10 Musical Shifts That Fell Flat On Their Face

The disastrous left-turns.

Metallica St Anger
Elektra

It's always admirable seeing an artist reach outside of their comfort zone. Though their rabid fans might only know them for playing a certain type of music, these guys go against the grain and try to prove that they are equally comfortable molding them into a new sound.

While it can be very rewarding in some cases, doing a new style poorly can be just as dangerous.

Whereas a lot of bands put time and effort into learning these new styles of music before playing, this lot dove head first into a new style and came up empty. Instead of having songs that went in bold new directions, these tracks came off lifeless, cynical, and just meaningless for the band's hardcore fanbase.

Oftentimes, the failure can just be an experiment gone wrong, but at the worst of times, this could be a cheap way to get fans excited about your next subject instead of...y'know...writing good material. All of these artists may have built up a humongous amount of fans over the years, but these are the abrupt shifts that even the diehards couldn't defend.

The musicians might be here in name, but this is not the music you are looking for.

10. Slang - Def Leppard

Def Leppard have been known for making records that sound absolutely perfect.

Even if the actual composition wasn’t all that great, the way they constructed their tracks into pop epics on Pyromania and Hysteria set them apart from the other run of the mill hair bands. However, that kind of style wasn’t necessarily going to hold up in the era of flannel and grunge.

Instead of going back to the drawing board, Slang came out in 1995 and sounded like a pale imitation of the alternative sound. While it’s always good to recharge your batteries, this felt like the band were ditching everything that made them great to begin with in the hopes that they would transition into the next Alice in Chains.

Even in retrospect, guitarist Vivian Campbell questioned why the band were spending a fortune on all of the organic approaches knowing that no one was going to buy the record. You can imagine that the layers of sound over the years had taken its toll on the band, but Slang is the one album that went too far the other way with songs that feel like they should be B-sides at best.

The ‘80s sheen of the band’s glory years probably wouldn’t have worked out in the early ‘90s, but it would have been a lot better than what we actually got.


9. Just Push Play - Aerosmith

Aerosmith’s history has been a series of ups and downs throughout the years. While the band have some of the greatest rock records of all time to their name, they also have a handful of records that don’t deserve to be anywhere near the heavy hitters. Though it’s understandable for a band to have a few clunkers, it’s strange how we didn’t see the sheen of Just Push Play coming.

Ever since Aerosmith had gotten a second wind in the mid ‘80s, they spent the rest of their tenure chasing the more pop rock sound. Even if it wasn’t as dangerous as something like Toys in the Attic, it still held up as decent pop music, but Just Push Play is where the band left their rock roots behind.

As soon as you heard the first single “Jaded,” fans knew that something was terribly wrong, with a guitar riff that could fit on a backing track from any other pop star at the time.

That’s not where it ends though, with most of the record being a final wake for the Bad Boys from Boston who were consumed by the pop monster. Some of these work as decent pop tracks, but the sonic polish is so bright that you don’t even recognize the band anymore.


8. Two Virgins - John Lennon

Yoko Ono tends to get a bad reputation as being the woman who broke up the Beatles. Just when the Fab Four started making some of the greatest pop music ever made, they started to splinter off into different directions, with John Lennon’s relationship with Ono being pegged as the reason behind their downfall.

Though the Beatles’ breakup was inevitable, no one could have been prepared for what Lennon had up his sleeve as a solo artist.

After his relationship with Ono started, he began to make avant garde works with her, with the first one being named Two Virgins. With years of songwriting brilliance under his belt, this is Lennon putting half-baked ideas onto a full release, complete with background noise and screaming. To cap it all off, Lennon chose probably the most uncommercial album cover in history by posing nude with Yoko.

Lennon was always known to be the eccentric Beatle, but one listen to this album makes you question whether this was the same guy who wrote stuff like “Strawberry Fields Forever.” John may have found his soulmate, but the first creative steps he took afterwards left many die hard Fabs fans concerned for his well being.


7. Liz Phair - Liz Phair

Liz Phair does not get celebrated nearly enough credit as one of the greatest female voices of the ‘90s.

For as much as people like to talk about people like Alanis Morissette and Courtney Love as the female counterparts to grunge, Phair’s Exile In Guyville made her the undisputed Queen of Alternative Music almost overnight. Even with all her previous accolades, that didn’t mean she was bulletproof from the ‘00s cliches.

Much like a lot of her female counterparts, Phair used her 2003 self-titled album to do a left turn into pop music. Instead of rocketing her into stardom, this ended up being one of the death knells of her career, with songs that tried to compromise Phair’s gruff sound with crystal clean production. While most of these songs aren’t bad on principle, they all feel like a severe step down from the artist we got to know back in ‘93.

The snide attitude is still here, but the way it's married to shiny pop hooks just make the album feel disjointed rather than experimental. At a time when people were counting on Phair to deliver more poignant material, some of these songs feel like they should be coming from an edgy Avril Lavigne record than from one of the greatest voices in alternative music.


6. Generation Swine - Motley Crue

After years of riding the waves of hair metal, Motley Crue finally got their shot at the end of the ‘80s. With everyone newly sober, the band’s 1989 release Dr. Feelgood sent them into the big leagues after nearly half the album landed on the singles charts. Though the high couldn’t last forever, it was unbelievable how far the mighty had fallen in less than a decade.

Shortly after the tour, singer Vince Neil left the band, leading to the rest of guys hiring singer John Corabi for a record their fanbase promptly forgot about. Once Neil finally returned though, Generation Swine ended up being more hit and miss than anyone could have imagined.

