The Who: Ranking Their Albums From Worst To Best

How do you even begin sorting through some of the best albums of all time? We've definitely give it our best.

Widely viewed as one British rock's 'golden trinity' along with Rolling Stones and The Beatles, The Who have had a massive influence on many of our modern day rock bands. They have an output most can only dream of, ranging from being a singles band early on, to producing the great sprawling concept albums such as 'Quadrophenia' and 'Tommy'. The four original band members are some of the most talented musicians on Earth. Roger Daltrey has an incredibly powerful voice, Pete Townshend is one the greatest songwriters of all time, all the while bassist John Entwistle and drummer Keith Moon are often viewed as the very best at their respective instruments. The songs vary from moving, quiet ballads to thumping , snarling and majestic rock anthems. The albums of The Who cover a great range and this list will attempt to put some sort of definitive ranking for each of them. This is difficult, mainly due to the very high quality of their albums; putting the top four in any sort of order was particularly difficult. The list will cover live albums but not the BBC sessions or compilation albums as these are difficult to compare to their other work.

14. Who's Last (1984)

Whos Last It'd be fair to say the early 80s were not the Who in their heydays. The loss of Keith Moon had clearly affected the band; Pete Townshend had a severe cocaine addiction and they had released two pretty mediocre studio albums (more on those later). Thus in 1982 the band decided to embark on their 'farewell tour' and release a live album of it two years later, which was marketed as being their 'final album.' Thankfully, it wasn't as a pale shadow of the mighty band that had gone before. The track listing is pretty good with a mixture of the biggest hits as well as some slightly more obscure songs such as 'Dr Jimmy' or 'Long Live Rock'. Yet this is probably the only positive point to a seriously poor album. Roger Daltrey sounds simply atrocious, with the usually magnificent 'Love Reign o'er Me' being particularly painful. The rest of the band don't stoop to such lows as they all put in a decent shift, but there's no disguising Kenney Jones is no Keith Moon and John Entwistle's 'Twist and Shout' is pretty lame. It's also clear some of the album has been tinkered with by the marketing experts, with any songs from the past two albums being omitted due to poor sales and a clear attempt to pack all the big hits in. A really poor effort from the band, this really was their lowest point. Best Song: They're all pretty ropey but 'Summertime Blues' is just about acceptable.

13. It's Hard (1982)

As stated in the above post, the early 80's weren't a great period for The Who and it really shows in this album. They were being held together by Roger and John, with Pete wishing to leave to continue his flourishing solo career. Perhaps most of the blame for this album can be put at their door for forcing him to stay, as this is definitely The Who's worst studio album. The cover almost seems to promise something new and futuristic, but with nods to the past as shown by the funky 80's lettering and the boy playing pinball in the background. In fact what we get can best be describes as a mess. There is the occasionally bright spot - the title song isn't too bad and 'I've Seen No War's is a decent enough effort. The rest is pretty much uniformly rubbish. John Entwistle has clearly lost his songwriting techniques by this point, giving us three lumpy, melody-less songs while the main single 'Athena' doesn't sound like The Who or any other rock band at all. The best song by a country mile also fails to sound like a Who song too, in that it's quite clearly a Pete Townshend solo effort. He even sings 'Eminence Front' but at least it has a pretty cool keyboard introduction and interesting beat, leaving it head and shoulders above anything else. Best Song: 'Eminence Front'- It may be a Pete solo effort but at least it sounds good. Great beat.

12. Endless Wire (2006)

A few eyebrows were probably raised that The Who were to make their first album of new material, considering that half of the band is no longer with us. Yet, it was true with Pete and Roger releasing an album, which, despite not being a patch on previous efforts is actually okay. They'd released two new songs in 2004 - 'Old Red Wine' and 'Real Good Looking Boy' which were both very nice efforts, so it probably made sense to make a whole new album. Again, it's virtually a Pete Townshend solo record with Roger providing lead vocals and Pete providing everything else (including being a drum machine). Obviously, the songs are a lot slower than the older material and Roger can't hit the notes as well as he used to be able to, but what it presents us is a quieter, almost reflective Who. The first half of the album is a number of individual tracks and is in general a bit of a mixed bag. The highlights are definitely 'Mike's Post Theme', 'A Man in a Purple Dress' and 'It's not Enough' , each displaying the moving songwriting styles Pete once employed to bombastic rock operas. The second half is an attempt at yet another 'rock opera', this time entitled 'Wire & Glass'. Again it's mixed-there are a few good songs but most are far too short often clocking up under the 90 second mark. An enjoyable, but mixed album. Best Song: ' Mike's Post Theme': A love song attached to TV themes with some great lines, 'If there really is a God, we'll get laid today' and cracking vocal performance from Roger.

