8 Harry Potter Characters JK Rowling Really Didn't Have To Kill

When Wizards go to war, you better get out of the way.

JK Rowling wasn€™t shy when it came to pulling the trigger throughout her Harry Potter saga, killing off some of her most adored characters over the course of seven books. While some of the deaths in the series were inevitable (€œneither can live while the other survives€) or were simply essential to the evolution of the plot, it€™s the ones that she really didn€™t have to take that seem to stick in the throat the most. While she never quite reached a George RR Martin level of unpredictable ruthlessness, JK swung the axe a total of 76 times in the series, with a number of favourites meeting untimely and unexpected ends. Dumbledore was a real kick in the remembralls, and there can€™t be many fans that didn€™t shed a tear for Snape (even if Alan Rickman couldn€™t), but we€™d be lying if we said that we didn€™t see both of their deaths coming. Sirius was another huge blow, though witnessing his step-father€™s death first hand helped to turn Harry into the man he needed to be to take on the quest at hand. Cedric Diggory had to go to show the world that Voldemort meant business, and Mad Eye Moody€™s somewhat underwhelming demise let us know that nobody was invincible. But what about all the others? Did all 76 deaths serve a purpose? Here are 8 characters that JK Rowling really didn€™t need to kill€

8. Florean Fortescue

The name Florean Fortescue might not mean a whole lot to the casual Potter fan, though this Diagon Alley ice cream man was once pencilled in for a sub-plot that linked him with the all-important Elder Wand. Unfortunately for Florean, JK decided that the story wasn€™t really going anywhere, and so he wound up on her hit list. Fortescue provided Harry with free ice cream sundaes every half an hour (nice guy, poor businessman) while young Potter was staying at the Leaky Cauldron during the summer of 1993, a simple act of kindness that seemed to be opening the door to a future relationship, though it wasn€™t meant to be. €œI seemed to have him kidnapped and killed for no reason,€ JK wrote on her Pottermore website, €œhe is not the first wizard Voldemort murdered because he knew too much (or too little), but he is the only one I feel guilty about, because it was all my fault.€ Poor old Florean, he became a loose end and paid the ultimate price €“ unceremoniously dragged from his ice cream parlour by Death Eaters and murdered by Voldemort, all because his story didn€™t fit.

7. Colin Creevey

This guy was the original Harry Potter superfan. Arriving at Hogwarts with his camera the year that Salazar Slytherin€™s heir managed to reopen the Chambers of Secrets, Muggle-born Colin was sorted into Gryfindor and wasted no time getting to work on his collection of Harry snaps. He intended to send his photos back to his milkman father, though unfortunately for Mr Creevey, young Colin€™s film melted into mush when he went all National Geographic on Slytherin€™s Basilisk. The lens of his rusty old Muggle camera saved his life on that day (big thumbs up from Arthur Weasley) but he wouldn€™t be so jammy come the Battle of Hogwarts. Having joined student militia Dumbledore€™s Army in order to learn the skills necessary to survive such an event, Colin was always going to stick around for the final showdown with Voldemort. Professor McGonagall did her best stay the heartache when she forbid any underage wizards from participating in the battle, though Colin, scamp that he was, found his way into the castle grounds where he met his untimely end. €œHarry glanced down, and felt another dull blow to his stomach: Colin Creevey, though underage, must have sneaked back just as Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle had done. He was tiny in death.€ I like to think that he went out with his camera lens blazing, documenting the war like the fearless photographer that he was.

6. Lavender Brown

We€™re all guilty of wishing misfortune on that irritating old flame you just can€™t seem to shake, but it€™s hard to imagine any ex going through what Lavender Brown did, no matter how much she annoyed Ron. Pure-blood Lavender was an OG €“ Original Gryffindor, I mean €“ who arrived at Hogwarts the same year as Harry and the gang. A bubbly and likeable character, she always popped up when anything of note was happening at school, from second year duelling club to the formation of Dumbledore€™s Army in year 5. By the beginning of 6th year Lavender had developed her crush on Ron, a crush that she acted upon after the ginger Quidditch keeper played a blinder in front of the hoops €“ who wouldn€™t want to be a Hogwarts WAG? Unfortunately for her it just wasn€™t meant to be. Her Won-won was in love with Hermione Grainger, and so Lavender was quite literally thrown to the wolves. €œNO!€ shrieked Hermione, and with a deafening blast from her wand, Fenrir Greyback was thrown backward from the feebly stirring body of Lavender Brown. Man, what a way to go, savaged by a werewolf Death Eater. Lavender died from her injuries, the only saving grace being that she was spared a life as a disfigured moon howler.

