9 Rock Bands Who Hate Their Own Famous Songs

It seems that everyone is a fan of these greats songs... except the bands who made them.

Music is a funny industry. Some acts, bands and musicians will spend their entire lives investing energy into achieving fame, and a lot of the time they hate the very material which eventually gives it to them. The love/hate relationship between bands and their most famous songs is a widespread tale almost as old as the entity of modern era pop culture itself.

Time and time again, we see famous musicians slating their own hard work and material for various reasons, in favour of other less known or appreciated pieces they have contributed to. This irks a plethora of emotions from fans: some resonate with the belief of the artists, especially if they're well-known for one particular song when they have plenty of other great songs in their catalogue. Meanwhile, others criticise musicians over their stance, saying they should acknowledge the popularity of these songs and give the fans what they want to hear.

Regardless of which side of the discussion you reside on, the fact of the matter is this disparity between musicians and their material seems like it will never end. In this article, we will look at nine rock songs which are absolutely hated by the musicians who created them.

9. Foo Fighters - All My Life

Few people in rock music history can claim to have been in even one generation-defining band, which is what makes Dave Grohl being in two so impressive. Even though Nirvana had more drummers than albums in their time, Dave Grohl was the man behind the kit for their breakthrough record, 'Nevermind' and their final album 'In Utero'. Following Kurt Cobain's death, Grohl went on to form Foo Fighters and the rest is history.

While Foo Fighters have a number of exceptionally famous songs such as 'Everlong', 'The Pretender' and 'Learn to Fly' to their name, 'All My Life' has become an outlying entity in the eyes of Grohl. Grohl's distaste isn't limited to the 'All My Life' single though, and instead extends to the entire 'One By One' album.

When interviewed by Billboard, Grohl said. "It didn’t sound like the band does live. It didn’t feel right." He then continued to say that "we were making an album that wasn’t working" and called the sound of the final product "unfamiliar".

However, Foo Fighters continue to play 'All My Life' and other songs from 'One By One' live, showing that you can still play songs live even if you don't like them.


8. Cane Hill - French 75

As a song that sticks out like a sore thumb compared to the rest of Cane Hill's back catalogue, it isn't hugely surprising to learn that the band absolutely hate this song.

Founded in 2011, the Louisianan alternative metal band have wasted no time in excelling towards the upper reaches of the sub-genre. Building an impressive reputation in their local scene through a string of booming live shows, Cane Hill capitalised on their hype with the release of a self-titled debut EP in 2015, shortly after signing with Rise Records. Comprised of seven songs, this compact, concise and crushing release blew metal fans away on an international scale with its fresh, fiery sound.

However, song number five, 'French 75', seemed like it had been left on the final mix of the EP by accident, as it adopted an almost alien style compared to the other six devastating tracks. Deviating from the brutal basslines and vicious vocals, 'French 75' was a warped alternative track with a much calmer focus. It seems the band weren't too keen on the song from day one, and their opinions haven't improved much since.

'French 75' is the butt of many jokes from the Cane Hill fanbase, who are generally encouraged by the band's open begrudgement and ridiculing of the song. Cane Hill do not play 'French 75' live and take any opportunity possible to distance themselves from this avoidable outlier.


7. Paramore - Misery Business

While other bands on this list simply hate their songs because they are horrifically overplayed and steal the spotlight from their other releases, Paramore's relationship with 'Misery Business' is much more complicated.

Featuring on the Tennessee based band's second studio album, 'Riot!', 'Misery Business' remains the group's most well-known song, despite tough competition being offered up by 'That's What You Get', 'Still Into You' and 'Ignorance'.

Released as the lead single for 'Riot!' in 2007, this single spearheaded what would become the band's breakthrough album, setting up the foundations for a phenomenally successful career which is still going strong today. However, Paramore pulled the song from their live setlist in 2018, saying that the lyrics were "anti-feminist" and that "it shouldn’t be used to promote anything having to do with female empowerment or solidarity".

After spending four years on the shelf, the band's biggest hit made a surprise return to the world of live music on 2nd October 2022 for their show in California. Even though the song is back in action, the controversy surrounding the nature of the lyrics persists.


6. Deaf Havana - Friends Like These

Being one of the lesser known bands on this list, the UK's Deaf Havana will likely be a new name to a lot of readers.

Having formed in 2005, 'Friends Like These' was the lead single from the band's debut album and was unleashed onto the world in 2009. In the grand scheme of things, the single hardly made a splash, but it was impactful enough to cause a stir in the UK underground rock scene. Almost overnight, Deaf Havana had established themselves as a strong name for the future of British rock, but their feelings towards the song which allowed this to happen were always mixed.

As years went by, the members of the band started to distance themselves from the song, and the genre of crossover post-hardcore as a whole. Their second album, 'Fools and Worthless Liars', marked a sudden transition into soft rock, adopting a much more approachable sound compared to their prior hard-hitting style.

During the opening song of said album, 'The Past Six Years', the following lyrics can be heard in reference to 'Friends Like These':

Because I made plans of being more than just that band

Who had that song about friends and not much else

Not only were Deaf Havana feeling creatively contained by their label at the time, but they also had growing fears of becoming a 'one hit wonder', like so many other bands who burst onto the scene. Deaf Havana now have six studio albums to their name, with the latest being 'The Present is a Foreign Land'.