11. Face Dances (1981)

The first album to be released post-Moon, and probably the best of that era. Moon was replaced by Small Faces drummer Kenney Jones who has often come under heavy criticism after leaving from Roger Daltrey. It's clear that Jones is a talented drummer, but he doesn't haven't the wildness and unpredictability of Moon, which can leave the drumming seem a little uniform. 'Face Dances' was released to very mixed reviews but listening now it isn't actually too bad. Again, the problem with it is that it isn't particularly 'Who-like' and is a clear attempt to almost re-imagine the band. The Ox's songs are pretty dire and Pete's are only slightly better. Yet, unlike the previous two albums, 'Face Dances' has at least as two absolute Who classics in 'Another Tricky Day' and 'You Better You Bet.' The former is a surprisingly pessimistic song from Pete although it does have a great beat and some of Kenney's best drumming, making it definitely worth a latter. If that is a little dreary, 'You Better You Bet' is the total opposite as it's just a really fun track to take in. It has a good, fast beat, some catchy singing by Roger and some moments of romance that seem to be recapturing Pete's songs of old. Overall, a mediocre album elevated by two classics. Best Song: 'You Better You Bet'

10. The Who By Numbers (1975)

The rather wonderful cover illustration of the band by John Entwistle almost seems to point towards this be a fun-loving album, full of catchy, enjoyable songs. It is anything but. This is Pete Townshend baring his soul to us, as he produces some of his most personal writing. It's absolutely gorgeous, but at the cost of an enjoyable listen. Incredibly, Roger Daltrey even refused to sing 'However Much I Booze' as he viewed it as too personal to Pete. It isn't all bad and the writing as stated above is superb, especially in 'How Many Friends', which seems relevant to almost everyone. There are two absolutely beautiful ballads on here -' Blue, Red & Grey' and 'Dreaming from the Waist with some absolutely lovely melodies. The rest just fall flat though - either far too long ('However Much I Booze'), or just lack a clear melody making them difficult to listen too. In fact, the most enjoyable song is probably the delightfully risqué 'Squeeze Box'. It's hardly Pete's finest piece of writing but thanks to to some wonderful innuendos ('She goes in and out'), as well as a good, fast pace it makes it an absolutely cracking listen. This isn't a particularly bad album but coming after 'Who's Next' and 'Quadrophenia' it's disappointing. Best Song: 'Squeeze Box'

9. Who Are You (1978)

A poignant album for many Who fans with it being the last to feature Moon, it's also surprisingly good despite a fairly poor reputation. Partially intended as a follow up to the failed Lifehouse project, 'Who Are You' sees a more electronic approach to the Who's music, as well as longer songs often hitting five minutes or more. The drumming is far less noticeable than previous albums as years of alcohol and drug abuse caught up on an unfit Moon, reducing him to nothing but a few cymbal crashes on 'Music Must Change'. Entwistle gets a more prominent songwriting role on this album, penning three of the songs. The best is probably 'Trick of the Light', a rather amusing tale of man facing inadequacy opposite a prostitute, the other two also being fairly enjoyable affairs. Most of Pete's efforts are fairly enjoyable listens, but distinctly average by his high standards except for the excellent 'Sister Disco.' The highlight of the album is undoubtedly the title song which is often viewed as one of The Who's finest efforts. The lyrics, telling the tale of one of Pete's drunken nights, coupled with some of Keith's best drumming and some fantastic, growling vocals from Daltrey make it one of their most beloved songs. It's not hard sot see why. Best Song: 'Who Are You'- Probably the last great Who song.

8. My Generation (1965)

The album which set The Who on their way to rock and roll stardom, this is often seen as one of the defining mod albums of the 1960's. The album cover shows the band as fresh-faced young mods, vastly different to their rough rock persona they'd acquire in subsequent years. As a debut album, it's absolutely superb with a good mix of a few blues covers, coupled with mostly original songs. The surprising thing about this album is how 'poppy' many of their songs sound. It's easy to forget that in their early years the band was mostly a singles band and many of the songs here feel like such things, such as 'Substitute' or 'Pictures of Lily'. Yet, even in these early days there is still a raw, loud sound often associated with The Who in the background thanks to Keith's manic drumming. Roger's voice is light years away from his lion's roar of later years and this unfortunately affects the two James Brown covers which are the weakest efforts by far. Along with the previous album on this list, the title track is the very best. One of the greatest rock songs of all time, Pete's lyrics show the full force of 1960's youth culture anger with brilliant lyrics such as the infamous line, 'I hope I die before I get old.' Coupled with some simply insane drumming from Moon and the magnificent bass solo from Entwistle, it's not a bad way to break onto the music scene at all. Best Song: 'My Generation'- a generation's anthem, still popular today.

