Radiohead: Every Album Ranked From Worst To Best

Down really is the new up.

There are three things that should not be discussed late at night, when everyone in your group is tired, emotional, and has had a drink or three. The first of these is politics, the second religion, and the third is which album by Radiohead is their best. Because for many, the Oxford band are like a religion, and any criticism of them - constructive or otherwise - can be treated like you'€™ve just nailed a heretical tract to a church door.

Choosing their worst work is a pretty thankless task too, because even a bad Radiohead album is far superior to most other bands€™ good ones. Not to mention the fact that they€™re so enigmatic, a new album could literally be announced any minute, meaning this article could in theory be redundant by the time you'€™ve finished reading it.

But ever the gamblers we'€™re willing to risk the potential double-whammy of fans€™ fury and being gazumped by Thom Yorke and co, to bring you the definitive ranking of Radiohead'€™s eight studio albums, from worst to best.


8. Pablo Honey

Let€™s get this out of the way. Just about every Radiohead fan is going to tell you that their 1993 debut Pablo Honey is their worst record. It€™s not that it€™s necessarily a bad album per se €“ in fact the BBC called it €œone of rock€™s most impressive debuts€ - but it suffers massively from what followed later. Though it birthed one of the band€™s most famous songs in Creep, even that ended up being so despised that it was dropped it from live sets completely in the late 90s, and they haven€™t played it since 2009. That song€™s self-pitying lyrics have become one of its most loved aspects, but these same traits crop up time and time again throughout the album, and it starts to grate. All in all, it sounds like it€™s trying too hard to come across as depressing. Pablo Honey is also formulaic, with very little of the innovation that Radiohead would later become famed for. Anyone new to the band listening to it for the first time would be amazed they became anything beyond one-hit wonders.

7. Hail To The Thief

After the electronic experimentation of Kid A and Amnesiac, Radiohead attempted to go back to their guitar roots for their sixth album, 2003€™s Hail To The Thief. What resulted was a good record barred from greatness by clunky political statements and too many songs that weren€™t up to scratch. The band have even admitted as much, with Ed O€™Brien telling Mojo magazine that they €œshould have pruned it down to 10 songs, then it would have been a really good record€. It€™s also their most imbalanced release. Amongst the attempt to go back to their rock roots, they couldn€™t resist throwing in some of the electronic and jazz flourishes that had crept into their previous work. Whereas before they were melded into the songs seamlessly, on Hail To The Thief they sound crow-barred in. Nigel Godrich once called it more like €œa homogeny of previous work€ and that probably describes it best. There are some classic Radiohead moments on there, but overall it sounds more like a b-sides collection than a cohesive work.

6. The King Of Limbs

Radiohead€™s most recent effort, 2011€™s The King Of Limbs was announced five days before it was released, and even then it arrived a day early. This brevity took fans by surprise, but a bigger shock was in store for them when they started to actually listen to it. It€™s comfortably Radiohead€™s weirdest album, featuring two drummers throughout, one playing in a conventional way, and one trying to mimic a drum machine. In fact, it could be argued the whole album is one long showcase of Radiohead€™s under-appreciated yet exceptional rhythm section. Ed O€™Brien told an interviewer that on The King Of Limbs €œrhythm dictates the record. It's very important€the rhythm is king." Heavily influenced by dubstep and jazz, it€™s a very impersonal record, and there is an eerie malevolence that lies just beneath the surface throughout much of it. The lighter moments, songs like Codex and Separator, almost come as a relief after the chilly and syncopated Bloom, or Feral. Overall, it demands the attention of the listener €“ this is not an album to be played in the background while doing other tasks.

5. The Bends

If anything in Radiohead€™s canon could be called €œstadium rock€, the most likely suspect would be their second album, 1995€™s The Bends. Bigger, bolder and more expansive than Pablo Honey, The Bends marks the point in Radiohead€™s career when they first started to become the band we know and love today. The title is based on the band€™s very real feelings of discomfort at their sudden fame off the back of Creep, and Yorke€™s lyrics moved from self-loathing onto larger, more abstract themes. Though it sold slowly at first, it was met rapturously by the music press, with NME giving it 9 out of 10. Their review imagined the band had €œresolved to make an album so stunning it would make people forget their own name, never mind that albatross-like 45€, that last point being a reference to Creep. It threw off that heavy weight to breathtaking effect, with the band switching effortlessly between melodic songs and muscular, intriguing rock anthems. Without it, it€™s very possible bands like Coldplay would not exist today, such is its influence over British music history. On Creep Yorke had wished he was special, but with The Bends it became clear that he and his band actually were.

