10 Reasons Why Zodiac Killer MAY Have Been Solved
The most notorious modern true crime case might FINALLY be solved.
There's perhaps no serial killer in modern history more fascinatingly elusive than the Zodiac, who between December 1968 and October 1969 is confirmed to have murdered five people in the San Francisco Bay Area, and has himself claimed to have killed 37 victims.
Over 50 years later, Zodiac's identity remains unconfirmed despite a number of prominent suspects, and barely a few months ever pass without sleuths bringing a new candidate forward.
But the most recent suspect just might be the most compelling one yet. In Jarett Kobek's book How to Find Zodiac, published this past February, Kobek's research pointed to Paul Doerr, a Vallejo resident at the time of the murders who passed away in 2007.
Though Kobek's book released to little fanfare, it was given a major signal boost last month by true crime writer Paul Haynes, who posted an epic 40-tweet thread detailing the book's most eye-opening findings.
The thread is absolutely worth reading in its entirety, and while the "evidence" is all entirely circumstantial, it collectively paints quite the persuasive account of Doerr's possible guilt.
While it remains to be seen whether or not the San Francisco Police Department will entertain Doerr as a suspect and run his fingerprints opposite the partial Zodiac print on file, these are the 10 most compelling arguments for Doerr indeed being Zodiac...
10. Paul Doerr (Mostly) Matches The Physical Description
The most immediate link between Doerr and the Zodiac Killer? He consistently matches the physical descriptions made of Zodiac by survivors and eyewitnesses.
Doerr was 42 years old in 1969, when Zodiac was said to be anywhere from 35 to 45, of equivalent height, similarly sported a crew cut, and looked not dissimilar to the famous composite sketch of Zodiac made by police officers believed to have encountered him.
And while the photo of a young Doerr shows him without glasses and sporting a beard, according to Doerr's own daughter Gloria, he periodically wore glasses throughout his life and also switched between facial hair and clean shaven styles.
Though Doerr's weight yo-yoed throughout the 1970s, he indeed had the same "stocky" build that was used to describe the Zodiac at the time his crimes were perpetrated.
While Doerr largely matching Zodiac's apparent physical attributes doesn't alone make him a prime suspect, when tied together with the rest of Kobek's findings it certainly adds fuel to the fire.
9. Doerr's Writing Style Is Incredibly Similar To Zodiac's
Zodiac is famed for writing taunting letters and cards to regional California newspapers, and Doerr himself had a penchant for writing letters to his favourite "zines" (self-published magazines) and also publishing his own.
Due to many of the zines being digitised online, Kobek was able to track a trove of Doerr's written contributions, which bear marked similarities to Zodiac both in terms of content and writing style.
He's written letters making references to slavery - something Zodiac also wrote about as part of his apparent motive - and penned a letter to the SF Examiner without a street address, just as the Zodiac did. They also both wrote about something as esoteric as magnetic poles.
Furthermore, an anonymous letter written to one of Doerr's favourite zines - and believed to have been written by him - bears many superficial hallmarks of Zodiac's writing style, such as including seemingly intentional spelling mistakes and signing off with a symbol as a signature.
Like Zodiac, Doerr also enjoyed writing lists, used an ampersand instead of "and," often wrote sentences in all-caps except for lower-case i's, and occasionally used a circle to dot lower-case i's and punctuate sentences.
This is without getting into recurring language which can be seen in both Doerr and Zodiac's writing, which while hardly a smoking gun in its own right simply illustrates further shared characteristics between the two.
8. Doerr Was Into Cryptography & Ciphers
Here's where the coincidences really start piling up, and it becomes ever more difficult to discount Doerr as anything less than an incredibly compelling and serious Zodiac suspect.
One of Zodiac's defining traits involved writing cryptograms and ciphers to newspapers containing coded messages, and of the four he sent out, only two have been solved over 50 years later.
Doerr was also interested in cryptography, to the extent that he even published a cipher in his own Tolkien zine, Hobbitalia, just three days after Zodiac sent out his famous "Z13" cipher.
Considering that cryptography is quite the niche interest, it's a majorly compounding piece of circumstantial evidence in tandem with everything else discovered by Kobek.
7. Doerr Wrote A Formula For A Bomb Like Zodiac's
Zodiac famously sent a letter to the San Francisco Chronicle on November 9th 1969 threatening to bomb a bus, which included a list of the items he would use to construct such an explosive device.
In Doerr's own zine Pioneer, he included a similar formula for building a bomb, also stating that it would need to be kept dry and leaving one item out just as Zodiac did: a starter.
In the very least, this confirms that Doerr had knowledge of explosive materials not unlike Zodiac. It's also far from the only weapons-based similarity between the two, as we'll be exploring further shortly.
6. He Was A Roleplay Fanatic
Doerr apparently had a fondness for roleplay events, regularly attending renaissance festivals as pictured in the above image.
Why is this important? For one, it would plausibly explain why Doerr could have an executioner's hood - as worn by Zodiac when he attacked Bryan Hartnell and killed Cecelia Shepard at Lake Berryessa - in his possession if ever questioned about it, being part of an historical re-enactment and all.
But more curiously, there was in fact a renaissance faire happening in the San Francisco Bay Area the very same day that Zodiac struck at Lake Berryessa.