7. A Quick One (1966)

Probably the most interesting album in The Who's back catalogue, it's certainly their most experimental. It's miles away from the more R&B sound of their debut album, instead being an almost psychedelic mix of rock pop and just plain weirdness. One reason for this is almost certainly the fact that all band members had to write two songs, which produces mixed results. Daltrey has never been known for his songwriting, and while his effort 'See My Way' is listenable, the group clearly weren't impressed as his second song never mad it onto the album. Keith's efforts are bizarre; ' I Need You' sounds like a Beach Boys song with wild drumming, while 'Cobwebs and Strange' is just unbelievably weird. The album presents a positive in that it helps Entwistle's fledgling song writing career. 'Whiskey Man' shows his flair of amusing, strange lyrics but his other effort- 'Boris the spider is rightly viewed as a classic thanks to it's cheeky lyrics and cracking bass. Pete only gets four songs but they are all pretty enjoyable. Three of them are typical of early Who; short and 'poppy' with 'So Sad About Us' being the best. The other is his first foray into rock opera territory with 'A Quick One, While He's Away. It's a funny but rude nine-minute epic, creating the wonderful character of Ivor the Engine Driver. It's a great song, although probably better live than on the album. Best Song: 'Boris the Spider'

6. Live At The Isle Of Wight Festival (1996)

Recorded in 1970, but not released until 1996 this one rivals 'Live at Leeds' as being the best live album by the band. It's definitely worth a listen due to having the whole of 'Tommy' live, right as it was being played at it's peak of popularity. The whole album is a typically excellent Who performance from this period, although it can't quite reach the heights of Leeds, with some of the earlier songs not being quite as well performed. The 'Tommy' section is a definite highlight, despite a couple of omissions. The highlights are probably an absolutely brilliant performance of 'Go to the Mirror, helped along by the crowd and 'The Acid Queen' sung with gusto by Townshend. A personal favorite is the absolutely insane 'Sparks' with Keith's drumming being at it's absolute finest.It's a great performance of the album, rivaling the studio version. While some of the songs also played on Leeds don't match the colossal heights of that effort, it's nice to get some fairly rare material on here. 'Water' is helped along by a roaring vocal performance from 'Daltrey', with 'I Don't Know Myself' benefiting from some cheeky drumming from Keith on the quieter sections. The best is the simple mesmerising performance of 'Naked Eye' at the end, caught brilliantly on the excellent concert movie. Best Song: 'Naked Eye' on the concert film although 'Go to the Mirror' sounds best on the album.

5. The Who Sell Out (1967)

The 60's saw some very varied output from the Who, with this being their idea of concept album. The format is a piece of genius; a broadcast from the fictional pirate radio station 'Radio London'. Unlike some of the other concept albums of this period, this one sticks to the format all the way through complete with some rather wonderful faux commercials ('Heinz Baked Bean's) and cheeky radio jingles. The songs that make up the album also contribute to its success, often being brilliantly written in a fun and tongue-in-cheek way. It kicks off with a rare foray by the Who into psychedelic territory with the surprisingly catchy 'Armenia City in the Sky'. Pete's fun way with humorous lyrics is shown best by 'Mary Anne with the Shaky Hand', with a lovely little melody and some VERY ambiguous lyrics. 'Tattoo' is another favourite, telling the tale of boys becoming men in a very unique way, while 'Our Love Was' and 'Sunrise' are absolutely gorgeous little songs, still vastly under-appreciated today. The album ends with another foray into mini rock opera territory, with 'Rael.' It's a decent enough song, let down by it's beat which is far too reminiscence of a military drill. The most famous and popular song of the album is 'I Can See For Miles.' One of the few that can be listened too outside of the album, it was see by Pete as a surefire hit. Sadly, it failed, although it's difficult to see why as it's a brilliant, brash song and far heavier than anything that had gone before. Best Song: 'I Can See For Miles'

4. Quadrophenia (1973)

Townshend's second rock opera for The Who, this one tells the tale of a young mod Jimmy and his struggles with four distinct personalities, each based on the band members. A personal, almost heartbreaking tale it managed to spawn the 1979 cult film of the same name and various tours, most recently in 2013. With some of the finest songwriting from Pete and some superb musicianship, it makes it a magnificent album. It kicks off with 'The Real Me', a cracking rock tune with a beat that really makes you want to get up and dance. The first half is slightly weaker than the second; there's some great songs such as 'The Punk and the Godfather' and the moving 'Cut my Hair', but a couple of others while still pretty good do feel a bit like filler. The second half kicks off in absolutely cracking fashion with the manic '5.15', one the group's most popular songs, helped along by some of Keith's best drumming as he mimics a train thundering on. Keith gets center stage again in 'Bellboy', with his Cockney tones being a perfect fit for the song's character and again shows off his magnificent drumming in 'Dr Jimmy'- the highlight of that song being the wonderful, moving 'Is it me? ' section delivered beautifully by Daltrey, The final song on the album is one of the Who's most famous and it's not hard to say. Combining some beautiful lyrics, great drumming and Daltrey's finest vocal performance, 'Love Reign O'er Me' is a crashing, brilliant end to a superb album. Best Song: Love Reign O'er Me

