Newcastle: Alan Pardew's 8 Biggest Head Aches Right Now

And for once, they're all pretty positive.

Victories cause headaches. They're not the bad kind of headaches that keep you up at night, or the ones that throw the ominous shadow of relegation over you, but they're important all the same. Right now, Alan Pardew could be forgiven for keeping his team as it is following a run of four straight wins in the Premier League and an impressive one over Man City in the League Cup, but thanks to the injury crisis that has at times decimated the first team, he's got decisions to make. No player should return to the first team immediately simply because of their name or what they've done in the past, but equally keeping the likes of Tiote, Cisse, Taylor and even Gouffran and Riviere out of the team for too long is a recipe for frustrating them all. Because being a manager is about more than selections, and is increasingly concerned with morale and psychology, that has to be playing a big part in how Pardew sees himself going forward. So with another boring international break upon us, let's look at the headaches that the Newcastle manager should be dealing with in the next two weeks or so...

8. Is Abeid Worth Keeping Tiote Out For?

The emergence of Mehdi Abeid this season in the holding role vacated by the mysteriously injured (and reportedly sometimes unhappy) Cheick Tiote has been one of the revelations of Newcastle's most impressive run of form. Having been mostly cast off as an inevitable sale, he returned from loan at Panathinaikos with ringing endorsements, and has forced his way admirably into Pardew's thinking. But is he good enough to keep Cheick Tiote out? The Answer Tiote is a different kind of player: more aggressive, more likely to hold up play and retain possession, and more likely to stop Newcastle breaking quickly. He shouldn't play in this system, but he's Pardew's man and has already been called "world class" this season by his manager. Rumour has it he wants out, and the club are considering cashing in, but you still have to suspect that Pardew will put him back in the team as soon as he's fit.

7. Dummett, Taylor Or Williamson?

Unfortunately, news that Fabricio Coloccini might be out for a while might make this question a little easier to answer in the long run, but when fit the Argentinian is clearly the club's first choice, and rightly so. But who do you play with him? Steven Taylor has done well since he came back in, and Pardew seems to consider Mike Williamson to be the best option to partner Coloccini in the long-term. But Paul Dummett has been brilliant in the position twice now, and he deserves a chance to make his claim to it full-time. The Answer Dummett should be the answer, based on form, but his versatility means Pardew doesn't always have to make the choice of dropping someone (something he has no issue doing to Massadio Haidara apparently). Without Coloccini in, it's likely to be Williamson and Dummet or Taylor, as there's no way Pardew will go for the Geordies together, no matter how much he should.

6. Dummett Or Haidara?

With all of his centre-halves fit, Pardew usually shifts Paul Dummett out to the left to help continue his "football education", but the Geordie is simply not the best left-back at the club. His positional naivety is shown up badly when he's not on the ball, and he isn't comfortable marking space, as well as being mostly useless going forward. Massadio Haidara meanwhile impresses every time he comes into the team, and his performance against West Brom is worth more than being immediately dropped. The Answer The real answer is to play Haidara at left-back: he is quick, tough and athletic and he is far more valuable going forward, which adds balance with Janmaat on the right. But for some reason, he's not fancied as a long-term solution and he seems destined to drift in and out of the team for now. Dummett will more than likely end up back at full-back, even as his impressive form in the middle continues. It's there in Pardew's language already.

5. Should Armstrong Go Out On Loan?

Pardew has already said that Adam Armstrong could well be the biggest prospect on Newcastle's books, which is saying something when Rolando Aarons and Ayoze are both in the first-team picture already, and the question must be asked of whether he would benefit from a spell away from the club. He's a free scorer in the U21 side, and he looked tidy against Man City, if a little isolated, so the potential is definitely there, but if Armstrong fails to break into the first team, his development might stagnate a little. A loan, on the other hand might help him - as long as it's to the right place. The Answer A loan would be best, though not to the likes of Yeovil. Rangers might not as bad a prospect, as he'd probably score a hatful, but a Championship club (preferably Middlesbrough) would be the best bet.