Though highly circumstantial, it's absolutely plausible that Doerr attended the faire, even in the very same or similar executioner garb, before driving the approximately two hours to Lake Berryessa and carrying out the attack there.
5. Doerr Had A History Of Violence
Crucially, Doerr has a history of violence that further posits him as a potential suspect, or in the very least suggests him capable of heinous acts such as murder.
For starters, in a 1974 letter to the editor of his favourite zine, Green Egg, Doerr straight-up implied that he's killed people, and in his own zine Pioneer, stated "the only good enemy is a dead enemy."
Furthermore, Doerr was reportedly discharged from the Military after a year's service for attempting to shove a fork down someone's throat.
And Doerr's daughter Gloria, who will become a more vital piece of the puzzle later on, has corroborated that Doerr was a violent man throughout his life, with a history of abusing her and other family members.
A man being violent doesn't immediately peg him as a serial killer, yet his not-so-cryptic suggestion in writing that he has killed someone certainly raises some major red flags.
4. Doerr's Similar Choice Of Weaponry
Even beyond the fact that Doerr laid out the design for a bomb like that of Zodiac, Doerr had other weapon-related preferences in common with him.
For one, the aforementioned picture of Doerr in role-play get-up sees him touting a knife and scabbard similar to those said to be worn by Zodiac during the Lake Berryessa attack.
Furthermore, Zodiac's knife was described as looking homemade, and in a 1969 letter to the zine Tightbeam, Doerr wrote about casting his own metal blade.
Yet the similarity extends beyond blades to guns also. Zodiac wrote in one of his letters that he acquired his unregistered guns either through the mail or by buying out of state, while in a zine Doerr massively decried the intrusiveness of gun registration and even made a classified ad where he wished to trade his wares for guns.
3. Doerr Wrote A Serial Killer Magazine... But Ignored Zodiac
Doerr has also made reference to serial killers in his own writing. In both a 1970 letter to Pioneer and another letter in 1979, Doerr mentions crimes which were widely reported as Zodiac copycat incidents, yet never once references Zodiac himself.
But it gets better - Doerr also registered himself as an investigator and started his own zine dedicated to serial killers, yet curiously never mentioned the Zodiac, despite having spent so much of his adult life in the Northern California region where the Zodiac struck.
Doesn't that seem rather odd, that someone who Doerr would've likely been acutely aware of as an adult doesn't even get a passing mention in his zine about serial killers? Unless, of course, he didn't want to risk drawing any attention towards himself as a suspect.
2. All The Assorted Circumstantial "Evidence"
The above entries cover the most compelling "evidence" linking Doerr to Zodiac, but it's also only just scratching the surface of everything Kobek uncovered in his book. Here are some of the other, more scattered coincidences and similarities worth thinking about.
- One of Doerr's 1960s music zines was heavily inspired by Gilbert and Sullivan, who are also referenced in at least three of Zodiac's letters.
- In later life, Doerr was confirmed to own a sky blue '63 Chevy Nova similar to one seen at Lake Berryessa on the day of Zodiac's attack.
- Doerr drew diagrams in many of his zines which look superficially similar to Zodiac's bus bomb drawings.
- Doerr was on the mailing list of right-wing militia The Minutemen, who used a gunsight logo similar to Zodiac's. Also, they published the bomb formula reproduced by both Doerr and Zodiac, and offered advice on how to send mail anonymously and acquire untraceable weaponry.
- Zodiac wore military-issued Wingwalker boots, which Doerr would've had easy access to because he spent decades working at Vallejo's Mare Island Naval Base.
- The year after Zodiac used one-cent stamps to post a letter, Doerr suggested using one-cent stamps to spite the post office for raising their stamp costs. Zodiac also used an out-of-circulation commemorative stamp for his one of his letters, while Doerr had spoken about collecting commemorative stamps, and both used the same eight-cent Eisenhower stamp within a year of one another.
- Zodiac was said to use a pencil flashlight as a gun sight in the dark, as was detailed in a magazine, Popular Science, that Doerr collected.
- Zodiac referenced the Sierra Club in one of his postcards, as does Doerr in numerous issues of Pioneer.
Separately, these might be cute coincidences, but together? They form a fascinating picture of Doerr as a person who should be considered at least a major person of interest in the Zodiac investigation.
1. Even Doerr's Daughter Thinks He's Zodiac
Even Doerr's own daughter, Gloria Doerr, agrees that her father was most likely Zodiac, as detailed in a recent interview with LA Mag.
Though Doerr stated that she doesn't want to believe Kobek's claims, as no child would, she couldn't help but note the many similarities listed in his investigation.
Furthermore, Doerr revealed that her father's abuse became violent enough that she moved out of the family home at the start of Christmas break 1968, which would've been mere days at most before Zodiac claimed his first victim.
Plus, many of Zodiac's murder spots were popular teen hangouts Gloria herself frequented, with LA Mag even floating the theory that Doerr could've murdered Vallejo youths in an attempt to scare his "straying" daughter straight.
But at the end of the interview, Doerr outright says that she believes Kopek's investigations to be correct, that her father was more probably than not Zodiac.
While family members certainly don't make for immediately objective or reliable witnesses, it is nevertheless interesting to hear Doerr's own flesh and blood openly appreciate the theory.