Ranking The '27 Club' Based On Musical Talent

The legendary '27 Club' has members ranging from Janis Joplin to Kurt Cobain, but who was the best?

It is bizarre to think that enough talented musicians have died at the tender age of 27 to warrant an entire 'club', or even enable a list of this nature, but oddly they have. In 2011 the world was shaken by the passing of Amy Winehouse, which in turn reignited a media and social obsession with the tragic, ever increasing death toll of 27 year-old musical icons. There are only two things connecting each member; age and profession. Yet, we have become so fascinated with the tenuous link, that the '27 club' was born. This list features music legends of all genres, with intriguing and often even compelling back stories. If you disregard music for a short moment, it is incredibly interesting to take ten different human beings, all of which died at an untimely age and simple compare their cases. Some of the deaths have a common theme, while others are completely unique; some even believe that a particular entry's cause of death is due to a debt owed to the devil after previously exchanging their soul for talent, those same people would most likely still leave a tooth under their pillow hoping to wake up to a cash prize. There have been a whole host of books, plays and films based on the 27 club. The recurring pattern of premature musical tragedies even resulted in studies being carried out to determine if the risk of death is higher for a twenty seven year-old musician than a person of the same age in an alternative line of work. The ranking system throughout the list is based on a variety of factors: mainstream success, musical originality, influence on the industry and the impact had on the public. Let's begin:

10. Rudy Lewis

Since 1988, Rudy Lewis has been a certified member of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame for his work with legendary soul band, The Drifters. After lead singer Ben E. King left the group in pursuit of a solo career, the band needed a new front man - step forward Rudy Lewis. Replacing Ben E. King would be quite a daunting task for most musicians, considering both King's success and popularity. However, Rudy Lewis' audition was considered perfect for the role and was therefore hired on the spot; making The Drifters whole again. Lewis made some beautiful music with the group before his untimely death in 1964. Ironically, the band were scheduled to record 'Under the Boardwalk' when the singer passed away; a song that was written specifically to fit Rudy Lewis' voice. The band would still have great mainstream success with the record, though featuring the vocals of a different lead singer. Lewis was found dead in his hotel room in Harlem with the presumed cause being a heroin overdose. As for The Drifters, they are still active today and since forming in 1953 have had an astonishing fifty one different people make up the four piece group throughout the years. So if you ever hear someone claiming they were in band, they're probably telling the truth.

9. Brian Jones

Brian Jones was a very talented musician, and could play a whole host of musical instruments, more so in fact than any other member of his fellow band, The Rolling Stones. Unfortunately for Jones however, it was soon established that Mick Jagger and Keith Richards would be the band members the media donated their interest to; particularly after the pair became a solid songwriting team. It is not uncommon in music for certain members of a band to become more popular amongst the industry and their fans; The Beatles, Guns N Roses, Oasis etc. Sadly, this realisation hit Jones very personally, particularly as he was the original bandleader. In the early days Brian Jones did everything; he named the band, chose the members and even got the group their initial gigs. Jones' envy resulted in a serious drug problem. On 2nd July 1969, the musician was found in a static position at the bottom of his swimming pool by girlfriend Anna Wohlin. A coroner's report of the incident confirmed that his heart and liver were hugely increased in size by both alcohol and drug abuse. Since the death of Brian, The Rolling Stones have had 'moderate' success as we all know - when your 'moves' get mentioned in a Maroon 5 song, you know you've done alright.

8. Alan Wilson

Alan 'Blind Owl' Wilson is probably one of the more underrated entries on this list, which is a shame, because he made great blues music. Wilson and his band Canned Heat often get overlooked when it comes to American blues. The musician's delicate voice was very unique in a genre that was dominated by very powerful, deep, masculine sounds; perhaps it was the singer's exclusive pitch that had an effect on Canned Heat's lack of recognition. The singer was also incredible with a harmonica, a sound that would compliment his voice and create a back-catalogue of hit records for his band. Away from music, Wilson was a pretty eccentric character. He would regularly sleep outside rather than in his house, as he preferred to be closer to nature. It was actually within his camper van in the woods where Wilson's body was found. It is heavily assumed that the musician took his own life after overdosing on barbiturate pills, though that has not been established for certain. However, reports suggest that he had unsuccessfully attempted suicide on a previous occasion. Canned Heat were forced to replace Wilson immediately due to an unbreakable tour contract and prearranged studio dates. Unfortunately personalities in the new formed band would soon clash, creating a damaging lack of rapport and an absence in progression.

