Metallica: 10 Best Songs AFTER St. Anger
The 2000s and beyond era of Metallica. What are the best tracks?
The legendary Metallica have had a career that is easy to compartmentalise.
Their classic period up until their self-titled 1991 album ('The Black Album') and after this are distinct and oftentimes have a differing fanbase. Beyond that we have the controversial St. Anger, which was ripped apart by fans for such a divisive stylistic change. A conscious decision to not have any guitar solos was also puzzling, along with their overall move closer to alternative metal.
After 2003, Metallica embarked on a journey of musical discovery and have found their modern identity. This new signature sound encompasses all their previous sounds and lessons they've learned in a lengthy career. While some will always deride the group for daring to change their image and style so much, their more recent output still has a huge following.
Metallica have only released two studio albums since the contentious St. Anger period, but in that time have produced several standout tracks. It feels as though the group have found themselves and are comfortable in their legacy.
Here are some of the best songs Metallica have committed to record since the end of the St. Anger album cycle.
10. Dream No More
From the opening notes the tone is set. This is a dark, heavy song. It burns slow and is a complete throwback to the likes of The Thing That Should Not Be and Sad But True.
Affectionately dubbed by some fans as 'Sad But Two', this song is a combination of their 1980s and 1990s output and is greater than the sum of it's parts. Musically it's absolutely reminiscent of Sad But True from their classic self-titled album, more famously known as 'The Black Album'. The slow, chugging riffage is certainly inspired by Black Sabbath legend Tony Iommi. Lyrically, Dream No More harkens back to The Thing That Should Not Be with its H.P. Lovecraft influence.
Besides its excellent composition, one of the standout facets of the song is James Hetfield's energised bark. The vocalist sounds as aggressive as ever which is impressive considering the band's longevity.
Dream No More is a great modernisation of an older sound and it belongs on more of the band's setlists when they return to touring.
9. The Unforgiven III
The Unforgiven III is perhaps a controversial entry on this list. It proves to be divisive among the Metallica fanbase. Musically it has little in common with the previous two entries, although the lyrical content matches the same overarching theme of forgiveness.
Despite any fair criticism it remains a wonderfully well-composed piece of music. The main guitar riff is one of the most memorable the band have produced this side of the millennium. The slow build in the second half of the song leads to a roaring vocal from James Hetfield, which acts as a powerful lead in to one of Kirk Hammett's absolute best guitar solos since the Load and Reload duo of albums.
The string arrangements heard throughout the piece are tasteful and add to the already-epic feel of the song. The lyrics cap off this trilogy of songs with Hetfield pondering if the protagonist can forgive themselves after many misdeeds. This raw song strongly stands up next to it's two predecessors.
8. Moth Into Flame
Moth Into Flame is one of the more anthemic songs of Metallica's more recent albums and quickly became a live favourite. All the crucial Metallica elements are present to create a modern staple of any setlist.
The guitar work is excellent and varied, morphing from muscular guitar riffing into Iron Maiden-inspired lead guitar sections. There are structural changes found throughout the song. It moves from middle and fast tempos quickly, to a compelling middle section that is liable to leave you humming. The lyrical inspiration comes from an unlikely place. Amy Winehouse and her tragic passing served as the heart of the subject matter, used by the band as an allegory of the dangers that come with fame and fortune.
Moth Into Flame is truly one of Metallica's modern live favourites. It's easy to foresee this retaining its status as a mainstay of live sets even into the next touring cycles when they have new material to show off. Perhaps not the Enter Sandman of this generation, but the closest we may get to it with an aged Metallica.
7. All Nightmare Long
All Nightmare Long started life during the St. Anger sessions. This is somewhat surprising considering the general sonic style the band achieved with it. It goes to show that some of the material they had at the time could have been great given the right treatment.
This is a monolith of metal from the band's Death Magnetic album. The main charging riff drives the song forward. Throughout the song we are treated to thumping, fast sections featuring blistering soloes from Kirk Hammett. This is atypical of modern Metallica in that it contains many different riffs, sections and is overall a long song at nearly 8 minutes in length. The lyrics delve into Cthulhu fiction once again, detailing the Hounds of Tindalos. These inescapable creatures hunt through nightmares.
In what has become a sad trend, All Nightmare Long rarely shows up at Metallica's live shows despite it being one of their best modern songs. It was heavily featured when the band were touring in support of Death Magnetic but has since faded into obscurity to some degree.
This chunk of heavy metal remains one of their best modern offerings.
6. Now That We're Dead
Now this is a Metallica anthem for modern times. Its hard not to tap your feet to this triumphant-feeling song.
Perhaps obviously the song details love existing beyond life and through death eternally. For such a dark-tinged song, Metallica have rarely sounded s confident and upbeat in their output. The chorus alone is one of the catchiest pieces of music the band have crafted in a long time. The main guitar riff is chunky, powerful and hook-laden. This is a great example of the band creating a catchy song without compromising their signature metal sound. Now That We're Dead is not the heaviest of their output but it never needed to be on an album like Hardwired.. to Self-Destruct.
