5 Bands Who Improved After Replacing Their Singer (And 5 Who Didn't)
5. Improved - Dropkick Murphys
Dropkick Murphys were formed in Quincy, Massachussetts in 1996. They brought the Celtic Punk sub-genre to the forefront, blending aggressive street punk and traditional Irish music. In 1997, the band was signed to Hellcat Records and produced Do or Die, their first full-length record.
Up through the making of Do or Die, Dorchester native Mike McColgan served as lead vocalist. His raw vocal style helped make Do or Die a breakthrough for the band. As the other members of the group were getting more serious about the band professionally, McColgan's interest began to wane. A mutual, amicable split ensued and DKM were in need of a new frontman.
McColgan was quickly replaced by The Bruisers' vocalist Al Barr. Will Barr, DKM quickly evolved into their signature sound. They also reached new heights post-McColgan when their song I'm Shipping Up to Boston was used in the soundtrack for the film The Departed. The song has been their biggest single to date.
Unlike Pink Floyd, who essentially became a new band, or Journey, who replicated their old singer, Dropkick Murphys hit the sweet spot. Barr didn't change the direction of the band stylistically. He helped them to become the best version of themselves. As of 2022, they are still going strong.