10 Rock Music Songs That Were Almost Never Released
How different things could have been if these songs never saw the light of day?
Though it might be clear with the power of hindsight, one can never tell what is going to be a hit before it leaves the studio.
A musician or band never knows how their song is going to be perceived; what they think is genius might be viewed as total nonsense by the public or, in the case of the entries on this list, vice versa.
These ten songs are all considered sure-fire smashes today, but there was one point in time where they weren't deemed worthy enough to be released. Whether they were too long, too complicated, or just thought to be bad, in an alternate timeline, they never left the vault.
Some of this resistance came from record label executives, who continuously prove to be out of touch with public opinion despite that literally being their job.
Other times, it was the artist themselves who weren't so keen and had to be talked round by their fellow bandmates.
Remember, a song you're hearing for the first time is one that the person who made had heard hundreds of times during the production process. That's enough to drive anyone mad.
10. The Boys Are Back In Town - Thin Lizzy
Though they have a bulging back catalogue of excellent songs to sample - Jailbreak, Whiskey in the Jar, Waiting for an Alibi - the one track that most people immediately associate with Irish twin guitar magicians Thin Lizzy is their raucous summer anthem, The Boys Are Back in Town.
First released in 1976, this ode to troublemaking quickly gained popularity amongst those who liked their rock hard and feisty. It's a good thing this happened as, had it not been a success, Thin Lizzy might have ceased to exist.
The Boys Are Back in Town was not originally selected as one of the ten songs to feature on the album Jailbreak, but a decision by one of their managers put on the record.
When the band found out that a song that was almost cut had become a radio hit, they were flabbergasted, with guitarist Scott Gorham calling it their "saviour" in a 2016 interview, as the album was "make or break time" for the group.
Managers might not always get it right in rock music, but sometimes they do actually know what they're doing. Not often, but sometimes.
9. 1979 - Smashing Pumpkins
Though it may have one of the most pretentious names in music history, the album Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness by Smashing Pumpkins is regarded as one of the most important alt-rock releases ever.
This mammoth 28-song collection helped the band cross over into the mainstream and pushed the boundaries of what rock music could be with its vast thematical scope. It could have been even longer, as frontman Billy Corgan actually wrote a staggering 56 songs during the production process, the last one being 1979.
What would eventually become the album's second single was originally dismissed by producer Flood as not good enough for the record, but Corgan clearly saw its worth, as he spent that evening rejigging the track.
Upon a second listen, Flood was on board.
1979, which is Corgan reflecting on his childhood, was a worldwide hit and is widely regarded as one of the band's best ever songs. Don't hold the fact that Flood very nearly kept it off the album against him though; the man had just sat through 55 other demos.
He must have been exhausted.
8. Lazy Sunday - Small Faces
British band Small Faces are one of the great "What ifs?" of the 1960s. Had they been around for longer than four years, they might have become one of the biggest groups of the era, but fate had other ideas.
In their short existence, they managed to release several classics, including Itchycoo Park, Tin Soldier, and Lazy Sunday from 1968. Although, if the band had gotten their way, then this ode to the weekend would never have seen the light of day.
The song, which features lead singer Steve Marriott getting into an argument with his neighbours, wasn't initially going to be released as a single, but the record label had other ideas.
Whilst the band were on tour in Germany, Lazy Sunday was greenlit without their knowledge. This perceived infraction only weakened relations between Marriott and management, and the singer was out the door by the end of the year.
Did this decision pay off? Well, the song did reach second place in the UK, but was that really worth breaking up the band?
If it made them money, then the label would probably say yes.
7. Where The Streets Have No Name - U2
Though they had been successful before, it all changed for U2 upon the release of 1987's The Joshua Tree.
Widely regarded as one of the greatest albums of all time, The Joshua Tree is a embarrassment of riches when it comes to great U2 songs; I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For; One Tree Hill; With or Without You; Red Hill Mining Town; and, of course, Where the Streets Have No Name.
The opening track on the album, Where the Streets Have No Name is based on Bono's experiences in Belfast, Northern Ireland, and is one of the most recognisable tracks in the band's discography. It's unthinkable that someone wanted to destroy it, especially when that someone was legendary producer Brian Eno.
Eno estimates that about half of the recording sessions for Joshua Tree were dedicated to this one song, it was that difficult to record. He attempted to erase the original tapes in order to force the band to start it again, but sound engineer Pat McCarthy allegedly physically prevented him from doing this.
Thank God he did, otherwise the version of Where the Streets Have No Name that exists today would have been lost forever.
6. Creep - Radiohead
It might be the song that started it all for Radiohead, but man do they hate Creep.
Thom Yorke told Rolling Stone in 1993 that "It's like it's not our song any more... It feels like we're doing a cover" in reference to how many times the band had played the song during its early days. This resentment could have all been avoided, had they just not listened to their producers.
Sean Slade and Paul Q. Kolderie were working with the band one day when they started playing Creep, a song they had never planned to record. At Slade and Kolderie's insistence, it got laid down, and the rest is history.