Live performances of the songs have become commonplace at Metallica live shows. The percussive, slow-burn intro seems to resonate wonderfully with fans and is guaranteed to get people moving and singing along.
Not quite heavy and not quite soft, this is Metallica sounding their best in a moderate context.
5. That Was Just Your Life
In this seven minute Death Magnetic opening track, Metallica loudly announced to the world of music that they were back creating heavy, thrash-inspired music.
The heartbeat intro symbolises their resurgence and a return to making music they love. The furious riffing could have spawned from Master of Puppets, ...And Justice for All or any of their 1980s albums. Its clear that the band were inspired by their own early-career output and it shows. Fast guitar riffs, James Hetfield barking about soldiers returning from war, and a more solid drumming effort from Lars Ulrich than we have become accustomed to, Metallica were back.
This bold proclamation of a song has seemingly faded from the consciousness of fans but back in 2008 it was very much the opposite. That Was Just Your Life heralded a partial return to the Metallica of old. Their newer music doesn't all sound like this but it shows a band who are no longer afraid to take on their older style, one that made them the legends they are today.
4. The Day That Never Comes
They say that imitation is the greatest form of flattery. We see that on full display with The Day That Never Comes. This is a love letter of sorts to their classic track One, featuring similar style and structure.
This is very much a song of two halves. The first section of the song spotlights a chiming, melodic guitar and overall calmer pace. This gives plenty room for James Hetfield and his signature vocals to tackle the subject of war. As the song progresses we hear slow changes with some heavier guitar riffs seeping in. Before long The Day That Never Comes evolves into a fast-paced, thrash-light song. There are some complex changes and progression found on the song with a great lead guitar pieces that are evocative of the Diamond Head classic Am I Evil?.
Metallica's reverence for their earlier work is on full display here. They emulated a formula that worked before at a time when they most needed it and it worked out excellently. While not exactly a mainstay of their live performances, the song receives some attention occasionally at gigs. Most recently it was a highlight of the group's S&M2 concerts and fit in perfectly with the symphonic additions.
3. Halo On Fire
Halo On Fire is a song that deals with the duality of good and bad that exists within us all. This subject is perfectly represented by the instrumentation of the song.
One on hand we see a melodic, restrained piece in the verses. Its quiet and unassuming at first. As we reach the chorus it quickly gets loud. Led by a doom-inspired main riff, James Hetfield takes the vocals up a notch and replaces his hushed tones with a louder shout. The true hook of the song comes in the last quarter. Following a quiet lead in, Kirk Hammett plays an amazingly simple yet emotive lead guitar piece with Hetfield vocalising over the top of it. In this section he sings of the protagonist rising to meet their own darkness and turning their back on it.
It's a powerful piece of song writing that is simple and effective. The final few minutes of the songs show modern Metallica at their best, displaying a style that has been amalgamated from their exploration of several different styles over their long career.
2. Hardwired
If you wanted the Metallica of old on full display then this is it. Hardwired is the opening track from 2016's Hardwired... to Self-Destruct and it is three minutes of full on thrash mastery.
It has been a long time since Metallica sounded so angry and energised. Every constituent part of Hardwired is honed perfectly. The guitars are fast and messy, and the drums are a cut above what we've been used to hearing from Lars Ulrich. The bass is tight and creates a frenetic backbone of the song and with the vocals we hear a furious Hetfield. The song deals with humanity's propensity to keep f*****g things up and the state of the world we live in as a result.
For the remainder of Metallica's career its not a bold claim to expect to see this on most of their setlists. The perfect opener or first song of the encore, Hardwired will get a live audience headbanging and moving without fail.
1. Spit Out The Bone
This is a song written and recorded completely out of time for Metallica. If Spit Out the Bone was a part of Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets or ... And Justice for All it would have been hailed as one of their greatest songs ever.
This is seven minutes of pure unadulterated heavy metal fury. It's pace is nonstop fast with one of the few moments of reprieve being a bass solo from the incomparable Robert Trujillo. Spit Out the Bone is uncompromising and features a viciousness we have not heard from Metallica since the late 1980s. The lyrics delve into transhumanist fantasy and how our reliance on technology may betray us some day.
Spit Out the Bone is Metallica's modern masterpiece. Its hard to find an old school fan who dislikes the song. Even the most ardent of detractors cannot deny that this is not only a return to form but a redemption of sorts. The band have experienced various discordant periods during their existence and they once again seem confident in what they're doing. One would hope they chose to close this album with this song as an indicator of what to expect from their next record.
Let's hope they can stay the course.
Watch Next
Metallica Quiz: Can You Name These 10 Things Only Die Hard Fans Would Know