Ranking All 9 Foo Fighters Studio Albums From Worst To Best

Two decades and nine albums for one of the biggest bands on the planet - which is best?

Foo Fighters Albums
Roswell Studios

Global rock sensation (and all-round great guys) the Foo Fighters have a storied career of creating mainstay rock music since 1995, and like any band with a lifespan of two decades, they have created a back catalogue of albums ranging in sound and quality.

Dave Grohl and his troupe of merry rockers have shown a diversity in their music since the early days - which is understandable given their first album was recorded almost entirely by Grohl on every instrument, and the fact the band has had many lineup changes over it's history. But no matter what has faced them, the Foo Fighters have long served as a staple of modern rock music, hence their numerous Grammy wins and nominations, even when recording their "worst" material.

With their latest release 'Concrete And Gold' now firmly cemented in the Foo's back catalogue - and fully integrated into many a fan's conversation - it begs the question: Of all their nine albums and with so much learnt in between each release, which is their best?

9. One By One (2002)

One by One suffers due to the strained relationships of the band at the time. In 2001, drummer Taylor Hawkins suffered a heroin overdose and was left comatose, leaving the band to take some time off and freeing frontman Dave Grohl up to perform as drummer for Queens of the Stone Age, with the Foos reuniting in October of that year.

After initial recordings for the album were disliked they took a break from the recording process, as members of the band moved onto different projects. They reunited at Coachella in April, 2002, a performance that would be pivotal in the rebuilding the band's internal relationships.

In rehearsals huge fights between Grohl and Hawkins would break out, but after the performance itself - and given that the band really enjoyed this gig - they decided to return and re-record the album.

This context of uncertainty is recognised by the band themselves, who have since grown to dislike One by One, although some songs have withstood the negativity and still feature on tours. The electrifying 'All My Life' is a set regular, and serves to do what the album as a whole was intended to do: Convey the energy of a Foo Fighter's live performance.


8. Sonic Highways (2014)

With only eight tracks to its name, Sonic Highways is hindered by being so short. The experimental nature of each track being recorded in a different city was an attempt to catch the essence of that city's musical history, and while exceptionally ambitious, ultimately it's not as effective as one might hope, leaving the album to feel a little disjointed, although the songs themselves are enjoyable.

While Grohl threw himself into the experiment, travelling around the USA and interviewing a range of people in the business, from musicians to recording engineers, the finished product is, unfortunately, not their best work.

The accompanying Making Of documentary is insightful, but when comparing the album to the rest of the Foo's discography, it has to fall to a low position. While nowhere near the disappointment and universally recognised low-point of 'One by One', this album has to rank below the rest.

Highlights include, 'Something From Nothing' and 'Congregation', which stand very strongly as singles, while not entirely creating a thematic or flowing album experience.

There isn't much more to be said, there's just a lot better to come.


7. Concrete And Gold (2017)

The band's newest album, 'Concrete and Gold', shows the band's excitement at blending hard and soft sounds with ease and their ability to craft amazing melodies. This one is hindered by not having much of a history in comparison to the following albums on the list, but a great showing nonetheless.

Working with new producer Greg Kurstin - whose previous work was deeply rooted in pop - meant an element of experimentation was brought in, but in a way that seems to have worked as a positive for the group.

This newest release was composed initially by a solo Grohl, who was taking time off to recover from his infamous leg break (nobody can forget his Game of Thrones inspired throne of guitars), and later worked on with the band, a process that seems to evoke their best work.

Add to this a passionate lyrical motivation, Grohl's darker world view thanks to the 2016 Presidential election, and his worry for the future his children would be left with as a result, and the album comes together rather nicely with a connective theme of duality, or as the band have said, "hope and desperation".


6. Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace (2007)

While this album's track listing is enjoyable on the whole, the shifts can be inconsistent, and so this has sunk lower on the rankings. The highlight is unquestionably ''The Pretender', a track which has to be seriously considered among the best the Foos have written; a true testament to their wallop n' wail stylings. Dave Grohl has said that "we wanted the stops to be pin-drop silent before exploding", and 'The Pretender' is a perfect example of this.

Perhaps there were some improvements that could have been made, with the decision not to re-record any of the album, you can't help but wonder what a few weeks off and a different perspective might have improved.

Also, Grohl had started writing lyrics before the recording began, and maybe this hindered the quality to a degree, trying to fit music around words rather than the other way around.

But it is a great album, helped by the passion of Grohl's introspective lyrics, stemming from the birth of his daughter, and began a process of thinking about everything, life, death, and birth, in a different light.


5. In Your Honour (2005)

Hugely loved by fans for it's acoustic second disc, and its ability to blend the rock side of their identity with a softer sound. Dave Grohl decided to do a diversify, as he felt that after ten years of existence, the band had to break new ground with their music.