4. Who Plays Wide?

Though Gabriel Obertan has now joined the long injury list - and for a long time - Newcastle have a surprising wealth of options in wide positions. The emergence of Rolando Aarons and Sammy Ameobi's step up to the first team have been big parts of the successful run, and while the latter's form against West Brom was nothing to write home about he remains in contention. And then of course there's Remy Cabella - blossoming nicely compared to his first six games - and Yoan Gouffran, the scapegoat of Alan Pardew's reliance on unnatural width in the 4-2-3-1 system. With Moussa Sissoko able to play wide right too, that's five players for two positions. The Answer If fit, it should be Rolando Aarons and Remy Cabella, simply because of their ability on the ball and their creativity. Cabella might be pushed off the ball too much, but he creates chances, and can cross a ball, while Rolando's ability to run at defenders should be classed as his biggest virtue. With those two running with the ball, Newcastle can really hurt defences.

3. Cisse Or Ayoze?

Despite the impact that Ayoze Perez has had in the two starts he's been given in the Premier League, and his three goals, questions will inevitably arise over whether he is ready to play first team every game. He was bought as a development player, and while he's made a massive impact so far, that will make it easier to keep him on the bench if Papiss Cisse (himself in form when he's fit) comes back to full fitness. His knee is still reacting badly to the screws in it, but it surely won't be long before we have two goal-scorers vying for a starting place. The Answer After that goal, Ayoze is undroppable, but Cisse is Newcastle's number 9 and will be aware of the prestige and power in the squad that gives him. He's unlikely to be happy about sitting watching Ayoze get all the glory, and though he will probably go to the African Cup Of Nations in January (assuming it happens), he's more than likely going to be back in the team as soon as his knee responds well.

2. Is It Time To Get Rid Of Anita?

Vurnon Anita ia an enigma: he's very talented, hugely thought of in Holland, and was a brilliant prospect when we signed him (likened, in fact to Clarence Seedorf), but he's not the enforcer type that Cheick Tiote is, and he's a progressive defensive midfielder, rather than a reductive one. Newcastle fans have never really understood that, and neither has Alan Pardew, and he's now faced with the prospect of simply not giving him any game time, or getting rid and freeing up some funds. The Answer Unfortunately, yes. The minute Alan Pardew came out in the press and said he still hadn't settled (inspiring the Chronicle to allegedly make up a quote from the player about being unhappy) was the minute his fate was sealed, especially with Mehdi Abeid's progress. We've simply never got the best out of Anita because he's not suited to the style of defensive midfielder we play. He'd probably thrive in a footballing side, rather than one that absorbs pressure, throws bodies in the line of fire and breaks, but that's not what he's going to get at Newcastle. So selling him is best for all parties.

1. Do We Still Need Reinforcements?

For most of the season, Newcastle fans - and indeed the media - have called for Newcastle to add another striker and a centre-half to the mix of their squad. Both were intended targets at the end of the summer apparently, but time and slow progress got in the way, and it was thought the process would simply roll over into January. But now we're back to having four centre-halves with Paul Dummett making a surprising claim to one of the spots, and the strike-force has been buoyed by the emergence of Ayoze Perez. If we sign new players, Dummett and Ayoze might not get their chance to make those positions their own, and on recent performances, they deserve to. The Answer Yes. The injury situation is such at Newcastle that while the squad has cover in every position, it's never far away from a point where there's no available cover, which not only adds pressure on players not to get injured (taking away some commitment even unconsciously), but also takes away the pressure they feel from competition. In short, it's not good for the team on either account. There's definitely room for another striker - though Ayoze's progress might make it less pressing if he scores five or six between now and January - because Cisse will be off to Africa next year. And because the African Nations could take away Tiote, Abeid and Ameobi, midfield reinforcements are also a must. Plus, a centre-half to add competition and keep Mike Williamson as a backup is still definitely needed.

Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.