3. Tommy (1969)

The album which thrust the Who into worldwide rock dominance, 'Tommy' is often viewed as one of the most important albums of all time, with it being the first 'rock opera' of all time. It's suffered a bit of a backlash in recent years, with some of the song's quality being put under scrutiny compared to the album's reputation. This is a little unfair, as it's a highly enjoyable listen despite its simply bonkers premise of a 'deaf, dumb and blind' boy becoming a pinball messiah. The only negative of the album is that the mix for Keith's drum's is a bit low, but other than that it's a truly superb listen. The most famous song by a mile is Pinball Wizard, allegedly only put in by Townshend so it could get better reviews off a pinball mad journalist. Still popular to this day, it's an absolute cracker of a song, with some of Pete's most catchy lyrics. The rest of the album is pretty strong. 'Go to the Mirro' has a brilliant guitar riff, 'Cousin Kevin' & 'Fiddle About' are some wonderfully creepy tunes from Entwistle with '1921', 'The Acid Queen' and 'Sally Simpson' being other highlights. Even the songs of about 10 seconds such as 'Miracle Cure' are still enjoyable and well-crafted. The closing song is again a doozy- the wonderful 'See Me, Feel Me' delivered with emotion by Roger Daltrey before crashing into the 'Listening to You' section, one of their most popular live offerings. A brilliant album, which spawned and equally insane 1975 musical film and many, many attempts of recreation. Best Song: The 'See Me, Feel Me/Listening to You' section of 'We're not Gonna Take It'

2. Live At Leeds (1970)

Often voted as the Best Live Album Of All Time, this is The Who at their absolute peak of performing live. The simple cover almost reflects the music on offer - this is the Who at their raw best, with Roger roaring his way through lyrics with the crashing band behind. The original LP is only seven songs but when they are all so perfect as they are on here, it's certainly worth it's lofty reputation. The covers are particularly brilliant - the opening guitar to 'Young Man Blues' is one of the finest beginnings to any album, with 'Summertime Blues' being superior to the bluesy original. The famous guitar riff of 'Shakin All Over' also makes an appearance with the song far louder and madder than the original Johnny Kidd and the Pirates versions. Only three Who songs actually appear - 'Magic Bus' is a bit long but helped by some great interplay between Daltrey and Townshend, before the final 15 minute long 'My Generation' jam; a wonderful mix of many different songs done simply brilliantly. The album was released as a deluxe edition in 1995 which added seven more songs. There all great additions to an already magnificent album - 'Heaven and Hell' is particularly brilliant, while the previously quieter singles of 'Happy Jack' and 'I'm a Boy' are given a louder, much more rocky stance. Other highlights on the deluxe include a great performance of 'A Quick One, While He's Away' and a very enjoyable version of the wonderfully written 'Tattoo.' Best live album of all time? Probably Best Song: Difficult but I'll go with 'Young Man Blues'

1. Who's Next (1971)

The Who's most famous and finest effort, 'Who's Next' must also be viewed as one of the greatest rock albums of all time. A change from their previous efforts, it sees tighter songwriting from Townshend and all four members at their peak, coming together to produce something of pure brilliance. It was almost so different, the infamous 'Lifehouse' project collapsing leading to Pete falling into depression and a constant hating of this album - he's probably the only person who does. It starts off with the band's most famous song thanks to it's association with CSI - the magnificent 'Baba O'Reilly' often mistakenly called Teenage Wasteland. Showcasing Pete's new obsession with synthesisers, as well as Keith's new drumming skills it's an almost perfect song - with the famous "We're all wasted" line often heard being shouted by thousands at stadiums all around the world. The rest of the album never drops in quality. 'Bargain' has some of the most perfect rock drumming ever, 'My Wife' is a typically cheeky Entwistle song, while the middle two of 'The Song is Over' and 'Getting in Tune' are elated by Daltrey's cracking vocals. It ends with two of the band's most famous songs. 'Behind Blue Eyes' starts off as a slow, almost moving tune of loneliness before crashing into typical rock territory, while 'Won't Get Fooled Again' almost defines rock music - it's brilliant all round with the final, astonishing scream from Daltrey being one the greatest moments in rock history. A brilliant, brilliant album. Best Song: Tough to chose between 'Baba O'Reilly' and 'Won't get Fooled Again'. It'll have to be the former....just.

In this post: 
The Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I'm Will an 18 year old archaeology student at Durham University. I have a particular interest in the wonderful world of Doctor Who as well as science fiction, fantasy and geekdom in general.