5. Dobby

Dobby went from slightly irritating stray to fully fledged family pet over the course of the series, and nobody wants to see their little furry friend take a throwing-knife in the chest. The big-eared, bug-eyed, self-harming house elf first arrived on the scene in The Chamber of Secrets, in which he tried to warn Harry that there was a plan afoot to open the chamber and set Salazar Slytherin€™s monster free to reek havoc in Hogwarts. This would not go down well with his masters The Malfoys, though the joke would be on them come the end of that book as Harry not only succeeded in slaying the Basilisk, but managed to trick old Lucious Malfoy into freeing Dobby to boot. Thus began Dobby€™s time as a free elf, which is exactly how he died, popping up at Malfoy manor to rescue Harry and his cohort in their hour of need. I mean, I know Griphook had to survive to help plan the Gringotts break in, and Ollivander knew too much about the Elder Wand to be sacrificed, but if Bellatrix€™s dagger had veered slightly in the direction of Dean Thomas I wouldn€™t have had any objections. €œSuch a beautiful place, to be with friends. Dobby is glad to be with his friend, Harry Potter.€ Wow. I€™m not quite sure how Harry managed to live with himself after that one.

4. Fred Weasley

The Battle of Hogwarts, the day the laughter died. We all knew deep down that the chances of the entire Weasley clan surviving the war were slim to none, but I think we all just kind of hoped it would be Percy. And it so easily could have been! Percy and Fred were fighting side by side when an explosion outside the Room of Requirement killed the latter and took away half of the double act that kept us laughing well into the darkest reaches of the story. When things got hairy in the run up to the final showdown, Percy turned cloak and sided with his Imperiused boss, Minister for Magic Pius Thicknesse. It was only in the moments before the battle that the estranged Weasley decided that he€™d been batting for the wrong team, so it only seemed fair that his be the first face scratched off the family clock, right? Wrong! At least JK had the decency to apologise for this one, making a rare appearance on Twitter to accept responsibility for her actions: €œToday I would just like to say: I€™m really sorry about Fred. *Bows head in acceptance of your reasonable ire.*€

3. Hedwig

This one really stung. Harry€™s pet Snowy Owl was a gift from Hagrid, given to him on his first trip to Diagon Alley and killed six years later during the Battle of the Seven Potters. The only thing that could have jarred the guts more at this stage would have been Hagrid himself getting blown out of the sky. One thing most of us seem to be in agreement over when it comes to Hedwig€™s death is that it was a lot more dignified in the film version. Deathly Hallows director David Yates allowed everyone€™s favourite owl to go down swinging, clawing at the face of a Death Eater chasing down Harry and Hagrid and winding up on the end of a killing curse as a result. In JK Rowling€™s original text, Hedwig was caged during the flight from Little Whinging, and she turned out to be a bit of a sitting duck. Unable to flee or fight, Hedwig took the Death Eater€™s killing curse right in the beak and dropped to the bottom of her cage like a rag doll. To add insult to injury, book Harry then decided to destroy the sidecar containing Hedwig€™s body in an attempt to slow down the pack of pursuing Death Eaters. No fear, though, as Hagrid was there to console Harry, assuring him that Hedwig had €œa great old life.€ Easy for him to say €“ he was nearly 70 years old at this point!

2. & 1. Remus Lupin And Nymphadora Tonks

Lupin and Tonks count as a single entry here, as one of their deaths might have been just about bearable. Two more victims of the Battle of Hogwarts, Remus and Nymphadora left behind their infant son Ted when they answered their call to arms. By this point Remus Lupin was the last surviving member of The Marauders (of magic map fame) and the last of Harry€™s father€™s best friends. With Uncle Sirius a goner at the hands of Bellatrix LeStrange, Remus was the last direct connection Harry had to his parents, though his dad€™s old school chum wasn€™t allowed to see out the chaos. Losing a duel with big time Death Eater Antolin Dolohov, Lupin was killed pretty early doors when the fighting began, and his wife was close behind him, another name on Bellatrix€™s impressive hit list. €œHarry had a clear view of the bodies lying next to Fred: Remus and Tonks, still pale and peaceful-looking, apparently asleep beneath the enchanted ceiling.€ If only. JK dispensed with the newlyweds and left little Teddy an orphan, set to go through some of the same trials and tribulations as Harry only with the added complication of werewolf blood. At least Lupin was able to pass on a message whilst briefly brought back with the resurrection stone, but for me the only redemption for this double blow would be to give Ted Tonks his very own book.

Contributor

Phil still hasn't got round to writing a profile yet, as he has an unhealthy amount of box sets on the go.