Paramore: Every Album Ranked Worst To Best

They're in the business of music, let's take it from the top...

The Farro brothers, Josh and Zac, formed Paramore in 2004 along with the band’s frontwoman Hayley Williams. The band have gone through multiple line-up changes throughout their sixteen-year existence, but currently consist of founding members Zac Farro and Williams, as well as fellow high school friend Taylor York, who joined the band in 2007.

Paramore found success early on in their careers after the release of their debut album ‘All We Know Is Falling’ and have gone on to release a total of five albums.

The band is currently on hiatus while Hayley Williams focuses on her solo career. Her debut solo album, ‘Petals For Armor’, was released earlier this month to largely favourable reviews. Fellow Paramore band members have been supportive of Williams’ new endeavour with York producing the album and Zac directing some of her music videos.

Williams recently told NME that Paramore will return with more albums in the future and said that the band’s next release could see them return to more of a pop-punk sound.

Paramore continue to evolve as artists and are not afraid to experiment with different music genres, something that has given each of their five albums their own unique sound. But which album ranks as Paramore’s best release to date?

5. All We Know Is Falling

Paramore’s debut album was released in 2005 with the majority of the line-up still in their early to mid-teens. Lead singer Hayley Williams and Zac Farro were the youngest members of the band and were just sixteen and fourteen respectively during the making of the album.

The album was recorded during a tumultuous time for Paramore, something which would go on to become a common theme for the band, after the departure of bassist Jeremy Davis during the album’s recording process. Davis did eventually rejoin the band before leaving once again in 2015.

With this in mind, as well as the youthful inexperience of the band, it’s quite incredible how strong of an album Paramore were able to produce during this period of their careers. However, the album does pale in comparison to their future releases.

The honest lyrics and impressive songwriting did show some glimpses of what Paramore would go on to become, but when matched up against their subsequent albums, they come across as a band who hadn’t quite yet found their sound. Therefore ‘All We Know Is Falling’ does stand out as Paramore’s most generic sounding album to date.


4. Riot!

Paramore gained more mainstream attention with the release of their sophomore album ‘Riot!’ in 2007.

Their breakout single ‘Misery Business’ catapulted them into the charts and helped them stand out from the pack of emo-punk bands that emerged in the mid to late-2000s, particularly with Hayley Williams’ striking, bright orange hair.

The album as a whole was a strong effort and saw Paramore create a deep connection with their dedicated, loyal fanbase; therefore it may come as a surprise to see it ranked this low. However, the varied music genres explored on the record did make ‘Riot!’ sound a bit disjointed at times and disrupted the flow of the album.

There were definitely high points, with songs such as ‘Fences’ and ‘crushcrushcrush’ standing out in particular, but the overall piece did come across as a young band still experimenting with their sound, which to be fair, they still were at the time.

The follow-up singles to ‘Misery Business’, such as ‘Hallelujah’ and ‘That’s What You Get’, did not find the same level of success and casual fans were left to wonder whether Paramore would just be a flash in the pan. Obviously, history now tells us they were not.


3. Paramore

Following the departure of the Farro brothers in late 2010, the future of Paramore as a band was uncertain. With two of the founding members gone and Hayley Williams making multiple guest vocal appearances on other bands’ tracks, many people thought that Paramore could well be finished.

But then, in 2013, Paramore returned as a three-piece as Hayley, Jeremy Davis and Taylor York released a defiant 17-track album to prove that they were not done yet.

The self-titled album served as a re-introduction to Paramore as they began the next chapter of the band’s existence. A slight departure from the band’s roots, ‘Paramore’ saw the band experiment with a more new wave sound and take influence from everything from funk to pure bubble-gum pop on tracks like ‘Still Into You’.

Although the tracks were arguably more varied in sound than the likes of ‘Riot!’, the seventeen-song album felt more professional and was held together by short ukulele-infused interludes that helped create an easier listening experience.

This was a more mature Paramore that returned with a vengeance to silence any critics and show that they were here to stay.


2. After Laughter

The band’s latest album to date, ‘After Laughter’, was released in 2017 and saw a further departure from their emo, punk roots and delve deeper into a funky, new wave sound with this predominantly synth-pop album.

‘After Laughter’ felt like a reinvention of Paramore, but also felt like an honest album that stayed true enough to the bands established values to prevent any suggestions of selling out.

Another line-up change occurred prior to this album as Jeremy Davis once again departed and founding member Zac Farro returned on drums. It also saw Taylor York’s influence on the album grow, as he was a co-producer on the album.

The new direction that Paramore seem to be heading in after the release of ‘After Laughter’ may have upset some fans that fell in love with the bands early albums, but the critically acclaimed album was a fresh addition to the music charts and helped establish Paramore as one of the most dynamic bands around today.


1. Brand New Eyes

Paramore’s ‘Brand New Eyes’, released in 2009, is the band’s most brutally honest and intriguing album to date and saw them evolve into a much more respected band by critics than they had been prior.

Teaming with legendary producer, Rob Cavallo gained the band a sense of credibility, particularly considering that Cavallo was just coming off the back of producing the incredibly successful ‘American Idiot’ and ‘The Black Parade’ albums for Green Day and My Chemical Romance respectively.

It also saw Paramore produce a more consistent collection of songs that largely dealt with the break-up of Hayley Williams and guitarist Josh Farro. The fact that the former couple had to work together on songs that directly addressed their failed relationship made for a morbidly fascinating interest in their album.

It can’t have been an easy process to create this album, but ‘Brand New Eyes’ contains many of Paramore’s strongest songs to date. From the aggressive and bitter sounds on ‘Ignorance’ to the soft and beautiful ‘The Only Exception’, the album’s eclectic mix of songs help reflect the complex emotions felt in dealing with relationships and break-ups.

‘Brand New Eyes’ marks the final chapter for the original incarnation of Paramore and is their most engaging and impressive collection of songs that the band have produced in their career so far.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Paramore
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Freelance journalist and serial moaner, obsessed with the ludicrous world of professional wrestling.