7 Reasons The Beach Boys Never Finished Their Masterpiece

SMiLE was supposed to eclipse whatever The Beatles could come up with, but instead it almost killed Brian Wilson.

Almost forty years ago, in February 1966, The Beach Boys began work on Good Vibrations, their most famous and visionary song. It was slated to be the centrepiece of what undoubtedly would have been their greatest album, SMiLE, which would have eclipsed even Pet Sounds. But SMiLE would never be released, and its convoluted and ultimately doomed recording process has since become the stuff of legend. Over more than 50 recording sessions in at least four different studios, the Beach Boys€™ leader Brian Wilson tried and failed to realise his vision, due to all manner of problems besetting the project. There was internal pressure from other band members, Brian€™s spiralling drug use and mental health issues, not to mention the fact that the songs he wanted to make were so far ahead of their time. On Pet Sounds, Brian had sung €œI just wasn€™t made for these times€, and with SMiLE he proved it, accelerating his own downfall in the process.

7. There Was Too Much Resistance From The Band

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R2_wBbS7I08 By the time SMiLE was being recorded, Brian Wilson had retired as a touring member of The Beach Boys. He stayed in the studio with a set of session musicians, while the other members went out and played shows. So when they returned and heard the completed instrumental songs, many for the very first time, they couldn€™t get their heads round them. What Brian called €œa teenage symphony to God€, and was meant to evoke themes as diverse as the American frontier and the four natural elements, seemed totally bizarre to the rest of the band. Mike Love in particular, the serial villain of the Beach Boys story, hated it. He aggressively questioned lyric writer Van Dyke Parks about what his words meant, and in a famous, yet possibly paraphrased, quote, told Brian €œdon€™t f**k with the formula!€ The formula was surfing, cars and girls, and SMiLE had none of the first two, and only a smattering of the latter. Love thought that omitting them would alienate many of their biggest fans. This was not the first time Love had strongly objected to what Brian wanted to make €“ he called Pet Sounds €œego music€ €“ but in the past compromises had been reached. On SMiLE, Love€™s pressurising of Brian would eventually contribute to the collapse of the whole project.

6. Brian Wilson Was Taking Too Many Drugs

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6OgTeInrUNM Brian Wilson once claimed that he wrote the famous riff of California Girls during his first acid trip. That was in early 1965, but a year later his drug use was starting to have less positive effects. To prepare for the writing and recording of SMiLE he bought $2,000 worth of marijuana, and a hefty batch of LSD. This was on top of the amphetamines he had been prescribed and took every day. A Playboy article about the author Thomas Pynchon gives an insight into the chaos that this drug intake created around Brian. Meeting for the first time, Pynchon was so dumb-struck by Brian€™s repeated and failed attempts to light an oil lamp fashioned from a parking meter that they never talked. Later they tried to go the studio where SMiLE was being recorded but were refused entry because one of Pynchon€™s friends €œwas a witch and f***ing with Brian€™s head so heavy by ESP that he couldn€™t work.€ As the pressures of the album grew, so did the drug taking, and before long, instead of continuing work on SMiLE, Brian would rather spend days in bed, smoking cannabis and eating candy.

5. Carl Wilson Was Drafted Into The Army

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fjxK9ojmAT8 Carl, the youngest of the three Wilson brothers, was the most naturally gifted singer in the Beach Boys, and his soaring falsetto vocals made many of their songs. Though an infrequent lead singer in their early days, his vocals on Pet Sounds€™ track God Only Knows opened the door for more opportunities to take a more central role. He sang lead vocals on four of the songs from SMiLE, but his involvement would arguably have been much greater were it not for a protracted legal struggle which would have consequences for the whole band and project. In 1966, Carl was drafted by the US Army to serve in Vietnam, and ordered to report for duty in January of the following year. 1967 came around, but he refused to honour the draft, sparking a long court battle. He justified his refusal to join up by claiming to be a conscientious objector, but lodged his objections too late. He was charged with draft evasion and arrested in New York before a concert in April 1967. Though these charges were later dropped, he was still ordered to do community service, something he also didn't turn up for. He was again charged, and the legal problems would drag out right up to the summer of 1971. By this time, the SMiLE had project had been dead for four years, Brian€™s involvement in the band was minimal, and Carl would soon become its de-facto leader.