7. Amy Winehouse

When Amy Winehouse released her second studio album 'Back to Black' in 2006 there was a collective cheer from millions of music fans around the world. For half a decade the charts had been dominated by reality TV show winners and generic indie rock bands. Music required something new, a different sound, a record with genuine emotion; the world needed 'Back to Black'. The album shortly went platinum in both the UK and the USA; reminding the industry that there was still a market for artists who dared to make creative music. Sure, the charts hadn't completely washed their hands of the endless acts churned out each year by Simon Cowell; but they did become easier to ignore. Thanks to the success of 'Back to Black', the industry suddenly found room for the likes of Adele, Lana Del Rey and Emeli Sandé. As with many other artists on this list, Winehouse had a well documented heroin addiction. Though her cause of death wasn't actually the Class A drug, but instead alcohol poisoning, a coroner's inquest reviewing the casualty later revealed that the singer's blood alcohol content was higher than five times the legal drink-drive limit when she passed away.

6. Robert Johnson

Robert Johnson is most recognised for his blues music, but could also easily adapt his style into both a country and jazz form of sound. His music usually featured a soft guitar riff and the sound of a harmonica; as well as his cool, slick vocals. Unfortunately for Johnson it wasn't until many years after his passing that his talent was discovered on a more mainstream scale. During his lifetime he was left to play his records in juke joints for very little money, but his music hit popularity afterwards, being reissued in the 1960s and influencing the likes of Eric Clapton and The Rolling Stones. The cause of the musician's death is unclear; creating a variety or versions, some pretty farfetched. People claim that the devil came back for Johnson, after he had previously exchanged his soul for the music talent he acquired. The most common theory though is that he was given a bottle of whiskey containing poison after flirting with another man's wife. As the years have passed by, Johnson has received many accolades for his musical talent. Including two Grammy Awards for 'Best Historical Album' and the 'Lifetime Achievement' honour; yet he died unfamiliar with success. Maybe that was down to the Devil too?

5. Richey Edwards

Richey Edwards is on this list, because he did die at twenty seven... presumably. The musician's death/disappearance created a fascinating guessing game amongst the media and while he was confirmed legally dead in 2008; there are still occasional random 'sightings' of Edwards around the world. Edwards' disappeared on 1 February 1995; he was scheduled to fly to the US with Manic Street Preachers bandmate James Dean Bradfield, but never showed up at the airport. His car was later discovered parked close to the Severn Bridge, which is a known suicide spot, however his body was never found. Now that's cleared up, let's talk music. Edwards was an extremely intelligent, yet enigmatic man, who was having a constant battle with depression; which was often showcased in his poetic, yet culture-based lyrics. Here is an example taken from the track 'Faster': "Self-disgust is self-obsession honey and I do as I please. A morality obedient only to the cleansed repented." It is hard to debate the Welsh rocker's lyrical talent or his expressive, passionate personality. Edwards even famously cut the words '4 real' into his arm, to proclaim his sincere feelings towards art when pressed by a journalist. Manic Street Preachers still had great commercial success as a three piece since the disappearance of Richey Edwards.

4. Janis Joplin

Janis Joplin was an artist gifted with an extremely captivating and beautiful husky voice; an emotional and driven sound which glows when placed over the top of a psychedelic rock beat or a blues guitar riff. Go and listen to 'Kozmic Blues' or 'Work Me Lord' to get a true understanding of how enchanting her voice really is. Though it was the singer's live performances that made her stand out from the average musician and develop such a devoted fan base. Her slot at the original Woodstock concert in 1969 was one of the most talked about at the event and gained 'Pearl', a nickname used by friends, her legendary status. She shortly followed Woodstock with very well received shows at Madison Square Garden and on the Festival Express Tour. Unfortunately, Joplin had a very strong addiction to heroin. If you watch any of the footage from her Woodstock performance, you will see that she is clearly under the influence. Perhaps drugs added to the energy of her performance, perhaps they did not; either way they were the eventual reason for her short life span. Joplin was highly respected both by fans and the music community, with a whole host of tribute songs being released in her honour; notable mentions being The Mamas & The Papas track 'Pearl' and Leonard Cohen's 'Chelsea Hotel #2'.

