharp, displaying his effortless vocal range, the hook is anthemic and the chorus packs a punch every time it arrives. If Disloyal Order of Water Buffaloes was featured on any other Fall Out Boy album, it wouldn't be as forgotten as it regrettably is.
8. Tiffany Blews
Yet another underrated gem from Folie a Deux, Tiffany Blews has all the makings of a top-tier Fall Out Boy single, but the band decided tunes like America's Suitehearts and the uncommonly-known Headfirst Slide into Cooperstown on a Bad Bet would be preferable to audiences.
An unexpected Lil Wayne feature doesn't have the song stray from the Fall Out Boy sound, in fact it enhances it. Tiffany Blews' somewhat docile bridge is underpinned by a verse that's sung(!) by the Louisiana-born rapper that gives the segment of the song the depth that it needs to carry into the remainder of the tune.
Features with hip-hop artists aren't a rare occurrence for the Chicago native band - especially after the years-long hiatus - but the early sighting of a rap royal was new for audiences in 2009.
Features aside, Tiffany Blews features catchy (if uninspired) opening vocal notes that appear throughout, as well as a progressive guitar riff that flows into a memorable chorus. It's a formula that's familiar to fans, but the inclusion of another artist in the mix really rounds the tune out, and makes it worth returning to.
Like a little black dress, Tiffany Blews should be a classic.
7. Homesick At Space Camp
As nostalgic as it makes many of us feel, 2003's Take This To Your Grave was a debut filled with growing pains.
Fall Out Boy were a mere two years into what would become a long, successful music career, and before their tenure as one of pop-punk's elite offerings truly kicked into high gear with From Under The Cork Tree, the four-piece had to carve out a niche within the genre.
A significant bright spark of the release sat directly after the first three singles, as track 5 goes largely unnoticed after following the superb Dead On Arrival, Grand Theft Autumn and Saturday.
With lyrics that are at home on any 2000's teen's MSN profile, Homesick at Space Camp dives into themes of loneliness and begrudgingly leaving those you love. It's a tune that was surely inspired by leaving home to go on tour, and as such it effortlessly captures the band's naivety of just how unfamiliar their surroundings would become.
Fundamentally, Homesick at Space Camp is a song about change, and captures a band in transition. It feels like a true starting point for the band that would - at one point or another - become your favourite.
6. Uma Thurman
Twangy, surf-inspired guitar flourishes (that are an unapologetic sampling of the theme song from '60s sitcom The Munsters), a clap-happy backing track for the verses and an all-too-familiar standout vocal performance from Stump makes Uma Thurman a thoroughly entertaining three-and-a-half minutes.
Featured on the somewhat overlooked American Beauty/American Psycho, the song, predictably, is inspired by the Pulp Fiction actress. After the band graciously asked her for permission, Fall Out Boy began work on a tune that is a true highlight of their post-hiatus works.
Frivolous use of its catchy chorus makes Uma Thurman feel somewhat limited lyrically, but the integration of a quirky-yet-effective backing track and polished production value all combine to conjure a Frankenstein's monster of musical styles that never feels too crowded. Uma Thurman is a song that uses its distinct lack of identity as a drawing factor, and as such it feels like a truly unique component of their catalogue.
Like the Hanzo sword in Oren Ishii at the end of Kill Bill Vol 1, Uma Thurman by Fall Out Boy will undeniably be stuck in your head.
5. 27
Breaking the mould of lengthy song titles, the aforementioned 27 seems to be a reference to the club, which includes members such as Janis Joplin, Amy Winehouse and Kurt Cobain, each tragically passing before their 28th birthday.
The song itself doesn't get much more cheerful, as the introspective lyrics leave much to be desired in the jolly department. It explores the potentially destructive lifestyle of modern music artists, and rarely shy's away from the dangerously seductive nature of rock and roll. 27 undoubtedly highlights some of the mental and physical pitfalls that the band has to navigate.
Immediately kicking off with a clap-a-long drum beat and tinny guitar riff, the arrangements match the abrasive lyrics perfectly. As the song develops into its pre-chorus, similarities are forged between it and Chris Cornell's Bond offering You Know My Name. The likeness is far from forgery, as the tune is never stripped of that magic, Fall Out Boy feeling.
