10 Star Trek Timelines That Were Erased
These are the most important times in Star Trek that simply never existed at all
Star Trek has often teased the audience with a glimpse into what could be, what was, and what never came to pass. They have it down to an art form, spreading across all of the franchise iterations. While sometimes those timelines were fascinating, there are yet more that would freeze the soul, were they left to seep into our main reality.
There are simply too many possible universes and timelines that could exist out there, so much like DC's decision with their Crisis On Infinite Earths, the producers have erred on the side of caution in Star Trek. A timeline that may seem cool and inviting today may simply vanish from existence tomorrow. When that timeline sees your ship battered day after day by a seemingly unstoppable force, then perhaps not all destruction is an ill, nor loss of memory a sad thing.
Here are just some of those timelines that have gone to the great recycling bin in the sky, and while some may hope for a restoration worthy of the Bajoran Prophets, there are yet more who we were glad to see the back of.
10. Voyager's Year Of Hell
With the fourth season of Star Trek: Voyager upping the ante for the show, the writers chose to swing big. Introducing Seven of Nine, and casting Jeri Ryan in the part, was a clear ratings grab that, despite that obvious attempt to appeal to the younger male audience, accidentally delivered one of the most beloved characters in the franchise.
How, then, to keep the momentum going? Kick seven layers of crap out of the ship, of course! Year Of Hell delivered on some of the promise that the show had to offer. A Starfleet ship, alone in the Delta Quadrant, rapidly running out of resources. It had no safe harbour to lay low (save for a less-than-friendly nebula), and the crew's battered morale was evident in the bulkheads themselves.
This is easily one of the most popular stories in Voyager's seven-year run, though it is all undone at the end of the second episode. Perhaps the writers were nervous, fearing the audience wouldn't be able to handle a season of dark, heavy imagery (clearly, they hadn't even dreamed of Discovery's first season) and opted for the reset. There is much to be grateful for though. This timeline saw Tuvok lose his eyesight and Janeway lose her life, both of which were happily undone by the latter's heroic sacrifice.
9. The Defiant's Children Of Time
Children Of Time arrives in the later end of Deep Space Nine's fifth season. As the show was gearing up for the true explosion of the Dominion War, this was a little glance at what could be, if events went another way. The Defiant encounters a planet that is surrounded by a barrier - one strong enough to cause havoc with the ship's systems.
This leads to a crashlanding and a meeting of the minds that was, to put it plainly, unexpected. This was both the first time that the ship had arrived - and it was a long-awaited return at the same time. The barrier surrounding the planet was temporal. A settlement had sprung up, almost two centuries old, made of survivors - from the Defiant.
In a spot of timey wimey hijinks, the ship was transported back in time when it tried to leave the planet. That time was devastating, leading to the deaths of several crew, and making the ship unsalvagable. Only Odo (and technically Dax, via the symbiont) survived to 'modern' day - which leads to this timeline's erasure.
Odo, unable to lose Major Kira once again, uses the research that he spent centuries working on to ensure that this time, the Defiant escapes orbit. He saves Kira - at the cost of the entire settlement, and two century's worth of history.
8. The Enterprise Of Yesteryear
When the Enterprise-C responded to the distress call from Narendra III, they found themselves thrown twenty years into a possible future. That future was erased, but it also happens to be one of the more confusing, temporally speaking, entries on this list.
Had the ship never entered that distortion, then presumably Captain Rachel Garrett would have perished during the fight. Though some survivors may still have been brought back to Romulus for questioning, the legacy of the battle would have been the building blocks of peace with the Klingon Empire.
Instead, Garrett is killed in this alternate future, leaving Lt. Richard Castillo in command. Lt. Tasha Yar of the Enterprise-D returns with the ship to aid them in their fight, leading, of course, to the eventual birth of Sela. Though, by and large, the legacy of the battle remained the same - peace was achieved with the Klingons, thus that future never came to pass - Yar's existence in the past, as well as Sela's existence in the present, confirm that this timeline was both erased and retained via her bloodline.
This is a contender for the most wibbly wobbly entry today.
7. Edith Lives So That Starfleet May Die
The City On The Edge Of Forever is one of the earliest examples of Star Trek episodes that pack a whallop. The reason that it works as well as it does, thanks in no small part to the acting on show, is the fact that there is no other option: Edith Keeler must die.
Many characters in history are remembered for what they did. Edith is remembered as the voice of peace who was killed outside of her Mission. Had she survived, she would have set the human race on a far darker path than she ever intended. In the 23rd century, the Enterprise discovers Carl, then in the form of the Guardian of Forever. A drug-crazed McCoy jumps through this time portal, then all goes dark.
The landing party, protected in the eddies of time emanating from the device, find that they cannot raise the ship on hails. As far as they know, there is no ship, no fleet, no Federation. Something very wrong has happened. McCoy, in his haste to do the right thing, saved Keeler in the past. She then continued her push for peace, delaying the United States' entry into WW2. The Axis powers won the war, leading to a timeline too dark to imagine.
Kirk and Spock travel to the past and stop McCoy, ensuring that Keeler has her meeting with that car. Though Starfleet and the future are saved, it is a sombre ending.
6. Pike Can Walk And All It Cost Was The Life Of One Vulcan Officer
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds has been adding further depth to what is known about Captain, later Fleet Captain, Christopher Pike. Where previously there were only The Cage and The Menagerie for Pike, we now know far more about his role as Captain of the Enterprise - and when that role was not in Starfleet's best interests.