Yes, all the members of Motley are still accounted for, but the entire record is the band hopping on the train of industrial music, with Mick Mars’ roaring riffs being replaced by synthesized parts and a wall of effects.

There’s nothing wrong with trying to roll with the punches of music, but no one was really coming to a Motley Crue record expecting to hear something that sounds like Nine Inch Nails. The band may be geared up to reunite as of late, but don’t expect any of these songs to find their way into the setlist any time soon.


5. Dee Dee Ramone's Rap Career

Dee Dee Ramone is one of the reasons we’re still talking about the Ramones today. For as much as people rag on the band for being basic, Dee Dee was the one who founded the group that single handedly created the punk rock movement. Dee Dee could have easily kept writing letter-perfect punk for the rest of time, but instead he decided to ruin his track record by trying his hand at rap.

Given everything that seems wrong with this idea on paper, one can almost see this working. After all, punk rock and hip hop both have roots in New York City and are both known for being from the streets first and foremost.

Masking himself as Dee Dee King, most of the songs released during this time end up feeling like throwaways from lesser hip hop acts. Ramone’s original approach was always known for its simplicity, but this is where the charm wears off and it starts sounding dumb.

It’s noble of Dee Dee to still try to sound dangerous after years of punk rock bombast, but these verses have no business being anywhere near stuff like the Beastie Boys or Run-DMC. All musicians should follow their muse, but in terms of making enjoyable music, Dee Dee should have probably stuck to what he knew best.


4. Path of Totality - Korn

There’s an entire generation of metal musicians who owe their careers to Korn. Coming in the mid ‘90s, these guys from Bakersfield shocked the music world with some of the most visceral music in metal history that ended up igniting the spark of nu metal. As the years went on though, Korn ended up getting into some really bad habits.

While the band has started to improve as of late, many fans have still not forgiven them for Path of Totality. In a bold new shift, Korn decided to use their next record to hook up with a bunch of dubstep producers, which went about as well as you'd expect.

It doesn’t sound all that bad on the surface, with most nu metal bands employing DJs, but the electronic soundscapes end up overtaking all of the menace that this band has.

Instead of having two disparate styles bouncing off each other, the way the production fits with Jonathan Davis’ vocals just feel like two completely different songs being played at the same time. The band was already a long way away from something like Follow the Leader, but this record’s experimentation gave many fans a good reason to jump ship.


3. Pop - U2

By the early ‘90s, it seemed that U2 could do no wrong. Even with the endless amount of pretentiousness radiating off of Bono, albums like the Joshua Tree and The Unforgettable Fire marked a turning point in ‘80s rock. After the electronic sounds of Achtung Baby launched the band into the ‘90s, things started going downhill fast.

Starting with Zooropa, the band started to go down a more electronic road, which seemed like the next logical step considering the previous album’s success. After that album’s lackluster reception, the band released Pop, which is exactly what it says on the tin.

Instead of incorporating their lush soundscapes into the mix, this record just sounds like the band threw together a bunch of keyboard loops into Pro Tools and hoped for the best, with Bono delivering some of his most synthetic vocal performances on record.

For a band that always made you feel elated every time you heard them, this feels like you’re witnessing the BizarroWorld version of the band, whose personality had been sucked dry. All of Bono’s pretentious statements could be forgiven in the ‘80s, but this was the moment where U2 let themselves buy into their ego.


2. St. Anger - Metallica

The early ‘00s are not really looked at as a high point in Metallica’s career. After losing Jason Newsted and nearly falling apart due to James Hetfield’s alcoholism and time in rehab, it was a small miracle that the band was even able to recover. Though the outlet for their frustrations came in St. Anger, fans have been turning their back on this album for decades.

Originally, the idea was for the band to go into the studio with producer Bob Rock and pump out an album that took the band back to their garage rock roots, which they hinted at on their covers album Garage Inc. However, with all the drop tunings, abrasive sounds, and lack of guitar solos, the album sounds closer to the greatest modern metal band trying to play catchup with the nu metal trends that were already growing stale.

Since Hetfield had just gotten out of rehab, most of the vocals are pretty raw, leaving many of his agonized wails coming off as painful rather than menacing.

To put the cherry on top of this dumpster fire, Lars Ulrich also seems to have traded in his snare sound for what sounds like a Tupperware container, with each hit slamming you in the head until you physically can’t take it anymore. Metallica have multiple classics in their catalog, but this record will sooner give you a headache than make you want to headbang.


1. Music From the Elder - KISS

Everytime you turn on a KISS song, life just feels like a non-stop party. Ever since the band was formed by Paul Stanley and Gene Simmons, the goal was always to leave their fans happy with some of the most care-free rock music ever created. So how do you screw that up?....you start to care too much.

After a few years of losing the plot with disco and power pop detours, KISS decided that the best way to get back in good favor with their audience was to release a concept album to show their musical strengths. Telling a long winded story about the Chosen One, Music From the Elder feels like what happens if you ask a band like Cheap Trick to cover the Wall, with disastrous results all around.

Even when pulling in heavyhitters like Lou Reed and producer Bob Ezrin, this album feels like a desperate plea to find a new audience, with Stanley and Simmons playing up the more fantastical elements of their convoluted story. Nowadays, almost everyone involved in the project said it was a mistake, with Stanley and Simmons only keeping “A World Without Heroes” in the setlist. Though the band recovered quite nicely with the venomous spit of Creatures of the Night, they really had their work cut out for them after this went belly up.


In this post: 
Metallica
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm just a junkie for all things media. Whether it's music, movies, TV, or just other reviews, I absolutely adore this stuff. But music was my first love, and I love having the opportunity to share it with you good people. Follow Me On Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/timcoffman97