4. They Were Suing Their Record Label At The Same Time

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RSTJJKffsPI In October 1966, The Beach Boys released Good Vibrations, the €œpocket symphony€ that Art Garfunkel called €œTHE greatest, MOST creative record of them all." Such was the success of that song that soon after NME readers voted the Beach Boys the most popular group in the world - more popular than even the Beatles, who at the time were at the height of their powers. The Beach Boys expected this renewed success to be reflected in increased earnings, and when that didn€™t happen, they got suspicious. The band believed that their record label Capitol was withholding royalties worth $225,000, so in March of 1967 they asked to terminate their contract. Shortly after that, Capitol announced a settlement had been reached, and allowed The Beach Boys to set up their own imprint label, Brother Records to release their music through. But the new label became dormant almost immediately, and Capitol reasserted control, leading to the Beach Boys suing them. This lawsuit, which dragged on and on, and the troubles surrounding the new label were unneeded distractions for Brian Wilson at time when he above all needed focus. Capitol were also heavily-promoting the unfinished album, and as the pressure from all sides grew and grew, Brian eventually found it too much.

3. The Man Who Wrote The Album€™s Lyrics Quit Halfway Through

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ptxwWt2JeGQ Prior to Pet Sounds, Mike Love had been the Beach Boys€™ primary lyricist, and what he wrote centred around surfing, cars and girls. But for Pet Sounds, Brian Wilson wanted a clean break from their past sound, and to work with someone new, someone he hadn€™t collaborated with before. He chose copywriter Tony Asher, who listened to some of the instrumental tracks, wrote You Still Believe In Me, and was instantly hired for the whole album. For SMiLE though, Brian brought in another new collaborator, the budding composer Van Dyke Parks. The two had been introduced by David Crosby in 1965, and Parks€™ unique manner of speaking so enthralled Brian that he quickly asked Parks to help with SMiLE. Initially things went well, but the friction between Brian and the other Beach Boys who didn€™t understand some of the lyrics soon pushed a wedge between the collaborators. In the end that pressure, coupled with all the other madness surrounding the project, got too much for Parks. He became increasingly apprehensive around Brian, and more and more frustrated with Love€™s scepticism over his lyrics. He quit SMiLE in April 1967, saying he didn€™t want to be responsible for adding tensions to the band. In a 2013 interview, he described the project he had left as a €œshambles€.

2. Brian Wilson€™s Mental Health Was Declining

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=31pCY1uDRzY As the sixties progressed and the success of the Beach Boys grew, Brian Wilson€™s mental health declined. He placed his piano in a sandpit in his house, and had a giant tent put up in his living room He became convinced that Phil Spector and his father, Murry, were both spying on him, and as a result he insisted on holding business meetings in his swimming pool in the middle of the night. His paranoia most famously took hold during the recording of the €œFire€ section of SMiLE. After lighting a small blaze in the studio to enhance the song€™s vibe, he became convinced that the music they were recording was responsible for starting a number of actual fires in the immediate neighbourhood. He started hearing voices €“ LSD-induced auditory hallucinations €“ and at one point he even called these his €œheroes and villains€, possibly in reference to the SMiLE song and 1967 Single. His mental health was also not helped by hearing Strawberry Fields Forever, from Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. It€™s said he heard the song while driving, pulled over and told his friend Michael Vosse that The Beatles had €œgot there first€. He started to believe that SMiLE could never top what The Beatles had already done, so why bother finishing it?

1. SMiLE Was Just Too Far Ahead Of Its Time

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdt0SOqPJcg The thing that probably did for SMiLE more than anything else was that it was so far ahead of its time. With the technology on offer in the mid-1960s, it was almost impossible to realise Brian Wilson€™s vision in a way that satisfied him. Phil Spector and his wall of sound production technique hugely influenced Brian, but he took things further. He actively used the studio as an instrument, pushing it to its very limit. A song had never been stitched together from so many fragments in the way Good Vibrations was. It was a stellar leap from Pet Sounds, which itself had been a stellar leap from the Beach Boys€™ previous work. They had even won over one of Brian€™s heroes, Leonard Bernstein. The composer behind West Side Story hosted a CBS TV special in 1967, and on it Brian performed a solo version of Surf€™s Up, one of SMiLE€™s most spectacular songs. Bernstein called Brian €œone of today€™s most important pop musicians€, and called Surf€™s Up €œpoetic, beautiful even in its obscurity€. Had it been released, SMiLE would have been the first major concept album by a commercially successful group. In the end, that honour would go to The Beatles, and Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band.

Contributor
Contributor

A man who writes things.