Creep was released as the first single from Radiohead's debut album, Pablo Honey, and after initially failing to make a splash, it quickly took over the world. Now, it has over 1.3 billion streams on Spotify and is by far and away their biggest seller.
The band have softened their stance on the song in recent years, slipping it back into the setlist on their most recent tours, but please don't make it the only thing you talk to them about. They won't be happy.
5. Nothing Else Matters - Metallica
It must be difficult as a professional musician to write a song solely for yourself, as there is surely immense pressure to bring everything up to release standards.
Metallica frontman James Hetfield did just this in 1990, when he wrote himself a simple ballad to cope with feeling homesick whilst on tour. This was just a man getting out his feelings through song, nothing more... until Lars Ulrich heard it.
Damn you, Lars! Little eavesdropper.
At Ulrich's insistence, Nothing Else Matters was considered for the band's upcoming self-titled record, also known as the Black Album. It made the cut and found its way into the band's regular rotation, having been played over 1,000 times live.
The finished product of Nothing Else Matters is so aggressively radio-friendly that it would have been criminal not to release it as a single; a decision that helped change the perception of Metallica from "those blokes who make a lot of noise" to "those blokes who make a lot of noise, but also write love songs sometimes."
Some would say this was a bad shift, but Hetfield's bank account would disagree.
4. Livin’ On A Prayer - Bon Jovi
If you were to look up "hair metal" in the dictionary, then you'd just find a bunch of stills from the Livin' on a Prayer music video and a receipt for a leather jacket.
The signature song of Bon Jovi, Livin' on a Prayer was one of the many gigantic hits to come from the band's 1986 album, Slippery When Wet. The story of Tommy and Gina has become one of the most recognisable and popular rock songs of all time, thanks to its catchy chorus and expert deployment of a talk box.
Fun fact, a similar effect can be achieved by singing with an electric toothbrush in your mouth.
Jon Bon Jovi was originally displeased with the song and went to abandon it before guitarist Richie Sambora stepped in. Sambora helped Bon Jovi to rework the song, as did bass player Hugh McDonald, who would go uncredited on the final release. Eventually, they had something they were happy with, and that was that.
You can hear that original Livin' on a Prayer demo on the compilation album 100,000,000 Bon Jovi Fans Can't Be Wrong, if you're that way inclined.
3. Smells Like Teen Spirit - Nirvana
The song that launched grunge into the stratosphere and ensured that green stripey shirts would always be fashionable, Smells Like Teen Spirit is the Nirvana song and, in many ways, the song of the 90s.
Taken from their industry-shifting album, Nevermind, Smells Like Teen Spirit made Nirvana gods on Earth and opened the floodgates for dozens of imitators, pastiches, and parodies for years to come. And guess what? Bassist Krist Novoselic hated it the first time he heard it.
After Kurt Cobain had first recorded the song, which he wrote in homage to the band Pixies, he presented it to the rest of the band. Novoselic called it "ridiculous", claiming that the riff was too predictable. Cobain thought about this and, in a clear and rational manner, made the group play it for an hour-and-a-half.
Over the next 90 minutes, Novoselic softened on the track and it was decided that it should feature on Nevermind. Had Cobain not been so ruthless in exercising his power as band leader, then Smells Like Teen Spirit would have never left the studio.
This means that there would be no Weird Al version, and what sort of a world would that be?
2. (I Can’t) Get No Satisfaction - The Rolling Stones
According to legend, so take this with a 60s-sized grain of salt, Keith Richards of The Rolling Stones wrote (I Can't) Get No Satisfaction in his sleep.
In the morning, he woke up to find a tape player by his bedside. He played it to himself, listened to two minutes of him messing around on the acoustic guitar, and then another 40 of him snoring.
It was originally intended to be a piece of filler for an unspecified album, but Richards and Jagger were eventually outvoted by the rest of the band and crew, leading to Satisfaction getting put out as a single. On this rare occasion, the Glimmer Twins were wrong.
Satisfaction became a must-play, helping raise the Stones' already-impressive stock even higher. The Gibson Fuzzbox, the effect pedal used to create its signature sound, became so popular that the company sold out all of its stock by the end of 1965.
Whilst it was always intended to be put out, (I Can't) Get No Satisfaction was very nearly relegated to a minor spot in the middle of an album; a position not befitting its greatness in any way.
1. Bohemian Rhapsody - Queen
As anyone who has seen the acclaimed-yet-flawed Queen biopic of the same name will tell you, the executives at EMI waged war with the band over the release of the song Bohemian Rhapsody.
The suits thought the song was way too long and, at nearly six minutes, it was, in terms of conventional wisdom. However, Freddie Mercury took one look at conventional wisdom, spat on it, and then strutted out the door.
To get around his corporate obligations, Mercury took the song to his good friend, the DJ Kenny Everett. After teasing the track to his listeners, Everett played it on his radio show 14 times in two days, and the public ate it up. With demand for the song rising, EMI had no choice but to put it out as a single.
Bohemian Rhapsody would have won over some fans as an elaborate album track on A Night at the Opera, but there can be no denying that the choice to release it as a single was the correct one.
It's one of the greatest songs in the history of British music, even if its B-side was the ludicrous I'm in Love with My Car.