Pike became aware of his wheelchair-bound fate ten years before it happened. As part of his accident, he discovered that several cadets would perish. When he later came face to face with one of those cadets (though when they were only a child) he made the decision to warn them, thus saving their life.
It came with a cost. Pike would be spared his fate, rise through the ranks to Admiral, and serve in Starfleet as their war with the Romulans raged on. As Captain of the Enterprise, history swerved to put him in Kirk's place during the events of Balance Of Terror. Pike, skilled as he was in many areas, simply was the wrong man for the job in facing them down. This not only led to war but also to the death of Spock, who was killed in the opening battle.
Pike, knowing this wasn't an option, accepted his fate, put history back to the way it was meant to be, and went on knowing that his day was coming.
5. THIS Is Ceti Alpha V!
Star Trek: Enterprise brought, with its third season, one of the darkest versions of humanity's future. Following a devastating war with the Xindi, Earth had been destroyed, Starfleet was crippled, and those few humans who survived limped across space to Ceti Alpha V.
Though they wouldn't have known it, there was no future for them. Ceti Alpha V would suffer ecological doom after the explosion of Ceti Alpha VI just over one hundred years later. So, even though T'Pol and Archer seemed cosy enough twelve years after landing, they were counting down seconds that they didn't know were numbered.
This timeline was erased with a little help from Denobulan ingenuity. Archer had been infected with interspatial parasites that prevented him from forming long-term memories. Phlox's treatment destroyed them in both the present and the past, thus allowing them to rewrite history. Though the MacGuffin of the piece was less than important, it allowed for a dark, brutal look into what might have been for Starfleet's first warp five ship.
4. Happy Confederation Day!
In Star Trek, most one-off timelines tend to be exactly that: one-off. For Star Trek: Picard's second season, the writers decided to take things in a different direction. Q's deterioration led him to send Picard on another quest, though this was far less mischievous than his previous visits.
Q ends up sending Jean-Luc, Raffi, Seven, Rios, and Elnor into an altered version of the present. Here, there is no Federation, nor is there a Starfleet, so to speak. Instead, the Confederation rules supreme. In one chilling scene, Q shows Picard the skulls of the latter's enemies. At least, they belong to the enemies of General Picard, slain, and put on display as a warning for those who would challenge him.
This was anathema to Admiral Picard, who immediately set about setting history right again. This included seeking help from the Borg Queen, travelling back to the 21st century, dallying with yet another Soong, and enduring yet more personal loss.
Though Q helped to send them home in the end, this was one of the darkest visits from the omnipotent being - one who may or may not be dead, depending on the day of the week.
3. See You Soon, Harry
How must it feel to carry the weight of death on your shoulders? Harry Kim felt this, not just for one person, but for the lives of his entire crew, in the episode Timeless. He blamed himself for Voyager's crashlanding, from which only he and Chakotay escaped, zooming ahead in the Delta Flier.
That guilt weighs a person down. As the years went on, neither man could stomach it, so they set about changing the past. They stole a temporal transceiver from Starfleet, 'reclaimed' the Flier, and found the remains of their old ship and crew. The plan was simple: send the corrected data back in time, and save the crew. Easy, right?
Not quite. The USS Challenger appeared, captained by none other than Geordi LaForge. He posed a question to which they did not have a simple answer: did they have the right to change history so? Fifteen years had passed since their return home, full of joy, sorrow, and everything in between. Who were they to decide that didn't matter?
Frankly, by the episode's end, that question remains unresolved, even though Harry does change the past. Timeless then is similar to Children Of Time. Though as an audience we are happy to see our familiar crews survive, did Odo or Harry truly have the right to erase what they did?
2. Slingshot Around The Sun For Saturn
Tomorrow Is Yesterday tends to fall between the cracks in Star Trek history. The slingshot-around-the-sun technique was used to great effect in Star Trek IV, though it originates here. The Enterprise is accidentally thrown into the past when it is caught in the gravity of a Black Hole, while en route to Starbase 9. This has the unfortunate side effect of dumping the ship in Earth's atmosphere - in the mid-1960s.
The timeline that is created by the Enterprise's appearance feels like more of a threat than an eventuality. Captain John Christopher has the unlucky honour of being the pilot who spots the ship, only to be beamed aboard. Kirk initially gives him free reign of the vessel, then breaks the news that he can never go home. However, Spock points out that this isn't an option.
Christopher's son manned the first Earth-Saturn mission. Quite annoyingly, said son had yet to be born - so Christopher couldn't remain removed from history.
This remains the only example of using a slingshot around the sun, combined with the transporter, to deposit people plucked from history back into their earlier selves. Technically, the Enterprise manages to prevent a new timeline from being created, though one wonders how Dulmur and Lucsly would interpret it.
1. I Don't Know Why I Ever Gave This Up
Admiral Janeway brought her crew home. It may have taken far shorter than initially planned, but it was far longer than anyone would have liked - and there were casualties along the way. As the captain of the ship, she took responsibility for every life lost, no matter the reason.
She openly admitted to becoming a pragmatist with age, so her mission into the past was, in her view at least, the only option available. It broke every rule in the book when it came to the Temporal Prime Directive - surely there's a clause that screams 'please don't erase everyone's lives because you don't like the outcome of your own.'
However, like Harry before her, Janeway weighed the pros against the cons, and opted for a bit of Borg-icide along the way. In doing so, she managed to save many lives, Tuvok's mind, and dealt a crippling blow to Starfleet's greatest foe.
Her actions will be debated (by those in the know) for years to come, but the results speak for themselves. Whether she did the right thing or not, she did what she believed was best, and she got her ship home.