4. Amnesiac

Largely recorded at the same time as Kid A, 2001€™s Amnesiac was seen by some as an outtakes album, but that assessment falls short of doing it justice. For one it features the band€™s greatest single achievement, the charmingly simplistic and stunningly gorgeous Pyramid Song, which Ed O€™Brien called €œthe best song we've recorded." It is also notable for its moments of clear anger from Yorke€™s lyrics. Dollars And Cents is inspired by Naomi Klein€™s No Logo, and is a tirade against people€™s powerlessness in the face of capitalism. You And Whose Army? meanwhile is a 1940s doo-wop inspired critique of Tony Blair. It even features the late, great trumpeter Humphrey Lyttelton and his band on meandering album closer Life In A Glasshouse. Despite its initial assessment, the fact it didn€™t sound much like Kid A was a positive for many, and while that album has grown in stature, Amnesiac is a great record in its own right. Its highs are as good as any in the band€™s career, and this was reflected when Amnesiac became Radiohead€™s second album to gain a Mercury Prize nomination, and their fourth nominated for a Grammy.

3. Kid A

On their debut album, Thom Yorke sang €œanyone can play guitar€, but by the turn of the century, Radiohead had grown so disillusioned with that instrument they decided to relegate it to the background. The result of this six string banishment was the icy follow-up to the widely lauded Ok Computer, 2000€™s Kid A. Feeling that rock music had €œrun its course€, Thom Yorke started listening to other genres of music, and these would come to have a huge influence over Kid A: avant-garde jazz, Krautrock, and the artists of Warp Records The jazz influence is most clear on The National Anthem, the horns on which the band wanted to sound like Charles Mingus. The song€™s memorable bass line was played on record by Yorke himself rather than bassist Colin Greenwood, and it€™s said he wrote the riff when he was just 16. Warp Records crept in most notably on Idioteque, pared down from a 50 minute long drum pattern (with added €œchaos€) created by Jonny Greenwood. When the album arrived, it confounded fans who wanted more guitar, but critics loved it, and Pitchfork famously gave it 10 out of 10. Though it may not be their best album, it remains their most important, laying the groundwork for the band€™s future.

2. OK Computer

Now recognised as one of the greatest albums of all time, 1997€™s OK Computer was a sonic leap compared to the album it followed. Where The Bends was full of guitar anthems, its follow-up was endlessly experimental, imbued with brooding pre-millennium tension. OK Computer€™s jumping off point was what Yorke called the "incredibly dense and terrifying sound" of Miles Davis€™ Bitches Brew, but the myriad touchstones and subtle influences throughout come together to make something utterly unique. Opener Airbag for example was heavily influenced by DJ Shadow, and its drums in particular were cut up and pasted back together in an attempt to emulate his distinctive sound. Climbing Up the Walls took its cue from modern classical composer Krzysztof Penderecki, Let Down tried to emulate Phil Spector€™s wall of sound, while Lucky was an attempt to put the horror of the Bosnian conflict to music. It€™s only through repeated listens that all these small details of OK Computer really come to the fore. For example, the screaming underneath the solo at the end of Paranoid Android can only really be heard with headphones, and even then it€™s not obvious. The album even features a plate reverberator previously owned by Jona Lewie, famous for being the one-hit wonder behind the Christmas song Stop The Cavalry.

1. In Rainbows

With albums rush-released on such a regular basis nowadays, it€™s hard to remember just how ground-breaking Radiohead€™s release of In Rainbows was back in 2007. Its pay-what-you-want basis was a first for a major act, and Time called it "easily the most important release in the recent history of the music business". Their fellow musicians were less positive though. Trent Reznor was dismissive, as was Kim Gordon of Sonic Youth, while Lily Allen called them €œarrogant€ and blasted them for devaluing music. In Rainbows itself is a perfect mix of their experimental side and their rock side, the point at which these two opposing sides finally dovetail perfectly. 15 Step was influenced by the Peaches song F€”k The Pain Away, Bodysnatchers was described by Yorke as sounding like Wolfmother, while the lyrics throughout are closest in feel to the tension of those on OK Computer. But In Rainbows is less about individual songs and more about its whole, which is infinitely greater than the sum of its parts. NME called it the point at which Radiohead realised they could €œembrace pop melodies and proper instruments while still sounding like paranoid androids located somewhere around the outskirts of Venus€. In simpler terms, it€™s their pinnacle, a cherry on top of the incredible cake that is their career. Because this is Radiohead, it may well be topped in the future, but for now In Rainbows is their best work.

In this post: 
Radiohead
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A man who writes things.