5. Bon Jovi - Livin On A Prayer

At this stage, it would be safe to argue that Bon Jovi's most famous hit is probably more famous than the band themselves. Credited with bringing rock and glam metal to a mainstream audience, Bon Jovi have forged a formidable path as an important rock band through the decades, with a fair portion of this influence being generated by their 1986 megahit, 'Livin on a Prayer'.

Appearing on their third and most commercially successful record, 'Slippery When Wet', the song has gone on to become one of the most famous rock songs ever with 15 platinum certifications as a single, 15 million physical sales as part of 'Slippery When Wet' and earning over 1 billion Spotify streams.

However, the band never expected it to be this successful and weren't even sure they liked it when it was first recorded. When talking to the Irish Times, Jon Bon Jovi recalled that his initial reaction to hearing the final mix for the first time was "Eh, it’s okay." On the other hand, bandmate Richie Sambora saw its potential immediately, and called Bon Jovi an "idiot" for not liking it upon his first listen.


4. The Who - Pinball Wizard

As the undisputed faces of the mod-rock movement, The Who are without doubt one of the most famous and influential bands of all time. Famous tunes of theirs include 'My Generation', 'Baba O'Riley', 'Behind Blue Eyes' and the song in question here, 'Pinball Wizard'.

The Who originally formed in 1964 and are currently on their fifth stint as an active band following break-ups in 1983, 1985, 1991 and 1997. Despite their unimaginable success over the past six decades, founding member Pete Townshend has expressed his grievances towards their 1969 hit. Townshend admitted that he only wrote 'Pinball Wizard' to gain favourable reviews from music critics and said he was "embarrassed" to have written it.

In an interview years later, Townshend said his initial reaction to writing the song was "Oh my God, this is awful". Adding to Townshend's impatience and hatred towards the song is the fact it's been featured in almost every live show by The Who for the past 50 years. If Deaf Havana got sick of 'Friends Like These' after two years, just imagine how The Who feel after 50.


3. Kings Of Leon - Sex On Fire

A tragic tale for fans of the band and rock as a whole, the rise and demise of Kings of Leon was a sight to behold. One minute, the band of brothers were the indie sweethearts of America's alternative scene; the next they were possibly the most hated band on the entire planet. But how did it happen?

Before picking up major stardom thanks to the international superhit, 'Sex on Fire', Kings of Leon had built a respectable reputation as plucky upstarts with a trifecta of great albums: 'Youth & Young Manhood' (2003), 'Aha Shake Heartbreak' (2004) and 'Because of the Times' (2007). But their fourth album, 'Only By the Night', marked an abrupt and immediate shift towards a mainstream market, spearheaded by one of the 21st century's biggest rock hits.

Despite the success 'Sex on Fire' brought the band, vocalist Caleb Followill has constantly expressed his disdain towards the megahit. He stated that the band didn't even want to include the song on the album because they hated it so much. Drummer Nathan Followill also admitted in a 2014 interview with The Sun that he was "sick and tired" of playing it, adding:

I would be pretty damn happy if my sex was never ever on fire again.

The subsequent tour was a disaster for the band, with the members constantly fighting and walking off stage during shows. Although they enjoyed the fame it brought, Kings of Leon have never truly recovered from 'Sex on Fire'.


2. Panic! At The Disco - I Write Sins Not Tragedies

Having gone through a number of transitional styles, appearances and line-ups over the years, Brendon Urie admits that Panic! at the Disco is effectively a solo project at this point. It wasn't always that way though, as Panic! initially formed as a band in 2004. Over time, members have gradually moved onto new things leaving Urie to work independently under the Panic! name.

Urie has collaborated with a number of high profile singers and artists throughout his career, but 'I Write Sins Not Tragedies' definitely remains his most well-known song. Initially released in 2005 as part of the then-band's debut album, 'A Fever You Can't Sweat Out', this hit single has become a staple feature of the alternative music scene.

Although the song has enjoyed great success, Urie was filmed at a live Panic! show years ago telling fans "Goddammit, I’m f*cking tired of this song". In interviews since this remark, Urie has reiterated that he actually doesn't hate the song, claiming his remark was a joke and conceded that "obviously, my humour doesn’t hit."


1. Radiohead - Creep

It's unlikely that anyone reading this is surprised to learn which song occupies the top spot on this list. Like many bands who have appeared thus far, Radiohead's frustration with 'Creep' tends to stem from the fact it sponges attention away from their other songs, which in the band's eyes are just as good, if not better.

'Creep' hasn't been a regular feature of Radiohead live shows since 1997, with the song making less than a dozen setlist appearances in the last 25 years. When questioned about the song by fans, Yorke simply replied "F*ck off, we’re tired of it" during the press run for 'OK Computer' in 1997. In response to the backlash of refusing to play it, Thom Yorke branded fans who wanted to hear it played live "r*tarded".

Thom Yorke's dislike for the song is so extreme, that he re-released a version of 'Creep' in 2021 which was intentionally bad, in an attempt to make people hate the song as much as he does. Unfortunately for Yorke, his effort was in vain and 'Creep' remains an all-time melancholic classic.


In this post: 
Radiohead
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Hi everyone, I'm a signed author and journalist. Despite my main area of expertise being rock music, I have an interest in loads of other subjects like films, TV series, sports and of course, wrestling.