10 Worst Rock Band Member Replacements
If ain't broke, don't fix it... and certainly don't replace it with something worse.
Anyone who has ever been on the Wikipedia page of a classic rock band will know that they cycle through members like most people cycle through underwear. Well, most normal people, anyway.
Sometimes members pass away, sometimes they fall out with other members, and sometimes they just don't fancy being in the band anymore or want to pursue other projects. Whatever the reason, they have to go, and they usually end up getting replaced by someone new.
There have been a few instances where the old switcheroo has panned out quite well for a band; Dave Grohl replacing Chad Channing in Nirvana, for example, or Brian Johnson taking over from Bon Scott as AC/DC's lead singer.
Unfortunately, not everyone gets so lucky.
The following ten figures all had big shoes to fill when they stepped into their respective bands and, sadly, they ended up getting lost in all that extra space. Whether they didn't fit the vibe of the band or just weren't up to the job, most of these substitutes did not last long before getting their marching orders.
Sorry, guys, but music is a brutal business.
10. Rome Ramirez Replaces Bradley Nowell - Sublime
Ska punk group Sublime looked set to have a very good 1996. They had built up a strong fanbase thanks to their unique combination of pop punk, hip-hop, and reggae, and were set to release their third album.
Unfortunately, in May of that year, lead singer Bradley Nowell died as a result of a heroin overdose. He was 28.
Nowell's passing ripped through the music world like wildfire, devastating everyone who had gotten behind this young talent. Sublime's third album did come out, to rave reviews and their strongest chart position ever, but after that, they went their separate ways.
Until they didn't.
In 2009, guitarist Eric Wilson and drummer Bud Gaugh teamed up with singer Rome Ramirez to form a new version of Sublime. That was, until Nowell's estate shut them down, and they started going by the name "Sublime with Rome" instead.
Not sure how they got away with that one, but there you go.
Ramirez stuck out like a sore thumb, especially on songs that had previous been performed by the late Nowell. The whole thing felt a bit tasteless and tacky, but hey, they got a top ten album in 2011, so there.
9. Joe Lynn Turner Replaces Ian Gillan - Deep Purple
Deep Purple are one of those classic rock bands that have gone through members like an ordinary person goes through tissues.
The line-up has chopped and changed so many times over the years that it would struggle to recognise itself in the mirror if it were sentient. The version most people are familiar with is Mark II, which lasted from 1969 to 1973 and featured Ian Gillan on vocal duties.
Gillan has taken a few breaks from the band over the years, including one that began in late 1989. Joe Lynn Turner, former vocalist with the band Rainbow, was named his replacement and, unfortunately for Joey, things did not go well.
Turner's one and only album with Deep Purple, 1990's Slaves and Masters, was far from a classic. It just didn't click with him on the mic and, in late 1992, Turner was let go.
Who took over from him, you ask? Ian Gillan! He made his Deep Purple comeback shortly thereafter and has been a part of the band ever since.
That's gotta hurt - like the musical equivalent of someone dumping you to get back with their ex.
8. Josh Klinghoffer Replaces John Frusciante - Red Hot Chili Peppers
Replacing a lead singer is the most obvious change a band can make, but some non-vocal swaps have also caused stirs over the years.
The Red Hot Chili Peppers have been through plenty of guitarists since their initial axeman, Hilel Slovak, died in 1988. John Frusciante first held the spot from late '88 to 1992, and then again between '98 and 2009. After that, he was subbed out for Josh Klinghoffer, who had previous served as a session musician for the likes of Gnarls Barkley.
Now, this entry is in no way meant to imply that Klinghoffer is a bad guitarist. The guy has gone on to play with legends like Beck, Pearl Jam, and Jane's Addiction in the years since, but with the Chilis, he didn't quite gel.
His playing style was too safe for the frenetic, hip-hop-infused stylings of his employers. The two albums he played on, I'm With You and The Getaway, both sounded way too flat, which might be why Frusciante was brought back in 2019.
The two are good friends in real life, so there was no beef over this... hopefully...
7. Matt Skiba Replaces Tom DeLonge - Blink-182
Only five different men have ever been official members of pop punk idols Blink-182.
There's Tom DeLonge, Mark Hoppus, and Travis Barker, the current gang, and then there's Scott Raynor, the original drummer who Barker replaced, and Matt Skiba, who was guitarist and vocalist between 2015 and 2022.
Skiba had found success with a band he started called Alkaline Trio before Hoppus and Barker got in touch. DeLonge had left Blink after a very public fallout with their management, so a new arm of the triumvirate was needed.
Unfortunately, whilst the other two members were Octavian and Marc Anthony, Skiba turned out to be more of a Lepidus. Bit of Ancient Roman humour for you there.
Whilst some of the songs with Skiba on turned out alright, it felt like there was something missing from Blink the entire time he was there.
Hoppus' vocals dominated proceedings, which kind of defeated the point of having two singers in the first place, and, eventually, DeLonge was brought back in for a new album called One More Time..., which released in 2023.
Skiba was dealt a bad hand, sure, but this was still a big let-down.
6. Ray Wilson Replaces Phil Collins - Genesis
Whilst most bands would jump at the chance to have one legendary singer in their ranks, Genesis can claim two of them as part of their alma mater.
First up was Peter Gabriel, who led the group through their successful days as a prog act between 1967 and 1975. Then, when Petey went off to do his own thing, drummer Phil Collins stepped up to fill the position, heading up Genesis' transformation into a more mainstream rock act.
