8 Bizarre Music Collaborations That Were Surprisingly Successful

Talented artists who defied all sense of logic and said, "To hell with it. Let's spend some time together."

Have you ever known two wildly different people who have begun dating, even though all logic and social norms points at this being a recipe for disaster? This couple appears so ridiculously mismatched that you're forced to believe they got together JUST to mess with you? Well, every once in a while, a song featuring two musicians that are basically from different planets hits the charts and garners a very similar reaction from listeners. It€™s not unusual for a pair of musicians--or even a gaggle, if this happens to be a Lady Marmalade type of situation--to test their chemistry by writing a song together. What€™s surprising is just how many of those duos come from completely different backgrounds and genres, with almost no common musical DNA. And even more surprising is how many of those ridiculously conceived collaborations go on to become iconic pieces of pop culture history. Rappers and rock stars, guitarists and DJs, wistful crooners and angry growlers: eventually, they end up in the same room together and get the idea to put a record together. Over time, the results have been middling to horrifying. But the law of averages suggests that sometimes, against all odds, a few of these oddball combinations will actually turn into something magnificent. Here are the artists who defied all sense of logic and said, "To hell with it. Let's spend some time together."

8. Moby And Gwen Stefani - "South Side"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uBTyrKLlVwc On paper, the teaming of techno geek Moby and the midriff-bearing semi-punkster Gwen Stefani appeared to be the result of a bored 12-year-old playing around with daddy's mixing equipment. "I should layer the hot girl's whiny vocals over top of those creepy industrial beats," the precocious little tween might've said. And somehow, it sounded like a real song. A really good song, actually. Considering Stefani hadn't yet done any solo work, it was a risky proposition removing her from the ska punk confines of No Doubt and pairing her with a virtually unknown electronica artist. The timing was simply perfect, however, as Return of Saturn, the follow-up to No Doubt's immensely popular breakthrough album Tragic Kingdom, had just cemented Stefani as the poster girl for rebellious punk chicks (even if her punk credibility was a little...manufactured). Since this was still technically the 90s, and the 90s were all about celebrating weirdness for weirdness' sake, "South Side" ate up the US and Canadian Charts. And it turned Moby's brand of techno trip hop into the soundtrack of everyone's Y2K fears, making Moby a household name almost overnight. Of course, his name vanished from the commercial public's collective consciousness almost immediately. But still, "South Side" made more of a mark than it really had any right to. Stefani would later go on to have another oddly successful collaboration with rapper Eve (2001's "Let Me Blow Ya Mind"), while Moby went on to constantly be mistaken for Dr. Bunsen from The Muppet Show.

7. Santana And Michelle Branch - "The Game of Love"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKLnmMacEB4 Carlos Santana had just tasted success for the first time in decades by pairing up with post-grunge enthusiast and butt-rock pioneer Rob Thomas for the mega-hit "Smooth," which subsequently gave him his best-selling album (1999's Supernatural). But aside from more money and fame, what could have inspired the legendary latin guitarist to sink so low as to team up with every mediocre pop star of the day for his follow-up album, Shaman? Oh, it was just the money and fame? Okay then. Santana seemingly picked through the charts for anyone that kids those days liked to bop around to. The results are mixed, with contributions from Dido, Macy Gray, and even the king of butt-rock Chad Kroeger. But the most surprisingly wonderful collaboration came from the moderately folksy, mostly cutesy singer-songwriter Michelle Branch. The saccharine ode to the games we play in love, aptly titled "The Game of Love," might have been dripping with the passionless sentimentality, but it certainly won over the hearts of the listening public as well as the music industry, earning the unlikely duo a Grammy. The guitar playing is tight and on-point, and though Michelle Branch isn't much of a powerhouse vocalist, she's certainly a better compliment to the light, bluesy Santana sound than Rob Thomas' herniated grunting sounds.

