Premier League: 10 Biggest Transfer Window Mistakes

The January transfer window presents every team with the opportunity to improve their squad for the battles ahead and offload those players that aren't good enough. A club may cash in on a player to help balance the books or use the funds to strengthen available squad options (or not in the case of Newcastle United,) and they may also fork out a hefty sum of money in order to bring in a player they believe will become their saving grace (see United, Manchester.) It's common in football that mistakes will be made and the mid-season transfer window is no different, arguably offering the biggest opportunity for mistakes, given the perfect storm of desperation, an inflated market and vast sums of money being thrown around. Clubs can be desperate and it can show, though sometimes even the greatest signing can prove to be a flop - as Chelsea have found to their eternal detriment with Torres and Shevchenko. Of course, these mistakes will also be made during the Summer but there is a much higher possibility for error at the beginning of the year, and the results are often cause for greater scrutiny because of the false inflation of fees. While the window is open for a month the business only really gets going in the last week, with the final few days being extremely chaotic, and that is not the smartest foundation for good decisions to be made. The window just gone was no different and despite not throwing up as many big moves as some - including Jim White, no doubt - would have hoped, there was still a lot to talk about, including a number of glaring mistakes that should definitely have been avoided, and which will have repercussions for the clubs who made them in the next few months. What follows here is a ranking of the worst of those decisions...

10. Palace Sign Ince (But Only On-Loan)

On paper this is a great deal for Crystal Palace - they get one of England's brightest young talents to help them avoid relegation and give him a crack in the top flight, and possibly the opportunity to build up some affinity with the club ahead of a potential summer permanent move on a free. However, when you look into it things aren't as great as they seem. Tom Ince is using the club as a stepping stone and he's made it blindly obvious: in the summer he will be a free agent and he will be able to choose between a number of clubs to sign for - even Liverpool are said to be monitoring the situation. Fair play to him, he's landed the jackpot and he's on to a winner. Palace, however, aren't. Ince (and the large number of singings Tony Pulis inevitably brought in with him) may not be able to save them from the drop and frankly, why would he care? Come August he'll still be in the Premier League no matter what happens during this loan spell, meaning he doesn't really have to put in loads of effort. He will want to impress other clubs but he'll be selfish, as he's playing for his own future rather than that of the club. If he's through on goal late on with the chance to score the winner do you think he'll shot himself, or lay it off to a teammate for an easy tap-in?

9. Fulham Splash Out

Mitroglou joining Fulham is another deal that on paper looks fantastic given his record in Greece, but it isn't as great as it seems, as it raises many potential problems. The Cottagers paid some way more than £10m to bring the Olympiacos striker to Craven Cottage, making his one of the biggest deals of the window, and unlike for neighbours Chelsea and the likes of Manchester City, that amount is vast for a club like Fulham and the situation is extremely different. Fulham aren't flying high in the table, they're not even hovering in the middle - they're bottom, rock bottom, and at this stage their safety and Premier League status is far from secure for next season. To say it's squeaky bum time at Fulham is something of an understatement, and this transfer is a massive, massive risk. There's no doubting that Mitroglou is a superb player, or that the signing is a massive coup for Fulham, but if the worst case scenario does happen and the club drops down a division they will surely lose the player - and it's unlikely they'll get a similar figure to what they paid. Fulham's best hope if they do go down is that the Greek enjoys a wonderful half season at the club and continues in the same fashion for the World Cup.

8. No Move For McCormack

Arguably the biggest story of deadline day involved Leeds United and Ross McCormack, which went something like this: Leeds turn down Cardiff bid, manager Brian McDermott is sacked, McCormack is devastated, McCormack issues come and get me plea live on SSN, six clubs enquire, nothing materialises, McCormack pledges his allegiance to the club again via Twitter. That entire shambles was just one day at Leeds United, and things haven't got any less ridiculous since then. It emerged that the lawyer that sacked McDermott didn't even have the authority to do it and he's now back in charge at the club, and there's also a potential court date in March. The situation is a mess, the club is in turmoil and in the middle of it lies captain Ross McCormack, who now faces a challenging few months at Elland Road when he could've been experiencing Premier League football. He really should have forced through a move. Get your agent on the phone, hand in a transfer request, get out as soon as possible - the situation at Leeds is not a healthy one, and you could hardly blame him if he did.

7. Spurs Loan Holtby To Fulham

Fulham struck gold here, landing a very capable young starlet for the remainder of the season when in all honesty he should be featuring for Tim Sherwood's side. The fact that Spurs let him go was nothing short of bizarre. Lewis Holtby shouldn't be in a relegation battle - he belongs at the other end of the table fighting for Champions League football, which is precisely what parent club Tottenham are doing - but he, for unknown reasons, doesn't get the opportunities he deserves. Now he has the chance of regular first team football and if he competes as highly as he is capable of then Tottenham will be surely regret the decision to farm him out on loan, especially if they struggle to make it into the Champions League, which should be counted as their primary objective after such a summer of flux. Holtby could have helped Spurs in their Champions League battle and with the sides they're competing with they need all the help they can get - and probably more. The decision is made even worse by the lack of arrivals at White Hart Lane, but more on that later.