But who came after Phil? Who had the unfortunate task of following two of the greats? Sadly, that hefty task fell to Mr. Ray Wilson.
Wilson had been the frontman of Scottish grunge group Stiltskin before he got the phone call from Genesis HQ in 1996. He appeared on one album, ...Calling All Stations..., which was roundly thumped by the musical press, before the band retired from full-time performing in 2000.
Well done, Ray, you just killed Genesis.
There was no way Wilson was ever going to stand up to such giants, but at least his time in the firing line was relatively short.
Thank Heavens for small mercies, eh?
5. Tim “Ripper” Owens Replaces Rob Halford - Judas Priest
He may not have been the original lead singer of Judas Priest, but nobody can argue that Rob Halford isn't the most iconic member of the metal heavyweights.
Halford came onboard right before their first commercial release, Rocka Rolla, in 1974. He went on to appear on their most famous records - Stained Class, British Steel, Screaming for Vengeance, etc. - before the group went on hiatus in 1992.
When they got back together in 1996, Halford declined an offer to reunite with his brothers in leather, so they found a back-up in Tim "Ripper" Owens.
What made Owens such a viable replacement? He'd been the lead singer in a Judas Priest tribute band! Oh no...
In an outcome that could have been seen from space, fans did not take kindly to Owens playing the role of Halford-lite, and the Ripper was ripped from their line-up in 2003, after just two studio albums in the job.
Priest replaced Owens with yet another tribute singer, one who really looked and sounded exactly like Rob Halford... wait a second, that is Rob Halford!
Get used to the whole "original member returns" thing. It happens a lot.
4. John Corabi Replaces Vince Neil - Mötley Crüe
Vince Neil. Mick Mars. Nikki Six. Tommy Lee. This is the line-up that most people think of when they imagine hair metal hellraisers and umlaut abusers Mötley Crüe.
This configuration played on the first five of the Crüe's albums, on hits such as Smokin' in the Boys Rooms, Girls, Girls, Girls, and Kickstart My Heart. So, when Neil left the band (either of his own free will or due to someone else's, nobody knows) in 1992, they had no idea what to do.
In came John Corabi, formerly of groups like Angora and The Scream. Heard of them? Of course you haven't.
Corabi was front and centre for the Crue's one and only '90s studio release, the self-titled Mötley Crüe from 1994. This album attempted to position the band as a hybrid of old-school hair metal and the emerging grunge genre, but all it did was give a mediocre account of both.
For various reasons, Corabi's singing came under heavy fire from fans and critics alike. This, combined with the subpar material on the new record, meant his days were numbered.
He was gone by the next album, replaced by, you guessed it, Vince Neil.
3. Doug Yule Replaces John Cale - The Velvet Underground
Though they weren't especially commercially famous during their initial lifespan, time has been kind to The Velvet Underground, who are now considered one of the most important and influential bands of the entire 1960s.
The two Underground members most people will be aware of are Lou Reed, who went on to achieve infamy as a solo artist, and John Cale, the Welsh multi-instrumentalist who would work on numerous famous projects later in life, including the soundtrack to American Psycho.
As you can imagine, a rock band in the 1960s featuring Lou "I Will Attack You With A Sword" Reed was a stressful environment. Cale found this out first hand when, in 1968, he got sacked by Reed with no prior warning.
His replacement was Doug Yule, who, whilst a very capable singer and guitarist, just couldn't match Cale's natural knack for melody. He stayed with the band until their final release, Squeeze, by which point even Reed himself had split.
Yule was left to man the ship pretty much singlehandedly and, yeah, it didn't go well. Just look up the reviews for Squeeze if you want to know how not well it went.
2. Blaze Bayley Replaces Bruce Dickinson - Iron Maiden
One of the greatest replacements in rock music history is when Paul Di'Anno, the singer for Iron Maiden on their first two albums, made way for a man who would become intertwined with the band forevermore, Bruce Dickinson.
Brucey made an immediate impact, as his first Maiden album was the seismic The Number of the Beast. He oversaw several more smash hits, but this romance was not to last. By 1993, he was gone too.
The rest of the band clearly knew they were never going to find someone to live up to Dickinson's talents, so they hired the guy with the coolest name instead.
Blaze Bayley, real name Bayley Cooke, served as Dickinson's replacement for two albums, The X Factor and Virtual XI. How did that go? Oh, they both routinely rank amongst the worst Maiden albums of all time. Right...
Bayley's voice was totally different to Dickinson's, which automatically put him in a compromising position. He also didn't possess nearly as much range or charisma, and the whole sad affair finally came to an end when Bruce returned for Maiden's 2000 album, Brave New World.
That album was significantly better, by the way.
1. Gary Cherone Replaces Sammy Hagar - Van Halen
The words "Van Halen" on a list like this might lead some to think about Sammy Hagar taking over from David Lee Roth, but at least Hagar's version of the band produced some fun songs.
There is another singer swap in Van Halen's past that went much, much worse.
Hagar himself parted ways with the rockers in 1996 and, since Roth wasn't available to re-join them at the time, a completely new member was needed. The man they settled on was Gary Cherone, formerly of the band Extreme, and, well, it was a total disaster.
The only album released by this line-up was 1998's Van Halen III, which was neither a commercial hit nor critical success. Cherone brought nothing new to the band's output and plans for a second album with him on it were promptly shelved.
Cherone was gone by the following year and it would take Van Halen 14 years to release another collection of new songs, by which time Roth had returned to the fold.
An ill-fated experiment from one of rock's biggest bands, Cherone's time in Van Halen ended up being an Extreme disappointment.