6. Jay-Z And Linkin Park - "Numb/Encore"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DLlF2FMv968 One of the few nu-metal acts of the 2000s boon to make it out alive (or at least with a little bit of dignity), Linkin Park were always more adept at the rap-rock cross-pollination than their peers. That's probably because they actually knew how to incorporate rap. Whereas acts like Limp Bizkit and Korn had frontmen with a style one could generously describe as "kinda sorta rap-like," Linkin Park had an honest-to-goodness emcee in Mike Shinoda. With that credibility at play, it wasn't so crazy to think that a mash-up with Jay-Z could work. Two rappers on the microphone, trading off lines, complimenting each other's styles? With the slickest hard rock production available? That's gold! But that's not the way they went with "Numb/Encore," the only track anyone still remembers from the Collision Course EP. Strangely, Shinoda is relegated to the background here, only occasionally throwing in a "yeah" or "uh huh" like a second-rate P. Diddy. But the emcee swap-out worked pretty well, as the song hit every Billboard chart the US had to offer and nearing the top 10 in the UK.

5. Nelly And Tim McGraw - "Over and Over"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3htOCjafTc Whether or not you were a fan of popular country or Southern hip hop in 2004 (or rather inexplicably, both), chances are good that you remember hearing this strangely entrancing duet on the radio and not being able to turn it off. It wasn't necessarily that you wanted to listen, but you needed to, because this is the type of thing that typically precedes warnings about an impending apocalypse. Up until then, Nelly was best known the emcee with a slight drawl who wore Air Force Ones and liked it to be Hot in Herre, whereas Tim McGraw was, well, basically the exact opposite of Nelly. The combination was like mixing chocolate and jam: puzzling to think about, but too interesting to immediately spit out. To be fair, this wasn't so much a mixture of country and hip hop as it was a straight-ahead pop song with some twang and a good beat. Both musicians toned down their respective roots--there are no mentions of trucks or sneakers to be found--compromising on a sound that wouldn't alienate either fan base. The results made it apparent this was the right call, hitting number 1 on the UK charts. Unfortunately, it also inspired many more rap/country hybrids, ultimately claiming responsibility for Nelly's attempt to recreate the magic with Florida Georgia Line down the road. So its legacy is iffy at best.

4. Foo Fighters And Norah Jones - "Virginia Moon"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fGSzPwUXees Is there anything Dave Grohl can't do? Seriously. The guy apparently has no limitations on his knack for awesomeness. Just look at the list: Drummer for the biggest alternative band of the 90s (possibly of all time). Singer/guitarist for the most consistent hard rock group of the new millennium. Performed with a Beatle (who isn't Ringo). Created a supergroup with members of Queens of the Stone Age AND LED ZEPPELIN! Created a DIFFERENT supergroup that featured Lemmy from Motörhead. Played drums with comedy rock duo Tenacious D. Given the vast and varied number of collaborations listed above, you might be surprised to see Grohl's name show up on this list at all. But if you paid attention to the title of this entry, you'll have noticed this particular collaboration isn't with a rock and roll legend--or a rock and roll anything, for that matter. It's a bossa nova duet with sweet and soulful Norah Jones. While the Foo frontman was no stranger to softening things up a bit (listen to the incredibly underrated "Aurora" from There Is Nothing Left to Lose), in 2005 he decided to completely ditch the hard rock formula and go all-acoustic for one half of the Foo's double-album, In Your Honour. One of those softer tunes, "Virginia Moon," found Grohl and Jones trying to out-mellow each other, resulting in a jazzy, lounge style duet. Grohl provides the subtle acoustic guitar work and breathy vocals while Jones puts in the subtle piano and breathy female vocals. It's all quite subtle and breathy. It's one of the biggest stylistic detours the Foos have ever taken, which also makes it one of the most exciting. And it no doubt pushed the band to take more chances in the future, proving that Foo Fighters don't have to be playing loud guitars with their manhood pushed to the forefront at all times.

