10 Players Who Probably Regret Leaving Everton

Once a blue, always a blue. Except when you've left and hate your new colours.

Joe Giddens/EMPICS SportJoe Giddens/EMPICS SportEverton have been a Premier League stalwart ever since Homer wrote the Iliad. Yes they've had some near scrapes along the way, success in the 90's was defined by finishing 17th. Now, European football is the bare minimum for Toffee fans across the globe. With Bill Kenwright as Chairman, Everton players would be financially better off with a recent scratch card winner at the helm. This isn't to say there isn't a mystique surrounding Everton which allows them to acquire the odd star. A rich history and creeky ground add to this as does a fantastic youth system that has benefitted the club and its very shallow pockets. Here is a list of the 10 players who may well be richer having left Goodison but probably wish they were still there. Money doesn't always bring you happiness....

10. Tim Cahill

SIMON DAWSON/AP/Press Association ImagesSIMON DAWSON/AP/Press Association ImagesThis is a tricky one as an argument can be made that both parties were upset by the Aussies departure. Cahill's mesmeric performances at this year's World Cup demonstrate how much he could still offer at Everton. Conversely, Timmy would rather be lighting up the Premier League than MLS. Cahill's departure in 2012 was a poignant one. 56 goals in 226 appearances, including some crackers against Liverpool, bring back tears of emotion to even the manliest Evertonian. The leap of a salmon and heading that could place you in A&E for a week were just two of Cahill's strongest assets. 32 when he left Everton, both parties will feel slightly aggrieved his tenure wasn't extended a little more.

9. Thomas Gravesen

Neal Simpson/EMPICS SportNeal Simpson/EMPICS SportIt's not often an Everton player joins Real Madrid. Nor is it to suggest that this wasn't a good move. Gravesen joined Real Madrid at one of their low points. They failed to win La Liga nor did they impress in the Champions League in his 2 year tenure. Perhaps signing players from Everton was a major reason behind this. Nevertheless, he was soon shipped on to Celtic. Gravesen did make a brief appearance back at Everton in 2007 on loan but by then the love affair between two parties was but a distant memory. Gravesen's love affair with his bald brother Lee Carsley will however echo through the ages.

8. Steven Pienaar

David Davies/PA Wire/Press Association ImagesDavid Davies/PA Wire/Press Association ImagesSimilar to Gravesen this can be considered a slight cheat as Pienaar obviously returned to Everton. That doesn't hide the fact he regrets leaving the Toffees. Pienaar struggled to gain a foothold in the Spurs starting 11 and after two seasons called it quits at White Hart Lane. Since rejoining Everton his partnership down the left flank with Baines has been a joy for fans and neutrals alike to see. Special praise must go out to Daniel Levi for selling the player for twice the amount of money. The guy was older and unfit.

7. John Heitinga

Lynne Cameron/EMPICS SportLynne Cameron/EMPICS SportThree words: Premier League football. Heitinga demanded first team football and at Fulham for the second half of the season, his wish was granted. Fulham are now in the Championship, a dramatic fall for a man who boasts a World Cup Final appearance, all be it one where he was sent off. Patience is a virtue and at Everton, with Distin ageing, Jagielka's injury problems and Alcaraz akin to a bomb scare, Heitinga could still have filled a position of need. Instead he can look forward to away games at Rotherham.

6. Landon Donovan

John Walton/EMPICS SportJohn Walton/EMPICS SportSimilar to Cahill, how far can a player go in MLS? Donovan's performances for both Everton and the USMNT were at times dazzling. Still in his 20's at Everton, he could have successfully used Goodison Park as a permanent base for bigger things. If Donovan had continued his rich vein of form, teams the calibre of Dortmund and Milan wouldn't have been far away. Instead he returned to his native LA Galaxy picking up a few more titles along the way. Good but not great Mr. Donovan.

5. Andrew Johnson

Joe Giddens/EMPICS SportJoe Giddens/EMPICS SportA £10.5 million transfer to Fulham in 2008. I think we know which party was happier with this deal. Johnson may not have been as goal hungry at Everton as he was at Crystal Palace but he still managed to bag a few (17 in 61 appearances). At Fulham and QPR, injury and poor finishing has seen him cast into the doldrums of free agency. Whilst with Everton Johnson even managed to scrape together 8 England caps. This during England's so called 'golden generation'. Today he'd be lucky to see action in League 1.

4. Francis Jeffers

Tony Marshall/EMPICS SportTony Marshall/EMPICS SportJeffers left Everton in 2001 for Arsenal after scoring 18 goals in 49 games for the Toffees. This may not seem terribly impressive, but this was era in which mid-table mediocrity was a huge success for the Merseysiders. Another success story of the academy, at least in terms of transfer revenue, Jeffers failed spectacularly at Arsenal and everywhere else thereafter. In a 186 appearances for Arsenal, Sheffield Wednesday and Charlton to name a few of many, Jeffers scored 22 goals. We'd rather Peter Schmeichel up front.

3. Joleon Lescott

Lynne Cameron/EMPICS SportLynne Cameron/EMPICS SportThe top 3 are relatively interchangeable. It would be wise to include Lescott at no.3 as many will point out he's won two premiership titles. At Goodison Park, Lescott was a revelation. He could play at CB or LB, scoring more goals than any other defender. For all this, Everton were left with a sour taste in the mouth as he forced through a transfer away from Goodison. His presence in a 6-1 hammering at home to Arsenal proved how much he valued his current club. Now at West Bromwich Albion, Lescott has taken a backward step. Though at the time he may not have regretted leaving the Toffees, he probably regrets staying at City for so long. Unfortunately for Lescott, any possible return back to Merseyside is now long gone. Enjoy the relegation battle Joleon.

2. Jack Rodwell

Scott Heppell/AP/Press Association ImagesScott Heppell/AP/Press Association Images Another Manchester City player with a winners medal, ask most footballer's and they'll tell you they'd rather play week in week out. Another product of the academy, Rodwell was tipped for big things as England U21's captain and Everton starter in 2009-10. At Manchester City he does well to make the bench. Whether he'd swap a title for regular football remains to be seen. Similar to others on this list, a return to Goodison is a distinct possibility. Surplus to requirements at City it wouldn't be a surprise to see Rodwell at a new home come the start of the 2014 season. We can only hope he remembers what a football pitch looks like.

1. Marouane Fellaini

Media Image LtdMedia Image LtdNo it's not Wayne Rooney. Fellaini has been a disaster. His performances in a United shirt are lacklustre to say the least. Your gran has as many goals for United. Many Everton fans will tell you he was a poor £15 purchase in the first place from Liege. As a central midfielder he is one of the laziest individuals to grace the Premier League. Sure he can control the ball with his nipples better than anyone else on the planet, but this can only take you so far for £27.5 million. A few spectacular performances for Everton against the so-called 'bigger teams' propelled Fellaini into such stardom. Now it will be interesting to see how Van Gaal utilises him.If Van Gaal could recoup just half the initial transfer fee, most United fans would see this the most effective use of Marouane.

Contributor
Contributor

Current Masters student at St Andrews. Tennis player by day, golfer by late afternoon. Avid American Sports and Southern Hemisphere rugby fan in the early hours. Breathe sport but draw the line at dressage.