3. Jim Morrison

Jim Morrison is possibly the most mysterious and intriguing character on this whole list; lyrical he seems so vague, yet appears so deep. He seemed very fragile, yet glowing with mystical confidence, with quotes that show signs of both lunacy and genius in the same sentence. Case in point below:
"I think in art, but especially in films, people are trying to confirm their own existences."
What couldn't be debated about the singer was his ability to make incredible music. Morrison's band, The Doors, created timeless rock songs. Many of which have been covered time and time again, by modern artists. The band have also been awarded an extensive list of accolades, including a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. Even Morrison's death is heavily debated and mysterious. The rock star died in a bath tub in Paris, with his official death certificate stating that he passed away due to natural causes, heart failure to be precise. Friends of Morrison have since publically suggested that the singer died of a heroin overdose, a matter which was covered up by his drug dealers. Other artists on the list have received a lot of recognition and trophies since they passed away, but I'm pretty sure Jim Morrison is the only entry to have had a species of lizard named after them. A recently discovered fossil showcasing a large lizard was named Barbaturex morrisoni, in tribute of the singer.

2. Kurt Cobain

Kurt Cobain is one of the biggest music icons the modern generation has ever seen, not a bad achievement for a man that died at the age of twenty seven back in 1994. Even today, you could go to pretty much any western high school and see at least a handful of fourteen year olds wearing Nirvana badges, hoodies and/or bags. When you consider that many of these teen's parents had not even met at the time of Nirvana's success; it really paints a picture of the band's legacy. Grunge was a sound that had been around since the late 80's, when bands such as Soundgarden emerged onto the scene. However, it was Nirvana that changed the direction of music entirely with their second studio album 'Nervermind'. It was an album so popular that it displaced Michael Jackson's 'Dangerous' album at the top of the US Billboard Charts; a feat unheard of for a grunge band. Unfortunately whilst Nirvana were brilliant, they opened the floodgates for some horrendous copy-cat bands and the world suffered from a few years of awful grunge music throughout the mid-nineties. A fine example of terrible grunge being Cobain's ex-girlfriend Courtney Love's band, Hole. Cobain committed suicide at his home in Lake Washington Blvd, Seattle. He was found alongside a suicide note by an electrician, with the note being addressed to his imaginary childhood friend 'Boddah', explaining how his excitement for life and music had died a long time ago.

1. Jimi Hendrix

Hendrix is viewed as the greatest electric guitarist in music history by many and acclaimed as one of the greatest musicians of all time by most critics. He was both a music pioneer and visionary, fusing genres most would have previously considered incompatible. Jazz, American folk, psychedelic rock and hard rock would all be merged together to make one Hendrix record. The Rolling Stones magazine, named Hendrix as the 'greatest guitar player in history', via a poll compiled by top music experts. While his Rock and Roll Hall of Fame biography is also particularly complimentary about the rock star's ability with the instrument, stating: "Hendrix expanded the range and vocabulary of the electric guitar into areas no musician had ever ventured before." Outside of music, Hendrix had a history of substance abuse. A running theme on this list, it would seem. He also didn't react well to high quantities of alcohol and would often turn violent when drunk. In 1970, the musician's lifestyle caught up with him, when he died of a drug overdose and inhaling his own vomit. The Hall of Famer's legacy is one of the finest music has ever seen. There are now statues of the musician located in both the UK and USA. Not to mention, a park in Seattle was named after him in 2006. Simply put, there are very few artists idolised quite in the same way as Jimi Hendrix. If you enjoyed the list and would like instant updates of future articles follow my Twitter page @Dragonstravel.

Contributor
Contributor

A wrestling enthusiast, currently educating the youth of Taiwan English; there are now a bunch of Asian kids running around with Yorkshire accents. Read about that trip and others at dragonstravel.com.