6. Liverpool Don't Sign Konoplyanka

Yevhen Konoplyanka looked all set for a move to Liverpool before Dnipro stepped in at the last minute stating that they weren't going to sell him after all, leaving Liverpool, and Ian Ayre in particular, who flew out to complete the deal. The problem here is the deal should've been completed long before it reached that stage - in fact, how negotiations dragged on into the final day of the window is simply baffling. Liverpool's aim this season is to get back into the Champions League, but they face some really stiff competition from the clubs around them, including Everton, and their failure to capture their prime target might come back to haunt them badly. The Reds now have to work with what they've got, and even if the intention is to revisit the Konoplyanka situation in the Summer, by then it could all be too late, as other suitors no doubt emerge in the wake of another half season to impress.

5. Bye Bye Cabaye

It wasn't really surprising that Yohan Cabaye departed for Paris, but it left Newcastle in a sticky situation as this one sale resulted in two huge mistakes- which the Tyneside club will pay for later down the line. The first mistake is selling Cabaye to begin with: it may have been inevitable, but the club went about in completely the wrong fashion - Newcastle could've, and should've, held out for more money as they could surely have got around £25million for the French midfielder, as Mike Ashley no doubt believes, given his subsequent dealing with Joe Kinnear. His price would also have increased as the season progressed and if he continued in the form he was on Newcastle could've got close to the £30million mark, especially with the World Cup likely to showcase his talents further. Not only did they sell him for the wrong price, they also did it at the wrong time. Then you have to take the fact they didn't bring in anyone to replace him into consideration.: the Magpies lost one of the best midfielders in the league and they didn't fill the gaping hole he left at all. It's bound to cost them, and the injury to Cheick Tiote has already shown the decision was a mistake.

4. United Land Mata

The biggest transfer of the window without a doubt was Manchester United capturing Juan Mata from rivals Chelsea. The Red Devils probably couldn't believe their luck to see Jose Mourinho so willing to do business, and neither could many others. When Mourinho arrived and dropped Mata it was questionable, but you always expected he would come to his senses and fit the Spaniard back into his side at some point. But Mourinho's commitment to Oscar and Eden Hazard meant there was firmly no place at the inn for Mata, and he's now found a place somewhere else. Chelsea will regret this: he's a brilliant player and although United aren't having a good season, they'll be back at some point soon, which is when Mata will strike and hurt his former club right at their core, and prove that the decision to sell, and to a rival, no less, was a huge mistake. It would have been stupid to sell him to anyone but to give him to arguably the biggest club in England is just ridiculous - this is after all the same club that wouldn't loan Arsenal Demba Ba in the Summer and it raises questions about a certain Wayne Rooney.

3. City Fail To Finish Jigsaw

Manchester City are without a doubt one of the best sides in the division and they're rightly considered the favourites for the title. They are extremely close to a perfect squad but were missing one final ingredient - and still are thanks to a noticeable lack of activity this winter. City lack in defence: they need another centre-back to fix their defensive frailties and it was widely expected they would solve this issue in January. They have the money and the attraction but ultimately they ended up with nothing. If anything is going to cost City the title this year it is their failure to bring in a defender this January. They might have one of the most overloaded attacks in the league, but that cannot win the title on its own, and a strong defensive foundation has been the cornerstone for most successful Premier League winning sides in the history of the competition.

2. Spurs Sign No-One

The sole aim for Tottenham this season should be to fight their way back into Champions League football, but with the first three places seemingly heading to Arsenal, Manchester City and Chelsea they face stiff competition for the final place, especially without Gareth Bale, and with some of their summer signings failing to gel as successfully as would have been hoped. They are currently battling it out with Liverpool, Everton and Manchester United for fourth place, and one of those sides might not even get Europa League football. So, what do you do to improve your chances? You buy better players, you improve the squad, and you get a plan B in personnel terms. But, apparently if your Spurs, you don't. Not a single player arrived in January to boost their squad, despite the number of additions that really needed to be made. The North London club spent over £100million in the Summer, to limited success, and there remain some serious holes in the squad. Maybe that's what put them off? Still, at least their neighbours also made a huge error during the window...

1. Gunners Get No Striker

What do Miroslav Klose, Saloman Kalou, Dimitar Berbatov and Papiss Cisse have in common? Arsenal made a move for every single one of them in January, but somewhat spectacularly failed to get any of them. Arsenal are enjoying a great season and have surprised everyone by flying high at the top of the table for pretty much the entire campaign - a position they still hold. All is well but, like City, there is one thing missing: a new striker. After Theo Walcott was ruled out for the season the Gunners were left with just Olivier Giroud and Nicklas Bendtner as their only real choices up front, plus Yaya Sanogo who won't be troubling too many defences just yet. While both of the formerhave done well this season it's clear they needed help and that help was expected to arrive in January. It didn't, meaning Arsenal now have to battle on three fronts with only two strikers. Their inability to bring anyone in means that they may have just thrown away their best chance of winning a trophy and ending the drought that has run since 2005. Still, they could always give Park Chu-Young a chance... Or they might have if they hadn't loaned him to Watford. Which mistakes do you think were the worst of this summer? Share your opinions below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Josh has had work featured in the Evening Gazette and on Newcastle United website. He is a Multimedia Journalism student at Teesside University and runs a successful sports blog. He also enjoys films, comics and TV, writing about anything he can. Josh has recently started writing his first of what he hopes will be many books.