10 Unusual Music Collaborations That Should've Never Worked
Risk-taking is everything in music.
Music is usually a collaborative process, especially in the pop genre. Band members need chemistry to make great music, great songwriters need great arrangements to compliment their lyrics.
Popular music is more collaborative than ever nowadays, for better or worse. Most of the time the collaborations are safe and expected. You expect Shawn Mendes to make a song with Camilla Cabello. You expect Drake to make a song with Rihanna.
Of course, this formula still makes for some great music.
Sometimes artists try to step outside that comfort zone, but it unfortunately falls completely flat. Brian May collaborating with Dappy is something none of us asked for.
Thankfully, the risks these next ten artists took were certainly unexpected, but more than paid off.
Sometimes you just don’t know you wanted something until it pops into existence.
10. Kendrick Lamar & U2 - XXX.
Kendrick Lamar has always been a fantastic collaborator. He’s worked with an endless list of amazing artists. Beyoncé. Jay-Z. Travis Scott. Kanye West.
As great as he is, he has had a couple of collaborative efforts that have fallen flat. Lady Gaga was initially slated to appear on his 2012 track ‘B***h Don’t Kill My Vibe’ but it never fully materialised due to creative differences. His 2015 effort with Taylor Swift ‘Bad Blood’ was a smash hit, but he was batting well below his average with that one.
Fast forward to 2017. His fourth album ‘DAMN.’ is released and who is there appearing on the 11th song? None other than legendary Irish rock band U2. As it turns out, Bono has an ear for hip-hop.
XXX. is one of Kendrick Lamar’s most overtly political statements, and it makes for one of the most frantic and immediate songs of his career. Bono and friends appear in the transition between the two distinct halves of the song, providing the perfect backdrop for Kendrick to ponder the current state of America.
U2 couldn’t have picked a better time to dip their toes into the hip-hop world. Thanks to this effort they are now part of a Pulitzer Prize winning album.
9. Kanye West & Paul McCartney - Only One
Only One is actually the first of three collaborations between the two artists. They went on to work with Rihanna on the beautifully stripped back FourFiveSeconds, as well as the hard hitting drill inspired All Day. However Only One is the song that stands as the most impressive and powerful of all of them.
In concept alone the song oozes with soul. The narrative of the song is Kanye singing from the perspective of his late mother about his relationship with his daughter North. Just from the lyrics alone, you can gauge how cathartic and emotional the songwriting process must have been.
It’s appropriately stripped back considering the subject matter. The track is driven by Paul McCartney’s amazing key work and Kanye’s subtly auto tuned voice.
Paul McCartney does not contribute vocals to the song and this is an intelligent decision considering how deeply personal the song is. It wouldn’t have worked as well any other way.
Immensely influental in their respective generations, Kanye and Paul come together to transcend genre and tradition to make something so incredibly moving and uncharacteristicly devoid of ego for Kanye.
8. Young Thug & Elton John - High
Young Thug is a maverick in hip-hop. There is nobody quite like him at all. From his fashion sense to his extremely experimental vocal melodies, he has been trailblazing at the top of the genre for years now.
Even for someone has unorthodox as Young Thug, seeing him side by side with Elton John os still utterly surreal. On the surface they couldn’t be further apart, but look deeper and you can see why the collaboration makes sense. Both artists have been viewed as flamboyant, and at points in their career criticised for that attribute.
Young Thug was bold enough to reimagine one of Elton John’s most beloved songs of all time. Rocketman. Instead of the soothing, sombre soft rock classic it now also exists as a woozy psychedelic trap song. Nobody saw this coming.
Whether you're a fan of the song or not, you have to admire the sheer audiacity for someone like Young Thug to even attempt such a thing.
The praise he received from Elton himself was probably all the validation Young Thug needed.
7. Janelle Monáe & Brian Wilson - Dirty Computer
Both of these artists are extremely forward thinking. Brian Wilson effectively changed the face of popular music with his innovative compositions and vocal arrangements alongside The Beach Boys. Janelle Monáe has been making some of the most innovative and conceptual pop music for the best part of a decade now.
It’s always thrilling to hear artists of different generations coming together and essentially breaking down the walls of genre. The title track from Janelle Monae’s third album is also its opener and it sets the mood perfectly for the rest of the run time.
In just two minutes the song combines Brian Wilson’s classic vocal layering and arrangements with elements of neo soul, funk, rnb and pop. Most artists wouldn’t be able to juggle this many different influences in a whole album, let alone a single track.
It sounds futuristic, yet organic and classic at the same time. That’s a quality both artists posses. This song is a manifestation of two parallel generations finally converging, and it’s perfect.
6. Blue & Elton John - Sorry Seems To Be The Hardest Word
This should never have worked. Never. Blue was one of most popular British boy bands of the early 2000s. How on Earth were they going to even shine a light to one of Elton John’s very best songs? As well has have the man himself appear on the song?
Thankfully this modern reinterpretation is not a car crash. In fact, it’s a respectable and well put together collaboration. Tasteful and simple modern RnB drums and bass are added and the tempo is slightly increased. The boys from Blue provide what is probably their best vocal performances on a song as well, which is needed when you’re performing side by side to a living legend.