Following on from 'One by One' and the turmoil the band faced at that time, Grohl was, understandably, uncertain. He wanted the Foo Fighters to go on, but found himself experimenting, and eventually had an acoustic album to bring to the band.

The lyricism of both the rock and acoustic halves have their own feel, the rock album focusing on universal themes, whilst the acoustic album is more revealing about Grohl and his personal feelings.

The acoustic album plays superbly in the sun, perfect to set the summer mood, while the rock album features the touring mainstay 'DOA' and arguably the best song in the Foo Fighter's arsenal, 'Best of You'.

Hailed by some critics as a "magnum opus", and hailed unanimously, 'In Your Honor' is an exceptional album from the group, and one that will surely stand the test of time.


4. Wasting Light (2011)

With guitarist Pat Smear rejoining the band for recording, the three-guitar piece leading the Foos provided some amazing rhythmic blends, and the stripped back, grittier sound achieved from recording in Grohl's garage meant Wasting Light had a unique feel.

Wanting to capture the rock and roll essence of their earlier days, the band recorded on now-outdated analogue equipment, and called upon producer Butch Vig in order to obtain this. Vig was responsible for producing possibly the best known album Grohl has ever been involved in, Nirvana's 'Nevermind'.

Due to the equipment, the band couldn't afford mistakes, so they rehearsed an incredible amount, making the mayhem they could cause seem strangely tight and controlled, like handling a ball of raw energy. And this made the live shows a must-see, as the songs were rehearsed to be recorded live, and hold up exceptionally well when heard in an arena.

This return to roots sound produced an incredible album. With stand out tracks such as 'Rope' and 'Walk' leading the way for an album that doesn't seem to have any weak links, 'Wasting Light' acts as a refreshing return to the near-perfect form they had in their early days.


3. Foo Fighters (1995)

A personal outing for the first album under the Foo Fighters name as Grohl recorded all instruments himself and wrote every song himself, some during his time in Nirvana. This album is a quiet affair, but that works in its favour, and separates Grohl from his previous work, meaning this passion project could present him as the multi-faceted musician he is.

With Grohl recording the album for fun, there wasn't any pressure on Grohl, as the Foo Fighters name gave him an anonymity, and with that, a freedom. Grohl has described this experience as cathartic; a way of handling his emotions and recovering after Kurt Cobain's tragic suicide.

The personal nature of the project and the hectic recording process, with Grohl running from room to room and instrument to instrument, worked incredibly well. He had been sitting on these songs for years, and here he was recording them in 45 minutes. Even the lyrics seemed to be written incredibly fast, with Grohl admitting to writing some 20 minutes before recording, but found that the spontaneous thoughts and feelings that came out of him, in hindsight, were incredibly meaningful.


2. There Is Nothing Left To Lose (1999)

This third album served to solidify the Foo Fighters sound, build upon growing success, and launch the band in to a new era of stardom with Grammy success. The camaraderie of the group seeps through, and the basement-based recording makes the album feel tight and bursting with energy.

The album focused on melodies and some more experimental music, and also ushered in a new wave for the lineup, which now stood as a three-piece, and would feature drummer Taylor Hawkins on an album for the first time.

While these circumstances may sound tumultuous, the band couldn't have had a nicer time recording this album in Grohl's basement, giving them total freedom, allowing them to remain relaxed, and simply record the music they wanted to when they wanted to.

This resulted in some amazing tracks such as 'Stacked Actors', 'Breakout', and 'Learn to Fly', which have cemented the band's reputation. It's a follow up to the last album on this list, but by coming in second place, it serves as a worthy progression of the band's work and has just as much history and fan passion behind it to assure that 'There Is Nothing Left to Lose' will forever have a place in musical history.


1. The Colour And The Shape (1997)

This is the album that launched the Foos proper, and the one that every album after it will be compared to.

This album has a powerful theme due to Grohl's personal issues, going through a divorce and the process of healing. This is where Grohl's leading man voice takes shape, with the fantastic "One last thing..." part of 'Monkey Wrench' highlighting this with a bang, whereas 'Everlong' is brimming with emotion at finding a new love and being lost in it, and makes for amazing listening.

A lot of emphasis was put on the basics of the songs, with producer Gil Norton and Grohl stripping songs back from the start, then pushing to make them the best they possibly could be. Even 'Everlong', objectively the best song the band have ever recorded, started with Grohl playing and writing it on an acoustic guitar by himself.

The album feels like a therapy session, presenting conflicting emotions by mixing up-tempo songs and ballads to perfectly incapsulate the feeling of heartbreak, whilst also leading to some optimistic revelations, and it's a must listen not just for Foo Fighters fans, but for fans of music. It is a withstanding example of the Foos at their peak, and it is breathtaking.


In this post: 
Foo Fighters
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scriptwriting - BA Producing - MA Article-based online influence - TBD