3. Kanye West And Bon Iver - "Lost In The World"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofaRvNOV4SI By most accounts, Kanye West's innovative My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasty was the bold push forward hip-hop needed in 2010. Rather than emphasizing hit singles, West aimed for a tight, cohesive album, adding a dash of grandiose to every track along the way. Seriously, the guy was churning out 9-minute rap epics like this album was supposed to be the soundtrack to a urban version of The Lord of the Rings. With all its innovations, the one commonality West shared with his peers was in piling on the guest vocalists. This album contains more guest stars than an average season of The Simpsons, using them to diversify his sonic palate and turn every song into something crazier than the last. But the most unexpected addition to Yeezy's collaborators was Justin Vernon, the founding member and vocalist of indie folk group Bon Iver. Vernon was best known in 2010, if at all, as a softly sung troubadour whose music could easily put a mosh pit to sleep. What was he doing on a Kanye West album, especially one so aggressive and harsh in its sound? To put it bluntly, he was helping make the strongest song on Kanye's strongest album to date. "Lost in the World" doesn't just borrow Vernon's voice, but also a sample from Bon Iver's "Woods." Unbelievably, Yeezy claims to have been a fan of the group's first LP, For Emma, Forever Ago and their overall aesthetic, which explains why he invited the singer to lend his Auto-Tuned vocals to the track. The extensive collaboration, recorded in a tiny studio in Hawaii, opens with a full 60 seconds of uninterrupted a cappella from Vernon before erupting with all the thunderous bass West had at his disposal. It goes from melancholic to glorious triumph at the flick of a switch and is nothing short of a masterpiece. Plus, Kanye has called this "one of the greatest pieces of writing." Ever. And for once, he may not be speaking in hyperbole.

2. Eminem And Dido - "Stan"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOMhN-hfMtY Eminem certainly wasn't the first rapper to sample a chorus from a pop song, but "Stan" can claim bragging rights for incorporating Dido's verse from "Thank You" so seamlessly that you'd have thought she wrote the part especially for Eminem. Prior to the release of "Stan," Eminem was best known as the goofy white rapper who gave himself the nickname Slim Shady and occasionally rhymed about disposing of his ex-wife's corpse while his infant daughter watched. Contrast that with Dido, the angelic voiced singer-songwriter who sang about feeling so sad after a breakup that she didn't want to get out of bed, and you've got yourself quite an odd couple. To simply call it a dichotomy would be like calling a minotaur "a peculiar thing to see at the supermarket." The song's refrain is what ultimately made this tale of Eminem's obsessive, suicidal admirer so accessible. Without that little bit of softness, four verses about a deranged fan emulating the most grotesque portions of Eminem's discography to impress his idol might be a bit much for causal listeners to sit through. And yet, "Stan" went on to become one of the most successful rap songs of all time, climbing to the top of the UK charts and cementing Eminem's legacy as a serious rap artist with skills beyond rhyming about ripping Pamela Anderson's breasts off.

1. Aerosmith And Run-D.M.C. - "Walk This Way"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4B_UYYPb-Gk The original rap-rock mash-up, "Walk This Way" quite literally directed legions of hip hop heads and wannabe rock stars down the path to quality coalescence. "Walk this way," they said, gyrating their pelvises and swinging their gold chains, "and you'll be able to tap into two of the most divergent markets in the music industry at the same time." The crossover was equal parts rock mojo and hip hop flow, taking the best and most genuine parts of both worlds at a time when hair metal was all about the glamour (and not so much about the musicianship) and hip hop was still finding its footing. "Walk This Way" not only reinvigorated the dying, lifeless carcass of Aerosmith, but it gave Run-D.M.C. the opportunity to leave a huge imprint on the world of hip hop, defining its sound for years to come. Everything on the song worked, from the legendary vocal back-and-forth between the two emcees to Steven Tyler's cocksure delivery on the chorus. The instrumentation relied heavily on the original Joe Perry riff, but Jam Master Jay was also given some time to shine, tossing in a bit of record scratching, which was completely foreign to rock audiences at the time. Run-D.M.C. would go on to use heavy guitar riffs as a basis for a few other songs, like "King of Rock" and "Tougher Than Leather," but it never worked quite as well as it did on "Walk This Way." Still, it made electric guitars popular outside of mainstream rock, heavily influencing two of Michael Jackson's biggest songs, "Beat It" and "Black or White." It's nearly impossible to explain just how much this collaboration influenced pop music. The song became bigger than any of the individuals involved. It was a smash on the charts, but this is one instance where those numbers are completely underwhelming when compared to the legacy the song has left behind. To paraphrase Steven Tyler, those boys really "knew what they were doin'."

Watch Next


In this post: 
Eminem Dido
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.