The song was already successful prior to this of course. It cracked the Billboard Top 10 in America and reached number 11 in the UK. However the version with Blue managed to peak at the very top of the UK charts, no doubt sparking a newfound interest in Elton John amongst Blue’s hoard of teenage fans.
This one was definitely a win for all involved.
5. Christina Aguilera & Redman - Dirrty
This song was EVERYWHERE in the early 2000s, especially in the UK. Somehow it only managed to get to number 48 on the Billboard 100 chart in America, but reached number 1 in the UK. It’s a certified banger and God only knows why the Americans didn't realise this.
This was the moment Christina Aguilera asserted her intention to completely change her public image and persona. No longer the cute and safe teenage pop idol, she had transitioned into an assertive, edgy and sexually liberated woman. This is essentially the original Wrecking Ball. Looking back on it, it makes complete sense why such a gritty rapper like Redman was featured on the song.
Both Christina and Redman’s lyrics live up to the title. It’s dirty, it’s gritty and it’s catchy as hell.
This set the precedent for the rest of her career. Now Christina Aguilera has dipped her toes in everything from jazz and funk, to soul and of course hip hop. Not only is this one of the most iconic songs and music videos of the 2000s, it’s also extremely underrated as a musical trailblazer.
4. Beyoncé & Jack White - Don’t Hurt Yourself
Don’t Hurt Yourself was nominated for Best Rock Performance at the 59th Grammys. Performed by Beyoncé, the sweetheart of 2000s RnB. The same woman who helped create Bootylicious. That alone should go a long way to showing just how successful this collaboration was.
This track is the most defiant and anger fuelled song on Lemonade, so it makes perfect sense that its sonic palette reflects that. Jack White, formerly of The White Stripes, contributed his signature dirty and gritty production style, whilst Beyoncé aggressively sings about her husband’s issues with infedelity. Just to solidify its rock creditials, the song includes a sample of When The Levee Breaks by Led Zeppelin.
In the previous decade, the two artists could not have been making music that was more different. This is an example of how effective and downright awesome stepping out of your comfort zone can be.
3. Aerosmith & Run DMC - Walk This Way
The one that started it all. Along with the Beastie Boys, this song is what started the rap rock trend in the mid 1980s. It’s easy for hip-hop heads to look back on this as being corny or cheesy, but at the time of release it was boundary pushing.
Aerosmith’s relevance was weaning at the time and although Run DMC were young, hip and cool, the wider American public still saw hip hop as a relative novelty, not as the art form it is. It took literal walls being broken down in the music video for some to acknowledge this.
The importance of this song culturally cannot he understand. Released in July of 1986, later that very year America had its first ever Hip Hop number one album. Licensed To Ill by the Beastie Boys. A rap rock album in its purest form.
This wouldn’t have happened without this unprecedented collaboration. The musical landscape of popular music in the following years may have been very different if it hadn’t been for the success of this song.
2. Jay-Z & Linkin Park - Numb/Encore
The unique thing about this mashup is that it stems from two very different but equally impressive songs. Numb came from Linkin Park’s second album, Meteora.
It’s a powerful alt rock song about dissatisfaction and defying expectations. Encore comes from Jay-Z’s The Black Album. It’s one of his most confident and happy songs. It also features amazing production from Kanye West. How on Earth do these songs work so perfectly together?
The combination is so seamless that it sounds like a completely original composition, instead of two existing songs smashing together. New York streets came together with Californian angst, and it’s a match made in heaven.
This success of this song was also helped by the time it was released. The early 2000s were the prime time for rap rock and nu metal bands to flourish. The opportunity had to be seized.
Now over 15 years later this song is still fondly remember by both fans of Jay-Z and Linkin Park. It definitely broke barriers down between consumers of music and introduced people to music they otherwise never would have even tried.
1. Lil Nas X & Billy Ray Cyrus - Old Town Road (Remix)
The biggest song of 2019 by far, Old Town Road spent a record nineteen consecutive weeks at the top of the Billboard 100 chart. However it may not have been this successful if it hadn’t been for prior controversy. In March of 2019 the original version entered the Billboard Country charts at number 19, but was removed for not fitting the country genre. In a move that was pure genius, Lil Nas X decided to recruit country star Billy Ray Cyrus for the remix. And the rest is history.
The song has sparked debate about genres and how to categorise them, and whether they’re even relevant. It’s also catchy as hell. Perhaps too catchy. Nobody can get this song out of their head. Nobody. Once in your head, it is never leaving.
The song’s lyrical content could not be more country, and couldn’t be more hip hop either. This is the ambiguity that clearly worried the folks over at Billboard.
Billy Ray Cyrus is now more relevant than ever, and Lil Nas X is breaking down even more barriers regarding sexuality in hip hop. He’s also going around making paninis with Gordon Ramsay.
Out of context, none of this should make sense. But that’s the power of this collaboration. The most unlikely coming together of people ended up becoming a genuine pop culture phenomenon.