Around the 2-minute mark, an uncommon guitar solo emerges, showcasing the talents of long-time lead guitarist Joe Trohman. It balances the song beautifully, serving as a natural bridge to the tune's final chorus.
27 isn't really indicative of the Fall Out Boy of old, and that makes it special.
4. Just One Yesterday
If there's an album in the ever-expanding Fall Out Boy catalogue that deserves the award of 'underrated', it's Save Rock and Roll.
The first offering since returning from a four-year long Hiatus, Save Rock and Roll is packed with 11 songs that could each occupy a slot in this list. From The festival-perfect lead single My Songs Know What You Did In The Dark (still not letting go of lengthy titles, apparently) to the weirdly melancholic titular song that features music royalty Elton John, the album is simply sublime.
A standout song, even for this release, is Just One Yesterday.
The lyrical wordplay is cryptic, and will take at least a masters degree in pretentiousness to decipher, but it all feeds into the song's overall tone. Depicting a flawed relationship, Fall Out Boy flirt with a real world theme, and do well to match the dire story with a musical atmosphere that does the story justice.
The inclusion of British artist Foxes is minimal, but effective, making the song feel far more like a dialogue than a mansplainy mess that it could very easily have become.
Just One Yesterday is perhaps the albums most grounded song, and it's one that you can't help but return to.
3. Thriller
"Long live the car crash hearts."
Leaning into heavy guitar riffs that are quickly overtaken by Stump's impressive range, Thriller mimics heavier contemporaries like A Day To Remember, but as soon as the vocals emerge, the tune settles into its stature as a top tier Fall Out Boy song.
Ambitious title aside, Thriller feels like a sharper, more refined Fall Out Boy to the one we had become accustomed to with 2005's From Under The Cork Tree. Being the opening track on their new project Infinity On High, it was crucial that the song made a good first impression, as the expectations this time around were lofty thanks to the success of previous works.
Thriller flows beautifully, fusing fuzzy guitars with a somewhat simplistic but always enjoyable melody that reaffirms Fall Out Boy's mastering of their pop-punk craft. The Infinity On High album gets more experimental (and longer in song titles) as it goes on, but the decision to open with something safe was an excellent one.
Thriller kickstarts Fall Out Boy's golden age in style, firmly solidifying them as "poster boys for their scene".
2. Yule Shoot Your Eye Out
As the festive season gains traction once again, we're reminded of peace and good will to all men. The true meaning of Christmas is known to us all, yet the memo perhaps got lost on its way to Fall Out Boy, as the little-known Yule Shoot Your Eye Out is far from jolly.
A bonus track on the 2009 greatest hits compilation, Yule Shoot Your Eye Out is a less-than-gracious depiction of heartbreak over the holidays. It's scathing in all the right ways, and anyone who isn't the subject of the song will find it a thoroughly entertaining component of the family Christmas playlist.
The song emphasises bass guitarist Pete Wentz' reluctance to join in the festivities, and tackling the issue in such a hot-headed way makes for a song that is radically different from its Christmas contemporaries, which is something that Mariah Carey can't even achieve.
Predictable flourishes like jingling bells in the opening only serve to decorate the already amusing tune, and cement it not only as a thoroughly underrated Fall Out Boy song, but also as one that deserves far more love among Christmas music enthusiasts.
1. Sunshine Riptide
The only song with a credited feature on 2018's M A N I A, Sunshine Riptide feels like a song steeped in hip-hop influence.
An era of Fall Out Boy that isolates the pre-hiatus fringe-flickers, M A N I A is a project that relentlessly replaces any shred of punk influence of previous works with all-out pop, and while many write it off as a failure, others embraced the change.
Tunes like The Mighty Fall (ft. Big Sean) and the aforementioned Tiffany Blews (with a subtle, yet significant Lil Wayne inclusion) have indicated that the band are willing to experiment with rap music, and an anthemic, synthy, sunlight-bathed song like Sunshine Riptide was the perfect opportunity to forge something new.
Passed over as a single from its respective album (an album in which no single reached the billboard top 100) in favour of the underwhelming The Last Of The Real Ones and the janky Champion, Sunshine Riptide is a season-specfic song that's at home in the summertime. Unfortunately for it, the album released in January, when most of us are in the thick of our annual Christmas hangover.
It's a shame, as Sunshine Riptide deserves to be a summer staple for anyone who values Fall Out Boy's work.