Top 3 Atheistic Pop Songs

John-Lennon_Imagine-e1345992229515 Popular music is categorized thus because it is catchy and appeals to the masses. In many cases this means that the lyrics end up feeling rather superficial. In fact, do an experiment right now€”turn on your radio to a pop music station and jot down the first lyrics you hear. (I took up my own challenge and heard €œCalifornia rest in peace/Simultaneous release,€ so€you know€) But sometimes pop artists try for something a little deeper. It doesn€™t always work and frequently ends up sounding cheesy, but every once in a while they can tap into some emotional truths that allow their music to make you think in addition to dancing and singing along. We could highlight effective songwriting on many different topics, but I€™m choosing the always controversial topic of religion. Specifically I am featuring three songs that have lyrics promoting an atheistic or anti-religion stance. I am certainly not composing this article with the goal of necessarily proclaiming these songwriters as right, but I do think they are providing us a service by opening the discussion of religion in our society. I had a college dorm-mate who loved Sarah McLachlan's music, but being a conservative Christian refused to actually purchase any of her work (particularly after she heard McLachlan's cover of the second song on this list). You may end up feeling similarly or you may become huge fans of the following performers. Either way, they€™ve started a conversation and we are continuing it.

3. I Will Follow You Into The Dark By Death Cab For Cutie

deathcabnforcutiejan2012 Significant lyrics: In catholic school, as vicious as Roman rule/I got my knuckles bruised by a lady in black/And I held my tongue as she told me "Son fear is the heart of love"/So I never went back If heaven and hell decide that they both are satisfied/Illuminate the no's on their vacancy signs/If there's no one beside you when your soul embarks/Then I'll follow you into the dark This Grammy nominated track is an almost undeniably pretty song. And it is a powerful love song. The song is Ben Gibbard€™s promise to stay by a loved one even after death, but importantly in this case, death does not take them to a religiously accepted afterlife. Perhaps the song is more powerful because of that. Instead of suggesting that the couple will get to continue their existence indefinitely in a comfortable place like heaven, he is satisfied simply to pass on from this life with his partner not knowing what (if anything) comes next. This point is further driven home by the verse describing the abuse administered by a teacher/nun. Gibbard is ultimately contrasting the type of love accepted by some traditional Christians as being based in fear, with the love he feels for his partner that contains no fear. This is a poetic and romantic gesture, especially if the person he is singing to shares his philosophy or experiences. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Am0IFwjPyYA

2. Dear God by XTC

Significant Lyrics: (the whole song, really) And all the people that You made in Your image/See them fighting in the street/'Cause they can't make opinions meet about God/I can't believe in You/Did You make disease and the diamond blue?/Did You make mankind after we made You?/And the Devil too? This is certainly the most overt example of anti-religion in this article. There is really nothing subtle about Andy Partridge€™s lyrics, especially as he ends every verse with €œI can€™t believe in you.€ The approach is what makes this especially noteworthy as he is expressing his frustration and disbelief in a letter to the exact entity he is saying doesn€™t exist. Needless to say, the actual intended recipient of his words is not God but the people who believe in God, particularly those who don€™t work to improve life here on Earth because they are instead wrapped up in their infatuation of God. Again, the truth or merit of these lyrics can be argued forever, and if people are approaching the conversation from different perspectives, they will likely never come to an agreement. But we can all acknowledge that Partridge is providing us with an interesting challenge to either refute or defend.

1. Imagine by John Lennon

Screen Shot 2013-06-05 at 19.38.24 Significant lyrics: Imagine there's no heaven/It's easy if you try/No hell below us/Above us only sky/Imagine all the people living for today Imagine there's no countries/It isn't hard to do/Nothing to kill or die for/And no religion too/Imagine all the people living life in peace Certainly the best known of the songs in this list, Imagine is not so much an atheist song as it is an anti-religion song. Ultimately what Lennon is describing is a utopia where identifying characteristics like nationality, religious affiliation, politics, etc. aren€™t present to give rise to disagreements and wars. Lennon€™s difficulty with the €œmy God is better than your God€ mentality is a driving force behind the song. Imagine has been a hugely successful song, ranking number two on Rolling Stone€™s list of The 500 Greatest Songs of All Time, and continuing to be popular even forty years after its release as is evidenced by its use during the Closing Ceremonies of last year€™s Summer Olympics in London. It has become an anthem of peace, but that description ignores the fact that Lennon states that to achieve peace, we need to do away with organized religion. So, let the debate begin. Are these good songs? Do you have to agree with their religious stances to appreciate them? What other atheistic songs are out there? And on the flip side, what would be the strongly pro-religion songs that could serve as a foil for these pieces?

 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I humbly claim the title of renaissance man. I am a professional writer (published playwright), college soccer coach, world traveler, crime-fighting vigilante, part-time juggler, serious hiker, coin collector, counseling student, and doting father/husband among many other roles. (OK, one of those may not be true.)